Witten vs. Dallas Clark (1 Viewer)

[Craig_MiamiFL]

Where would you guys rank these 2 in terms of TE's dynasty wise? PPR wise I believe Witten's ranked #1 and Dallas is in the Top 5 or so.

Clark's seemingly done minimal until this year (contract year I believe) but looks to be now the #3 WR option there and Witten's had a couple very solid seasons and looks to be Romo's #1 target their in Big D.

 

[maxwell1295]

Right now they're close because Romo has been shaky and Harrison has been hurt. If and when Marvin gets back to being Marvin again, Clark will return to his #3 status in that offense. Whitten has been the #1 target in Dallas. How long will that last before T.O. starts getting in Romo's ear? I like Whitten better, but Clark has been impressive so far...

 

[fruity pebbles]

Easily Witten for me. More of a history of performance year after year.

 

[bumpman]

I would rate Witten higher, largely because I think Clark gets injured pretty regularly. Also, Witten gets more of his points from yardage than TDs. As the number of TDs vary year to year, I think that makes Witten a more consistent performer.

 

[JohnnyU]

I think you should trade Witten for Clark + something to help your team. If you own Clark, I think you should stand pat

 

[David Yudkin]

Clark DOB 6/12/79

Witten DOB 5/6/82

 

[murzman]

I think you should trade Witten for Clark + something to help your team. If you own Clark, I think you should stand pat

Aother one JohnnyU! Saw your post in the thread about if Rod Smith has any value. THis is getting annoying. You are digging too much to try and police threads into the ACF.Here's some more policing you can do and suggested comments you can make:

Jordan-Rhodes Full Blown Committee?

Post: "I think you should bench Jordan and pick up Rhodes from the waiver wire"

Tampa Def!, Upgrade?

Post: "Yes, you should pick up and start TB this week"

Is Tom Brady a top 5 pick next year in fantasy drafts?

Post: "I don't think you should draft Brady with your #5 pick in your 2008 draft"

Weather for NYG-Mia London game?

Post: "You should bench Eli if it is too windy"

Free agent RBs at the end of the 07 season?

Post: "You should try and trade for Michael Turner this year"

Brady vs. Manning

Post: "No, don't trade Brady for Manning in dynasty"

Now I can't wait to open some of these threads and actually see a post like these that is already there!

My point in posting this is to say that probably >90% of activity in this forum does pertain to people's fantasy teams. I would guess that most people spend most of their time in threads pertaining to fantasy players they own or are thinking of acquiring. So really, most posts are in some way associated with someone's team. The others are for enjoymenet of football discussion. I may start a thread on Oakland's starting QB situation with updates because I own Cpepp. Is that wrong? Does that belong in the ACF then? Maybe the guy started the "Tampa Def!, Upgrade?" thread because he owns them or is thinking of picking them up. That is fine. It is still relevant information for people to recognize that the Jags are starting a weak D and their offense in general should be downgraded. Nothing wrong with a post like that IMO.

 

[JimboJim]

I think you should trade Witten for Clark + something to help your team. If you own Clark, I think you should stand pat

Aother one JohnnyU! Saw your post in the thread about if Rod Smith has any value. THis is getting annoying. You are digging too much to try and police threads into the ACF.Here's some more policing you can do and suggested comments you can make:

Jordan-Rhodes Full Blown Committee?

Post: "I think you should bench Jordan and pick up Rhodes from the waiver wire"

Tampa Def!, Upgrade?

Post: "Yes, you should pick up and start TB this week"

Is Tom Brady a top 5 pick next year in fantasy drafts?

Post: "I don't think you should draft Brady with your #5 pick in your 2008 draft"

Weather for NYG-Mia London game?

Post: "You should bench Eli if it is too windy"

Free agent RBs at the end of the 07 season?

Post: "You should try and trade for Michael Turner this year"

Brady vs. Manning

Post: "No, don't trade Brady for Manning in dynasty"

Now I can't wait to open some of these threads and actually see a post like these that is already there!

I find the self-righteous know-it-all "board policing" post way more annoying than WDIS or "should I make this move" topic.

I actually entered this thread to find out a little more on the long-term prospects of both players.

Get a life Johnny U...