With Petrino out will the Falcons still go after Brian Brohm? (1 Viewer)

[Jeff Haseley]

Now that Bobby Petrino has left for Arkansas, will Atlanta still go after Brian Brohm in the 2008 NFL Draft? It's pretty evident that a QB is on top of their list of must haves, but without the connection to Louisville and Brohm anymore, who will/should Atlanta pick? Discuss

 

[Pigskins]

Maybe they can draft a head coach.

 

[awesomeness]

Brohm or Ryan.

 

[Jeff Haseley]

From a recent article - Link - Opinions about drafting Darren McFadden over a QB in the first round to targeting JP Losman in a trade...

Petrino's departure also means Blank's franchise isn't tied to taking a Petrino-system quarterback in the first round of the '08 draft. All thoughts of drafting Brian Brohm and then praying that Brohm doesn't become a big bust should be gone. Like the Saints did by bringing in Reggie Bush, the Falcons should focus all their attention on bringing a dynamic, explosive rookie that can help the Atlanta fans forget about Michael Vick -- coincidentally, that's Arkansas junior running back Darren McFadden, who probably will leave school early rather than play for Petrino.

Of course, there's the job that still remains, regardless if Petrino had stayed or left: finding a quarterback. Again, they should just draft McFadden and not consider the possibility of Brohm or any other quarterback such as Matt Ryan, Colt Brennan or Andre' Woodson. Instead, they should go after a young veteran who should be available rather cheaply via trade: J.P. Losman.

Losman showed promise last season, and the Bills prematurely shut the door on him being their long-term starter. He has the mobility and strong arm to develop into a Tony Romo type, given the right coaching. Wait, hasn't Garrett done a good job with the actual Romo in Dallas? Interesting.

 

[PatrickT]

Losman is certainly on my list of QBs we should be interested in. I haven't seen much of him at all, and feedback here has been about 70% positive that he could be a good one.

 

[burd]

as one of the lone Falcons fan living in upstate NY, i've seen a lot of Losman the past couple of years and i think he can perform well ... in the right system. But i don't consider him a franchise QB, now or 5 years from now. I think he's reached the peak of his ability and the best a team can hope for is for JP to come in a manage the team much like a Brad Johnson-type QB. I think he'll be a vast improvement over Lefty but I would like the falcons to shoot for the moon and pickup Brohm or Ryan.

 

[jasonbay]

I doubt it, also after this move a lot have been saying now they will draft Matt Ryan, what about Andre Woodson?

 

[sdsjr3]

I think in the position that the Falcons are in, next year will likely be a development/rebuilding year. Thus, I think regarding the draft you take the best available players and fill in where you need via FA or trade.

 

[Max Power]

Losman is certainly on my list of QBs we should be interested in. I haven't seen much of him at all, and feedback here has been about 70% positive that he could be a good one.

That list must be quite short.I can only think of Grossman who will be a FA. Maybe Pennington can be had at a reasonable price. I doubt Derek Anderson really comes into play.Really what else is left? Culppeper?

 

[PatrickT]

Wasn't limiting it to just FA. It's in the Falcons season thread that I haven't posted in for awhile but off the top of my head, QBs that might be available via trade/FA, in no particular order.

Losman

McNabb

Andrew Walter

Aaron Rodgers

Chris Simms

Pennington

Quinn

Grossman

There were others. Some of those might be guys you want to look at as possible futures of the franchise, but most are experienced QBs who can keep you competitive while you groom a young QB that you drafted.

 

[sdsjr3]

Losman is certainly on my list of QBs we should be interested in. I haven't seen much of him at all, and feedback here has been about 70% positive that he could be a good one.

That list must be quite short.I can only think of Grossman who will be a FA. Maybe Pennington can be had at a reasonable price. I doubt Derek Anderson really comes into play.Really what else is left? Culppeper?

Have to think Clev. must be wondering what they can get on the market for Quinn. If they make the decision to stick with Anderson going forward, it would hardly be worth paying Quinn top dollar to learn for 3 or 4 years. Or course, GB has done that with Rogers so who knows.

 

[patrickmcgroin]

From a recent article - Link - Opinions about drafting Darren McFadden over a QB in the first round to targeting JP Losman in a trade...

Petrino's departure also means Blank's franchise isn't tied to taking a Petrino-system quarterback in the first round of the '08 draft. All thoughts of drafting Brian Brohm and then praying that Brohm doesn't become a big bust should be gone. Like the Saints did by bringing in Reggie Bush, the Falcons should focus all their attention on bringing a dynamic, explosive rookie that can help the Atlanta fans forget about Michael Vick -- coincidentally, that's Arkansas junior running back Darren McFadden, who probably will leave school early rather than play for Petrino.

Of course, there's the job that still remains, regardless if Petrino had stayed or left: finding a quarterback. Again, they should just draft McFadden and not consider the possibility of Brohm or any other quarterback such as Matt Ryan, Colt Brennan or Andre' Woodson. Instead, they should go after a young veteran who should be available rather cheaply via trade: J.P. Losman.

Losman showed promise last season, and the Bills prematurely shut the door on him being their long-term starter. He has the mobility and strong arm to develop into a Tony Romo type, given the right coaching. Wait, hasn't Garrett done a good job with the actual Romo in Dallas? Interesting.

I hope they don't, but that is probably their best bet.

