What's new
Fantasy Football - Footballguys Forums

This is a sample guest message. Register a free account today to become a member! Once signed in, you'll be able to participate on this site by adding your own topics and posts, as well as connect with other members through your own private inbox!

Will Antonio Brown be suspended? (1 Viewer)

people calling for suspension need to watch the replay again but focus on the punter instead of brown. he crouched down for a low tackle but fell backwards instead of executing the tackle. all before the face kick occurred. its pretty obvious this was incidental

 
Should get fined, but I don't think it was in his head to boot the guy. Looked to me like he was going to try and hurdle the guy, got caught in the air and reacted.

Had a guy like Brandon Merriweather kicked someone in the face, he might be looking at 8 games.
If he were a professional ninja, instead of a professional football player, he couldn't have timed and orchestrated a perfect sprinting, leaping front kick to a moving target's head wearing full head-to-toe protective gear.

Cleats high, plus head contact = penalty and very possibly a fine. But it's that malicious intent that gets guys suspended, and he couldn't have intended that result unless he's secretly Keanu Reeves in the Matrix, and if he is, I'd like to see a few more TD's with my 100/1500 this year.

 
This is a very funny thread, some of you guys should write comedy professionally.

I'm sure he will be fined and warned and that will be as far as it goes and as far as it should go. I say fined because of the contact to his head/face area, but they could just let him off with a warning.

 
You've heard of a stiff arm right? He gave him the stiff leg.

If any of us are in mid-air trying to jump over anything that is moving and we face the possibility of coming down on top of it or being flipped, odds are we are going to react in a way to try and not land on it or get flipped. I figure he will get fined since intent really doesn't matter, I mean those linemen don't mean to jump offside either but it's still a penalty. Had it been all Bruce Lee style then sure give him a 1 game break.

 
I've mostly avoided this thread, but it is hilarious listening to armchair Jim Garrison's looking at the film ("His foot moved back, and to the left") for evidence that a kick was intentional. :lmao:

 
Where is the speculation that he was wearing a Karategi under his uniform and had a cleverly hidden samurai sword tucked in his hip pad? Clearly he was out for blood. :wall:

 
Last edited by a moderator:
I've mostly avoided this thread, but it is hilarious listening to armchair Jim Garrison's looking at the film ("His foot moved back, and to the left") for evidence that a kick was intentional. :lmao:
If you look closely at the video, you can see clear evidence of a second foot.

 
It you watch it in slow motion Brown was going to hurdle the punter but took off one stride too early or he would have cleared him with ease. Combined with the punter going down into a submissive position instead of trying to tackle Brown there should not even been a penalty called.

 
It you watch it in slow motion Brown was going to hurdle the punter but took off one stride too early or he would have cleared him with ease. Combined with the punter going down into a submissive position instead of trying to tackle Brown there should not even been a penalty called.
My thought when I saw it: Who does he think he is, Michael Jordan?

 
I think he definitely kicked him on purpose - look at how his leg follows through as he kicks him and immediately after; that is not how you extend your leg when trying to stick to landing after a hurdle. I doubt there was any preconceived intent, but just a split second "I'll kick this guy in the head" reaction to the punter being where he was. Probably should be a fine, but not a suspension, although it should obviously go down as strike 1 for him as far as unnecessary shots to an opponent's head.

 
Last edited by a moderator:
I remember the same sort of inane questions about suspending Lawrence Timmons when he stepped on Ricky Williams on his way to recovering a fumble and Ricky tore his pec.

Football play. Spectacular one at that. No big deal. Certainly not going to be suspended.

 
Should not be a suspendable offense by any means. You have two things here---1) a punter who instead of trying to make a solid tackle--decides to try to go low but ends up ahead of the play 2) antonio brown sees this "low" punter and needs to make a decision on how to work around/through him--and decides that hurdling him is the best option. All Antonio brown was guilty of is mis-calculating how far he could jump and ended up jumping too early. I see no ill intent here at all. We have a punter that didn't make the best decision when it comes to making a tackle--and we have a wr that mis-timed or mis-evaluated how far/high he could jump. The closest comparison that I can make to this is a basketball player trying to draw a charge.

 
Just saw on RotoWorld that Chuck Norris has been hired as a secondary coach for the Raiders. With the limitations on leading with the helmet, the Raiders have decided to adopt this as a tackling technique.

 
Pretty dissapointed Goodell hasn't issued any further punishment on this.

I get he will have his hands tied with the Rice stuff again but Brown should not be in uniform this weekend

 
Pretty dissapointed Goodell hasn't issued any further punishment on this.

I get he will have his hands tied with the Rice stuff again but Brown should not be in uniform this weekend
It hasn't even been 24 hours yet! :lol:

There is no way to know if it was intentional and Brown has zero history of unsportsmanship conduct. My guess is that he gets a fine but with Goodell you never know -- he might not get any further action to a multiple week suspension.

 
Pretty dissapointed Goodell hasn't issued any further punishment on this.

