What's new
Fantasy Football - Footballguys Forums

This is a sample guest message. Register a free account today to become a member! Once signed in, you'll be able to participate on this site by adding your own topics and posts, as well as connect with other members through your own private inbox!

What is the worst dynasty trade you have been offered? (1 Viewer)

Got another picks offer:

Give: 1.09, 1.11
Receive: 2026 2nd, 2026 2nd, 2026 3rd

Really don't understand the logic on this one...so I asked.
Did you get an answer ?
Should have been this years seconds for next years firsts.
they said they accidently put both firsts in there. My guess is they were deciding which of 1.09 and 1.11 they wanted for those picks next year and just forgot to unclick one (or they take me for an idiot and this was their excuse). I still told them they were short a 2nd at least.
We didn't iron out a trade. Too far apart on pick values.
 
I am sure that I may have gotten worse but I can't remember them....offered me Josey Jewell and a 6th round pick for my 2nd round pick (ind)

and then the other one was his 2025 1.6 and a sixth rounder for my 2025 3 or 4 (I forgot which) my 2026 and my 2026 4th. Maybe this was fair, I don't know but it felt like mortgageing my future so I wasn't into it.
 
Here's one of the worst trades I've ever seen that recently happened in an RTSports startup Superflex draft:


TEAM A sends:
2025 13.2
2025 14.11
2025 15.2
2025 16.11
2026 Rd 4
2026 Rd 4
2026 Rd 5


TEAM B sends:
2025 5.10
2025 6.3

The Commish on that site has no clue what he's doing nor any courage and he won't overturn any trades despite there clearly being collusion. TEAM B gains absolutely nothing in this trade.
 
Here's one of the worst trades I've ever seen that recently happened in an RTSports startup Superflex draft:


TEAM A sends:
2025 13.2
2025 14.11
2025 15.2
2025 16.11
2026 Rd 4
2026 Rd 4
2026 Rd 5


TEAM B sends:
2025 5.10
2025 6.3

The Commish on that site has no clue what he's doing nor any courage and he won't overturn any trades despite there clearly being collusion. TEAM B gains absolutely nothing in this trade.
I agree it's really bad, but I don't feel like it's the kind of thing that you can't make a case that the guy just has a weird strategy. He's splitting up larger assets into many more smaller assets. But I agree he should have gotten way more.
 
Got another picks offer:

Give: 1.09, 1.11
Receive: 2026 2nd, 2026 2nd, 2026 3rd

Really don't understand the logic on this one...so I asked.
Answer: I was hoping you were dropped on your head as a child.
Yeah, that kind of response makes me want to put that guy on speed dial if they still had such a thing. Gen Zers are asking, “what is speed dial?”.
Zoomers are asking “what’s a dial?”
 
Year 2025 Draft Pick 3.10
Year 2026 Round 3 Draft Pick

-for-

Walker III, Kenneth SEA RB, 3 year contract
Williams, Jameson DET WR, 3 year contract
 
Year 2025 Draft Pick 3.10
Year 2026 Round 3 Draft Pick

-for-

Walker III, Kenneth SEA RB, 3 year contract
Williams, Jameson DET WR, 3 year contract

FYI, I replied asking if he sent that by mistake and was missing assets.

I just traded Walked, so he sent...

Year 2025 Draft Pick 3.10
-for-
Williams, Jameson DET WR, 3 year contract

I asked again if he was missing something and he replied, "He is the 3rd best Wr on the team"

I think one of us is an idiot. Am I missing something about Jameson?
 
Got another picks offer:

Give: 1.09, 1.11
Receive: 2026 2nd, 2026 2nd, 2026 3rd

Really don't understand the logic on this one...so I asked.
Answer: I was hoping you were dropped on your head as a child.
Yeah, that kind of response makes me want to put that guy on speed dial if they still had such a thing. Gen Zers are asking, “what is speed dial?”.
Zoomers are asking “what’s a dial?”
What’s a zoomer?
 
Got another picks offer:

Give: 1.09, 1.11
Receive: 2026 2nd, 2026 2nd, 2026 3rd

Really don't understand the logic on this one...so I asked.
Answer: I was hoping you were dropped on your head as a child.
Yeah, that kind of response makes me want to put that guy on speed dial if they still had such a thing. Gen Zers are asking, “what is speed dial?”.
Zoomers are asking “what’s a dial?”
What’s a zoomer?
Someone who knows how to use a search engine.

lol

It’s the same thing as Gen Z. People born between ~1997-2012

Year 2025 Draft Pick 3.10
Year 2026 Round 3 Draft Pick

-for-

Walker III, Kenneth SEA RB, 3 year contract
Williams, Jameson DET WR, 3 year contract

FYI, I replied asking if he sent that by mistake and was missing assets.

