WSL 3 (1 Viewer)

[Pictus Cat]

gocats

6.16 QB15 Jay Cutler, DEN

8.16 QB25 Byron Leftwich, JAC

18.16 QB38 D. Garrard JAC

1.01 RB 1 LaDainian Tomlinson, SD

4.16 RB 30 Marshawn Lynch, ???

10.16 Ricky Williams, RB51, MIA?

15.01 RB65 Brandon Jackson ???

2.16 WR7 Terrell Owens, DAL

3.01 WR8 Torry Holt, STL

5.01 WR25 Joey Galloway, TB

9.01 WR48 Reggie Williams, JAC

11.01 WR62 Ted Ginn, ???

12.16 WR78 Robert Meachem

20.16 Shaun McDonald WR105 Rams

7.01 TE10 Benjamin Watson, NE

13.01 TE19 Ben Troupe TEN

16.16 PK23 Kris Brown HOU

19.01 PK26 O. Mare MIA

14.16 Dallas Cowboys DT12

17.01 def28 Washington

Nugget

4.15 QB5 Tom Brady, NE

5.02QB6 Michael Vick, ATL

1.02 RB 2 Steven Jackson, STL

6.15 RB38 Warrick Dunn, ATL

9.02 RB42 DeShaun Foster, CAR

13.02 RB56 Michael Pittman TB

2.15 WR6 Anquan Boldin, ARZ

3.02 WR9 Roy Williams, DET

8.15 WR47 Ronald Curry, OAK

10.15 WR61 Patrick Crayton DAL

11.02 WR63 Brandon Jones, TEN

12.15 WR77 Dwayne Bowe, LSU

18.15 WR96 Samie Parker, KC

19.02 WR97 Roscoe Parrish, BUF

7.02 TE11 LJ Smith, PHI

20.15 TE28 Randall Williams, OAK

16.15 PK12 Jason Hanson DET

17.02 PK13 Stephen Gostkowski

14.15 DEF11 Miami Dolphins, MIA

15.02 DEF13 Seattle Seahawks, SEA

Wolverine

6.14 QB14 Tony Romo DAL

7.03 QB16 Ben Roethlisberger PIT

11.03 Jake Plummer, QB30, ???

1.03 RB 3 Larry Johnson, KC

4.14 RB29 Cedric Benson, CHI

5.02 RB 31 Fred Taylor, JAC

19.03 Tony Hunt RB70 ??

3.03 WR10 Andre Johnson, HOU

8.14 WR46 Eddie Kennison, KC

9.03 WR49 Joe Horn, NO

10.14 DJ Hackett WR60 Seattle

13.03 Terance Copper WR79 NO

15.03 WR83 Ashley Lelie ??

20.14 Anthony Gonzales WR104 ??

2.14 TE2 Kellen Winslow III, CLE

14.14 Daniel Graham TE21 NE

17.03 PK14 John Carney

18.14 S. Janikowski PK25 Oak

12.14 New England Patriots D/ST 3

16.14 D/ST23 Oakland

Getinthemix

6.13 QB13 Matt Leinart, AZ

8.13 QB24 Chris Simms, TB

1.04 RB 4 Brian Westbrook, PHI

2.13 RB20 Carnell "Cadillac" Williams, TB

3.04 RB 21 Adrian Peterson, ???

4.13 WR24 Braylon Edwards, CLE

5.04 WR26 Randy Moss, OAK

9.04 WR50 Chad Jackson, NEP

10.13 Jerry Porter, WR59, OAK

12.13 WR76 Eric Parker, SD

15.04 Nate Burleson, WR84, SEA

18.13 Derek Hagan, WR95, MIA

20.13 Mike Williams, WR103, DET

7.04 TE12 Heath Miller, PIT

11.04 Owen Daniels, TE16, HOU

16.13 Josh Scobee, PK11, JAX

17.04 John Kasay, K15 CAR

13.04 Philly Eagles, D5

14.13 Tennesee Titans D10

19.04 Houston Texans, D28

oldfatguy

2.12 QB3 Drew Brees, NO

8.12 QB23 Bret Favre QB GB

1.05 RB 5 Joseph Addai, IND

3.05 RB 22 Marion Barber III, DAL

9.05 RB43 Ladell Betts, WAS

19.05 RB71 Marcel Shipp ARI FA

15.05 RB66 Lorenzo Booker ???

4.12 WR23 Jerricho Cotchery, NYJ

5.05 WR27 Mike Furrey, DET

7.05 WR35 Vincent Jackson, SDG

10.12 Kevin Curtis WR58 STL

12.12 WR75 Mark Bradley CHI

13.05 WR80 Nate Washington PIT

20.12 WR102 Maurice Stivall TMB

6.12 TE9 Vernon Davis SF

18.12 TE24 Chris Baker NYJ

14.12 PK5 Shayne Graham CIN

17.05 PK16 J. Reed, PIT

11.05 San Diego DEF2

16.12 Cincinnati DEF22

pigskin pimp

6.11 QB12 Jon Kitna DET

11.06 QB31 Tarvaris Jackson MN

20.11 QB42 Joey Harrington MIA

1.06 RB 6 Reggie Bush, NO

2.11 RB19 Willis McGahee, BUF

12.11 RB55 Chris Brown UFA

14.11 RB64 Wali Lundy HOU

13.06 RB57 Kevin Faulk NE

15.06 RB67 Anthony Thomas BUF

3.06 WR11 Marques Colston, NO

5.06 WR28 Donte Stallworth UFA

7.06 WR36 Matt Jones, JAX

8.11 WR43 Brandon Marshall DEN

10.11 WR57 Troy Williamson MIN

4.11 TE5 Jeremy Shockey NYG

19.06 TE24 Zach Miller ASU

17.06 K17 Lawrence Tynes KC

18.11 K24 Rian Lindell BUF

9.06 DEF1 Chicago Bears

16.11 DEF21 Kansas City Chiefs

aposulli

2.10 QB2 Carson Palmer, CIN

9.07 QB26 Chad Pennington, NYJ

1.07 RB 7 Shaun Alexander, SEA

5.07 RB32 Jamal Lewis, BAL

7.07- Mike Bell, RB 39, DEN

10.10 Kenny Irons, RB50, ???

13.07- Musa Smith, RB58, BAL

14.10- Maurice Morris, RB63, SEA

20.10 Mike Anderson, RB74, BAL

3.07 WR12 TJ Houshmandzadeh, CIN

4.10 WR 22 Reggie Brown, PHI

6.10 WR38 Calvin Johnson, ???

8.10 WR42 Chris Henry, CIN

12.10- Jabbar Gaffney, WR74, NE

11.07- Jerramy Stevens, TE17, SEA

18.10 Eric Johnson, TE23, SF

17.07 Rob Bironas, K18, TEN

19.07 Mason Crosby, K27, ???

15.07- New York Jets, D/ST14

16.10- New York Giants, D/ST20

wannabee

2.09 QB1 Peyton Manning, IND

11.08 Charlie Frye, QB32, Cleve

1.08 RB 8 Frank Gore, SF

4.09 RB 28 Thomas Jones, CHI

8.09 RB41 Corey Dillon, NE

18.09 Brian Leonard, RB69, ????

20.09 Dwayne Wright, RB73, ???

3.08 WR13 Lee Evans, BUF

5.08 WR33 Terry Glenn, DAL

6.09 WR37 Bernard Berrian, CHI

12.09 Demetrius Williams, WR73, Balt

14.09 Joe Jurevicius, WR82, Cleve

15.08 Drew Carter, WR85, Carolina

16.09 Peerless Price, WR91, Buf

7.08 TE13 Desmond Clark, CHI

9.08 TE14 Randy McMichael, Mia

13.08 Adam Vinateri, PK1, Ind

19.08 Matt Bryant, K28, TB

10.09 Baltimore Ravens Def2

17.08 Arizona Cardinal Defense24

H.K.