I get he will have his hands tied with the Rice stuff again but Brown should not be in uniform this weekend
It hasn't even been 24 hours yet! :lol:

There is no way to know if it was intentional and Brown has zero history of unsportsmanship conduct. My guess is that he gets a fine but with Goodell you never know -- he might not get any further action to a multiple week suspension.
I've watched hundreds of Antonio Brown games and practices.

I have seen him hurdle players at a higher distance.

His combine vertical jump was 33.5". When you factor in a running start he could easily clear 4'

I expect Goodell to piggyback on the domestic abuse issues of Ray Rice and come down hard on Brown trying to intentionally hurt a fellow player.

 
Pretty dissapointed Goodell hasn't issued any further punishment on this.

I get he will have his hands tied with the Rice stuff again but Brown should not be in uniform this weekend
Why would Goodell punish him? It sure looked to me like Antonio leaped too soon, and it was an accident. Even the guy he came down on thinks the same thing.

 
knowing how the suspension process works... could be any where from a game to a career ban.

as a steeler fan i expect him to be gone for the season. lol...

 
Last edited by a moderator:
Pretty dissapointed Goodell hasn't issued any further punishment on this.

I get he will have his hands tied with the Rice stuff again but Brown should not be in uniform this weekend
It hasn't even been 24 hours yet! :lol:

There is no way to know if it was intentional and Brown has zero history of unsportsmanship conduct. My guess is that he gets a fine but with Goodell you never know -- he might not get any further action to a multiple week suspension.
I've watched hundreds of Antonio Brown games and practices.

I have seen him hurdle players at a higher distance.

His combine vertical jump was 33.5". When you factor in a running start he could easily clear 4'

I expect Goodell to piggyback on the domestic abuse issues of Ray Rice and come down hard on Brown trying to intentionally hurt a fellow player.
:goodposting: I expect Goodell to give Brown the punishment he should have given Rice....

 
Pretty dissapointed Goodell hasn't issued any further punishment on this.

I get he will have his hands tied with the Rice stuff again but Brown should not be in uniform this weekend
It hasn't even been 24 hours yet! :lol:

There is no way to know if it was intentional and Brown has zero history of unsportsmanship conduct. My guess is that he gets a fine but with Goodell you never know -- he might not get any further action to a multiple week suspension.
I've watched hundreds of Antonio Brown games and practices.

I have seen him hurdle players at a higher distance.

His combine vertical jump was 33.5". When you factor in a running start he could easily clear 4'

I expect Goodell to piggyback on the domestic abuse issues of Ray Rice and come down hard on Brown trying to intentionally hurt a fellow player.
That's ridiculous. The two incidents have nothing to do with each other.

 
Sweet Chin music by the kung fu fighter.
I know you post this in jest, but my kids take Kung Fu lessons; that was a classic front kick. No doubt he knew what he was doing.
as a steeler fan I'd be surprised if he isnt suspended for atleast one game. Seemed like such a strange play.

It was like a hurdle but a jump over a guy. idk why he didnt keep the play outside and just run by the punter he had blockers on the outside

 
3C said:
Got quiet in here all of a sudden.
:shrug:

Not really much to talk about. A little wishful thinking being bandied about by those who dislike PIT for whatever reason, but there's no legs to this.

 
Brown should not be suspended but fined. The NFL is trying to clean up everything these days. They cannot have players kicking other players to the head.

 
comfortably numb said:
Pretty dissapointed Goodell hasn't issued any further punishment on this.

I get he will have his hands tied with the Rice stuff again but Brown should not be in uniform this weekend
:lmao:

 
He should receive a 1 quarter suspension and be required to speak at local schools as to why karate kicks should be saved for the dojo

 
B-Deep said:
AhrnCityPahnder said:
Mike Pereira -- (Former Vice President of Officiating in the National Football League. Current Rules Analyst at FOX Sports)

https://twitter.com/MikePereira/status/508684672876822529

"For those asking more about the Brown video, it's so unusual I'm surprised they even called it let alone ejecting him. He wont be suspended."
i had to look up what they called, like what penalty covers that?

illegal foot to the face?
"Unsportsmanlike conduct, blow to the head."

 
B-Deep said:
AhrnCityPahnder said:
Mike Pereira -- (Former Vice President of Officiating in the National Football League. Current Rules Analyst at FOX Sports)

https://twitter.com/MikePereira/status/508684672876822529

"For those asking more about the Brown video, it's so unusual I'm surprised they even called it let alone ejecting him. He wont be suspended."
i had to look up what they called, like what penalty covers that?

illegal foot to the face?
The only thing he was guilty of is letting the kicker prevent a TD.

 
B-Deep said:
AhrnCityPahnder said:
Mike Pereira -- (Former Vice President of Officiating in the National Football League. Current Rules Analyst at FOX Sports)

https://twitter.com/MikePereira/status/508684672876822529

"For those asking more about the Brown video, it's so unusual I'm surprised they even called it let alone ejecting him. He wont be suspended."
i had to look up what they called, like what penalty covers that?

illegal foot to the face?
The only thing he was guilty of is letting the kicker prevent a TD.
He is also guilty of displaying one of the most bizarre leaps in NFL history.

 

Users who are viewing this thread

Back
Top