What's new
Fantasy Football - Footballguys Forums

This is a sample guest message. Register a free account today to become a member! Once signed in, you'll be able to participate on this site by adding your own topics and posts, as well as connect with other members through your own private inbox!

What kind of WINE did you drink last night? (2 Viewers)

Here is where I shop in Canada.

http://www.vintages.com/

With exchange I am assuming you guys could save money.

Maybe I could set up a business shipping to the US?? I am guessing it's not legal though.

 
Last edited by a moderator:
BTW this a great site where I purchase a lot of wine. I actually work near them so I will often pick up wine at the store. They have a fantastic selection. I will often use it for price comparisons or reviews even if I am buying elsewhere.

Wine Library
Oh I like this sight.Has anybody here tried this Nineteen Nineteen line? It looks to be Argentine and I like the price. They hav a Cab, Syrah, and Malbec.

I see Cartlidge and Browne Cab on there. I haven't tried the Cab but I do have some of the Pinot Noir. Really nice value in the Pinot.
I have had the Malbec. I like it quite a bit. It definitly has the charactaristic chewyness and gaminess of Malbecs.
 
A couple of people have said the Cline Cellars Red Truck is a tastey little number, has anyone tried it ?

Also been tempted to try Armida Wineries Poizin Zinfandel just because everytime I see the marketing of it draws my attention, has anyone had it ?

 
Question for those of you that are into simply collecting wine for the sake of collecting it, and I don't mean this to be rude, just curious. What exactly do you get out of having a certian 1989 Shiraz say if you have no intention of drinking it or sharing it with friends ? Are you buying it as an investment or just to say that you have it ?

I guess we'll I can understand discovering a good wine and wanting to buy it to enjoy I just don't get collecting it for the sake of collecting it.
No one who's paying attention "collects" wine. Many French wines are not ready to drink, but are priced to buy. When most good wines are "ready" they are significantly more expensive. Sure, you lose some before they get good due to cork issues, or they just plain never get good. The other reason I have wine in the cellar is because the good ones sell out. I don't want to have to buy wine off an auction site later becuase I didn't buy enough to store.Take a 1999 Silver Oak, about $150 in a store. I bought 4-5 bottles 2-3 years ago and paid less than $60/bottle. That's not "collecting", that's saving $300 on a wine I knew would be fantastic.
Is that the Napa or Alexander Valley?
Napa. Actually, I've seen the 99 and the 2000 vintage in wide ranges, from 110-150. I've never bought in online, where you'd likely find it cheaper, but will have to pay shipping charges of $6-10/bottle, if you bought in quantity.
I prefer the Alexander Valley over the Napa. Otherwise I have the '01 Alexander and '00 Napa, and '01 Napa which I received as a gift. I also have the only wine that Silver Oak makes that isn't Cabernet and doesn't have the Silver Oak name on it.

What is it?
I knew this once. I have a buddy who's been to both their vineyards. Do tell.
 
Question for those of you that are into simply collecting wine for the sake of collecting it, and I don't mean this to be rude, just curious. What exactly do you get out of having a certian 1989 Shiraz say if you have no intention of drinking it or sharing it with friends ? Are you buying it as an investment or just to say that you have it ?

I guess we'll I can understand discovering a good wine and wanting to buy it to enjoy I just don't get collecting it for the sake of collecting it.
No one who's paying attention "collects" wine. Many French wines are not ready to drink, but are priced to buy. When most good wines are "ready" they are significantly more expensive. Sure, you lose some before they get good due to cork issues, or they just plain never get good. The other reason I have wine in the cellar is because the good ones sell out. I don't want to have to buy wine off an auction site later becuase I didn't buy enough to store.Take a 1999 Silver Oak, about $150 in a store. I bought 4-5 bottles 2-3 years ago and paid less than $60/bottle. That's not "collecting", that's saving $300 on a wine I knew would be fantastic.
Is that the Napa or Alexander Valley?
Napa. Actually, I've seen the 99 and the 2000 vintage in wide ranges, from 110-150. I've never bought in online, where you'd likely find it cheaper, but will have to pay shipping charges of $6-10/bottle, if you bought in quantity.
I prefer the Alexander Valley over the Napa. Otherwise I have the '01 Alexander and '00 Napa, and '01 Napa which I received as a gift. I also have the only wine that Silver Oak makes that isn't Cabernet and doesn't have the Silver Oak name on it.

What is it?
I knew this once. I have a buddy who's been to both their vineyards. Do tell.
Merlot? Toomey?
 
Trying to get my hands on this right now.

POGGIO ANTICO BRUNELLO DI MONTALCINO 1999

DOCG

700377 (XD) 750 mL $ 62

Tasting note: Aromatic and fruity, with hints of flowers and perfume. Very generous. Full-bodied, with silky and caressing tannins and a long, long finish. Wonderful. Best after 2006. Score - 95. (James Suckling, www.winespectator.com, May 15, 2005)

 
Trying to get my hands on this right now.

POGGIO ANTICO BRUNELLO DI MONTALCINO 1999

DOCG

700377 (XD) 750 mL $ 62

Tasting note: Aromatic and fruity, with hints of flowers and perfume. Very generous. Full-bodied, with silky and caressing tannins and a long, long finish. Wonderful. Best after 2006. Score - 95. (James Suckling, www.winespectator.com, May 15, 2005)
WLIs the $62 US?

 
Trying to get my hands on this right now.

POGGIO ANTICO BRUNELLO DI MONTALCINO  1999

DOCG  

700377   (XD)   750 mL    $  62  

Tasting note: Aromatic and fruity, with hints of flowers and perfume. Very generous. Full-bodied, with silky and caressing tannins and a long, long finish. Wonderful. Best after 2006.  Score - 95.  (James Suckling, www.winespectator.com, May 15, 2005)
WLIs the $62 US?
Canadian. Different label.The one you show I can't find.

 
Last edited by a moderator:
Since we have started talking about the Alexander Valley, are any of you familiar with the Alexander Valley Vineyards (AVV)? I love their merlot, and they also make a nice Gewurz, Cab, Syrah, & Pinot. I highly recommend checking them out! They label is boring, which means most of America doesn't drink their stuff, but I find them to be exceptional value wines ($10-$20).

AVV Wines

 
Another reason to buy and store your own wine is the exorbitant mark up in restaurants.

We do lots of client dinners, and the wine bill can get $$$. I'd much rather pay whatever their corking fee is and bring my own. For example, this past weekend, we had a dinner party of 6. That's three bottles of win if everyone drinks 2-3 glasses over 3 hours. We were going to Ruth's Chris, and I brought the wine. 1) Caymus Conundrum, 2) Barnett Pinot Noir, 3) Sherwin Family Cabernet. I'd paid maybe $125 total for those 3 bottles of win. Add in the corking charges, and it was $150 total for 6 people to drink wine at dinner. Just for kicks, I looked at the wine list. While it was impressive in it's depth, it was sickening in it's prices. 2003 Shafer "Relentless" was being sold for $115. I have 4 bottles I bought for $55 each. The Conundrum was double what I'd paid for it. And while the Barnett wasn't on the list, a comparable Pinot Noir was $100.

So not only did I have the satifaction of knowing we were going to have spectacular wine, we had it for at least half of what we'd have paid if we'd have bought it in a restaurant.

 
Question for those of you that are into simply collecting wine for the sake of collecting it, and I don't mean this to be rude, just curious. What exactly do you get out of having a certian 1989 Shiraz say if you have no intention of drinking it or sharing it with friends ? Are you buying it as an investment or just to say that you have it ?

I guess we'll I can understand discovering a good wine and wanting to buy it to enjoy I just don't get collecting it for the sake of collecting it.
No one who's paying attention "collects" wine. Many French wines are not ready to drink, but are priced to buy. When most good wines are "ready" they are significantly more expensive. Sure, you lose some before they get good due to cork issues, or they just plain never get good. The other reason I have wine in the cellar is because the good ones sell out. I don't want to have to buy wine off an auction site later becuase I didn't buy enough to store.Take a 1999 Silver Oak, about $150 in a store. I bought 4-5 bottles 2-3 years ago and paid less than $60/bottle. That's not "collecting", that's saving $300 on a wine I knew would be fantastic.
:goodposting: This explains it pretty well. As soon as new vintages are released for sale, you can buy them directly from the vineyard in many cases. If you know what you like and who's making very good wine, you can get in early and save a lot of cash for top notch wine. In the late 1990's, Silver Oak had an amazing run of exceptional wine. There was a time when you could buy their bottles for $40-80, depending on exactly when and where you were. Today, those wines are hitting their peak, and are easily $150 in stores, twice that in restaurants. However, with that success, Silver Oak has gotten pricier, and it's harder to get good value out of their new releases. And because they set the bar so high in the late 1990's, many of their new releases are getting as good of a buzz as the 1990's stuff did.

Horror story about good wine and storage. The oenophile who introduced us to wine in Napa this past summer has been at it for 30+ years, and remembers the days when "American" wine was Blue Nun and Cold Duck. Anyway, he's been at it a while, and collected hard throughout much of the 1990's. Cases of Silver Oak, 1995-2000. Cases of Châteaneuf-du-Pape he'd bought when in France for several weeks. Had an exceptionally good wine storage unit - 400-500 bottle capacity with variable temp regions - and was building a new house with a basement cellar. He'd been away for business for a week or so, and returned to a strange smell. He went to the room where his wine unit was, and it had malfunctioned and was STEAMING hot throughout the unit. Many bottles had popped their cork. 400-500 bottle of wine colelcted across a decade, ruined. :hot:

He still gets upset talking about it. :cry:
There used to be the Minnesota Club in downtown St. Paul. Right next to the James J Hill library, Ordway theater, and old Roy Wilkins. It is now the 317 Club and owned by the Minnesota Wild. Back in '96 or 97, after I had left working there they had some lady who was a bartender. One VERY COLD Saturday January evening she cracked open the window ever so slightly because some of the members were there on enight smoking cigars. Now these are windows that swing in and out, not up and down. When she closed she didn't latch the window closed and the window blew open to that VERY COLD January evening. The Club was closed Sunday and Monday. They came in on Tuesday to a frozen bar and guess where they kept the nice red wines. In a controlled temp cabinet in the bar. Lafite-Rothchilds, Margeaux, Latour, La Louviere, St. Emilion, etc... All of them had froze and corks popped off and wine was all over the cabinet, all over everything. Frozen red winesicles hung from the cabinet door.
 
Another reason to buy and store your own wine is the exorbitant mark up in restaurants.