6.08 QB11 Philip Rivers, SD

8.8 QB22 Jason Campbell, WAS

1.09 RB 9 "Fast" Willie Parker, PIT

2.08 RB 18 Deuce McAllister, NO

9.09 RB 44 Dominic Williams (formerly Davis), Texans

13.09 RB59 Correll Buckhalter, Eagles

19.09 Najah Davenport, RB 72 Steelers

3.09 WR14 Plaxico Burress, NYG

4.08 WR 21Chris Chambers, MIA

7.09 WR37 Derrick Mason, BAL

10.08 Michael Clayton, WR56 Buccaneers

11.09 WR64 Travis Taylor, Vikings

20.08 Josh Reed, WR101 Bills

5.09 TE6 Chris Cooley, WAS

12.08 Alex Smith, TE18 Buccaneers

15.09 David Akers, K6 Eagles

17.09 M. Nugent, K19 Jets

14.08 Jacksonville Jaguars, D/ST 9

16.08 Atlanta Falcons D/ST19

18.08 St. Louis Rams, D/ST27

Domination

6.07 QB10 Eli Manning, NYG

11.10 QB33 JaMarcus Russell, ????

13.10 QB Jeff Garcia, Eagles ???

1.10 RB 10 Rudi Johnson, CIN

5.10 RB33 Julius Jones, DAL

9.10 RB 45 Michael Bush, ???

10.07 RB49 Dominic Rhodes, Indianapolis Colts

12.07 RB54 Brian Calhoun, DET

3.10 WR15 Javon Walker, DEN

4.07 WR20 Darrell Jackson, SEA

7.10 WR38 Issac Bruce, STL

8.07 WR41 Antonio Bryant, SF

16.07 WR90 Brandon Stokley, IND

20.07 WR100 JASON AVANT, Philly

2.07 TE1 Antonio Gates, SD

19.10 TE25 Greg Olson, ???

14.07 PK4 Neil Rackers, AZ

17.10 PK18 Jay Feely, NYG

15.10 Carolina Panthers Def15

18.07 San Francisco 49'ers Def26

wraith5

4.06 QB4 Donavan McNabb, PHI

7.11 QB17 Jake Delhomme, Carolina Panthers

20.06 Damon Huard, QB41, Kansas City Chiefs

1.11 RB 11 Maurice Jones-Drew, JAC

5.11 RB 34 Tatum Bell, DEN

9.11 RB 46 Leon Washington, NYJ

12.06 Vernand Morency, RB53 Green Bay Packers

18.06 Justin Fargas, RB68 Oak

2.06 WR5 Reggie Wayne, IND

3.11 WR16 Donald Driver, GB

8.06 WR40 Mushin Muhammad, CHI

10.06 Keyshawn Johnson (hopefully) wr55 Carolina

11.11 Marty Booker, WR65 Miami Dolphins

16.06 Bobby Engram, WR89 Seattle

6.06 TE8 Jason Witten, DAL

13.11 Jermaine Wiggins TE 20 MIN

15.11 Jeff Wilkins K7 STL

17.11 Joe Nedney, K19 49'ers

14.06 Minnesota Defense 8

19.11 DEF/ST31 Detroit Lions

CommuterMan

8.05 QB21 JP Losman BUF

10.05 David Carr - QB29 Hou

19.12 Aaron Brooks - QB39 Oak (???)

1.12 RB 12 Kevin Jones, DET

3.12 RB23 DeAngelo Williams, CAR

6.05 RB37 Michael Turner, SD

7.12 Lendale White - RB 40 TEN

2.05 WR4 Chad Johnson, CIN

5.12 WR 34 Mark Clayton, BAL

9.12 Drew Bennett - WR51 Tennessee

11.12 Rod Smith - WR66 Denver

12.05 Eric Moulds - WR72 Houston

15.12 Sinorice Moss - WR86 NYG

20.05 Brandon Lloyd - WR99, Wash

4.05 TE4 Todd Heap, BAL

18.05 Bo Scaife - TE22, Ten

14.05 Robbie Gould - PK3 Chicago

16.05 Josh Brown - PK10 Sea

13.12 Steelers Def6

17.12 Tampa Bay Bucs def25

Pictus Cat

7.13 QB18 Rex Grossman, CHI

8.04 QB20 Daunte Culpepper MIA

13.13 QB35 Matt Schaub ATL?

1.13 RB 13 Ronnie Brown, MIA

5.13 RB 35 Reuben Droughns, CLE

9.13 RB47 Cedric Houston, NYJ

10.04 RB48 Chris Perry, CIN

2.04 WR3 Marvin Harrison, IND

3.13 WR17 Hines Ward, PIT

6.04 WR36 Deion Branch, SEA

11.13 WR67 Wesley Welker, MIA

12.04 WR71 Bryant Johnson ARI

14.04 WR81 Roddy White, ATL

20.04 WR98 Billy McMullen , Min

4.04 TE3 Tony Gonzalez, KC

19.13 TE26 G Wrightster, JAX

17.13 PK20 Ryan Longwell, MIN

18.04 PK22 Phil Dawson, CLE

15.13 DST16 New Orleans

16.04 DST18 Indianapolis Colts

JetsWillWin

5.14 QB7 Marc Bulger, STL

9.14 Trent Green, QB27 KCC

14.03 QB36 Brady Quinn

18.03 KELLEN CLEMENS, QB37 NYJ

1.14 RB 14 Clinton Portis, WAS

2.03 RB 17 Laurence Maroney, NE

3.14 RB24 Travis Henry, TEN

11.14 TJ DUCKETT, RB 52 ???

13.14 Antonio Pittman, RB 61 ??

4.03 WR19 Santana Moss, WAS

6.03 WR35 Greg Jennings, GB

7.14 WR39 Santonio Holmes, PIT

10.03 Dwayne Jarret, WR54

12.03 Wilford, Ernest JAC WR70

15.14 Sidney Rice, WR87 ??

17.14 David Givens, WR92 TEN

8.03 TE 13 Dallas Clark IND

20.03 DAVID THOMAS, TE27 NEP

19.14 MIKE VANDERJAGT, FA IDIOT K29

16.03 Buffalo DST17

jmills

5.15 QB8 Matt Hasslebeck, SEA

7.15 QB19 Alex Smith, SF

20.02 Seneca Wallace - QB40, Oak

1.15 RB 15 Edgerrin James, ARZ

3.15 RB 25 Lamont Jordan, OAK

6.02 RB36 Jerious Norwood, ATL

13.15 Greg Jones, RB 60, Jax

2.02 WR2 Steve Smith, CAR

4.02 WR18 Laveranues Coles, NYJ

10.02 Hank Baskett, WR53, PHI

11.15 Michael Jenkins, WR68, ATL

12.02 Amani Toomer, WR69, NYG

16.02 Antwaan Randle-El, WR88, Was

17.15 Johnnie Lee Higgins, WR93, ??

8.02 TE 12 Tony Scheffler, DEN

9.15 Marcedes Lewis, TE15, Jax

1515 Matt Stover PK8 Bal

18.02 Dave Rayner, PK21, GB

14.02 Denver Broncos D 7

19.15 Cleveland Browns D 32

Tony Jabroni

5.16 QB9 Vince Young, TEN

10.01--QB28--Steve Mcnair--BAL

1.16 RB 16 Chester Taylor, MIN

3.16 RB26 Ahman Green, GB

4.01 RB27 Brandon Jacobs, NYG

11.16--Ron Dayne RB 56

14.01 RB 62 Mewelde Moore MIN

14.01 RB 75 Madison Hedgecock STL

2.01 WR1 Larry Fitzgerald, ARZ

7.16 (8.12) WR44 Devery Henderson, NO

8.01 (8.13) WR45 Reche Caldwell NE

9.16--WR52--Arnaz Battle--SF

16.01--Jeff Webb--WR87--KC

18.01 Keenan Mccardell--WR94--SD

20.01 Taye Biddle--WR106--CAR

6.01 TE7 Alge Crumpler, ATL

17.16 Ben Utecht--TE24--IND

13.16 PK2 Nate Kaeding SD

15.16--Jason Elam--K9--DEN

12.01 --Packers DEF4

 

[gocats]

Im having an excellent draft so far, stacked at RB and WR

 

[pigskin pimp]

Im having an excellent draft so far, stacked at RB and WR

I think anyone's lineup would look pretty good with the #1 overall selection, not to mention 3 picks in 33.

