What's the most Oreos you've consumed in one sitting? (1 Viewer)

[gianmarco]

What's the most Oreos you've ever consumed in one sitting?

Polls suck now so I can't add a second question, but, if you had to guess, what's the most Oreos you think you can consume in one sitting?

 

[Mrs. Rannous]

Is there an app for estimating how many were in the Cookies 'n Cream ice cream I ate? That might affect my answer.

 

[Dan Lambskin]

Probably 4. Not a huge cookie guy. Possible I’ve had 3 (my usual cookie grab is 3) and gone back for another 3

Im sure I could eat an entire family pack

 

[belljr]

does it count as one sitting if a ate some said i was done but then a couple minutes later went for some more

 

[NutterButter]

How many oreos are in a package?

 

[belljr]

How many oreos are in a package?

regular 36 family size 48

 

[NutterButter]

How many oreos are in a package?

regular 36 family size 48

This would have been in my teenage years and I don't think they had family size yet.

 

[Cowboysfan8]

if you had to guess, what's the most Oreos you think you can consume in one sitting?

This is a different question than the poll. I answered 6-10 but I CAN consume twice that many I believe if I have the munchies

 

[Cowboysfan8]

Double stuf ftw

 

[massraider]

How many oreos are in a package?

The only correct answer

 

[Ron Swanson]

How many oreos are in a package?

Always know your competition...

 

[psychobillies]

1. Oreos are disgusting. it's one of the only foods on the planet that I just won't eat under any normal circumstances.

 

[STEADYMOBBIN 22]

1. Oreos are disgusting. it's one of the only foods on the planet that I just won't eat under any normal circumstances.

I admit that there are far better cookies out there- but I can demolish them with a nice glass of ice cold milk.

Without milk- zero.

 

[guru_007]

1. Oreos are disgusting. it's one of the only foods on the planet that I just won't eat under any normal circumstances.

I admit that there are far better cookies out there- but I can demolish them with a nice glass of ice cold milk.

Without milk- zero.

Right.
Even with milk, Oreos are a 2, 3 tops cookie consumption.
Entenmanns soft chocolate chip or freihofer's chocolate chocolate chip cookies with a half gallon of milk nearby, I don't think they can make them as fast as I could consume them.

 

[raidergil]

1. Oreos are disgusting. it's one of the only foods on the planet that I just won't eat under any normal circumstances.

I admit that there are far better cookies out there- but I can demolish them with a nice glass of ice cold milk.

Without milk- zero.

Dunked in milk! Takes a bit of experience to get right softness without it crumbling into the milk.

 

[Dr_Zaius]

1. Oreos are disgusting. it's one of the only foods on the planet that I just won't eat under any normal circumstances.

I agree they aren't great. The thin ones with the mint filling are decent. I also think the regular ones are better if they are left out in a humid environment because then they get softer over time. Which kind of tells you all you need to know - a real cookie shouldn't get better the staler it gets.

 

[Drunken knight]

I am not a huge oreo guy, but have liked their other flavors (ie: mocha, toffee, smores, etc).

normal is 2 or 3, so maybe most in a sitting was about 5

 

[Van Dyman]

I generally dislike Oreos but on very rare occasions enjoy them. Several times I have consumed (with milk, of course) a full row or row and a half of the standard package (12 per row). Nowadays? 1 or 2, and the only circumstance where I might ingest them would be at some gathering where all choices were equally bad.

 

[Fat Nick]

When I was in my late-teens / early 20's and had a metabolism, I'm sure I ate a whole box at some point.

Now, I limit myself to usually ~6, but sometimes up to 12. It's restraint, not getting full, just so we're clear. I LOVE Oreos...love them even more with milk (Dippper gadgets are great if you don't have one)...and in what I'm sure may be a divisive opinion, I prefer Golden Oreos above all others, although I've never met an Oreo I didn't like.

 

[belljr]

peanut butter oreos are the cats pajamas

 

[MTskibum]

When I was in my late-teens / early 20's and had a metabolism, I'm sure I ate a whole box at some point.

Now, I limit myself to usually ~6, but sometimes up to 12. It's restraint, not getting full, just so we're clear. I LOVE Oreos...love them even more with milk (Dippper gadgets are great if you don't have one)...and in what I'm sure may be a divisive opinion, I prefer Golden Oreos above all others, although I've never met an Oreo I didn't like.

Name checks out

 

[MTskibum]

Probably a whole package as a teenager, maybe 2 cookies as an adult. I prefer salty snacks for my junk food.

 

[The Gator]

@mr. furley has the record I believe.

 

[mr. furley]

@mr. furley has the record I believe.

we talking classic Oreo or vanilla Oreo?

answer is the same for both just looking for clarification

 

[belljr]

When I was in my late-teens / early 20's and had a metabolism, I'm sure I ate a whole box at some point.

Now, I limit myself to usually ~6, but sometimes up to 12. It's restraint, not getting full, just so we're clear. I LOVE Oreos...love them even more with milk (Dippper gadgets are great if you don't have one)...and in what I'm sure may be a divisive opinion, I prefer Golden Oreos above all others, although I've never met an Oreo I didn't like.