We do lots of client dinners, and the wine bill can get $$$. I'd much rather pay whatever their corking fee is and bring my own. For example, this past weekend, we had a dinner party of 6. That's three bottles of win if everyone drinks 2-3 glasses over 3 hours. We were going to Ruth's Chris, and I brought the wine. 1) Caymus Conundrum, 2) Barnett Pinot Noir, 3) Sherwin Family Cabernet. I'd paid maybe $125 total for those 3 bottles of win. Add in the corking charges, and it was $150 total for 6 people to drink wine at dinner. Just for kicks, I looked at the wine list. While it was impressive in it's depth, it was sickening in it's prices. 2003 Shafer "Relentless" was being sold for $115. I have 4 bottles I bought for $55 each. The Conundrum was double what I'd paid for it. And while the Barnett wasn't on the list, a comparable Pinot Noir was $100.

So not only did I have the satifaction of knowing we were going to have spectacular wine, we had it for at least half of what we'd have paid if we'd have bought it in a restaurant.
:hot: :bag: We have to mark it up, it's the cost of doing business. I only mark things up $15-$20 per bottle, and my list is well below the industry standards for $. Also, when someone brings in their own wine, the waiter immediately knows he won't be making as much on this party and will more than likely give you worse service. I don't think it is the right approach for the waiter, but you are cutting into their livelyhood.

 
Last edited by a moderator:
Since we have started talking about the Alexander Valley, are any of you familiar with the Alexander Valley Vineyards (AVV)? I love their merlot, and they also make a nice Gewurz, Cab, Syrah, & Pinot. I highly recommend checking them out! They label is boring, which means most of America doesn't drink their stuff, but I find them to be exceptional value wines ($10-$20).

AVV Wines
I bought a case of the cabernet for $11 a bottle for an everday wine. Good value wine.
 
Question for those of you that are into simply collecting wine for the sake of collecting it, and I don't mean this to be rude, just curious.  What exactly do you get out of having a certian 1989 Shiraz say if you have no intention of drinking it or sharing it with friends ?  Are you buying it as an investment or just to say that you have it ?

I guess we'll I can understand discovering a good wine and wanting to buy it to enjoy I just don't get collecting it for the sake of collecting it.
No one who's paying attention "collects" wine. Many French wines are not ready to drink, but are priced to buy. When most good wines are "ready" they are significantly more expensive. Sure, you lose some before they get good due to cork issues, or they just plain never get good. The other reason I have wine in the cellar is because the good ones sell out. I don't want to have to buy wine off an auction site later becuase I didn't buy enough to store.Take a 1999 Silver Oak, about $150 in a store. I bought 4-5 bottles 2-3 years ago and paid less than $60/bottle. That's not "collecting", that's saving $300 on a wine I knew would be fantastic.
:goodposting: This explains it pretty well. As soon as new vintages are released for sale, you can buy them directly from the vineyard in many cases. If you know what you like and who's making very good wine, you can get in early and save a lot of cash for top notch wine. In the late 1990's, Silver Oak had an amazing run of exceptional wine. There was a time when you could buy their bottles for $40-80, depending on exactly when and where you were. Today, those wines are hitting their peak, and are easily $150 in stores, twice that in restaurants. However, with that success, Silver Oak has gotten pricier, and it's harder to get good value out of their new releases. And because they set the bar so high in the late 1990's, many of their new releases are getting as good of a buzz as the 1990's stuff did.

Horror story about good wine and storage. The oenophile who introduced us to wine in Napa this past summer has been at it for 30+ years, and remembers the days when "American" wine was Blue Nun and Cold Duck. Anyway, he's been at it a while, and collected hard throughout much of the 1990's. Cases of Silver Oak, 1995-2000. Cases of Châteaneuf-du-Pape he'd bought when in France for several weeks. Had an exceptionally good wine storage unit - 400-500 bottle capacity with variable temp regions - and was building a new house with a basement cellar. He'd been away for business for a week or so, and returned to a strange smell. He went to the room where his wine unit was, and it had malfunctioned and was STEAMING hot throughout the unit. Many bottles had popped their cork. 400-500 bottle of wine colelcted across a decade, ruined. :hot:

He still gets upset talking about it. :cry:
There used to be the Minnesota Club in downtown St. Paul. Right next to the James J Hill library, Ordway theater, and old Roy Wilkins. It is now the 317 Club and owned by the Minnesota Wild. Back in '96 or 97, after I had left working there they had some lady who was a bartender. One VERY COLD Saturday January evening she cracked open the window ever so slightly because some of the members were there on enight smoking cigars. Now these are windows that swing in and out, not up and down. When she closed she didn't latch the window closed and the window blew open to that VERY COLD January evening. The Club was closed Sunday and Monday. They came in on Tuesday to a frozen bar and guess where they kept the nice red wines. In a controlled temp cabinet in the bar. Lafite-Rothchilds, Margeaux, Latour, La Louviere, St. Emilion, etc... All of them had froze and corks popped off and wine was all over the cabinet, all over everything. Frozen red winesicles hung from the cabinet door.
Ugh. I am pretty sure that made baby Jeebus cry. We are building a new house. After our trip to Napa and hearing our friend's experience, we designed a cellar in our basement. Surrounded on three sides by earth, and room for several hundred bottles. Bought our first case of Shafer (1/2 last chance firebreak and 1/2 cab) to christen it, and a case of Sherwin Family is on the way. :thumbup:

 
Question for those of you that are into simply collecting wine for the sake of collecting it, and I don't mean this to be rude, just curious. What exactly do you get out of having a certian 1989 Shiraz say if you have no intention of drinking it or sharing it with friends ? Are you buying it as an investment or just to say that you have it ?

I guess we'll I can understand discovering a good wine and wanting to buy it to enjoy I just don't get collecting it for the sake of collecting it.
No one who's paying attention "collects" wine. Many French wines are not ready to drink, but are priced to buy. When most good wines are "ready" they are significantly more expensive. Sure, you lose some before they get good due to cork issues, or they just plain never get good. The other reason I have wine in the cellar is because the good ones sell out. I don't want to have to buy wine off an auction site later becuase I didn't buy enough to store.Take a 1999 Silver Oak, about $150 in a store. I bought 4-5 bottles 2-3 years ago and paid less than $60/bottle. That's not "collecting", that's saving $300 on a wine I knew would be fantastic.
Is that the Napa or Alexander Valley?
Napa. Actually, I've seen the 99 and the 2000 vintage in wide ranges, from 110-150. I've never bought in online, where you'd likely find it cheaper, but will have to pay shipping charges of $6-10/bottle, if you bought in quantity.
I prefer the Alexander Valley over the Napa. Otherwise I have the '01 Alexander and '00 Napa, and '01 Napa which I received as a gift. I also have the only wine that Silver Oak makes that isn't Cabernet and doesn't have the Silver Oak name on it.

What is it?
I knew this once. I have a buddy who's been to both their vineyards. Do tell.
Merlot? Toomey?
Correctamundo!
 
Question for those of you that are into simply collecting wine for the sake of collecting it, and I don't mean this to be rude, just curious. What exactly do you get out of having a certian 1989 Shiraz say if you have no intention of drinking it or sharing it with friends ? Are you buying it as an investment or just to say that you have it ?

I guess we'll I can understand discovering a good wine and wanting to buy it to enjoy I just don't get collecting it for the sake of collecting it.
It's all personal difference or personal philosophy. Scupper and Jules probably differ in the way they buy from proninja and myself, who differ from you or tipsey. Like anything else you own in life, it's nice to be able to say to someone you encounter, "I have a <insert item of prestige here> sitting at home." But mostly people buy with the intention of drinking it down the road when the wine has matured. They want to try the best wines at their peak.Some of it can be sentiment. I've got a bottle of '97 Fife Zinfandel that probably cost $15 when it was released, it's pretty much on it's downward slope now, yet I can't bring myself to open it because it's the last one of a half-case I bought after my wife and I fell in love with it on a trip for our first anniversary.

I enjoy wine, but I'm not willing to put the kind of money into it that Jules and Scupper seem to be. While they're trying wines I would love to try and will have some great ones to drink down the road, I probably have a different personal philosophy on it than they do.

We just started to really apprecaite wine about 6-7 years ago, and it's something we kept up with because it basically became one of the few shared hobbies my wife and I have. On a day-to-day basis, most of the wine I drink is in the $15-$25 range, and I save most my higher-$ purchases for special occasions or trips to wine country.

This is the first year in 5 or 6 that my wife and I have not made a trip to Napa, Sonoma, or the Mendocino area. Often times while there, we would find a wine we liked that was worthy of cellaring, and we'd pick up two bottles - one to drink in the near future and one to put away for 5, 7, 10 years, whatever. I normally just pick up an extra bottle rather than a case/half-case. Some of that is a product of income. I could afford to buy more or to drink better wines on a daily basis, but I'd have to sacrifice other things to do so. And I'm not willing to do that just for wine.

As opposed to Jules 400+, I've got a wine fridge that holds about 60 bottles. It's stocked to the gills right now, and some of the first wines we bought to hold for a while will start coming out after my daughter is born in June/July. Most of those bottles won't be Brunellos or Shafer wines or wineries at the tips of most people's tongues (A number of ours are from places like Peju, Del Dotto, Sullivan, Summers, Hall, Zahtila, Cosentino) - just bottles we encountered during our trips to wine country, really enjoyed, and we'll pull them out and reminisce over this trip or that trip. I think it's all just about personal preference.

 
Question for those of you that are into simply collecting wine for the sake of collecting it, and I don't mean this to be rude, just curious. What exactly do you get out of having a certian 1989 Shiraz say if you have no intention of drinking it or sharing it with friends ? Are you buying it as an investment or just to say that you have it ?

I guess we'll I can understand discovering a good wine and wanting to buy it to enjoy I just don't get collecting it for the sake of collecting it.
No one who's paying attention "collects" wine. Many French wines are not ready to drink, but are priced to buy. When most good wines are "ready" they are significantly more expensive. Sure, you lose some before they get good due to cork issues, or they just plain never get good. The other reason I have wine in the cellar is because the good ones sell out. I don't want to have to buy wine off an auction site later becuase I didn't buy enough to store.Take a 1999 Silver Oak, about $150 in a store. I bought 4-5 bottles 2-3 years ago and paid less than $60/bottle. That's not "collecting", that's saving $300 on a wine I knew would be fantastic.
:goodposting: This explains it pretty well. As soon as new vintages are released for sale, you can buy them directly from the vineyard in many cases. If you know what you like and who's making very good wine, you can get in early and save a lot of cash for top notch wine. In the late 1990's, Silver Oak had an amazing run of exceptional wine. There was a time when you could buy their bottles for $40-80, depending on exactly when and where you were. Today, those wines are hitting their peak, and are easily $150 in stores, twice that in restaurants. However, with that success, Silver Oak has gotten pricier, and it's harder to get good value out of their new releases. And because they set the bar so high in the late 1990's, many of their new releases are getting as good of a buzz as the 1990's stuff did.