 

[wannabee]

Im having an excellent draft so far, stacked at RB and WR

I think anyone's lineup would look pretty good with the #1 overall selection, not to mention 3 picks in 33.

as long as he does not waste a pick on that Ruben Jones guy .....

 

[Nugget]

My attempt to single-handidly start a QB run does not appear to be going so well.

Nugget

4.15 QB5 Tom Brady, New England Patriots

5.02QB6 Michael Vick, Atlanta Falcons

1.02 RB 2 Steven Jackson, St. Louis Rams

2.15 WR6 Anquan Boldin, Arizona Cardinals

3.02 WR9 Roy Williams, Detroit Lions

 

[gocats]

Im having an excellent draft so far, stacked at RB and WR

I think anyone's lineup would look pretty good with the #1 overall selection, not to mention 3 picks in 33.

 

[wraith5]

Im having an excellent draft so far, stacked at RB and WR

I think anyone's lineup would look pretty good with the #1 overall selection, not to mention 3 picks in 33.

as long as he does not waste a pick on that Ruben Jones guy .....

 

[H.K.]

My attempt to single-handidly start a QB run does not appear to be going so well.Nugget4.15 QB5 Tom Brady, New England Patriots5.02QB6 Michael Vick, Atlanta Falcons1.02 RB 2 Steven Jackson, St. Louis Rams2.15 WR6 Anquan Boldin, Arizona Cardinals3.02 WR9 Roy Williams, Detroit Lions

More bad news, Pats & Falcons have the same bye week.j/k

 

[gocats]

My attempt to single-handidly start a QB run does not appear to be going so well.Nugget4.15 QB5 Tom Brady, New England Patriots5.02QB6 Michael Vick, Atlanta Falcons1.02 RB 2 Steven Jackson, St. Louis Rams2.15 WR6 Anquan Boldin, Arizona Cardinals3.02 WR9 Roy Williams, Detroit Lions

More bad news, Pats & Falcons have the same bye week.The schedules arent even out yet correct?j/k

 

[ffweasel]

My attempt to single-handidly start a QB run does not appear to be going so well.Nugget4.15 QB5 Tom Brady, New England Patriots5.02QB6 Michael Vick, Atlanta Falcons1.02 RB 2 Steven Jackson, St. Louis Rams2.15 WR6 Anquan Boldin, Arizona Cardinals3.02 WR9 Roy Williams, Detroit Lions

More bad news, Pats & Falcons have the same bye week.The schedules arent even out yet correct?j/k

I think you missed the ( j/k ) part above.

 

[Jeff Pasquino]

After 10 rounds, Nugget, aposulli and wannabee out ahead.

 

[H.K.]

It all comes down to schedule and who gets burned with bye weeks and injuries.

I would really like Domination's squad if he had a 2nd QB, tho.

eta: Nugget has done a good job, too.

 

[aposulli]

After 10 rounds, Nugget, aposulli and wannabee out ahead.

 

[Domination]

I think that I am pretty satisfied with my team. But you asked for the early lead:

APOSULLI

 

[H.K.]

I think that I am pretty satisfied with my team. But you asked for the early lead:

APOSULLI

He has a good team, but its not my nature to be shy and I think you guys are overlooking some obvious issues with his roster in this survivor format:1) Three Bengals (Palmer, Housh, & Henry) - good luck if the offense goes through CJ & Rudi for a few weeks...not to mention the bye week hole.

2) No TE yet. At 2 PPR, the position makes more of an impact in this scoring system.

 

[pigskin pimp]

13.06 RB Kevin Faulk NE

...just saying...

 

[Pictus Cat]

Let me know if you find any errors in your team.

Anyone want to tier the teams? Evaluate them?

 

[H.K.]

Let me know if you find any errors in your team.

I found plenty... Please give me Peyton, Carson, LT, SJax, SAlex, LJ, Holt, SSmith, CJ, TO, Marvin, Gates, Vin, & Bears D and I should be all set.TIA!

 

[wraith5]

wraith5 -

Well, I'm not going to be the first to throw stones, but I'll take a look at my own results. I will say that I really did not prepare for this draft - I flew by the seat of my pants the whole way. Stayed away from the draft class entirely for this reason.

4.06 QB4 Donovan McNabb, PHI

7.11 QB17 Jake Delhomme, CAR

20.06 QB41 Damon Huard, KC

Taking two QB's that early, I'd better have a solid pair, and I think I do. QB is a high-scoring position, so I wanted to have this locked down each and every week. Huard was a flier - I think he has as much chance at QB'ing the Chiefs as Green, if not more. A.

1.11 RB 11 Maurice Jones-Drew, JAC

5.11 RB 34 Tatum Bell, DEN

9.11 RB 46 Leon Washington, NYJ

12.06 RB53 Vernand Morency, GB

18.06 RB68 Justin Fargas, Oak

After Maurice, there is a lot of risk here. You never know what is going to happen in Denver with Tater Bell - but his YPC is hard to ignore. If not for his injury this year he would have been VERY solid. The others are all BIG question marks... this is the weakest link on my squad. C.

2.06 WR5 Reggie Wayne, IND

3.11 WR16 Donald Driver, GB

8.06 WR40 Mushin Muhammad, CHI

10.06 WR55 Keyshawn Johnson, CAR

11.11 WR65 Marty Booker, MIA

16.06 WR89 Bobby Engram, SEA

Assuming Me-shawn returns to CAR, I like my WR's quite a lot. Booker and Engram both have good upside, IMO. Farve returning to GB ensures Driver should be very solid once again. I should be able to put up 3 good starters week in / week out, even on BYE weeks (famous last words right there). B+

6.06 TE8 Jason Witten, DAL

13.11 TE 20 Jermaine Wiggins MIN

Witten did better with Romo at QB than he did early, so I feel good about that pick. Wiggins is an acceptable back-up. B.

15.11 K7 Jeff Wilkins STL

17.11 K19 Joe Nedney SF

Both of these guys can have occasional big weeks and ranked high in '06 (#3 and #7, respectively). B.

14.06 DEF8 Minnesota Defense

19.11 DEF31 Detroit Lions

On the surface, this doesn't look all that great, but both of these teams created turnovers last year, and both seem to make things happen on special teams. DET is a total mess, so I guess we'll see what happens after the draft and free agency. C+

I think I make it past mid-season.

 

[H.K.]

wraith5 - Well, I'm not going to be the first to throw stones, but I'll take a look at my own results. I will say that I really did not prepare for this draft - I flew by the seat of my pants the whole way. Stayed away from the draft class entirely for this reason. 4.06 QB4 Donovan McNabb, PHI7.11 QB17 Jake Delhomme, CAR20.06 QB41 Damon Huard, KC Taking two QB's that early, I'd better have a solid pair, and I think I do. QB is a high-scoring position, so I wanted to have this locked down each and every week. Huard was a flier - I think he has as much chance at QB'ing the Chiefs as Green, if not more. A.1.11 RB 11 Maurice Jones-Drew, JAC5.11 RB 34 Tatum Bell, DEN9.11 RB 46 Leon Washington, NYJ12.06 RB53 Vernand Morency, GB18.06 RB68 Justin Fargas, OakAfter Maurice, there is a lot of risk here. You never know what is going to happen in Denver with Tater Bell - but his YPC is hard to ignore. If not for his injury this year he would have been VERY solid. The others are all BIG question marks... this is the weakest link on my squad. C. 2.06 WR5 Reggie Wayne, IND3.11 WR16 Donald Driver, GB8.06 WR40 Mushin Muhammad, CHI 10.06 WR55 Keyshawn Johnson, CAR11.11 WR65 Marty Booker, MIA16.06 WR89 Bobby Engram, SEAAssuming Me-shawn returns to CAR, I like my WR's quite a lot. Booker and Engram both have good upside, IMO. Farve returning to GB ensures Driver should be very solid once again. I should be able to put up 3 good starters week in / week out, even on BYE weeks (famous last words right there). B+6.06 TE8 Jason Witten, DAL13.11 TE 20 Jermaine Wiggins MIN Witten did better with Romo at QB than he did early, so I feel good about that pick. Wiggins is an acceptable back-up. B. 15.11 K7 Jeff Wilkins STL 17.11 K19 Joe Nedney SF Both of these guys can have occasional big weeks and ranked high in '06 (#3 and #7, respectively). B. 14.06 DEF8 Minnesota Defense 19.11 DEF31 Detroit LionsOn the surface, this doesn't look all that great, but both of these teams created turnovers last year, and both seem to make things happen on special teams. DET is a total mess, so I guess we'll see what happens after the draft and free agency. C+ I think I make it past mid-season.

