I remember when a thread like this used to have facts in it. Now we get a dozen decent posts in a three page thread, and the one thing the thread's supposedly about, nobody's interested in. I went back and read the thread thinking maybe I was just being lazy by asking someone to answer it, but apparently, I was almost completely alone in actually reading this for information about a starting RB in the NFL. The offseason used to be worth sticking around for; now I'm not so sure.
Well, for what it's worth you summarized the situation pretty well in your earlier post. One guy claimed LW weighs in at 260. The writer from Houston (who is close to Fisher) said the report was inaccurate. After that, everything is just LW bashing - similar to the annoying Benson-Jones threads we had to suffer through on a weekly basis last year.
What frustrates me is that the Shark Pool used to be heavily moderated (no ####ing in the Shark Pool, jokes and non sequiturs were moved to the FFA) while the FFA used to actually be free for all. Now, the FFA is the one that's moderated, arguably too heavily, while the quality of the Shark Pool is arguably in decline. There's a thread on the first page about Corey Dillon going to Tennessee. That seems pretty important to me, especially if the LenDale rumor is true. But it hasn't been mentioned in this thread, because this thread has officially become the "Make fat jokes about LenDale White" thread. Sure, people can just read the blogger. But the idea behind the shark pool used to be that we'd get a thread about a player, talk through the various pieces of news we'd heard about him, and people would respond to posts on their merit. If a piece of news came out, we'd see a bunch of posts about that news, and people would discuss who on the team benefits, and who suffers. Now, we get longtime posters, new posters, and staff members alike making jokes about a starting running back and continuing their personal jokes from thread to thread. I don't care if there's a guy here who knew all along that LenDale was going to be a bust, or another guy who knows that LenDale's going to break out. I don't care if you make a funny joke about LenWhale or LenDale Whitecastle. Once in a while that stuff's fine. But all we get in most of these threads is a bunch of worthless noise, and it keeps people from even trying to have a serious conversation about players. I think LenDale could be a very good fantasy player this year. A big, bruising Tennessee running back could be very successful with a coach that likes to run and has had successful backfields with less talent in the past. Vince Young is an exciting young player, but Fisher will want to protect him in his second year by establishing a running game and giving Young more room to run and more time to pass. But if it's true that White has gotten fat, or that Dillon is going to join the team, I think that whole situation turns into a mess. I have White in a keeper league, and I'm considering acquiring him in a dynasty league. This thread has done very little to help me with that decision, and it's frustrating.