Horror story about good wine and storage. The oenophile who introduced us to wine in Napa this past summer has been at it for 30+ years, and remembers the days when "American" wine was Blue Nun and Cold Duck. Anyway, he's been at it a while, and collected hard throughout much of the 1990's. Cases of Silver Oak, 1995-2000. Cases of Châteaneuf-du-Pape he'd bought when in France for several weeks. Had an exceptionally good wine storage unit - 400-500 bottle capacity with variable temp regions - and was building a new house with a basement cellar. He'd been away for business for a week or so, and returned to a strange smell. He went to the room where his wine unit was, and it had malfunctioned and was STEAMING hot throughout the unit. Many bottles had popped their cork. 400-500 bottle of wine colelcted across a decade, ruined. :hot:

He still gets upset talking about it. :cry:
There used to be the Minnesota Club in downtown St. Paul. Right next to the James J Hill library, Ordway theater, and old Roy Wilkins. It is now the 317 Club and owned by the Minnesota Wild. Back in '96 or 97, after I had left working there they had some lady who was a bartender. One VERY COLD Saturday January evening she cracked open the window ever so slightly because some of the members were there on enight smoking cigars. Now these are windows that swing in and out, not up and down. When she closed she didn't latch the window closed and the window blew open to that VERY COLD January evening. The Club was closed Sunday and Monday. They came in on Tuesday to a frozen bar and guess where they kept the nice red wines. In a controlled temp cabinet in the bar. Lafite-Rothchilds, Margeaux, Latour, La Louviere, St. Emilion, etc... All of them had froze and corks popped off and wine was all over the cabinet, all over everything. Frozen red winesicles hung from the cabinet door.
Ugh. I am pretty sure that made baby Jeebus cry. We are building a new house. After our trip to Napa and hearing our friend's experience, we designed a cellar in our basement. Surrounded on three sides by earth, and room for several hundred bottles. Bought our first case of Shafer (1/2 last chance firebreak and 1/2 cab) to christen it, and a case of Sherwin Family is on the way. :thumbup:
Try having the entire cities wine inventory (ie several of the local distributors) have their wine sit in flooded warehouses in 95 degree heat for a month or two. At the restaurant alone, we lost an estimated $7k of wine destroyed (or drank during evac :ph34r: ). One guy who had one of the best private collections in the city had his inventory thrown to the street by the cold storage facility only a week after the storm (ie the wine was still good at that point) because they decided all refridge units had to be emptied. :wall: He is suing the piss out of them currently.
 
Another reason to buy and store your own wine is the exorbitant mark up in restaurants.

We do lots of client dinners, and the wine bill can get $$$. I'd much rather pay whatever their corking fee is and bring my own. For example, this past weekend, we had a dinner party of 6. That's three bottles of win if everyone drinks 2-3 glasses over 3 hours. We were going to Ruth's Chris, and I brought the wine. 1) Caymus Conundrum, 2) Barnett Pinot Noir, 3) Sherwin Family Cabernet. I'd paid maybe $125 total for those 3 bottles of win. Add in the corking charges, and it was $150 total for 6 people to drink wine at dinner. Just for kicks, I looked at the wine list. While it was impressive in it's depth, it was sickening in it's prices. 2003 Shafer "Relentless" was being sold for $115. I have 4 bottles I bought for $55 each. The Conundrum was double what I'd paid for it. And while the Barnett wasn't on the list, a comparable Pinot Noir was $100.

So not only did I have the satifaction of knowing we were going to have spectacular wine, we had it for at least half of what we'd have paid if we'd have bought it in a restaurant.
:hot: :bag: We have to mark it up, it's the cost of doing business. I only mark things up $15-$20 per bottle, and my list is well below the industry standards for $. Also, when someone brings in their own wine, the waiter immediately knows he won't be making as much on this party and will more than likely give you worse service. I don't think it is the right approach for the waiter, but you are cutting into their livelyhood.
:shrug: Our service was very good, and we tipped 20% on a $300+ tab. There was no way I was going to pay those prices for wine, so we'd have likely done without if I hadn't brought my own. Some places are more cool about it than others, as is evideced by their corking fee. But if you don't want people bringing their own, then a) don't mark up 100-200% across the board the way they were, and b) charge a ridiculously high corking fee. The 2003 Relentless at $115 wasn't the worst offender. They had Dolce from Far Niente as a desert wine at $175 for a 375ml bottle when we paid $75 at the vineyard, and I've seen it in stores for $80.
 
Another reason to buy and store your own wine is the exorbitant mark up in restaurants.

We do lots of client dinners, and the wine bill can get $$$. I'd much rather pay whatever their corking fee is and bring my own. For example, this past weekend, we had a dinner party of 6. That's three bottles of win if everyone drinks 2-3 glasses over 3 hours. We were going to Ruth's Chris, and I brought the wine. 1) Caymus Conundrum, 2) Barnett Pinot Noir, 3) Sherwin Family Cabernet. I'd paid maybe $125 total for those 3 bottles of win. Add in the corking charges, and it was $150 total for 6 people to drink wine at dinner. Just for kicks, I looked at the wine list. While it was impressive in it's depth, it was sickening in it's prices. 2003 Shafer "Relentless" was being sold for $115. I have 4 bottles I bought for $55 each. The Conundrum was double what I'd paid for it. And while the Barnett wasn't on the list, a comparable Pinot Noir was $100.

So not only did I have the satifaction of knowing we were going to have spectacular wine, we had it for at least half of what we'd have paid if we'd have bought it in a restaurant.
:hot: :bag: We have to mark it up, it's the cost of doing business. I only mark things up $15-$20 per bottle, and my list is well below the industry standards for $. Also, when someone brings in their own wine, the waiter immediately knows he won't be making as much on this party and will more than likely give you worse service. I don't think it is the right approach for the waiter, but you are cutting into their livelyhood.
:shrug: Our service was very good, and we tipped 20% on a $300+ tab. There was no way I was going to pay those prices for wine, so we'd have likely done without if I hadn't brought my own. Some places are more cool about it than others, as is evideced by their corking fee. But if you don't want people bringing their own, then a) don't mark up 100-200% across the board the way they were, and b) charge a ridiculously high corking fee. The 2003 Relentless at $115 wasn't the worst offender. They had Dolce from Far Niente as a desert wine at $175 for a 375ml bottle when we paid $75 at the vineyard, and I've seen it in stores for $80.
I'm glad they didn't give you the French waiter treatment. Do remember the waiter still took a hit from ya'll not tipping on wine sales....they typically don't get the corkage fee. I'm not saying you were in the wrong, but just giving you "our" perspective on the issue. As an GM, I just want you to leave happy. I'll sell my bottles to the next guy. :yes: I sell Caymus Cabernet for $70. I've seen it in the French Quarter for $120...same year. My corking fee is $10 per bottle, unless you let us taste it. :yes:

I have to make money off of it, but I too hate places that think having wine should include a trip to your banker. High end chain places do this alot. Why? Because they can.

 
I've tasted 12 pinot noirs this week, 8 cabs, 6 merlots, 8 zins, and a slew of chardonnays (by slew I mean at least 10) this week.

Saintsbury Brown Ranch Pinot Noir.  About $42 wholesale or $55 retail.

It is the single best Pinot I have tried all year. :yes:   :yes:   :yes:

BTW...don't expect much from the 2005 Napas...their rain this past fall could not have come at a worse time. (I've heard this from 3 different winemakers in the last month).

Drunk & going to bed.  :bye:
I'll look it up - But, I know I read somewhere that the latest vintages of Italian wines are nothing special - So, you wind up paying way too much for a Brunello that's still living off it's 98' 99' reputation.
That is such a blanketing statement abut Italian wines it is ridiculous. In its worst years you can find INCREDIBLE wines from Itlay if for no other reason than they make so much of it. There are hundreds of "Napa's" in Italy.

Brunello is one of thousands of wines made in Italy.
Very True... But, i believe it was the Wine Spectator and the Gist of the article was that it was MUCH harder to find the good one's and the past few years have had Horrible weather conditions to produce wines that can compete with the late 90's wines.....They're recomendation was to just try a different region that had a more favorable climate and condtions.....

I'll dig the article out when I get home anc ome back with more specifics..

 
Another reason to buy and store your own wine is the exorbitant mark up in restaurants.

We do lots of client dinners, and the wine bill can get $$$. I'd much rather pay whatever their corking fee is and bring my own. For example, this past weekend, we had a dinner party of 6. That's three bottles of win if everyone drinks 2-3 glasses over 3 hours. We were going to Ruth's Chris, and I brought the wine. 1) Caymus Conundrum, 2) Barnett Pinot Noir, 3) Sherwin Family Cabernet. I'd paid maybe $125 total for those 3 bottles of win. Add in the corking charges, and it was $150 total for 6 people to drink wine at dinner. Just for kicks, I looked at the wine list. While it was impressive in it's depth, it was sickening in it's prices. 2003 Shafer "Relentless" was being sold for $115. I have 4 bottles I bought for $55 each. The Conundrum was double what I'd paid for it. And while the Barnett wasn't on the list, a comparable Pinot Noir was $100.

So not only did I have the satifaction of knowing we were going to have spectacular wine, we had it for at least half of what we'd have paid if we'd have bought it in a restaurant.
:hot: :bag: We have to mark it up, it's the cost of doing business. I only mark things up $15-$20 per bottle, and my list is well below the industry standards for $. Also, when someone brings in their own wine, the waiter immediately knows he won't be making as much on this party and will more than likely give you worse service. I don't think it is the right approach for the waiter, but you are cutting into their livelyhood.
:shrug: Our service was very good, and we tipped 20% on a $300+ tab. There was no way I was going to pay those prices for wine, so we'd have likely done without if I hadn't brought my own. Some places are more cool about it than others, as is evideced by their corking fee. But if you don't want people bringing their own, then a) don't mark up 100-200% across the board the way they were, and b) charge a ridiculously high corking fee. The 2003 Relentless at $115 wasn't the worst offender. They had Dolce from Far Niente as a desert wine at $175 for a 375ml bottle when we paid $75 at the vineyard, and I've seen it in stores for $80.
I'm glad they didn't give you the French waiter treatment. Do remember the waiter still took a hit from ya'll not tipping on wine sales....they typically don't get the corkage fee. I'm not saying you were in the wrong, but just giving you "our" perspective on the issue. As an GM, I just want you to leave happy. I'll sell my bottles to the next guy. :yes: I sell Caymus Cabernet for $70. I've seen it in the French Quarter for $120...same year. My corking fee is $10 per bottle, unless you let us taste it. :yes:

I have to make money off of it, but I too hate places that think having wine should include a trip to your banker. High end chain places do this alot. Why? Because they can.
I see this at one of my more frequented restaurants I go to. The lowest price for a bottle on their list is $20. I know this wine cost them $7. They have a majority of their wines in the $20-28 range. I figure these are the $7-10 bottles. They sell a lot of these bottles every night. The GM said they sell these at a 4-1 ratio over the spendier wines. The spendier ones they have aren't marked up the same way as the less expensive ones. They have a 1999 Opus One that they paid $107 for and they are selling it for $175. The '00 Silver Oak Napa is going for $170 and it cost them about $75. The '01 Alexander Valley for $110 and they paid $45 for it. Like I say , I really think the Alexander Valley is the better of the two. The '02 Turley Zinfandel is $180, the '02 Altamura is going for $100. They used to sell the '01 for $80. That was a bargain! I used to drink their '01 Franciscan "Oakville Estates" Cab for $30. That was a good deal.
 
