Question for those of you that are into simply collecting wine for the sake of collecting it, and I don't mean this to be rude, just curious. What exactly do you get out of having a certian 1989 Shiraz say if you have no intention of drinking it or sharing it with friends ? Are you buying it as an investment or just to say that you have it ?
I guess we'll I can understand discovering a good wine and wanting to buy it to enjoy I just don't get collecting it for the sake of collecting it.
It's all personal difference or personal philosophy. Scupper and Jules probably differ in the way they buy from proninja and myself, who differ from you or tipsey. Like anything else you own in life, it's nice to be able to say to someone you encounter, "I have a <insert item of prestige here> sitting at home." But mostly people buy with the intention of drinking it down the road when the wine has matured. They want to try the best wines at their peak.Some of it can be sentiment. I've got a bottle of '97 Fife Zinfandel that probably cost $15 when it was released, it's pretty much on it's downward slope now, yet I can't bring myself to open it because it's the last one of a half-case I bought after my wife and I fell in love with it on a trip for our first anniversary.
I enjoy wine, but I'm not willing to put the kind of money into it that Jules and Scupper seem to be. While they're trying wines I would love to try and will have some great ones to drink down the road, I probably have a different personal philosophy on it than they do.
We just started to really apprecaite wine about 6-7 years ago, and it's something we kept up with because it basically became one of the few shared hobbies my wife and I have. On a day-to-day basis, most of the wine I drink is in the $15-$25 range, and I save most my higher-$ purchases for special occasions or trips to wine country.
This is the first year in 5 or 6 that my wife and I have not made a trip to Napa, Sonoma, or the Mendocino area. Often times while there, we would find a wine we liked that was worthy of cellaring, and we'd pick up two bottles - one to drink in the near future and one to put away for 5, 7, 10 years, whatever. I normally just pick up an extra bottle rather than a case/half-case. Some of that is a product of income. I could afford to buy more or to drink better wines on a daily basis, but I'd have to sacrifice other things to do so. And I'm not willing to do that just for wine.
As opposed to Jules 400+, I've got a wine fridge that holds about 60 bottles. It's stocked to the gills right now, and some of the first wines we bought to hold for a while will start coming out after my daughter is born in June/July. Most of those bottles won't be Brunellos or Shafer wines or wineries at the tips of most people's tongues (A number of ours are from places like Peju, Del Dotto, Sullivan, Summers, Hall, Zahtila, Cosentino) - just bottles we encountered during our trips to wine country, really enjoyed, and we'll pull them out and reminisce over this trip or that trip. I think it's all just about personal preference.