I agree with this assessment, except the TE portion. In this scoring format last season, Witten was #8 and Wiggins was #14. So I think you grade out at B+ or A- for the position.Basically, if you hit on an RB or two, you'll be around for a long time. Nice team.

 

[Domination]

wraith5 - Well, I'm not going to be the first to throw stones, but I'll take a look at my own results. I will say that I really did not prepare for this draft - I flew by the seat of my pants the whole way. Stayed away from the draft class entirely for this reason. 4.06 QB4 Donovan McNabb, PHI7.11 QB17 Jake Delhomme, CAR20.06 QB41 Damon Huard, KC Taking two QB's that early, I'd better have a solid pair, and I think I do. QB is a high-scoring position, so I wanted to have this locked down each and every week. Huard was a flier - I think he has as much chance at QB'ing the Chiefs as Green, if not more. A.1.11 RB 11 Maurice Jones-Drew, JAC5.11 RB 34 Tatum Bell, DEN9.11 RB 46 Leon Washington, NYJ12.06 RB53 Vernand Morency, GB18.06 RB68 Justin Fargas, OakAfter Maurice, there is a lot of risk here. You never know what is going to happen in Denver with Tater Bell - but his YPC is hard to ignore. If not for his injury this year he would have been VERY solid. The others are all BIG question marks... this is the weakest link on my squad. C. 2.06 WR5 Reggie Wayne, IND3.11 WR16 Donald Driver, GB8.06 WR40 Mushin Muhammad, CHI 10.06 WR55 Keyshawn Johnson, CAR11.11 WR65 Marty Booker, MIA16.06 WR89 Bobby Engram, SEAAssuming Me-shawn returns to CAR, I like my WR's quite a lot. Booker and Engram both have good upside, IMO. Farve returning to GB ensures Driver should be very solid once again. I should be able to put up 3 good starters week in / week out, even on BYE weeks (famous last words right there). B+6.06 TE8 Jason Witten, DAL13.11 TE 20 Jermaine Wiggins MIN Witten did better with Romo at QB than he did early, so I feel good about that pick. Wiggins is an acceptable back-up. B. 15.11 K7 Jeff Wilkins STL 17.11 K19 Joe Nedney SF Both of these guys can have occasional big weeks and ranked high in '06 (#3 and #7, respectively). B. 14.06 DEF8 Minnesota Defense 19.11 DEF31 Detroit LionsOn the surface, this doesn't look all that great, but both of these teams created turnovers last year, and both seem to make things happen on special teams. DET is a total mess, so I guess we'll see what happens after the draft and free agency. C+ I think I make it past mid-season.

I was figuring to throw my team out there to be dismantled, but I guess I should respond to this first to try to get thing going.QB-I think that if DMac can come back healthy you will have a good tandem of QBs here. He generally performs as a top 3 QB when healthy and after he gets urt again you could fall back on Jake. Grade-ARB-Grade-C-Without question the weakest part of your team. I believe that you took some calculated risks on backups later in the draft with Washington and Fargas. MJD will need another big year for him to be able to carry your RB corps. (cross your fingers) WR-Grade-BI think that Wayne and Driver at the top make for a good starting point. Moose seemed to get faded out of the offense at the end of the year, so you will probably need someone else to step up. Engram and Booker off of injury plagued years and KJ mulling retiement aren;'t looking good. But always safer to go with the older vet than the young prospect. TE-Grade-BI think that Wittens performance improved greatly after Romo took over and think that he will get backto were he was 2 years ago. Wiggens adds good depth, because every young QBs best friend is the dump off to the TE.K/Def-Grade-BCan't complain about your kickers as they are both solid. Your defenses are high risk and high reward. They are ball-hawking defenses and look for turnovers, which could account for a couple of big weeks. Overall I think that you a solid team, and the ability to hang around for a little while.

 

[BassNBrew]

gocats

6.16 QB15 Jay Cutler, DEN

8.16 QB25 Byron Leftwich, JAC

18.16 QB38 D. Garrard JAC

B- Nicely executed on Leftwich/Garrand. If you get three starters then I'll bump you to a B

1.01 RB 1 LaDainian Tomlinson, SD

4.16 RB 30 Marshawn Lynch, ???

10.16 Ricky Williams, RB51, MIA?

15.01 RB65 Brandon Jackson ???

B This should have been an A with LT on board. Lynch was a huge mistake here. With a huge leg up at 1.1, you can't risk a RBBC or the historic rookie slow start / slow finish. You compound that with RW. You would have been my favorite to win this, but you took too much unnecessary risk for a team that started so strong.

2.16 WR7 Terrell Owens, DAL

3.01 WR8 Torry Holt, STL

5.01 WR25 Joey Galloway, TB

9.01 WR48 Reggie Williams, JAC

11.01 WR62 Ted Ginn, ???

12.16 WR78 Robert Meachem

20.16 Shaun McDonald WR105 Rams

A- Obviously the rookie league when your opponents let you get the top RB and top WR. Again, two rookies and too much risk. Not really an issue with the top end strength here.

7.01 TE10 Benjamin Watson, NE

13.01 TE19 Ben Troupe TEN

B Hopefully they fare better for you this year then they did for me last. I like the upside with these picks.

16.16 PK23 Kris Brown HOU

19.01 PK26 O. Mare MIA

14.16 Dallas Cowboys DT12

17.01 def28 Washington

B- You got two of each that will start.

I liken this team to having AA in poker and then slow playing a bunch of limpers with a flush/straight draw on the board.

This team should go deep into the year, but has opened itself up to hiccups along the way.

 

[BassNBrew]

Nugget

4.15 QB5 Tom Brady, NE

5.02QB6 Michael Vick, ATL

A Prefect tadem for this format.

1.02 RB 2 Steven Jackson, STL

6.15 RB38 Warrick Dunn, ATL

9.02 RB42 DeShaun Foster, CAR

13.02 RB56 Michael Pittman TB

B+ Great value with Dunn/Foster/Pittman

2.15 WR6 Anquan Boldin, ARZ

3.02 WR9 Roy Williams, DET

8.15 WR47 Ronald Curry, OAK

10.15 WR61 Patrick Crayton DAL

11.02 WR63 Brandon Jones, TEN

12.15 WR77 Dwayne Bowe, LSU

18.15 WR96 Samie Parker, KC

19.02 WR97 Roscoe Parrish, BUF

A- Overkill IMO. Parker and Parish may net you one posted score each this year assuming you don't get killed by byes/injuries. You should have divert one or two of these picks to shoring up your RB or TE depth.

7.02 TE11 LJ Smith, PHI

20.15 TE28 Randall Williams, OAK

C- LJ puts you in the middle of the pack, Williams loses some ground to the field.

16.15 PK12 Jason Hanson DET

17.02 PK13 Stephen Gostkowski

14.15 DEF11 Miami Dolphins, MIA

15.02 DEF13 Seattle Seahawks, SEA

B+ 2 of each, all with the potential to post big numbers any given week.

This team will be a contender for the title. A couple of minor mistakes in player allocation, but enough talent to overcome that.

 

[BassNBrew]

Getinthemix

6.13 QB13 Matt Leinart, AZ

8.13 QB24 Chris Simms, TB

D A little risky here, but QB isn't critical.

1.04 RB 4 Brian Westbrook, PHI

2.13 RB20 Carnell "Cadillac" Williams, TB

3.04 RB 21 Adrian Peterson, ???

B- Banking on Westbrook running the distance. Where does Perterson end up and when does he fade at the end of the year. Was being injury prone a requirment to being on your roster. Definately need one of those Pittman type 4th RBs to prevent some doughnuts.