 

[Slinger]

I can't remember who, but someone on the FBG's staff wrote about this and pointed out that picking a QB in the first round is typically a bad idea. So if I'm a Falcons fan I'm hoping they go elsewhere.

 

[PatrickT]

I think it's something 50/50 success rate. I'm with you, tho, I'd rather focus on the trenches.

 

[Max Power]

Wasn't limiting it to just FA. It's in the Falcons season thread that I haven't posted in for awhile but off the top of my head, QBs that might be available via trade/FA, in no particular order.

Losman - Solid QB

McNabb - with that O-Line, McNabb would be 100% worthless

Andrew Walter - sub par stop gap

Aaron Rodgers - Not going anywhere

Chris Simms - doubtful trade between division foes

Pennington - Might be the best bet. Hopefully Jets will let him go.

Quinn - I can't comment on this situation as no one knows what the Browns are thinking

Grossman - Can be had cheap. Might be a fun QB to watch for a rebuilding team

There were others. Some of those might be guys you want to look at as possible futures of the franchise, but most are experienced QBs who can keep you competitive while you groom a young QB that you drafted.

It is just a bad year for the QB market. Probably the best bet would be to pick up Grossman and draft a QB. I personally like Ryan more than Bhrom. I can only imagine Petrino left a bad taste in Blank's mouth. If Petrino openly stated that he wanted Bhrom, I can see them going in a different direction just because of how things played out.

 

[Max Power]

I can't remember who, but someone on the FBG's staff wrote about this and pointed out that picking a QB in the first round is typically a bad idea. So if I'm a Falcons fan I'm hoping they go elsewhere.

I would really love to read that article. I remember looking up how #1 overall QBs have played out for teams in the NFL. 25% of Superbowls have been won by #1 overall QB picks. I would love to see the % for first round QB picks.

 

[phthalatemagic]

Brohm or Ryan.

Why Ryan?Woodson >>>>>>>>>>>>>>> Ryan

 

[Max Power]

I can't remember who, but someone on the FBG's staff wrote about this and pointed out that picking a QB in the first round is typically a bad idea. So if I'm a Falcons fan I'm hoping they go elsewhere.

:X I would really love to read that article. I remember looking up how #1 overall QBs have played out for teams in the NFL. 25% of Superbowls have been won by #1 overall QB picks. I would love to see the % for first round QB picks.

after a quick search...Looks like a first round QB pick has won the SB 22 times. Over 50%.Not great, but enough to justify taking a QB early.

 

[PatrickT]

Wasn't limiting it to just FA. It's in the Falcons season thread that I haven't posted in for awhile but off the top of my head, QBs that might be available via trade/FA, in no particular order.

Losman - Solid QB

McNabb - with that O-Line, McNabb would be 100% worthless

Andrew Walter - sub par stop gap

Aaron Rodgers - Not going anywhere

Chris Simms - doubtful trade between division foes

Pennington - Might be the best bet. Hopefully Jets will let him go.

Quinn - I can't comment on this situation as no one knows what the Browns are thinking

Grossman - Can be had cheap. Might be a fun QB to watch for a rebuilding team

There were others. Some of those might be guys you want to look at as possible futures of the franchise, but most are experienced QBs who can keep you competitive while you groom a young QB that you drafted.

It is just a bad year for the QB market. Probably the best bet would be to pick up Grossman and draft a QB. I personally like Ryan more than Bhrom. I can only imagine Petrino left a bad taste in Blank's mouth. If Petrino openly stated that he wanted Bhrom, I can see them going in a different direction just because of how things played out.

I agree, but I really don't want Grossman. I think I'd rather have Losman over Grossman. I kinda like trading for McNabb and drafting a QB of the future. Then spend every other pick on offensive linemen. I don't know how serious the McNabb trade rumours are tho.

 

[Max Power]

Wasn't limiting it to just FA. It's in the Falcons season thread that I haven't posted in for awhile but off the top of my head, QBs that might be available via trade/FA, in no particular order.

Losman - Solid QB

McNabb - with that O-Line, McNabb would be 100% worthless

Andrew Walter - sub par stop gap

Aaron Rodgers - Not going anywhere

Chris Simms - doubtful trade between division foes

Pennington - Might be the best bet. Hopefully Jets will let him go.

Quinn - I can't comment on this situation as no one knows what the Browns are thinking

Grossman - Can be had cheap. Might be a fun QB to watch for a rebuilding team

There were others. Some of those might be guys you want to look at as possible futures of the franchise, but most are experienced QBs who can keep you competitive while you groom a young QB that you drafted.

It is just a bad year for the QB market. Probably the best bet would be to pick up Grossman and draft a QB. I personally like Ryan more than Bhrom. I can only imagine Petrino left a bad taste in Blank's mouth. If Petrino openly stated that he wanted Bhrom, I can see them going in a different direction just because of how things played out.

I agree, but I really don't want Grossman. I think I'd rather have Losman over Grossman. I kinda like trading for McNabb and drafting a QB of the future. Then spend every other pick on offensive linemen. I don't know how serious the McNabb trade rumours are tho.

Sounds like he is willing to move on, but only to a contender. Mcnabb doesnt even want to play for the Bears due to the "lack" of talent in his words. Id put the ATL O on par with the Bears. My guess is the Eagles will have a high asking price. I would pay a high price for a guy who woundn't want to be there.You should give Rexy a chance... he is a fun QB to watch when your team isn't playing for much.