I just traded Walked, so he sent...

Year 2025 Draft Pick 3.10
-for-
Williams, Jameson DET WR, 3 year contract

I asked again if he was missing something and he replied, "He is the 3rd best Wr on the team"

I think one of us is an idiot. Am I missing something about Jameson?
This is a serious contender for worst ever.
 
Woke up to this beauty today .. so, after spending 3 days at the beach and not looking at work, football, news or social media!

I give up: Bhayshul Tuten (who I just drafted at 2.09 before leaving), and Jauan Jennings
I get back: Rookie pick 4.07

Nothing else but the pick 2 rounds later than when I selected him
Counter with whoever he picked in round 1 for your 2028 4th round pick.
 
Woke up to this beauty today .. so, after spending 3 days at the beach and not looking at work, football, news or social media!

I give up: Bhayshul Tuten (who I just drafted at 2.09 before leaving), and Jauan Jennings
I get back: Rookie pick 4.07

Nothing else but the pick 2 rounds later than when I selected him
Counter with whoever he picked in round 1 for your 2028 4th round pick.
Funny ... I did counter ... I asked for Tee Higgins Cin WR
 
You'll have to tell me if I am missing something but got these two today:

I get
Mason, Jordan MIN RB
Sanders, Raheim LAC RB
Gadsden, Oronde LAC TE

I give
Brooks, Jonathon CAR RB
Etienne, Travis JAC RB
Hubbard, Chuba CAR RB

or

I get
Mason, Jordan MIN RB
Sanders, Raheim LAC RB

I give
Brooks, Jonathon CAR RB
Hubbard, Chuba CAR RB
 
You'll have to tell me if I am missing something but got these two today:

I get
Mason, Jordan MIN RB
Sanders, Raheim LAC RB
Gadsden, Oronde LAC TE


I give
Brooks, Jonathon CAR RB
Etienne, Travis JAC RB
Hubbard, Chuba CAR RB

or

I get
Mason, Jordan MIN RB
Sanders, Raheim LAC RB

I give
Brooks, Jonathon CAR RB
Hubbard, Chuba CAR RB
Who are they? The bold?

That is just plain horrible. Now, I understand some have questions... but still.
 
Last edited:
Year 2025 Draft Pick 3.10
Year 2026 Round 3 Draft Pick

-for-

Walker III, Kenneth SEA RB, 3 year contract
Williams, Jameson DET WR, 3 year contract

FYI, I replied asking if he sent that by mistake and was missing assets.

I just traded Walked, so he sent...

Year 2025 Draft Pick 3.10
-for-
Williams, Jameson DET WR, 3 year contract

I asked again if he was missing something and he replied, "He is the 3rd best Wr on the team"

I think one of us is an idiot. Am I missing something about Jameson?
Should just tell him you were about to accept but wouldn't want to stick him with only the third best WR on a team so no thanks.
 
You'll have to tell me if I am missing something but got these two today:

I get
Mason, Jordan MIN RB
Sanders, Raheim LAC RB
Gadsden, Oronde LAC TE

I give
Brooks, Jonathon CAR RB
Etienne, Travis JAC RB
Hubbard, Chuba CAR RB

or

I get
Mason, Jordan MIN RB
Sanders, Raheim LAC RB

I give
Brooks, Jonathon CAR RB
Hubbard, Chuba CAR RB
Both atrocious.
 
Won't say all time (been playing this game for 30 years) but earlier this week boy I got a stinker in one of my best ball SF dynasty leagues...

Give: Nabers
Get: Javonte Williams, Jayden Higgins, Sinnott, 2nd in 2026

Talk about giving away a gold dollar for pennies. No thanks. :x
 
Won't say all time (been playing this game for 30 years) but earlier this week boy I got a stinker in one of my best ball SF dynasty leagues...

Give: Nabers
Get: Javonte Williams, Jayden Higgins, Sinnott, 2nd in 2026

Talk about giving away a gold dollar for pennies. No thanks. :x
But, but, but. You get THREE players AND a pick

I hate these kind of offers. Can only think he was trying to get a counter out of you. Couldn't have seriously expected it to be accepted.
 
Won't say all time (been playing this game for 30 years) but earlier this week boy I got a stinker in one of my best ball SF dynasty leagues...

Give: Nabers
Get: Javonte Williams, Jayden Higgins, Sinnott, 2nd in 2026

Talk about giving away a gold dollar for pennies. No thanks. :x
But, but, but. You get THREE players AND a pick

I hate these kind of offers. Can only think he was trying to get a counter out of you. Couldn't have seriously expected it to be accepted.
Sadly not so sure. I like this owner, but he's nearly impossible to deal with. I was trying to get his #4 TE in Sinnott (and he has a real need at WR) and was told Sinnott was worth more than Aiyuk AND Juan Jennings. :shrug:
 
16 team SF PPR TEP IDP
Pick 1.12 OTC

I get: pick 1.12 and nothing else :pickle:

I give: Nico Collins. :oldunsure:

Where do I sign?! Almost broke my phone screen rejecting so hard.