4.13 WR24 Braylon Edwards, CLE

5.04 WR26 Randy Moss, OAK

9.04 WR50 Chad Jackson, NEP

10.13 Jerry Porter, WR59, OAK

12.13 WR76 Eric Parker, SD

15.04 Nate Burleson, WR84, SEA

18.13 Derek Hagan, WR95, MIA

20.13 Mike Williams, WR103, DET

B+ You're throwing enough #### against the wall that something is bound to stick. Definately overkill here.

7.04 TE12 Heath Miller, PIT

11.04 Owen Daniels, TE16, HOU

D+ You will lose ground to most of the field here.

16.13 Josh Scobee, PK11, JAX

17.04 John Kasay, K15 CAR

13.04 Philly Eagles, D5

14.13 Tennesee Titans D10

19.04 Houston Texans, D28

A+ 3 D's is a solid strategy. 2 good kickers.

All in all, not a bad team, but too much margin for error. 80% chance that you stumble before the final four.

 

[BassNBrew]

Wolverine

6.14 QB14 Tony Romo DAL

7.03 QB16 Ben Roethlisberger PIT

11.03 Jake Plummer, QB30, ???

B+ Good value and the variances in scoring should work well together. Move this to an A- if Plummer moves to Houston.

1.03 RB 3 Larry Johnson, KC

4.14 RB29 Cedric Benson, CHI

5.02 RB 31 Fred Taylor, JAC

19.03 Tony Hunt RB70 ??

B+ WTF is a Tony Hunt? This group is very hard to grade and could be the best stable come September. Would have like to seen one more RB that could post even a few points most weeks.

3.03 WR10 Andre Johnson, HOU

8.14 WR46 Eddie Kennison, KC

9.03 WR49 Joe Horn, NO

10.14 DJ Hackett WR60 Seattle

13.03 Terance Copper WR79 NO

15.03 WR83 Ashley Lelie ??

20.14 Anthony Gonzales WR104 ??

C meh. Kennison and Horn are past their prime. Middle of the pack group here.

2.14 TE2 Kellen Winslow III, CLE

14.14 Daniel Graham TE21 NE

A- Bump this to an A if Graham lands somewhere promising.

17.03 PK14 John Carney

18.14 S. Janikowski PK25 Oak

12.14 New England Patriots D/ST 3

16.14 D/ST23 Oakland

C+ 2 of each that will play

This team will hang around until all that is left is the cream of the league, then it just won't have the horsepower to hang.

 

[BassNBrew]

oldfatguy

2.12 QB3 Drew Brees, NO

8.12 QB23 Bret Favre QB GB

A- Although you overpaid for Brees.

1.05 RB 5 Joseph Addai, IND

3.05 RB 22 Marion Barber III, DAL

9.05 RB43 Ladell Betts, WAS

19.05 RB71 Marcel Shipp ARI FA

15.05 RB66 Lorenzo Booker ???

C Brees began to hurt you here. Your season could ride on Barber III.

4.12 WR23 Jerricho Cotchery, NYJ

5.05 WR27 Mike Furrey, DET

7.05 WR35 Vincent Jackson, SDG

10.12 Kevin Curtis WR58 STL

12.12 WR75 Mark Bradley CHI

13.05 WR80 Nate Washington PIT

20.12 WR102 Maurice Stivall TMB

C+ Very underated group no-name group here...I'm probably underating too. Middle of the pack scoring from bargain basement picks.

6.12 TE9 Vernon Davis SF

18.12 TE24 Chris Baker NYJ

C+ Slightly better than average TE1 and TE2

14.12 PK5 Shayne Graham CIN

17.05 PK16 J. Reed, PIT

11.05 San Diego DEF2

16.12 Cincinnati DEF22

B+ 2 of each that are better than most.

This team should last until the second half of the season. Too much rish at RB to be considered a contender at this time.

 

[Domination]

Rip away

Self critique:

6.07 QB10 Eli Manning, NYG

11.10 QB33 JaMarcus Russell, ????

13.10 QB Jeff Garcia, Eagles ???

This will be looked upon as the weakness of my team. I believe that when it all shakes out I will have 3 starting QBs, and with the Giants supposed to be having week 9 bye week, I expect Russell to be at least starting by then. Also, Eli was viewed to have had a bad year last year and still ranked #11. But in fairness, there are alot of questionmarks. Grade-C+

1.10 RB 10 Rudi Johnson, CIN

5.10 RB33 Julius Jones, DAL

9.10 RB 45 Michael Bush, ???

10.07 RB49 Dominic Rhodes, Indianapolis Colts

12.07 RB54 Brian Calhoun, DET

I think that there is a good compliment of RBs, with pretty solid depth. I think that Calhoun will be given the chance to start in KJ's absence. Rhoades will be RBBC, and very high on Bush.(hello Balt.) Grade-B+

3.10 WR15 Javon Walker, DEN

4.07 WR20 Darrell Jackson, SEA

7.10 WR38 Issac Bruce, STL

8.07 WR41 Antonio Bryant, SF

16.07 WR90 Brandon Stokley, IND

20.07 WR100 JASON AVANT, Philly

Solid production across the board is what I am expecting from this group. With Walker and DJax on top to solidify, and Bruce, Bryant, and Stokely to fall back on. I think that this is the strength of my team. Avavnt could be a nice bonus if he is the #2 in Philly. Grade-A

2.07 TE1 Antonio Gates, SD

19.10 TE25 Greg Olson, ???

Gates is the #1 Te in the league and Olsen is the best pass catching TE in the draft. I think that I have a nice tandem here, and could chance on a rookie with Gates. Grade-A

14.07 PK4 Neil Rackers, AZ

17.10 PK18 Jay Feely, NYG

Both are solid starting Kickers, and I think that they could both be top 10. But really, they are only kickers. Grade-B

15.10 Carolina Panthers Def15

18.07 San Francisco 49'ers Def26

Carolina underperformed and San Fran will definitely improve. ($40Mil cap room) I anticipate either A Samuel or Clements for SF, and Carolina just isn't that bad. Grade-B

Overall I am very satisfied with this team. I think that I added alot of proven NFL players and a few rookies for potential. I think the depth is there to sustain an injury or two.

Overall Grade-B+ I think that I could be there late into the season. Don't know that I have enough firepower to make it all the way, but should be consistant performers.

 

[Domination]

Wolverine

6.14 QB14 Tony Romo DAL

7.03 QB16 Ben Roethlisberger PIT

11.03 Jake Plummer, QB30, ???

B+ Good value and the variances in scoring should work well together. Move this to an A- if Plummer moves to Houston.

1.03 RB 3 Larry Johnson, KC

4.14 RB29 Cedric Benson, CHI

5.02 RB 31 Fred Taylor, JAC

19.03 Tony Hunt RB70 ??

B+ WTF is a Tony Hunt? This group is very hard to grade and could be the best stable come September. Would have like to seen one more RB that could post even a few points most weeks.

3.03 WR10 Andre Johnson, HOU

8.14 WR46 Eddie Kennison, KC

9.03 WR49 Joe Horn, NO

10.14 DJ Hackett WR60 Seattle

13.03 Terance Copper WR79 NO

15.03 WR83 Ashley Lelie ??

20.14 Anthony Gonzales WR104 ??

C meh. Kennison and Horn are past their prime. Middle of the pack group here.

2.14 TE2 Kellen Winslow III, CLE

14.14 Daniel Graham TE21 NE

A- Bump this to an A if Graham lands somewhere promising.

17.03 PK14 John Carney

18.14 S. Janikowski PK25 Oak

12.14 New England Patriots D/ST 3

16.14 D/ST23 Oakland

C+ 2 of each that will play

This team will hang around until all that is left is the cream of the league, then it just won't have the horsepower to hang.

 

[BassNBrew]

pigskin pimp

6.11 QB12 Jon Kitna DET

11.06 QB31 Tarvaris Jackson MN

20.11 QB42 Joey Harrington MIA

C- I only see 1.5 starters and Kitna will be phased out if Detriot sucks. What are the odds of Detriot sucking?

1.06 RB 6 Reggie Bush, NO

2.11 RB19 Willis McGahee, BUF

12.11 RB55 Chris Brown UFA

14.11 RB64 Wali Lundy HOU

13.06 RB57 Kevin Faulk NE

15.06 RB67 Anthony Thomas BUF

A Take notes people, this is how to build a stable of RBs. Actually he did too good of a job and wasted a pick with #6. Faulk wasn't needed on this team. You have huge upside with some protection from donuts.

