Would you trade Jamaal Charles for Arian Foster, rite now?! (1 Viewer)

[stymin52]

AND WHY???

 

[rizzler]

If you know me, you know my answer.

Mind you, I am a HUGE Charles fan, and was an early predictor of his NFL success.

Id happily have either, but if someone offered me Foster in return for my charles... Id take it.

 

[Sarnoff]

Why would the Texans agree to this? Foster is pretty well liked by the fans.

 

[Ignoratio Elenchi]

YES!?!

 

[rizzler]

Why would the Texans agree to this? Foster is pretty well liked by the fans.

er, this is more about his roster I believe.NFL wise, as of right now, Id want Charles. better proven.

 

[stymin52]

Why would the Texans agree to this? Foster is pretty well liked by the fans.

for my fantasy league man

 

[BearDown54]

if i was offered foster i'd take that and laugh all the way to the bank

 

[ConnSKINS26]

Why would the Texans agree to this? Foster is pretty well liked by the fans.

for my fantasy league man

I think we need all the details before we can make an informed decision. Your roster, your draft picks, the rosters of your opponents, your league rules and lineup, and a link to your league page. How much are your league dues? How long has your league existed? What other trades have gone down lately in your league? How many of your league's owners are married? Are their wives hot? Any kids? Where does everybody work? What teams do they root for? Where do you guys live? Republicans, Democrats, Libertarians? Star Wars or Star Trek? Gas or Charcoal? I mean, I'm just trying to be thorough. We need to know everything about YOUR fantasy team before we can give you team advice on YOUR fantasy team. http://forums.footballguys.com/forum/index.php?showforum=12

 

[Sarnoff]

Why would the Texans agree to this? Foster is pretty well liked by the fans.

for my fantasy league man

Wrong forum then, man

 

[Restricted]

Redraft yes. Dynasty no.

 

[Cenobite]

Why would the Texans agree to this? Foster is pretty well liked by the fans.

for my fantasy league man

Wrong forum then, man

Yet people are still answering the question. Lots of pissing in the pool. This is not the place for trade advice.

 

[Run It Up]

Yes, even though foster is recovering from a hammy injury he still plays for the Texans in the AFC south. Jamaal Charles on the other hand plays for the Chiefs and has the toughest schedule in the NFL.

 

[sharptongued1]

Redraft yes. Dynasty no.

I don't even think in a dynasty it matters. Charles is only a little over a year younger than Foster.

 

[Scooter71]

Absolutely and unhesitatingly yes.

 

[Hipple Long Ware & Peete]

ACF hoss. BECAUSE you CAN'T READ

 

[Restricted]

Redraft yes. Dynasty no.

I don't even think in a dynasty it matters. Charles is only a little over a year younger than Foster.

Charles is a considerably better talent in my eyes where Foster is in a better system for a time.

 

[mr roboto]

I'd want Foster.

Both their situations have significant questions (good young RB behind Foster, coach in KC who won't feed Charles the rock consistently and a putrid offense) but Foster will have more carries and chances at TD's assuming the hammy heals up.

Having said that, you may be able to get a throw-in with Foster right now because of the injury.

 

[Sarnoff]

rite now?!

Exorcism?