It’s not the worst I’ve ever been offered. It’s the worst I’ve been offered in quite some time.
 
Last edited:
Was offered 1.10 and 1.15 in a 16 teamer for Marvin Harrison.

Not that the offer was even close to the worst ever but the comment in the trade comment box was classic:

“Harrison is a FAILED EXPERIMENT for you”.

WTF does that even mean? It did make me laugh pretty hard though 😎
 
Was offered 1.10 and 1.15 in a 16 teamer for Marvin Harrison.

Not that the offer was even close to the worst ever but the comment in the trade comment box was classic:

“Harrison is a FAILED EXPERIMENT for you”.

WTF does that even mean? It did make me laugh pretty hard though 😎
lmao I’d be like “so why do you want him bro?”
He can fix him.
 
Was offered 1.10 and 1.15 in a 16 teamer for Marvin Harrison.

Not that the offer was even close to the worst ever but the comment in the trade comment box was classic:

“Harrison is a FAILED EXPERIMENT for you”.

WTF does that even mean? It did make me laugh pretty hard though 😎
lmao I’d be like “so why do you want him bro?”
Which was my exact reply 👍

I had won the league 2 years straight and only got to draft Harrison because of a series of off season trades prior to the 2023 season that netted me a high draft pick in 2024. Not like I am the league dummy 😉
 
Was offered 1.10 and 1.15 in a 16 teamer for Marvin Harrison.

Not that the offer was even close to the worst ever but the comment in the trade comment box was classic:

“Harrison is a FAILED EXPERIMENT for you”.

WTF does that even mean? It did make me laugh pretty hard though 😎
I resent those who criticize the player they want to trade for. I see a character flaw with people like that.
 
Last edited:
Was offered 1.10 and 1.15 in a 16 teamer for Marvin Harrison.

Not that the offer was even close to the worst ever but the comment in the trade comment box was classic:

“Harrison is a FAILED EXPERIMENT for you”.

WTF does that even mean? It did make me laugh pretty hard though 😎
I resent those who criticize the player they wnt to trade for. I see a character flaw with people like that.
“Negging” - just as scummy with FF offers as it is with picking up women.

“Hey baby, I know Marvin Harrison is a bust who’s dragged down your team like a boat anchor in a shallow bay, but I’ll help you out by taking him off your hands for a couple late 1sts. Call me? 📞”.
 
Last edited:
Was offered 1.10 and 1.15 in a 16 teamer for Marvin Harrison.

Not that the offer was even close to the worst ever but the comment in the trade comment box was classic:

“Harrison is a FAILED EXPERIMENT for you”.

WTF does that even mean? It did make me laugh pretty hard though 😎
I resent those who criticize the player they wnt to trade for. I see a character flaw with people like that.
“Negging” - just as scummy with FF offers as it is with picking up women.

“Hey baby, I know Marvin Harrison is a bust who’s dragged down your team like a boat anchor in a shallow bay, but I’ll help you out by taking him off your hands for a couple late 1sts. Call me? 📞”.
I'd trade your brains out.
 
So this wasn’t an offer, but a couple of offers across different leagues. AKA, the joy of being in multiple leagues with the same people.

A month ago I was tryna buy low on Diggs for WR depth. We got super close - I was gonna give a 2026 3rd, which I thought was a borderline offer & probably a slight overpay for a 31 y/o coming off ACL surgery. Last minute dude balks - says he’s thinking Diggs is gonna be the Pats WR1. Would need more than a 3rd.

Ok cool. Cool. All good. I didn’t have anything else to offer and I don’t wanna pay more than a 3rd. We move on.

Today in another league I’m in with that same dude, he sends me an offer of a 4th and 5th for my Diggs.

Cmon man. Make up your mind - is Diggs worth more than a 3rd or not? The irony is I’d probably take a 3rd for him - he’s my 6th WR. Maybe I’ll send him the offer. Maybe not. lol :shrug:
 
So this wasn’t an offer, but a couple of offers across different leagues. AKA, the joy of being in multiple leagues with the same people.

A month ago I was tryna buy low on Diggs for WR depth. We got super close - I was gonna give a 2026 3rd, which I thought was a borderline offer & probably a slight overpay for a 31 y/o coming off ACL surgery. Last minute dude balks - says he’s thinking Diggs is gonna be the Pats WR1. Would need more than a 3rd.

Ok cool. Cool. All good. I didn’t have anything else to offer and I don’t wanna pay more than a 3rd. We move on.