3.06 WR11 Marques Colston, NO

5.06 WR28 Donte Stallworth UFA

7.06 WR36 Matt Jones, JAX

8.11 WR43 Brandon Marshall DEN

10.11 WR57 Troy Williamson MIN

D- 5 WRs is strike one...now let's look deeper. Colston will have to beat the historic sophmore slump trend. Stallworth doesn't have a team. Jones isn't dependable. Marshall may or may not be the #2 on a team that wants to run. Williamson has been a bust. Well that's a bunch more wiffs. Why oh why didn't you spend 13.6 on a WR and make this team the favorite for the title.

4.11 TE5 Jeremy Shockey NYG

19.06 TE24 Zach Miller ASU

B+ Rookies TEs...blah. Still Shockey will get er done.

17.06 K17 Lawrence Tynes KC

18.11 K24 Rian Lindell BUF

9.06 DEF1 Chicago Bears

16.11 DEF21 Kansas City Chiefs

A Based on the Bears D.

This team will live and die on Kitna, schedule, injuries, FA, byes. I don't think any of the picks are bad individually, I just don't think the team gelled as a whole like it could have. Will make it to the second half on talent alone, but a lack of optimizing the scoring format will catch up with it.

 

[BassNBrew]

wannabee

2.09 QB1 Peyton Manning, IND

11.08 Charlie Frye, QB32, Cleve

C Peyton Manning you're not the guy, you're just like Charlie Frye. Damn you for not taking Farve too. Seriously, grade is an A. Great value for Manning where you got him.

1.08 RB 8 Frank Gore, SF

4.09 RB 28 Thomas Jones, CHI

8.09 RB41 Corey Dillon, NE

18.09 Brian Leonard, RB69, ????

20.09 Dwayne Wright, RB73, ???

B+ Nice collection, Gore/Jones/Dillon all offered value where you got them. Uusally the Manning teams have crappy RBs. I would have like to have seened another RB option than two rooks.

3.08 WR13 Lee Evans, BUF

5.08 WR33 Terry Glenn, DAL

6.09 WR37 Bernard Berrian, CHI

12.09 Demetrius Williams, WR73, Balt

14.09 Joe Jurevicius, WR82, Cleve

15.08 Drew Carter, WR85, Carolina

16.09 Peerless Price, WR91, Buf

B I wouldn't want any of these guys in a nrmal league, but in best ball you will finished above average with this cheap collection.

7.08 TE13 Desmond Clark, CHI

9.08 TE14 Randy McMichael, Mia

B These two will tadem nicely to be nipping at the heels of the studs.

13.08 Adam Vinateri, PK1, Ind

19.08 Matt Bryant, K28, TB

10.09 Baltimore Ravens Def2

17.08 Arizona Cardinal Defense24

A+ Speaks for itself.

This team is a title contender. I don't think I've ever said that for a Manning team. You navigated the early QB selection perfect and obvious studied the format. Well done!

 

[BassNBrew]

H.K.

6.08 QB11 Philip Rivers, SD

8.8 QB22 Jason Campbell, WAS

C+ Two starters, both in the middle of their tiers.

1.09 RB 9 "Fast" Willie Parker, PIT

2.08 RB 18 Deuce McAllister, NO

9.09 RB 44 Dominic Williams (formerly Davis), Texans

13.09 RB59 Correll Buckhalter, Eagles

19.09 Najah Davenport, RB 72 Steelers

B+ With the potential for an A-. Excellent drafting here. Two studs, one risk with RB1 potential, and a couple of donut preventers.

3.09 WR14 Plaxico Burress, NYG

4.08 WR 21Chris Chambers, MIA

7.09 WR37 Derrick Mason, BAL

10.08 Michael Clayton, WR56 Buccaneers

11.09 WR64 Travis Taylor, Vikings

20.08 Josh Reed, WR101 Bills

C+ The all underachiever WR corps. This really is their year...I mean it for real...just a slow start...any time now they'll bust out...they'll be money down the stretch....just wait until next year.

5.09 TE6 Chris Cooley, WAS

12.08 Alex Smith, TE18 Buccaneers

B Better than par for the draft.

15.09 David Akers, K6 Eagles

17.09 M. Nugent, K19 Jets

14.08 Jacksonville Jaguars, D/ST 9

16.08 Atlanta Falcons D/ST19

18.08 St. Louis Rams, D/ST27

A Those Ds will team together niclely to post Chi/stiff type numbers.

This team should make it to the final four.

 

[BassNBrew]

Domination

6.07 QB10 Eli Manning, NYG

11.10 QB33 JaMarcus Russell, ????

13.10 QB Jeff Garcia, Eagles ???

C- Could be a B depending on Garcia. Russell will likely see time late. Manning is enough to tread eater.

1.10 RB 10 Rudi Johnson, CIN

5.10 RB33 Julius Jones, DAL

9.10 RB 45 Michael Bush, ???

10.07 RB49 Dominic Rhodes, Indianapolis Colts

12.07 RB54 Brian Calhoun, DET

B- Went cheap here but didn't pay the price. Nice mix of consistancy, upside, and depth.

3.10 WR15 Javon Walker, DEN

4.07 WR20 Darrell Jackson, SEA

7.10 WR38 Issac Bruce, STL

8.07 WR41 Antonio Bryant, SF

16.07 WR90 Brandon Stokley, IND

20.07 WR100 JASON AVANT, Philly

B+ Walker at WR15...I guess you guys were sleeping while you were dominated and raped. Everyone of these picks offered value. One or two will pan out and this group will be a top producer.

2.07 TE1 Antonio Gates, SD

19.10 TE25 Greg Olson, ???

A+ Gates is a late 1st pick in this format.

14.07 PK4 Neil Rackers, AZ

17.10 PK18 Jay Feely, NYG

15.10 Carolina Panthers Def15

18.07 San Francisco 49'ers Def26

C Solid and servicable.

Another final four contender. This team is litter with value and has the horses to win a title.

 

[BassNBrew]

wraith5

4.06 QB4 Donavan McNabb, PHI

7.11 QB17 Jake Delhomme, Carolina Panthers

20.06 Damon Huard, QB41, Kansas City Chiefs

A Value and talent. Huard pick could have been better used elsewhere.

1.11 RB 11 Maurice Jones-Drew, JAC

5.11 RB 34 Tatum Bell, DEN

9.11 RB 46 Leon Washington, NYJ

12.06 Vernand Morency, RB53 Green Bay Packers

18.06 Justin Fargas, RB68 Oak

C- I have my concerns about Drew and the back end is light here. That said, there's enough depth to prevent losing too much ground to the field.

2.06 WR5 Reggie Wayne, IND

3.11 WR16 Donald Driver, GB

8.06 WR40 Mushin Muhammad, CHI

10.06 Keyshawn Johnson (hopefully) wr55 Carolina

11.11 Marty Booker, WR65 Miami Dolphins

16.06 Bobby Engram, WR89 Seattle

A- Assuming Meshawn is back. Without him it becomes dicey.

6.06 TE8 Jason Witten, DAL

13.11 Jermaine Wiggins TE 20 MIN

B Great pair, Wiggins offered excellent value.

15.11 Jeff Wilkins K7 STL

17.11 Joe Nedney, K19 49'ers

14.06 Minnesota Defense 8

19.11 DEF/ST31 Detroit Lions

C 2 of each.

Another team that will go into the field. If one of the RBs connects...mark it down...final 4!

 

[BassNBrew]

CommuterMan

8.05 QB21 JP Losman BUF

10.05 David Carr - QB29 Hou

19.12 Aaron Brooks - QB39 Oak (???)

F Ouch this is going to smart.

1.12 RB 12 Kevin Jones, DET

3.12 RB23 DeAngelo Williams, CAR

6.05 RB37 Michael Turner, SD

7.12 Lendale White - RB 40 TEN

D If Jones isn't starting the season, you may not even have a starting NFL RB.