I'm all about the corking fee as well, because I may not run into a bottle of wine on their list that I know I'm going to enjoy as well as the fact that I'm going to have to pay the huge markup.

I've got no problem with businesspeople making a profit on the items they sell, but when they mark it up 200%, sometimes it gets out of the range in which I think it's worth it.
Don't want to pay $15 for that Bartel & James huh? ;)
 
I'm all about the corking fee as well, because I may not run into a bottle of wine on their list that I know I'm going to enjoy as well as the fact that I'm going to have to pay the huge markup.

I've got no problem with businesspeople making a profit on the items they sell, but when they mark it up 200%, sometimes it gets out of the range in which I think it's worth it.
Don't want to pay $15 for that Bartel & James huh? ;)
Do they still have those Sun Country 2 liter jugs of wine coolers?
 
Last edited by a moderator:
I'm all about the corking fee as well, because I may not run into a bottle of wine on their list that I know I'm going to enjoy as well as the fact that I'm going to have to pay the huge markup.

I've got no problem with businesspeople making a profit on the items they sell, but when they mark it up 200%, sometimes it gets out of the range in which I think it's worth it.
Don't want to pay $15 for that Bartel & James huh? ;)
Do they still have those Sun Country 2 liter jugs of wine coolers?
This brings back bad memories from last month. My family has never been into wine, at all. Cab = the yellow car that picks you up from the airport. However, they've seen our pics from Napa and have heard us talk about wine, and know that I am getting into it. I got a decanter for Christmas last year, and a carrying case for wine, so they know about my budding taste for wine. So, last month I went to visit them for a few days, and we had dinner at a friend of theirs house. I've never met the guy, but my sister tells me he's a serious wine drinker and we'll have lots to talk about. Cool, I think to myself. I'm still very much a noob, and love learning, so we'll chat and compare favorite stories.

We get to the guy's house, and it's a nice country spread. He's out back getting the grill fired up, and when we walk in, he immediately offers everyone their favorite beverage. For my sister he's got ice cold Diet Coke, and for my BIL (who likes dark beer), he's got Newcastle. After getting them all squared away, he turns to me.

"Ahhh. You must be the wine drinker! Nice to meet you. I've got us set up out by the pool."

As we walk out to his pool area, I see the wine we've got in store for the evening. Sitting in the middle of a 5 gallon bucket of ice are two magnums - one white, one red - of Kendall Jackson Grocery Store quality Table Wines. Of course, knowing I am the big wine drinker, he pours me a heaping glass of ice cold red wine, and toasts. :X

Luckily, he was loaded so I could get away with barely drinking any and pouring it in the bushes while nobody was looking. Apparently, my sister's version of "big wine drinker" is a large man who gets bombed on cheap wine.

 
I'm all about the corking fee as well, because I may not run into a bottle of wine on their list that I know I'm going to enjoy as well as the fact that I'm going to have to pay the huge markup.

I've got no problem with businesspeople making a profit on the items they sell, but when they mark it up 200%, sometimes it gets out of the range in which I think it's worth it.
Don't want to pay $15 for that Bartel & James huh? ;)
Do they still have those Sun Country 2 liter jugs of wine coolers?
This brings back bad memories from last month. My family has never been into wine, at all. Cab = the yellow car that picks you up from the airport. However, they've seen our pics from Napa and have heard us talk about wine, and know that I am getting into it. I got a decanter for Christmas last year, and a carrying case for wine, so they know about my budding taste for wine. So, last month I went to visit them for a few days, and we had dinner at a friend of theirs house. I've never met the guy, but my sister tells me he's a serious wine drinker and we'll have lots to talk about. Cool, I think to myself. I'm still very much a noob, and love learning, so we'll chat and compare favorite stories.

We get to the guy's house, and it's a nice country spread. He's out back getting the grill fired up, and when we walk in, he immediately offers everyone their favorite beverage. For my sister he's got ice cold Diet Coke, and for my BIL (who likes dark beer), he's got Newcastle. After getting them all squared away, he turns to me.

"Ahhh. You must be the wine drinker! Nice to meet you. I've got us set up out by the pool."

As we walk out to his pool area, I see the wine we've got in store for the evening. Sitting in the middle of a 5 gallon bucket of ice are two magnums - one white, one red - of Kendall Jackson Grocery Store quality Table Wines. Of course, knowing I am the big wine drinker, he pours me a heaping glass of ice cold red wine, and toasts. :X

Luckily, he was loaded so I could get away with barely drinking any and pouring it in the bushes while nobody was looking. Apparently, my sister's version of "big wine drinker" is a large man who gets bombed on cheap wine.
Actually, some of the Kendall Jackson wines are highly regarded. You might have just self- :own3d: I know Robert Parker gave some of them 90+ points.

 
I'm all about the corking fee as well, because I may not run into a bottle of wine on their list that I know I'm going to enjoy as well as the fact that I'm going to have to pay the huge markup.

I've got no problem with businesspeople making a profit on the items they sell, but when they mark it up 200%, sometimes it gets out of the range in which I think it's worth it.
Don't want to pay $15 for that Bartel & James huh? ;)
Do they still have those Sun Country 2 liter jugs of wine coolers?
This brings back bad memories from last month. My family has never been into wine, at all. Cab = the yellow car that picks you up from the airport. However, they've seen our pics from Napa and have heard us talk about wine, and know that I am getting into it. I got a decanter for Christmas last year, and a carrying case for wine, so they know about my budding taste for wine. So, last month I went to visit them for a few days, and we had dinner at a friend of theirs house. I've never met the guy, but my sister tells me he's a serious wine drinker and we'll have lots to talk about. Cool, I think to myself. I'm still very much a noob, and love learning, so we'll chat and compare favorite stories.

We get to the guy's house, and it's a nice country spread. He's out back getting the grill fired up, and when we walk in, he immediately offers everyone their favorite beverage. For my sister he's got ice cold Diet Coke, and for my BIL (who likes dark beer), he's got Newcastle. After getting them all squared away, he turns to me.

"Ahhh. You must be the wine drinker! Nice to meet you. I've got us set up out by the pool."

As we walk out to his pool area, I see the wine we've got in store for the evening. Sitting in the middle of a 5 gallon bucket of ice are two magnums - one white, one red - of Kendall Jackson Grocery Store quality Table Wines. Of course, knowing I am the big wine drinker, he pours me a heaping glass of ice cold red wine, and toasts. :X

Luckily, he was loaded so I could get away with barely drinking any and pouring it in the bushes while nobody was looking. Apparently, my sister's version of "big wine drinker" is a large man who gets bombed on cheap wine.
Actually, some of the Kendall Jackson wines are highly regarded. You might have just self- :own3d: I know Robert Parker gave some of them 90+ points.
Do you think Robert Parker tasted a glass of KJ red that had been sitting in a bucket of ice?
 
I'm all about the corking fee as well, because I may not run into a bottle of wine on their list that I know I'm going to enjoy as well as the fact that I'm going to have to pay the huge markup.

I've got no problem with businesspeople making a profit on the items they sell, but when they mark it up 200%, sometimes it gets out of the range in which I think it's worth it.
Don't want to pay $15 for that Bartel & James huh? ;)
Do they still have those Sun Country 2 liter jugs of wine coolers?
This brings back bad memories from last month. My family has never been into wine, at all. Cab = the yellow car that picks you up from the airport. However, they've seen our pics from Napa and have heard us talk about wine, and know that I am getting into it. I got a decanter for Christmas last year, and a carrying case for wine, so they know about my budding taste for wine. So, last month I went to visit them for a few days, and we had dinner at a friend of theirs house. I've never met the guy, but my sister tells me he's a serious wine drinker and we'll have lots to talk about. Cool, I think to myself. I'm still very much a noob, and love learning, so we'll chat and compare favorite stories.

We get to the guy's house, and it's a nice country spread. He's out back getting the grill fired up, and when we walk in, he immediately offers everyone their favorite beverage. For my sister he's got ice cold Diet Coke, and for my BIL (who likes dark beer), he's got Newcastle. After getting them all squared away, he turns to me.

"Ahhh. You must be the wine drinker! Nice to meet you. I've got us set up out by the pool."

As we walk out to his pool area, I see the wine we've got in store for the evening. Sitting in the middle of a 5 gallon bucket of ice are two magnums - one white, one red - of Kendall Jackson Grocery Store quality Table Wines. Of course, knowing I am the big wine drinker, he pours me a heaping glass of ice cold red wine, and toasts. :X

Luckily, he was loaded so I could get away with barely drinking any and pouring it in the bushes while nobody was looking. Apparently, my sister's version of "big wine drinker" is a large man who gets bombed on cheap wine.
Actually, some of the Kendall Jackson wines are highly regarded. You might have just self- :own3d: I know Robert Parker gave some of them 90+ points.
I know KJ makes some good wine. These were very clearly not them.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
I'm all about the corking fee as well, because I may not run into a bottle of wine on their list that I know I'm going to enjoy as well as the fact that I'm going to have to pay the huge markup.

I've got no problem with businesspeople making a profit on the items they sell, but when they mark it up 200%, sometimes it gets out of the range in which I think it's worth it.
Don't want to pay $15 for that Bartel & James huh? ;)
Do they still have those Sun Country 2 liter jugs of wine coolers?
This brings back bad memories from last month. My family has never been into wine, at all. Cab = the yellow car that picks you up from the airport. However, they've seen our pics from Napa and have heard us talk about wine, and know that I am getting into it. I got a decanter for Christmas last year, and a carrying case for wine, so they know about my budding taste for wine. So, last month I went to visit them for a few days, and we had dinner at a friend of theirs house. I've never met the guy, but my sister tells me he's a serious wine drinker and we'll have lots to talk about. Cool, I think to myself. I'm still very much a noob, and love learning, so we'll chat and compare favorite stories.

We get to the guy's house, and it's a nice country spread. He's out back getting the grill fired up, and when we walk in, he immediately offers everyone their favorite beverage. For my sister he's got ice cold Diet Coke, and for my BIL (who likes dark beer), he's got Newcastle. After getting them all squared away, he turns to me.

"Ahhh. You must be the wine drinker! Nice to meet you. I've got us set up out by the pool."