Today in another league I’m in with that same dude, he sends me an offer of a 4th and 5th for my Diggs.

Cmon man. Make up your mind - is Diggs worth more than a 3rd or not? The irony is I’d probably take a 3rd for him - he’s my 6th WR. Maybe I’ll send him the offer. Maybe not. lol :shrug:
You should send an offer of Diggs for a third just for the curiosity factor. You could give him lots of **** if he turns it down.
And it would make for an interesting post in here in May 😂
 
You should send an offer of Diggs for a third just for the curiosity factor. You could give him lots of **** if he turns it down.
And it would make for an interesting post in here in May 😂
I’m trying to make another trade to add WR depth so I can do exactly that.
:lol:
 
Ahhhh... the true sign that the FF season is gearing up, receipt of my first truly awful offer. Names have been changed to protect the guilty. 16 team IDP starting only 1 QB.

I get:
Darnold, Sam SEA QB
Year 2026 Round 3 Draft Pick from Ruxin

for my:
Reed, Jayden GBP WR
Year 2025 Draft Pick 1.07

Welcome, welcome, 2025!! :ROFLMAO:
 
Ahhhh... the true sign that the FF season is gearing up, receipt of my first truly awful offer. Names have been changed to protect the guilty. 16 team IDP starting only 1 QB.

I get:
Darnold, Sam SEA QB
Year 2026 Round 3 Draft Pick from Ruxin

for my:
Reed, Jayden GBP WR
Year 2025 Draft Pick 1.07

Welcome, welcome, 2025!! :ROFLMAO:
lol off with a bang- that's a flaming bag of dog poo on the front porch.
 
FWIW, in one league where I adopted an orphan 2 years ago (and was forewarned to expect a lot of bad trade offers), I got so tired of "negotiating" with two particular managers who's counters were so light, always, that I had to change strategies. I stopped taking the time to come up with thoughtful counters and instead just started to zing the worst offender (also the commish lol) in the group chat. Nicknames and public embarrassment. This is the way. :shades:

As a result, I've gotten a less active in the amount of trades I do and in the time I invest in trying to come up with ideas for trades or counters.

Another bizarre result of being in dynasty leagues longer is that-- after a few years, most of my rosters are generally tilted in the direction of players I'm higher than consensus on. So there's not some existing polarity between my faves and fades and consensus.
 
I'm not sure how bad this one is, but he's getting the two best players in the trade (I rejected it). I give: Burrow and Gibbs and I get: Mahomes, James Cook, 2026 1st and a 2027 1st. These would more than likely be late first round picks. Thoughts?
 
I'm not sure how bad this one is, but he's getting the two best players in the trade (I rejected it). I give: Burrow and Gibbs and I get: Mahomes, James Cook, 2026 1st and a 2027 1st. These would more than likely be late first round picks. Thoughts?
Yeah, it would be hard to pry Gibbs away from me if I had him. That talent running behind that line is tough to give up for future picks. They would have to end up being top 3 picks to make beneficial for you. Plus, this is probably Cooks last year in Buffalo since it looks like they aren't going to pay him.
 
I'm not sure how bad this one is, but he's getting the two best players in the trade (I rejected it). I give: Burrow and Gibbs and I get: Mahomes, James Cook, 2026 1st and a 2027 1st. These would more than likely be late first round picks. Thoughts?
That’s not a horrible offer. It’s not even really bad. If I was looking to move Gibbs this would at least be something maybe I could try to work a framework of a deal around.
 
I'm not sure how bad this one is, but he's getting the two best players in the trade (I rejected it). I give: Burrow and Gibbs and I get: Mahomes, James Cook, 2026 1st and a 2027 1st. These would more than likely be late first round picks. Thoughts?
That’s not a horrible offer. It’s not even really bad. If I was looking to move Gibbs this would at least be something maybe I could try to work a framework of a deal around.
I would have to believe that 2027 1st would be high, even if hard to predict. Not a fan of 2026 draft. I would keep Burrow and Gibbs. If that 2027 1st isn’t top 2 you lose.
 
I'm not sure how bad this one is, but he's getting the two best players in the trade (I rejected it). I give: Burrow and Gibbs and I get: Mahomes, James Cook, 2026 1st and a 2027 1st. These would more than likely be late first round picks. Thoughts?
That’s not a horrible offer. It’s not even really bad. If I was looking to move Gibbs this would at least be something maybe I could try to work a framework of a deal around.
I would have to believe that 2027 1st would be high, even if hard to predict. Not a fan of 2026 draft. I would keep Burrow and Gibbs. If that 2027 1st isn’t top 2 you lose.
Totally agree. I’m just saying it’s not a horrible offer.
 

Users who are viewing this thread

Back
Top