Name checks out

Jokes on you he's not actually Nick........

 

[El Floppo]

Ok tubby, why this question today?

 

[Grahamburn]

You know that movie the Mighty Ducks? The kids had an "oreo line." I never knew what that meant until I was way older.

 

[TheBaylorKid]

When I was in my late-teens / early 20's and had a metabolism, I'm sure I ate a whole box at some point.

Now, I limit myself to usually ~6, but sometimes up to 12. It's restraint, not getting full, just so we're clear. I LOVE Oreos...love them even more with milk (Dippper gadgets are great if you don't have one)...and in what I'm sure may be a divisive opinion, I prefer Golden Oreos above all others, although I've never met an Oreo I didn't like.

What’s up Fat Nick

 

[Fat Nick]

When I was in my late-teens / early 20's and had a metabolism, I'm sure I ate a whole box at some point.

Now, I limit myself to usually ~6, but sometimes up to 12. It's restraint, not getting full, just so we're clear. I LOVE Oreos...love them even more with milk (Dippper gadgets are great if you don't have one)...and in what I'm sure may be a divisive opinion, I prefer Golden Oreos above all others, although I've never met an Oreo I didn't like.

What’s up Fat Nick

You like the Oreos too? If so...

 

[SWC]

like a hundred i guess take that to the bank brohans

 

[nirad3]

1. Oreos are disgusting. it's one of the only foods on the planet that I just won't eat under any normal circumstances.

I admit that there are far better cookies out there- but I can demolish them with a nice glass of ice cold milk.

Without milk- zero.

I get so irritated when I have the hankering for some Oreos and go to discover that we either don't have any milk or that the milk we do have has gone bad. Milk going bad quicker seems to be a thing lately, too.

 

[Gatorman]

12 - basically a sleeve. It's been a while since I did that however

 

[skol asylum]

Alot of liars here.

 

[Major]

Easily can take down an entire package of Oreos and have before but generally stay away from packaged shelf cookies unless they're Tate's. Those things are f'n delicious.

 

[Leroy Hoard]

peanut butter oreos are the cats pajamas

Yes, even better than nutter butters.

And off topic, who decided that a cat's pajamas were somehow the greatest thing in the world. Good luck trying to get your cat to wear them.

 

[Jayrod]

I'm sure I've done a dozen at some point in my life but doubt I've eaten many more than that.

Normally just have 2-4 nowadays.

 

[Dezbelief]

Smoreos

Eat out the inside
Roast marshmallow
Reconstruct cookie

 

[Andy Dufresne]

I could eat a whole container of these

Space Dunk

 

[nirad3]

I'm sure I've done a dozen at some point in my life but doubt I've eaten many more than that.

Normally just have 2-4 nowadays.

This is where I'm at. Now I'm in the 5-6 range (with milk) or if there's no milk available I'll just do a couple/3.

 

[wlwiles]

As a kid/teenager I killed an entire row (1/3 of a package) of Double Stuf Oreos on more than one occasion.

Couldn't tell you the last time I had any though, it's probably 10+ years.

 

[Van Dyman]

peanut butter oreos are the cats pajamas

Yes, even better than nutter butters.

Might have to try those. I do love nutter butters.

 

[Grahamburn]

I could eat a whole container of these

Space Dunk

No wonder why all those folks at Wal-Mart have to ride around on those scooters while they shop. "I can't even walk, but where are the birthday cake space dunk oreos?!"

 

[belljr]

peanut butter oreos are the cats pajamas

Yes, even better than nutter butters.

And off topic, who decided that a cat's pajamas were somehow the greatest thing in the world. Good luck trying to get your cat to wear them.

Wouldn't say better, it's a different cookie.

Nutter butters are all peanut butter
Peanut butter oreos are chocolate cookie peanut butter center

 

[3C's]

https://peytonsmomma.com/wp-content/uploads/2020/08/State-Fair-Deep-Fried-Oreo-Cookies.png

 

[nirad3]

peanut butter oreos are the cats pajamas

Yes, even better than nutter butters.

And off topic, who decided that a cat's pajamas were somehow the greatest thing in the world. Good luck trying to get your cat to wear them.

Peanut butter oreos are chocolate cookie peanut butter center

What's this, now? I am a HUGE fan of anything chocolate & peanut butter (I can eat like 100 Reese's cups in one sitting), and have never heard of these.

 

[belljr]

peanut butter oreos are the cats pajamas

Yes, even better than nutter butters.

And off topic, who decided that a cat's pajamas were somehow the greatest thing in the world. Good luck trying to get your cat to wear them.

Peanut butter oreos are chocolate cookie peanut butter center

What's this, now? I am a HUGE fan of anything chocolate & peanut butter (I can eat like 100 Reese's cups in one sitting), and have never heard of these.

And you call yourself a connoisseur


OreoPB

 

[Zow]

11-15 sounds about right.

 

[SWC]

brohans I just set a new pr with 73 take that to the bank broreogos

 

[the moops]

Milk is gross. Oreos by themself are just fine

 

[shuke]

I don't have any recollection of eating a certain amount. Totally educated guess would be maybe 12. I bet I could eat 50.