As we walk out to his pool area, I see the wine we've got in store for the evening. Sitting in the middle of a 5 gallon bucket of ice are two magnums - one white, one red - of Kendall Jackson Grocery Store quality Table Wines. Of course, knowing I am the big wine drinker, he pours me a heaping glass of ice cold red wine, and toasts. :X

Luckily, he was loaded so I could get away with barely drinking any and pouring it in the bushes while nobody was looking. Apparently, my sister's version of "big wine drinker" is a large man who gets bombed on cheap wine.
Actually, some of the Kendall Jackson wines are highly regarded. You might have just self- :own3d: I know Robert Parker gave some of them 90+ points.
Do you think Robert Parker tasted a glass of KJ red that had been sitting in a bucket of ice?
Probably not. I'm just saying, you can't always judge wine by the brand alone.
 
There's nothing about SIL phone sex in here. :(
I never thought wine would be so boring.We do they delete stuff like that.

If there is 1 offensive post....remove it.

Why ruin for everyone?

 
Question for those of you that are into simply collecting wine for the sake of collecting it, and I don't mean this to be rude, just curious.  What exactly do you get out of having a certian 1989 Shiraz say if you have no intention of drinking it or sharing it with friends ?  Are you buying it as an investment or just to say that you have it ?

I guess we'll I can understand discovering a good wine and wanting to buy it to enjoy I just don't get collecting it for the sake of collecting it.
It's all personal difference or personal philosophy. Scupper and Jules probably differ in the way they buy from proninja and myself, who differ from you or tipsey. Like anything else you own in life, it's nice to be able to say to someone you encounter, "I have a <insert item of prestige here> sitting at home." But mostly people buy with the intention of drinking it down the road when the wine has matured. They want to try the best wines at their peak.Some of it can be sentiment. I've got a bottle of '97 Fife Zinfandel that probably cost $15 when it was released, it's pretty much on it's downward slope now, yet I can't bring myself to open it because it's the last one of a half-case I bought after my wife and I fell in love with it on a trip for our first anniversary.

I enjoy wine, but I'm not willing to put the kind of money into it that Jules and Scupper seem to be. While they're trying wines I would love to try and will have some great ones to drink down the road, I probably have a different personal philosophy on it than they do.

We just started to really apprecaite wine about 6-7 years ago, and it's something we kept up with because it basically became one of the few shared hobbies my wife and I have. On a day-to-day basis, most of the wine I drink is in the $15-$25 range, and I save most my higher-$ purchases for special occasions or trips to wine country.

This is the first year in 5 or 6 that my wife and I have not made a trip to Napa, Sonoma, or the Mendocino area. Often times while there, we would find a wine we liked that was worthy of cellaring, and we'd pick up two bottles - one to drink in the near future and one to put away for 5, 7, 10 years, whatever. I normally just pick up an extra bottle rather than a case/half-case. Some of that is a product of income. I could afford to buy more or to drink better wines on a daily basis, but I'd have to sacrifice other things to do so. And I'm not willing to do that just for wine.

As opposed to Jules 400+, I've got a wine fridge that holds about 60 bottles. It's stocked to the gills right now, and some of the first wines we bought to hold for a while will start coming out after my daughter is born in June/July. Most of those bottles won't be Brunellos or Shafer wines or wineries at the tips of most people's tongues (A number of ours are from places like Peju, Del Dotto, Sullivan, Summers, Hall, Zahtila, Cosentino) - just bottles we encountered during our trips to wine country, really enjoyed, and we'll pull them out and reminisce over this trip or that trip. I think it's all just about personal preference.
You're a beautiful man, Bob, an incredibly beautiful man. Have heard good things about a couple of those wines you listed but haven't tried them. Had someone tell me to visit Del Dotto last time I went through Napa but I ran out of time on the trip and didn't get a chance to locate it.

 
Question for those of you that are into simply collecting wine for the sake of collecting it, and I don't mean this to be rude, just curious.  What exactly do you get out of having a certian 1989 Shiraz say if you have no intention of drinking it or sharing it with friends ?  Are you buying it as an investment or just to say that you have it ?

I guess we'll I can understand discovering a good wine and wanting to buy it to enjoy I just don't get collecting it for the sake of collecting it.
It's all personal difference or personal philosophy. Scupper and Jules probably differ in the way they buy from proninja and myself, who differ from you or tipsey. Like anything else you own in life, it's nice to be able to say to someone you encounter, "I have a <insert item of prestige here> sitting at home." But mostly people buy with the intention of drinking it down the road when the wine has matured. They want to try the best wines at their peak.Some of it can be sentiment. I've got a bottle of '97 Fife Zinfandel that probably cost $15 when it was released, it's pretty much on it's downward slope now, yet I can't bring myself to open it because it's the last one of a half-case I bought after my wife and I fell in love with it on a trip for our first anniversary.

I enjoy wine, but I'm not willing to put the kind of money into it that Jules and Scupper seem to be. While they're trying wines I would love to try and will have some great ones to drink down the road, I probably have a different personal philosophy on it than they do.

We just started to really apprecaite wine about 6-7 years ago, and it's something we kept up with because it basically became one of the few shared hobbies my wife and I have. On a day-to-day basis, most of the wine I drink is in the $15-$25 range, and I save most my higher-$ purchases for special occasions or trips to wine country.

This is the first year in 5 or 6 that my wife and I have not made a trip to Napa, Sonoma, or the Mendocino area. Often times while there, we would find a wine we liked that was worthy of cellaring, and we'd pick up two bottles - one to drink in the near future and one to put away for 5, 7, 10 years, whatever. I normally just pick up an extra bottle rather than a case/half-case. Some of that is a product of income. I could afford to buy more or to drink better wines on a daily basis, but I'd have to sacrifice other things to do so. And I'm not willing to do that just for wine.

As opposed to Jules 400+, I've got a wine fridge that holds about 60 bottles. It's stocked to the gills right now, and some of the first wines we bought to hold for a while will start coming out after my daughter is born in June/July. Most of those bottles won't be Brunellos or Shafer wines or wineries at the tips of most people's tongues (A number of ours are from places like Peju, Del Dotto, Sullivan, Summers, Hall, Zahtila, Cosentino) - just bottles we encountered during our trips to wine country, really enjoyed, and we'll pull them out and reminisce over this trip or that trip. I think it's all just about personal preference.
You're a beautiful man, Bob, an incredibly beautiful man. Have heard good things about a couple of those wines you listed but haven't tried them. Had someone tell me to visit Del Dotto last time I went through Napa but I ran out of time on the trip and didn't get a chance to locate it.
:lmao: You didn't look at the pictures that closely, did you?Del Dotto's cave tour/tasting is the best value of any of the wineries I've hit in Napa. It's pricey at upwards of $40, but seeing the caves is cool. And the way they do their tasting is outstanding. It starts as a barrel tasting. While you're touring the cave, they'll stop at one of their wines and thief two samples, one of a wine aged in a Missouri barrel and another of the exact same wine that's been aging in a French barrel. It's intereesting to get an idea of what the different barrels do to the wines. Almost unanimously the women preferred the French barrel aging and the men preferred the Missouri. They don't tell until afterwards which came from which.

At any rate, you taste a LOT of wines in the barrel tasting. And if you wish, you can grab tags detailing which wines you tried and buy futures on them as you leave. After that they take you to their conference room and pull out bottles of their current releases, and you taste them. You will leave there half in the bag. And all their wines are outstanding. Best American Sangiovese I've had.

 
Question for those of you that are into simply collecting wine for the sake of collecting it, and I don't mean this to be rude, just curious. What exactly do you get out of having a certian 1989 Shiraz say if you have no intention of drinking it or sharing it with friends ? Are you buying it as an investment or just to say that you have it ?

I guess we'll I can understand discovering a good wine and wanting to buy it to enjoy I just don't get collecting it for the sake of collecting it.
It's all personal difference or personal philosophy. Scupper and Jules probably differ in the way they buy from proninja and myself, who differ from you or tipsey. Like anything else you own in life, it's nice to be able to say to someone you encounter, "I have a <insert item of prestige here> sitting at home." But mostly people buy with the intention of drinking it down the road when the wine has matured. They want to try the best wines at their peak.Some of it can be sentiment. I've got a bottle of '97 Fife Zinfandel that probably cost $15 when it was released, it's pretty much on it's downward slope now, yet I can't bring myself to open it because it's the last one of a half-case I bought after my wife and I fell in love with it on a trip for our first anniversary.

I enjoy wine, but I'm not willing to put the kind of money into it that Jules and Scupper seem to be. While they're trying wines I would love to try and will have some great ones to drink down the road, I probably have a different personal philosophy on it than they do.

We just started to really apprecaite wine about 6-7 years ago, and it's something we kept up with because it basically became one of the few shared hobbies my wife and I have. On a day-to-day basis, most of the wine I drink is in the $15-$25 range, and I save most my higher-$ purchases for special occasions or trips to wine country.

This is the first year in 5 or 6 that my wife and I have not made a trip to Napa, Sonoma, or the Mendocino area. Often times while there, we would find a wine we liked that was worthy of cellaring, and we'd pick up two bottles - one to drink in the near future and one to put away for 5, 7, 10 years, whatever. I normally just pick up an extra bottle rather than a case/half-case. Some of that is a product of income. I could afford to buy more or to drink better wines on a daily basis, but I'd have to sacrifice other things to do so. And I'm not willing to do that just for wine.

As opposed to Jules 400+, I've got a wine fridge that holds about 60 bottles. It's stocked to the gills right now, and some of the first wines we bought to hold for a while will start coming out after my daughter is born in June/July. Most of those bottles won't be Brunellos or Shafer wines or wineries at the tips of most people's tongues (A number of ours are from places like Peju, Del Dotto, Sullivan, Summers, Hall, Zahtila, Cosentino) - just bottles we encountered during our trips to wine country, really enjoyed, and we'll pull them out and reminisce over this trip or that trip. I think it's all just about personal preference.
You're a beautiful man, Bob, an incredibly beautiful man. Have heard good things about a couple of those wines you listed but haven't tried them. Had someone tell me to visit Del Dotto last time I went through Napa but I ran out of time on the trip and didn't get a chance to locate it.
:lmao: You didn't look at the pictures that closely, did you?Del Dotto's cave tour/tasting is the best value of any of the wineries I've hit in Napa. It's pricey at upwards of $40, but seeing the caves is cool. And the way they do their tasting is outstanding. It starts as a barrel tasting. While you're touring the cave, they'll stop at one of their wines and thief two samples, one of a wine aged in a Missouri barrel and another of the exact same wine that's been aging in a French barrel. It's intereesting to get an idea of what the different barrels do to the wines. Almost unanimously the women preferred the French barrel aging and the men preferred the Missouri. They don't tell until afterwards which came from which.

At any rate, you taste a LOT of wines in the barrel tasting. And if you wish, you can grab tags detailing which wines you tried and buy futures on them as you leave. After that they take you to their conference room and pull out bottles of their current releases, and you taste them. You will leave there half in the bag. And all their wines are outstanding. Best American Sangiovese I've had.
Have you tried Chariot Sangiovese?
 
