OK, then guys. What should I have done with my stock today? Let it sit?
If I didn't TOUCH my stock. I would have:
1,651 shares worth $0.08 per share.
Since I did TOUCH my stock. It's currently worth:
1,666 shares worth $0.08 per share.
What exactly did I screw up?
You're completely ignoring transaction fees for one thing. When a single transaction fee equates to 8% of your portfolio, that's a big difference.
If you did nothing today and retained your 1651 shares (at an average cost basis of .0545), you would have had 1651 * .08 for $132.08 AND $15.90 in uninvested cash for a total of $147.98
Based on what you did, you now have 1666 shares (at a cost basis of .0714), you have 1666 * .08 for $133.28 LESS $15.90 for the fees you paid for a total of $117.38
This is what folks are saying that if you did nothing today, you'd be sitting better than you are now. We're just talking about FOR TODAY. Who knows whether the stock will take off tomorrow or not.
Feelings, intentions, etc all aside, this is your balance sheet as of right now.