2.05 WR4 Chad Johnson, CIN

5.12 WR 34 Mark Clayton, BAL

9.12 Drew Bennett - WR51 Tennessee

11.12 Rod Smith - WR66 Denver

12.05 Eric Moulds - WR72 Houston

15.12 Sinorice Moss - WR86 NYG

20.05 Brandon Lloyd - WR99, Wash

B Well rounded group that will be better than most.

4.05 TE4 Todd Heap, BAL

18.05 Bo Scaife - TE22, Ten

A- I really like the Bo pick with Heap.

14.05 Robbie Gould - PK3 Chicago

16.05 Josh Brown - PK10 Sea

13.12 Steelers Def6

17.12 Tampa Bay Bucs def25

B 2 of each and decent talent.

Important safety tip....don't wait until QB21 to draft your first one. Carr/Plumer was the proper play here. Too many holes for this team to last.

 

[BassNBrew]

Pictus Cat

7.13 QB18 Rex Grossman, CHI

8.04 QB20 Daunte Culpepper MIA

13.13 QB35 Matt Schaub ATL?

D+ Demerits for drafting Rexy.

1.13 RB 13 Ronnie Brown, MIA

5.13 RB 35 Reuben Droughns, CLE

9.13 RB47 Cedric Houston, NYJ

10.04 RB48 Chris Perry, CIN

C+ Good value and good mix.

2.04 WR3 Marvin Harrison, IND

3.13 WR17 Hines Ward, PIT

6.04 WR36 Deion Branch, SEA

11.13 WR67 Wesley Welker, MIA

12.04 WR71 Bryant Johnson ARI

14.04 WR81 Roddy White, ATL

20.04 WR98 Billy McMullen , Min

B+ Strong thruout. Some nice upside picks.

4.04 TE3 Tony Gonzalez, KC

19.13 TE26 G Wrightster, JAX

A Another guy who tied the right backup to the stud.

17.13 PK20 Ryan Longwell, MIN

18.04 PK22 Phil Dawson, CLE

15.13 DST16 New Orleans

16.04 DST18 Indianapolis Colts

C 2 of each.

Not bad, but not enough firepower to go deep.

 

[Domination]

Bass you are much more lenient and try not to rip people's hearts out right after the draft. Guess I got used to LHucks after MBSL.

 

[BassNBrew]

JetsWillWin

5.14 QB7 Marc Bulger, STL

9.14 Trent Green, QB27 KCC

14.03 QB36 Brady Quinn

18.03 KELLEN CLEMENS, QB37 NYJ

B+ But pissed away too many picks here.

1.14 RB 14 Clinton Portis, WAS

2.03 RB 17 Laurence Maroney, NE

3.14 RB24 Travis Henry, TEN

11.14 TJ DUCKETT, RB 52 ???

13.14 Antonio Pittman, RB 61 ??

A+ The first three had this group as the top trio. FYI...I got Duckett (soon to be starting/RBBC in Carolina) in round 20...go to the doctor and have him look at that shoulder pain) Pittman was a wasted pick.

4.03 WR19 Santana Moss, WAS

6.03 WR35 Greg Jennings, GB

7.14 WR39 Santonio Holmes, PIT

10.03 Dwayne Jarret, WR54

12.03 Wilford, Ernest JAC WR70

15.14 Sidney Rice, WR87 ??

17.14 David Givens, WR92 TEN

C- This is where it unravels. 2 rooks and a guy who might not play again. Your WR1 no-shows for weeks at a time.

8.03 TE 13 Dallas Clark IND

20.03 DAVID THOMAS, TE27 NEP

D- I hope you enjoy eating donuts...you won't be eating burgers as DAVE THOMAS is dead.

19.14 MIKE VANDERJAGT, FA IDIOT K29

F-

16.03 Buffalo DST17

F

You started off strong and should have been a title contender....then you leaked oil everywhere as you self destructed down the stretch. Consider this a cheap learning experience at 16 team survivor. This team will hang some 150s and then suddenly blow a 75. It's not a matter of if...just when.

 

[BassNBrew]

jmills

5.15 QB8 Matt Hasslebeck, SEA

7.15 QB19 Alex Smith, SF

20.02 Seneca Wallace - QB40, Oak

B Hasselbeck is underated and Smith is improving. Interesting play with Seneca if you can afford it.

1.15 RB 15 Edgerrin James, ARZ

3.15 RB 25 Lamont Jordan, OAK

6.02 RB36 Jerious Norwood, ATL

13.15 Greg Jones, RB 60, Jax

B Jordan is being overlooked and you really benfitted. Norwood is a great RB3

2.02 WR2 Steve Smith, CAR

4.02 WR18 Laveranues Coles, NYJ

10.02 Hank Baskett, WR53, PHI

11.15 Michael Jenkins, WR68, ATL

12.02 Amani Toomer, WR69, NYG

16.02 Antwaan Randle-El, WR88, Was

17.15 Johnnie Lee Higgins, WR93, ??

B+ Smith will lead the way. A lot of crap after that, but you'll cobble together two servicaable scores.

8.02 TE 12 Tony Scheffler, DEN

9.15 Marcedes Lewis, TE15, Jax

C- Won't lose ground to most teams, but not top shelf material.

1515 Matt Stover PK8 Bal

18.02 Dave Rayner, PK21, GB

14.02 Denver Broncos D 7

19.15 Cleveland Browns D 32

C 2 of each.

I really like this team and it''s draft. Definately a contender and not risking an early exit.

 

[BassNBrew]

Tony Jabroni

5.16 QB9 Vince Young, TEN

10.01--QB28--Steve Mcnair--BAL

B- Young loses some value in this format. McNair was a great pick.

1.16 RB 16 Chester Taylor, MIN

3.16 RB26 Ahman Green, GB

4.01 RB27 Brandon Jacobs, NYG

11.16--Ron Dayne RB 56

14.01 RB 62 Mewelde Moore MIN

B Nice mix here, good drafting.

2.01 WR1 Larry Fitzgerald, ARZ

7.16 (8.12) WR44 Devery Henderson, NO

8.01 (8.13) WR45 Reche Caldwell NE

9.16--WR52--Arnaz Battle--SF

16.01--Jeff Webb--WR87--KC

18.01 Keenan Mccardell--WR94--SD

C+ I don't like Fitz as the first WR off the board. If you take Fitz, you need one consistant producer to back him up. I see a whole mess of boom/bust type of players. Too a hair to risky.

6.01 TE7 Alge Crumpler, ATL

17.16 Ben Utecht--TE24--IND

B Nicely done.

13.16 PK2 Nate Kaeding SD

15.16--Jason Elam--K9--DEN

12.01 --Packers DEF4

D- Lack of a second D will hurt.

This could have been a great team, but the lack of interest may have doomed it.

 

[BassNBrew]

Bass you are much more lenient and try not to rip people's hearts out right after the draft. Guess I got used to LHucks after MBSL.

I already post enough bulletin board material around here.... I may have been hard on a few here. 75% of the time I can look at my teams in these 16 teamers and tell if I'm a contender. Sometimes the snake bites you and you can't defend against a run. There have been several of these drafts where I went value v. need and got rolled. Sometimes the draft breaks your way and you can oVVn it...other times the draft just breaks you.p.s. I lower all your grades by one mark for being one of the slowest damn drafts ever. Hell, people have retired since you started.

 

[Pictus Cat]

Thank you for the evaluations!

Hope everyone had fun during the draft. Will be interesting to see how the offseason affects the teams.

More comments are welcome.

PS: I'll work on my speed during the drafts.

 

[wannabee]

thank you Bass for doing these reviews.

 

[Wolverine]

Interesting read Bass. I can`t say I agree with everything but everyone has their own take on these things. You made a good point about how a draft rolls and falls into place , I`ve done a lot of these survivor drafts (I`m defending SSL#1 champion ) and they rarely work out like you originally plan. I think a lot of guys used interesting strategies in this draft , it wasn`t a sheep draft which too many survivor league things have become. I only wish it had drafted faster. Best of luck to everyone.