Question for those of you that are into simply collecting wine for the sake of collecting it, and I don't mean this to be rude, just curious.  What exactly do you get out of having a certian 1989 Shiraz say if you have no intention of drinking it or sharing it with friends ?  Are you buying it as an investment or just to say that you have it ?

I guess we'll I can understand discovering a good wine and wanting to buy it to enjoy I just don't get collecting it for the sake of collecting it.
It's all personal difference or personal philosophy. Scupper and Jules probably differ in the way they buy from proninja and myself, who differ from you or tipsey. Like anything else you own in life, it's nice to be able to say to someone you encounter, "I have a <insert item of prestige here> sitting at home." But mostly people buy with the intention of drinking it down the road when the wine has matured. They want to try the best wines at their peak.Some of it can be sentiment. I've got a bottle of '97 Fife Zinfandel that probably cost $15 when it was released, it's pretty much on it's downward slope now, yet I can't bring myself to open it because it's the last one of a half-case I bought after my wife and I fell in love with it on a trip for our first anniversary.

I enjoy wine, but I'm not willing to put the kind of money into it that Jules and Scupper seem to be. While they're trying wines I would love to try and will have some great ones to drink down the road, I probably have a different personal philosophy on it than they do.

We just started to really apprecaite wine about 6-7 years ago, and it's something we kept up with because it basically became one of the few shared hobbies my wife and I have. On a day-to-day basis, most of the wine I drink is in the $15-$25 range, and I save most my higher-$ purchases for special occasions or trips to wine country.

This is the first year in 5 or 6 that my wife and I have not made a trip to Napa, Sonoma, or the Mendocino area. Often times while there, we would find a wine we liked that was worthy of cellaring, and we'd pick up two bottles - one to drink in the near future and one to put away for 5, 7, 10 years, whatever. I normally just pick up an extra bottle rather than a case/half-case. Some of that is a product of income. I could afford to buy more or to drink better wines on a daily basis, but I'd have to sacrifice other things to do so. And I'm not willing to do that just for wine.

As opposed to Jules 400+, I've got a wine fridge that holds about 60 bottles. It's stocked to the gills right now, and some of the first wines we bought to hold for a while will start coming out after my daughter is born in June/July. Most of those bottles won't be Brunellos or Shafer wines or wineries at the tips of most people's tongues (A number of ours are from places like Peju, Del Dotto, Sullivan, Summers, Hall, Zahtila, Cosentino) - just bottles we encountered during our trips to wine country, really enjoyed, and we'll pull them out and reminisce over this trip or that trip. I think it's all just about personal preference.
You're a beautiful man, Bob, an incredibly beautiful man. Have heard good things about a couple of those wines you listed but haven't tried them. Had someone tell me to visit Del Dotto last time I went through Napa but I ran out of time on the trip and didn't get a chance to locate it.
:lmao: You didn't look at the pictures that closely, did you?Del Dotto's cave tour/tasting is the best value of any of the wineries I've hit in Napa. It's pricey at upwards of $40, but seeing the caves is cool. And the way they do their tasting is outstanding. It starts as a barrel tasting. While you're touring the cave, they'll stop at one of their wines and thief two samples, one of a wine aged in a Missouri barrel and another of the exact same wine that's been aging in a French barrel. It's intereesting to get an idea of what the different barrels do to the wines. Almost unanimously the women preferred the French barrel aging and the men preferred the Missouri. They don't tell until afterwards which came from which.

At any rate, you taste a LOT of wines in the barrel tasting. And if you wish, you can grab tags detailing which wines you tried and buy futures on them as you leave. After that they take you to their conference room and pull out bottles of their current releases, and you taste them. You will leave there half in the bag. And all their wines are outstanding. Best American Sangiovese I've had.
Have you tried Chariot Sangiovese?
I have not.
 
Question for those of you that are into simply collecting wine for the sake of collecting it, and I don't mean this to be rude, just curious. What exactly do you get out of having a certian 1989 Shiraz say if you have no intention of drinking it or sharing it with friends ? Are you buying it as an investment or just to say that you have it ?

I guess we'll I can understand discovering a good wine and wanting to buy it to enjoy I just don't get collecting it for the sake of collecting it.
It's all personal difference or personal philosophy. Scupper and Jules probably differ in the way they buy from proninja and myself, who differ from you or tipsey. Like anything else you own in life, it's nice to be able to say to someone you encounter, "I have a <insert item of prestige here> sitting at home." But mostly people buy with the intention of drinking it down the road when the wine has matured. They want to try the best wines at their peak.Some of it can be sentiment. I've got a bottle of '97 Fife Zinfandel that probably cost $15 when it was released, it's pretty much on it's downward slope now, yet I can't bring myself to open it because it's the last one of a half-case I bought after my wife and I fell in love with it on a trip for our first anniversary.

I enjoy wine, but I'm not willing to put the kind of money into it that Jules and Scupper seem to be. While they're trying wines I would love to try and will have some great ones to drink down the road, I probably have a different personal philosophy on it than they do.

We just started to really apprecaite wine about 6-7 years ago, and it's something we kept up with because it basically became one of the few shared hobbies my wife and I have. On a day-to-day basis, most of the wine I drink is in the $15-$25 range, and I save most my higher-$ purchases for special occasions or trips to wine country.

This is the first year in 5 or 6 that my wife and I have not made a trip to Napa, Sonoma, or the Mendocino area. Often times while there, we would find a wine we liked that was worthy of cellaring, and we'd pick up two bottles - one to drink in the near future and one to put away for 5, 7, 10 years, whatever. I normally just pick up an extra bottle rather than a case/half-case. Some of that is a product of income. I could afford to buy more or to drink better wines on a daily basis, but I'd have to sacrifice other things to do so. And I'm not willing to do that just for wine.

As opposed to Jules 400+, I've got a wine fridge that holds about 60 bottles. It's stocked to the gills right now, and some of the first wines we bought to hold for a while will start coming out after my daughter is born in June/July. Most of those bottles won't be Brunellos or Shafer wines or wineries at the tips of most people's tongues (A number of ours are from places like Peju, Del Dotto, Sullivan, Summers, Hall, Zahtila, Cosentino) - just bottles we encountered during our trips to wine country, really enjoyed, and we'll pull them out and reminisce over this trip or that trip. I think it's all just about personal preference.
You're a beautiful man, Bob, an incredibly beautiful man. Have heard good things about a couple of those wines you listed but haven't tried them. Had someone tell me to visit Del Dotto last time I went through Napa but I ran out of time on the trip and didn't get a chance to locate it.
:lmao: You didn't look at the pictures that closely, did you?Del Dotto's cave tour/tasting is the best value of any of the wineries I've hit in Napa. It's pricey at upwards of $40, but seeing the caves is cool. And the way they do their tasting is outstanding. It starts as a barrel tasting. While you're touring the cave, they'll stop at one of their wines and thief two samples, one of a wine aged in a Missouri barrel and another of the exact same wine that's been aging in a French barrel. It's intereesting to get an idea of what the different barrels do to the wines. Almost unanimously the women preferred the French barrel aging and the men preferred the Missouri. They don't tell until afterwards which came from which.

At any rate, you taste a LOT of wines in the barrel tasting. And if you wish, you can grab tags detailing which wines you tried and buy futures on them as you leave. After that they take you to their conference room and pull out bottles of their current releases, and you taste them. You will leave there half in the bag. And all their wines are outstanding. Best American Sangiovese I've had.
Have you tried Chariot Sangiovese?
I have not.
It's a wonderful Sangiovese. The fruit for the Sangiovese comes from Mer Soleil Vineyard in central California.Aromas of rose petal, Bing cherries, and wet rocks integrated with a little oak and fresh dirt. It doesn't sound appealing does it with the wet rock and dirt but it is a wonderful Sangiovese. Comes in at about $11-$13 a bottle.

 
Last edited by a moderator:
Question for those of you that are into simply collecting wine for the sake of collecting it, and I don't mean this to be rude, just curious.  What exactly do you get out of having a certian 1989 Shiraz say if you have no intention of drinking it or sharing it with friends ?  Are you buying it as an investment or just to say that you have it ?

I guess we'll I can understand discovering a good wine and wanting to buy it to enjoy I just don't get collecting it for the sake of collecting it.
It's all personal difference or personal philosophy. Scupper and Jules probably differ in the way they buy from proninja and myself, who differ from you or tipsey. Like anything else you own in life, it's nice to be able to say to someone you encounter, "I have a <insert item of prestige here> sitting at home." But mostly people buy with the intention of drinking it down the road when the wine has matured. They want to try the best wines at their peak.Some of it can be sentiment. I've got a bottle of '97 Fife Zinfandel that probably cost $15 when it was released, it's pretty much on it's downward slope now, yet I can't bring myself to open it because it's the last one of a half-case I bought after my wife and I fell in love with it on a trip for our first anniversary.

I enjoy wine, but I'm not willing to put the kind of money into it that Jules and Scupper seem to be. While they're trying wines I would love to try and will have some great ones to drink down the road, I probably have a different personal philosophy on it than they do.

We just started to really apprecaite wine about 6-7 years ago, and it's something we kept up with because it basically became one of the few shared hobbies my wife and I have. On a day-to-day basis, most of the wine I drink is in the $15-$25 range, and I save most my higher-$ purchases for special occasions or trips to wine country.

This is the first year in 5 or 6 that my wife and I have not made a trip to Napa, Sonoma, or the Mendocino area. Often times while there, we would find a wine we liked that was worthy of cellaring, and we'd pick up two bottles - one to drink in the near future and one to put away for 5, 7, 10 years, whatever. I normally just pick up an extra bottle rather than a case/half-case. Some of that is a product of income. I could afford to buy more or to drink better wines on a daily basis, but I'd have to sacrifice other things to do so. And I'm not willing to do that just for wine.

As opposed to Jules 400+, I've got a wine fridge that holds about 60 bottles. It's stocked to the gills right now, and some of the first wines we bought to hold for a while will start coming out after my daughter is born in June/July. Most of those bottles won't be Brunellos or Shafer wines or wineries at the tips of most people's tongues (A number of ours are from places like Peju, Del Dotto, Sullivan, Summers, Hall, Zahtila, Cosentino) - just bottles we encountered during our trips to wine country, really enjoyed, and we'll pull them out and reminisce over this trip or that trip. I think it's all just about personal preference.
You're a beautiful man, Bob, an incredibly beautiful man. Have heard good things about a couple of those wines you listed but haven't tried them. Had someone tell me to visit Del Dotto last time I went through Napa but I ran out of time on the trip and didn't get a chance to locate it.
:lmao: You didn't look at the pictures that closely, did you?Del Dotto's cave tour/tasting is the best value of any of the wineries I've hit in Napa. It's pricey at upwards of $40, but seeing the caves is cool. And the way they do their tasting is outstanding. It starts as a barrel tasting. While you're touring the cave, they'll stop at one of their wines and thief two samples, one of a wine aged in a Missouri barrel and another of the exact same wine that's been aging in a French barrel. It's intereesting to get an idea of what the different barrels do to the wines. Almost unanimously the women preferred the French barrel aging and the men preferred the Missouri. They don't tell until afterwards which came from which.

At any rate, you taste a LOT of wines in the barrel tasting. And if you wish, you can grab tags detailing which wines you tried and buy futures on them as you leave. After that they take you to their conference room and pull out bottles of their current releases, and you taste them. You will leave there half in the bag. And all their wines are outstanding. Best American Sangiovese I've had.
Have you tried Chariot Sangiovese?
I have not.
It's a wonderful Sangiovese. The fruit for the Sangiovese comes from Mer Soleil Vineyard in central California.Aromas of rose petal, Bing cherries, and wet rocks integrated with a little oak and fresh dirt. It doesn't sound appealing does it with the wet rock and dirt but it is a wonderful Sangiovese. Comes in at about $11-$13 a bottle.
WTF? I don't know what you do for food when you're not tasting wine, but your dinner parties seem to differ greatly from mine.
 
Question for those of you that are into simply collecting wine for the sake of collecting it, and I don't mean this to be rude, just curious. What exactly do you get out of having a certian 1989 Shiraz say if you have no intention of drinking it or sharing it with friends ? Are you buying it as an investment or just to say that you have it ?

I guess we'll I can understand discovering a good wine and wanting to buy it to enjoy I just don't get collecting it for the sake of collecting it.
It's all personal difference or personal philosophy. Scupper and Jules probably differ in the way they buy from proninja and myself, who differ from you or tipsey. Like anything else you own in life, it's nice to be able to say to someone you encounter, "I have a <insert item of prestige here> sitting at home." But mostly people buy with the intention of drinking it down the road when the wine has matured. They want to try the best wines at their peak.Some of it can be sentiment. I've got a bottle of '97 Fife Zinfandel that probably cost $15 when it was released, it's pretty much on it's downward slope now, yet I can't bring myself to open it because it's the last one of a half-case I bought after my wife and I fell in love with it on a trip for our first anniversary.

I enjoy wine, but I'm not willing to put the kind of money into it that Jules and Scupper seem to be. While they're trying wines I would love to try and will have some great ones to drink down the road, I probably have a different personal philosophy on it than they do.

We just started to really apprecaite wine about 6-7 years ago, and it's something we kept up with because it basically became one of the few shared hobbies my wife and I have. On a day-to-day basis, most of the wine I drink is in the $15-$25 range, and I save most my higher-$ purchases for special occasions or trips to wine country.

This is the first year in 5 or 6 that my wife and I have not made a trip to Napa, Sonoma, or the Mendocino area. Often times while there, we would find a wine we liked that was worthy of cellaring, and we'd pick up two bottles - one to drink in the near future and one to put away for 5, 7, 10 years, whatever. I normally just pick up an extra bottle rather than a case/half-case. Some of that is a product of income. I could afford to buy more or to drink better wines on a daily basis, but I'd have to sacrifice other things to do so. And I'm not willing to do that just for wine.

As opposed to Jules 400+, I've got a wine fridge that holds about 60 bottles. It's stocked to the gills right now, and some of the first wines we bought to hold for a while will start coming out after my daughter is born in June/July. Most of those bottles won't be Brunellos or Shafer wines or wineries at the tips of most people's tongues (A number of ours are from places like Peju, Del Dotto, Sullivan, Summers, Hall, Zahtila, Cosentino) - just bottles we encountered during our trips to wine country, really enjoyed, and we'll pull them out and reminisce over this trip or that trip. I think it's all just about personal preference.
You're a beautiful man, Bob, an incredibly beautiful man. Have heard good things about a couple of those wines you listed but haven't tried them. Had someone tell me to visit Del Dotto last time I went through Napa but I ran out of time on the trip and didn't get a chance to locate it.
:lmao: You didn't look at the pictures that closely, did you?Del Dotto's cave tour/tasting is the best value of any of the wineries I've hit in Napa. It's pricey at upwards of $40, but seeing the caves is cool. And the way they do their tasting is outstanding. It starts as a barrel tasting. While you're touring the cave, they'll stop at one of their wines and thief two samples, one of a wine aged in a Missouri barrel and another of the exact same wine that's been aging in a French barrel. It's intereesting to get an idea of what the different barrels do to the wines. Almost unanimously the women preferred the French barrel aging and the men preferred the Missouri. They don't tell until afterwards which came from which.

At any rate, you taste a LOT of wines in the barrel tasting. And if you wish, you can grab tags detailing which wines you tried and buy futures on them as you leave. After that they take you to their conference room and pull out bottles of their current releases, and you taste them. You will leave there half in the bag. And all their wines are outstanding. Best American Sangiovese I've had.
Have you tried Chariot Sangiovese?
I have not.
It's a wonderful Sangiovese. The fruit for the Sangiovese comes from Mer Soleil Vineyard in central California.Aromas of rose petal, Bing cherries, and wet rocks integrated with a little oak and fresh dirt. It doesn't sound appealing does it with the wet rock and dirt but it is a wonderful Sangiovese. Comes in at about $11-$13 a bottle.
WTF? I don't know what you do for food when you're not tasting wine, but your dinner parties seem to differ greatly from mine.
Please just try it. It is a great little bargain.
 
Question for those of you that are into simply collecting wine for the sake of collecting it, and I don't mean this to be rude, just curious.  What exactly do you get out of having a certian 1989 Shiraz say if you have no intention of drinking it or sharing it with friends ?  Are you buying it as an investment or just to say that you have it ?

I guess we'll I can understand discovering a good wine and wanting to buy it to enjoy I just don't get collecting it for the sake of collecting it.
It's all personal difference or personal philosophy. Scupper and Jules probably differ in the way they buy from proninja and myself, who differ from you or tipsey. Like anything else you own in life, it's nice to be able to say to someone you encounter, "I have a <insert item of prestige here> sitting at home." But mostly people buy with the intention of drinking it down the road when the wine has matured. They want to try the best wines at their peak.Some of it can be sentiment. I've got a bottle of '97 Fife Zinfandel that probably cost $15 when it was released, it's pretty much on it's downward slope now, yet I can't bring myself to open it because it's the last one of a half-case I bought after my wife and I fell in love with it on a trip for our first anniversary.

I enjoy wine, but I'm not willing to put the kind of money into it that Jules and Scupper seem to be. While they're trying wines I would love to try and will have some great ones to drink down the road, I probably have a different personal philosophy on it than they do.

We just started to really apprecaite wine about 6-7 years ago, and it's something we kept up with because it basically became one of the few shared hobbies my wife and I have. On a day-to-day basis, most of the wine I drink is in the $15-$25 range, and I save most my higher-$ purchases for special occasions or trips to wine country.

This is the first year in 5 or 6 that my wife and I have not made a trip to Napa, Sonoma, or the Mendocino area. Often times while there, we would find a wine we liked that was worthy of cellaring, and we'd pick up two bottles - one to drink in the near future and one to put away for 5, 7, 10 years, whatever. I normally just pick up an extra bottle rather than a case/half-case. Some of that is a product of income. I could afford to buy more or to drink better wines on a daily basis, but I'd have to sacrifice other things to do so. And I'm not willing to do that just for wine.

As opposed to Jules 400+, I've got a wine fridge that holds about 60 bottles. It's stocked to the gills right now, and some of the first wines we bought to hold for a while will start coming out after my daughter is born in June/July. Most of those bottles won't be Brunellos or Shafer wines or wineries at the tips of most people's tongues (A number of ours are from places like Peju, Del Dotto, Sullivan, Summers, Hall, Zahtila, Cosentino) - just bottles we encountered during our trips to wine country, really enjoyed, and we'll pull them out and reminisce over this trip or that trip. I think it's all just about personal preference.
You're a beautiful man, Bob, an incredibly beautiful man. Have heard good things about a couple of those wines you listed but haven't tried them. Had someone tell me to visit Del Dotto last time I went through Napa but I ran out of time on the trip and didn't get a chance to locate it.
:lmao: You didn't look at the pictures that closely, did you?Del Dotto's cave tour/tasting is the best value of any of the wineries I've hit in Napa. It's pricey at upwards of $40, but seeing the caves is cool. And the way they do their tasting is outstanding. It starts as a barrel tasting. While you're touring the cave, they'll stop at one of their wines and thief two samples, one of a wine aged in a Missouri barrel and another of the exact same wine that's been aging in a French barrel. It's intereesting to get an idea of what the different barrels do to the wines. Almost unanimously the women preferred the French barrel aging and the men preferred the Missouri. They don't tell until afterwards which came from which.

At any rate, you taste a LOT of wines in the barrel tasting. And if you wish, you can grab tags detailing which wines you tried and buy futures on them as you leave. After that they take you to their conference room and pull out bottles of their current releases, and you taste them. You will leave there half in the bag. And all their wines are outstanding. Best American Sangiovese I've had.
Have you tried Chariot Sangiovese?
I have not.
It's a wonderful Sangiovese. The fruit for the Sangiovese comes from Mer Soleil Vineyard in central California.Aromas of rose petal, Bing cherries, and wet rocks integrated with a little oak and fresh dirt. It doesn't sound appealing does it with the wet rock and dirt but it is a wonderful Sangiovese. Comes in at about $11-$13 a bottle.
WTF? I don't know what you do for food when you're not tasting wine, but your dinner parties seem to differ greatly from mine.
Please just try it. It is a great little bargain.
Oh, I will if I can find it. Finding wines can be a problem in the ridiculous state of Arizona.
 
Question for those of you that are into simply collecting wine for the sake of collecting it, and I don't mean this to be rude, just curious. What exactly do you get out of having a certian 1989 Shiraz say if you have no intention of drinking it or sharing it with friends ? Are you buying it as an investment or just to say that you have it ?

I guess we'll I can understand discovering a good wine and wanting to buy it to enjoy I just don't get collecting it for the sake of collecting it.
It's all personal difference or personal philosophy. Scupper and Jules probably differ in the way they buy from proninja and myself, who differ from you or tipsey. Like anything else you own in life, it's nice to be able to say to someone you encounter, "I have a <insert item of prestige here> sitting at home." But mostly people buy with the intention of drinking it down the road when the wine has matured. They want to try the best wines at their peak.Some of it can be sentiment. I've got a bottle of '97 Fife Zinfandel that probably cost $15 when it was released, it's pretty much on it's downward slope now, yet I can't bring myself to open it because it's the last one of a half-case I bought after my wife and I fell in love with it on a trip for our first anniversary.

I enjoy wine, but I'm not willing to put the kind of money into it that Jules and Scupper seem to be. While they're trying wines I would love to try and will have some great ones to drink down the road, I probably have a different personal philosophy on it than they do.