 

[Nugget]

gocats

6.16 QB15 Jay Cutler, DEN

8.16 QB25 Byron Leftwich, JAC

18.16 QB38 D. Garrard JAC

1.01 RB 1 LaDainian Tomlinson, SD

4.16 RB 30 Marshawn Lynch, ???

10.16 Ricky Williams, RB51, MIA?

15.01 RB65 Brandon Jackson ???

2.16 WR7 Terrell Owens, DAL

3.01 WR8 Torry Holt, STL

5.01 WR25 Joey Galloway, TB

9.01 WR48 Reggie Williams, JAC

11.01 WR62 Ted Ginn, ???

12.16 WR78 Robert Meachem

20.16 Shaun McDonald WR105 Rams

7.01 TE10 Benjamin Watson, NE

13.01 TE19 Ben Troupe TEN

16.16 PK23 Kris Brown HOU

19.01 PK26 O. Mare MIA

14.16 Dallas Cowboys DT12

17.01 def28 Washington

Initial thoughts:

Good QB's. I'm high on Cutler, down on JAX QB's, but if one leaves could have 3 starters at good value. LT alone could score more than most others 2RB's each week. Other rb's extremely risky. Strongest top 3 WR in the league, if Calvin becomes a Buc I'm nervous on Galloway's value. I'd like to see more from Troupe, Sciafe seemed to connect well with Vince Young last season. Should be around for quite a while.

 

[BassNBrew]

Interesting read Bass. I can`t say I agree with everything but everyone has their own take on these things. You made a good point about how a draft rolls and falls into place , I`ve done a lot of these survivor drafts (I`m defending SSL#1 champion ) and they rarely work out like you originally plan. I think a lot of guys used interesting strategies in this draft , it wasn`t a sheep draft which too many survivor league things have become. I only wish it had drafted faster. Best of luck to everyone.

Thoughts on my evaluation of your team? Keep in mind that I use a scale based on team rankings...A+ = 1, A = 2, A- = 3, C = 8/9, F = 16.

 

[Nugget]

Wolverine

6.14 QB14 Tony Romo DAL

7.03 QB16 Ben Roethlisberger PIT

11.03 Jake Plummer, QB30, ???

1.03 RB 3 Larry Johnson, KC

4.14 RB29 Cedric Benson, CHI

5.02 RB 31 Fred Taylor, JAC

19.03 Tony Hunt RB70 ??

3.03 WR10 Andre Johnson, HOU

8.14 WR46 Eddie Kennison, KC

9.03 WR49 Joe Horn, NO

10.14 DJ Hackett WR60 Seattle

13.03 Terance Copper WR79 NO

15.03 WR83 Ashley Lelie ??

20.14 Anthony Gonzales WR104 ??

2.14 TE2 Kellen Winslow III, CLE

14.14 Daniel Graham TE21 NE

17.03 PK14 John Carney

18.14 S. Janikowski PK25 Oak

12.14 New England Patriots D/ST 3

16.14 D/ST23 Oakland

Initial thoughts: Love the QB's, 2 starting gunslinging QB's, possibly a third. Boom/Bust RB's, only one surefire starter, but with 16 teams, that is very common. Benson and Taylor should get some points each week, good value for this early in the off season. WR's bit below average, AJ should be good, I think a better QB will be in HOU, don't know where Horn lands. I'd like to see more receivers who will be on the field for extended periods of time. Solid TE's, I'd have taken KWII or Graham at the next spot if they had fallen. Disappointed at K, I don't know how old Carney is know, Janikowski needs more attempts, but he should continue to be a startig K. I like these two defenses.

 

[Nugget]

Getinthemix

6.13 QB13 Matt Leinart, AZ

8.13 QB24 Chris Simms, TB

1.04 RB 4 Brian Westbrook, PHI

2.13 RB20 Carnell "Cadillac" Williams, TB

3.04 RB 21 Adrian Peterson, ???

4.13 WR24 Braylon Edwards, CLE

5.04 WR26 Randy Moss, OAK

9.04 WR50 Chad Jackson, NEP

10.13 Jerry Porter, WR59, OAK

12.13 WR76 Eric Parker, SD

15.04 Nate Burleson, WR84, SEA

18.13 Derek Hagan, WR95, MIA

20.13 Mike Williams, WR103, DET

7.04 TE12 Heath Miller, PIT

11.04 Owen Daniels, TE16, HOU

16.13 Josh Scobee, PK11, JAX

17.04 John Kasay, K15 CAR

13.04 Philly Eagles, D5

14.13 Tennesee Titans D10

19.04 Houston Texans, D28

Initial thoughts: I think QB's will be OK, I think TB had nothing at QB this season and Simms will get his team back. Leinart should improve, and you'll be OK. I think the RB-RB-RB will work for you, but with only three it is an injury risk. I think a PPR 3rd down back like Kevin Faulk would have been a nice add in the 2nd half. WR's scare me, there are a lot of question marks on where they will play. I think you have enough to hit on a couple. I wanted Hagan in the 18th. TE's are serviceable, would like to see more offensive teams for your K's, love the three D's. If you knew you were going to try for three, I'd have passed on the Eagles and picked up one in the 15th or 16th.

 

[Nugget]

More tomorrow.

 

[Domination]

Domination 6.07 QB10 Eli Manning, NYG11.10 QB33 JaMarcus Russell, ????13.10 QB Jeff Garcia, Eagles ???C- Could be a B depending on Garcia. Russell will likely see time late. Manning is enough to tread eater.1.10 RB 10 Rudi Johnson, CIN5.10 RB33 Julius Jones, DAL9.10 RB 45 Michael Bush, ???10.07 RB49 Dominic Rhodes, Indianapolis Colts 12.07 RB54 Brian Calhoun, DETB- Went cheap here but didn't pay the price. Nice mix of consistancy, upside, and depth.3.10 WR15 Javon Walker, DEN4.07 WR20 Darrell Jackson, SEA7.10 WR38 Issac Bruce, STL 8.07 WR41 Antonio Bryant, SF 16.07 WR90 Brandon Stokley, IND20.07 WR100 JASON AVANT, PhillyB+ Walker at WR15...I guess you guys were sleeping while you were dominated and raped. Everyone of these picks offered value. One or two will pan out and this group will be a top producer.2.07 TE1 Antonio Gates, SD19.10 TE25 Greg Olson, ???A+ Gates is a late 1st pick in this format.14.07 PK4 Neil Rackers, AZ17.10 PK18 Jay Feely, NYG15.10 Carolina Panthers Def1518.07 San Francisco 49'ers Def26C Solid and servicable.Another final four contender. This team is litter with value and has the horses to win a title.

bass I think that your evaluations were fair, with both your praise and criticism. I was anticipating the low grade at QB, and didn't think anyone would like my D's as much as I did. Hopefully they will perform as well as you think they will.

 

[BassNBrew]

Domination 6.07 QB10 Eli Manning, NYG11.10 QB33 JaMarcus Russell, ????13.10 QB Jeff Garcia, Eagles ???C- Could be a B depending on Garcia. Russell will likely see time late. Manning is enough to tread eater.1.10 RB 10 Rudi Johnson, CIN5.10 RB33 Julius Jones, DAL9.10 RB 45 Michael Bush, ???10.07 RB49 Dominic Rhodes, Indianapolis Colts 12.07 RB54 Brian Calhoun, DETB- Went cheap here but didn't pay the price. Nice mix of consistancy, upside, and depth.3.10 WR15 Javon Walker, DEN4.07 WR20 Darrell Jackson, SEA7.10 WR38 Issac Bruce, STL 8.07 WR41 Antonio Bryant, SF 16.07 WR90 Brandon Stokley, IND20.07 WR100 JASON AVANT, PhillyB+ Walker at WR15...I guess you guys were sleeping while you were dominated and raped. Everyone of these picks offered value. One or two will pan out and this group will be a top producer.2.07 TE1 Antonio Gates, SD19.10 TE25 Greg Olson, ???A+ Gates is a late 1st pick in this format.14.07 PK4 Neil Rackers, AZ17.10 PK18 Jay Feely, NYG15.10 Carolina Panthers Def1518.07 San Francisco 49'ers Def26C Solid and servicable.Another final four contender. This team is litter with value and has the horses to win a title.

bass I think that your evaluations were fair, with both your praise and criticism. I was anticipating the low grade at QB, and didn't think anyone would like my D's as much as I did. Hopefully they will perform as well as you think they will.

One thing I did forget to factor in is the Bryant suspension. At least you won't likely have bye conflicts with the early suspension.