We just started to really apprecaite wine about 6-7 years ago, and it's something we kept up with because it basically became one of the few shared hobbies my wife and I have. On a day-to-day basis, most of the wine I drink is in the $15-$25 range, and I save most my higher-$ purchases for special occasions or trips to wine country.

This is the first year in 5 or 6 that my wife and I have not made a trip to Napa, Sonoma, or the Mendocino area. Often times while there, we would find a wine we liked that was worthy of cellaring, and we'd pick up two bottles - one to drink in the near future and one to put away for 5, 7, 10 years, whatever. I normally just pick up an extra bottle rather than a case/half-case. Some of that is a product of income. I could afford to buy more or to drink better wines on a daily basis, but I'd have to sacrifice other things to do so. And I'm not willing to do that just for wine.

As opposed to Jules 400+, I've got a wine fridge that holds about 60 bottles. It's stocked to the gills right now, and some of the first wines we bought to hold for a while will start coming out after my daughter is born in June/July. Most of those bottles won't be Brunellos or Shafer wines or wineries at the tips of most people's tongues (A number of ours are from places like Peju, Del Dotto, Sullivan, Summers, Hall, Zahtila, Cosentino) - just bottles we encountered during our trips to wine country, really enjoyed, and we'll pull them out and reminisce over this trip or that trip. I think it's all just about personal preference.
You're a beautiful man, Bob, an incredibly beautiful man. Have heard good things about a couple of those wines you listed but haven't tried them. Had someone tell me to visit Del Dotto last time I went through Napa but I ran out of time on the trip and didn't get a chance to locate it.
:lmao: You didn't look at the pictures that closely, did you?Del Dotto's cave tour/tasting is the best value of any of the wineries I've hit in Napa. It's pricey at upwards of $40, but seeing the caves is cool. And the way they do their tasting is outstanding. It starts as a barrel tasting. While you're touring the cave, they'll stop at one of their wines and thief two samples, one of a wine aged in a Missouri barrel and another of the exact same wine that's been aging in a French barrel. It's intereesting to get an idea of what the different barrels do to the wines. Almost unanimously the women preferred the French barrel aging and the men preferred the Missouri. They don't tell until afterwards which came from which.

At any rate, you taste a LOT of wines in the barrel tasting. And if you wish, you can grab tags detailing which wines you tried and buy futures on them as you leave. After that they take you to their conference room and pull out bottles of their current releases, and you taste them. You will leave there half in the bag. And all their wines are outstanding. Best American Sangiovese I've had.
Have you tried Chariot Sangiovese?
I have not.
It's a wonderful Sangiovese. The fruit for the Sangiovese comes from Mer Soleil Vineyard in central California.Aromas of rose petal, Bing cherries, and wet rocks integrated with a little oak and fresh dirt. It doesn't sound appealing does it with the wet rock and dirt but it is a wonderful Sangiovese. Comes in at about $11-$13 a bottle.
WTF? I don't know what you do for food when you're not tasting wine, but your dinner parties seem to differ greatly from mine.
Please just try it. It is a great little bargain.
Oh, I will if I can find it. Finding wines can be a problem in the ridiculous state of Arizona.
B Line, Beverage House (Tucson), Cave Creek wines, Enotria, Epicurean Wine Service, Grapeables, Intermezzo, Jug-n-Barrel, The Wine Studio, and Time Market. Check the web for phone numbers and shipping information!
 
B Line, Beverage House (Tucson), Cave Creek wines, Enotria, Epicurean Wine Service, Grapeables, Intermezzo, Jug-n-Barrel, The Wine Studio, and Time Market. Check the web for phone numbers and shipping information!
:D Gracias. Enotria and Jug-n-Barrel will work just fine.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
We went to a family Christmas, and brought a bottle, nothing good, but a drinkable bottle of red. My aunt comes over "oh, you guys like wine? Wonderful! I love wine!" So, I pour her a glass, we go out in the living room and start chatting - when the hostess comes by, my aunt asks the hostess - "Excuse me, could I get an ice cube for my wine? It's room temperature." :wall:
Yeah, that's what she said. But what she meant was "That cheap ******* has over 100 bottles in his wine cellar but he brings this freakin' grape juice and tries to pass it off as wine! Maybe if I water it down a little I'll at least be able to swallow it."
 
Question for those of you that are into simply collecting wine for the sake of collecting it, and I don't mean this to be rude, just curious.  What exactly do you get out of having a certian 1989 Shiraz say if you have no intention of drinking it or sharing it with friends ?  Are you buying it as an investment or just to say that you have it ?

I guess we'll I can understand discovering a good wine and wanting to buy it to enjoy I just don't get collecting it for the sake of collecting it.
It's all personal difference or personal philosophy. Scupper and Jules probably differ in the way they buy from proninja and myself, who differ from you or tipsey. Like anything else you own in life, it's nice to be able to say to someone you encounter, "I have a <insert item of prestige here> sitting at home." But mostly people buy with the intention of drinking it down the road when the wine has matured. They want to try the best wines at their peak.Some of it can be sentiment. I've got a bottle of '97 Fife Zinfandel that probably cost $15 when it was released, it's pretty much on it's downward slope now, yet I can't bring myself to open it because it's the last one of a half-case I bought after my wife and I fell in love with it on a trip for our first anniversary.

I enjoy wine, but I'm not willing to put the kind of money into it that Jules and Scupper seem to be. While they're trying wines I would love to try and will have some great ones to drink down the road, I probably have a different personal philosophy on it than they do.

We just started to really apprecaite wine about 6-7 years ago, and it's something we kept up with because it basically became one of the few shared hobbies my wife and I have. On a day-to-day basis, most of the wine I drink is in the $15-$25 range, and I save most my higher-$ purchases for special occasions or trips to wine country.

This is the first year in 5 or 6 that my wife and I have not made a trip to Napa, Sonoma, or the Mendocino area. Often times while there, we would find a wine we liked that was worthy of cellaring, and we'd pick up two bottles - one to drink in the near future and one to put away for 5, 7, 10 years, whatever. I normally just pick up an extra bottle rather than a case/half-case. Some of that is a product of income. I could afford to buy more or to drink better wines on a daily basis, but I'd have to sacrifice other things to do so. And I'm not willing to do that just for wine.

As opposed to Jules 400+, I've got a wine fridge that holds about 60 bottles. It's stocked to the gills right now, and some of the first wines we bought to hold for a while will start coming out after my daughter is born in June/July. Most of those bottles won't be Brunellos or Shafer wines or wineries at the tips of most people's tongues (A number of ours are from places like Peju, Del Dotto, Sullivan, Summers, Hall, Zahtila, Cosentino) - just bottles we encountered during our trips to wine country, really enjoyed, and we'll pull them out and reminisce over this trip or that trip. I think it's all just about personal preference.
You're a beautiful man, Bob, an incredibly beautiful man. Have heard good things about a couple of those wines you listed but haven't tried them. Had someone tell me to visit Del Dotto last time I went through Napa but I ran out of time on the trip and didn't get a chance to locate it.
:lmao: You didn't look at the pictures that closely, did you?Del Dotto's cave tour/tasting is the best value of any of the wineries I've hit in Napa. It's pricey at upwards of $40, but seeing the caves is cool. And the way they do their tasting is outstanding. It starts as a barrel tasting. While you're touring the cave, they'll stop at one of their wines and thief two samples, one of a wine aged in a Missouri barrel and another of the exact same wine that's been aging in a French barrel. It's intereesting to get an idea of what the different barrels do to the wines. Almost unanimously the women preferred the French barrel aging and the men preferred the Missouri. They don't tell until afterwards which came from which.

At any rate, you taste a LOT of wines in the barrel tasting. And if you wish, you can grab tags detailing which wines you tried and buy futures on them as you leave. After that they take you to their conference room and pull out bottles of their current releases, and you taste them. You will leave there half in the bag. And all their wines are outstanding. Best American Sangiovese I've had.
Saw the pictures but might have been distracted by the mountain taking up most of the photo. Sounds like I definitely need to get to there eventually. I've been down through there 2 or 3 times but haven't been able to go to too many places. In Napa I've been to Clos Pegase, Markham, V. Sattui, Folie a Deux, Mondavi, Niebaum-Coppola, and Domaine Chandon and I've been to 3 or 4 over in Sonoma as well but those names aren't coming to me other than St. Francis.
 
Question for those of you that are into simply collecting wine for the sake of collecting it, and I don't mean this to be rude, just curious.  What exactly do you get out of having a certian 1989 Shiraz say if you have no intention of drinking it or sharing it with friends ?  Are you buying it as an investment or just to say that you have it ?

I guess we'll I can understand discovering a good wine and wanting to buy it to enjoy I just don't get collecting it for the sake of collecting it.
No one who's paying attention "collects" wine. Many French wines are not ready to drink, but are priced to buy. When most good wines are "ready" they are significantly more expensive. Sure, you lose some before they get good due to cork issues, or they just plain never get good. The other reason I have wine in the cellar is because the good ones sell out. I don't want to have to buy wine off an auction site later becuase I didn't buy enough to store.Take a 1999 Silver Oak, about $150 in a store. I bought 4-5 bottles 2-3 years ago and paid less than $60/bottle. That's not "collecting", that's saving $300 on a wine I knew would be fantastic.
Is that the Napa or Alexander Valley?
Napa. Actually, I've seen the 99 and the 2000 vintage in wide ranges, from 110-150. I've never bought in online, where you'd likely find it cheaper, but will have to pay shipping charges of $6-10/bottle, if you bought in quantity.
I prefer the Alexander Valley over the Napa. Otherwise I have the '01 Alexander and '00 Napa, and '01 Napa which I received as a gift. I also have the only wine that Silver Oak makes that isn't Cabernet and doesn't have the Silver Oak name on it.

What is it?
twomey merlot
 
Since we have started talking about the Alexander Valley, are any of you familiar with the Alexander Valley Vineyards (AVV)? I love their merlot, and they also make a nice Gewurz, Cab, Syrah, & Pinot. I highly recommend checking them out! They label is boring, which means most of America doesn't drink their stuff, but I find them to be exceptional value wines ($10-$20).

AVV Wines
i like their stuff quite a bit.i tried a darioush syrah tonight, it was really quite good. deep rich wine with good fruit. & i'd be interested to know what other grapes they put in it, i'm guessing a merlot or a cab franc because it had a real nice velvety quality unusual in a syrah.

 
I'm partial to Jacobs Creek myself, better then my gf & her Arbour Mist... sigh.....
jacob's creek actually has some stunning wines. try the 'steingarten' reisling, dry great minerality & will hold up to almost any food. it's grown in the german style on very steep hllsides, handpicked, etc. very limited production.another good one by them is the 98 'centennary' shiraz. 100 year anniversary wine made up of only their best lots.

 

Users who are viewing this thread

Back
Top