Your Top 25 QBs (1 Viewer)

[Clayton Gray]

Hey guys,

It's time for the 1st installment of the Footballguys.com Expert Rankings, and as usual, the message board will be listed as an expert.

Go ahead and leave your top 25 QBs here.

Please try and vote for the other positions as well:

Overall RB WR TE PK Defenses

Scoring system

4 pts = TD pass

6 pts = TD run/catch

1 pt = 20 YD pass

1 pt = 10 YD run/catch

-1 pt = INT

3 pts = FG

1 pt = PAT

 

[Harv72b]

1) Donovan McNabb2) Daunte Culpepper3) Rich Gannon4) Peyton Manning5) Mike Vick6) Jeff Garcia7) Brett Favre8) Tommy Maddox9) Trent Green10) Matt Hasselbeck11) Aaron Brooks12) Tom Brady13) Steve McNair14) Drew Bledsoe15) Chad Pennington16) Kerry Collins17) Kordell Stewart18) Joey Harrington19) Patrick Ramsey20) Jay Fiedler21) Kurt Warner22) Jake Plummer23) Jeff Blake24) Drew Brees25) David Carr

 

[Burning Sensation]

Im assuming redraft, here it goes:1.Vick2.Mcnabb3.Culpepper4.Manning5.Brooks6.Gannon7.Hassleback8.Bledsoe9.Maddox10.Garcia11.Pennington12.Brady13.Mcnair14.Ramsey15.Warner/Bulger16.Favre17.Ramsey18.Plummer19.Collins20.Green,T21.Couch/Holcombe22.Harrington23.Kitna24.Stewart25.Brees

 

[tom-dog1]

1. Michael Vick2. Donovan Mcnabb3. Daunte Culpepper4. Peyton Manning5. Rich Gannon6. Aaron Brooks7. Drew Bledsoe8. Chad Pennington9. Tommy Maddox10. Jeff Garcia11. Kurt Warner12. Matt Hasselbeck13. Brett Favre14. Steve Mcnair15. Tom Brady16. Trent Green17. Patrick Ramsey18. Jake Plummer19. Kerry Collins20. Jake Plummer21. Kordell Stewart22. Joey Harrington23. David Carr24. Drew Brees25. Jon Kitna

 

[KING]

1. vick2. mcnabb3. culpepper4. manning5. brooks6. gannon7. warner8. garcia9. green, t10 favre 11 bledsoe12 brady13 pennington14 mcnair15 collins16 hasselbeck17 couch/holcomb18 plummer19 brees20 johnson, b21 maddox22 harrington23 carr24 ramsey25 brunell

 

[elshagon]

1. McNabb2. Culpepper3. Manning4. Vick 5. Garcia6. Brooks7. Gannon8. Favre9. Bledsoe10.Maddox11.Hasselbeck12.Brady13.Green14.McNair15.Warner16.Pennington17.Holcombe18.Fiedler19.Harrington20.Ramsey21.Brunnell22.Brees23.Collins24.Kitna25.Carr

 

[Unlucky]

1. Culpepper2. McNabb3. Vick4. Ramsey5. Warner6. Manning7. Gannon8. Bledsoe9. T. Green10. McNair11. Kitna12. Garcia13. Maddox14. Brady15. B. Johnson16. Collins17. K. Stewart18. Hasselbeck19. Fiedler20. Pennington21. Favre22. Plummer23. Brees24. Carr25. Harrington

 

[mac daddy]

Unlucky - No Brooks?

 

[Uruk-Hai]

1. McNabb2. Manning3. Warner4. Culpepper5. Vick6. Green7. Gannon8. Garcia9. Brooks10. Favre11. Bledsoe12. McNair13. Ramsey14. Collins15. Pennington16. B Johnson17. Brady18. Maddox19. Plummer20. Hasselback21. Kitna22. Stewart23. Brees24. Harrington25. Fiedler

 

[TC]

1.Donovan Mcnabb - PHI 2. Kurt Warner - STL 3. Daunte Culpepper - MIN 4. Jeff Garcia - SF 5. Drew Bledsoe - BUF 6. Peyton Manning - IND 7. Michael Vick - ATL 8. Aaron Brooks - NO 9. Brett Favre - GB 10. Rich Gannon - OAK 11. Tom Brady - NE 12. Kerry Collins - NYG 13. Steve Mcnair - TEN 14. Patrick Ramsey - WAS 15. Chad Pennington - NYJ 16. Tommy Maddox - PIT 17. Jake Plummer - DEN 18. Matt Hasselbeck - SEA 19. Trent Green - KC 20. Kordell Stewart - CHI 21. Jay Fiedler - MIA22. Joey Harrington - DET23. Brad Johnson - TB 24. Mark Brunell - JAC 25. Drew Brees - SD

 

[saintsfan]

1. McNabb2. Culpepper3. Manning4. Gannon5. Warner6. Bledsoe7. Vick8. Brooks9. Favre10. Garcia11. Pennington12. McNair13. Brady14. Plummer15. Hasselbeck16. Maddox17. Ramsey18. Green19. Collins20. Johnson21. Stewart22. Harrington23. Carr24. Brees25. Fiedler

 

[Vivian Darkbloom]

1. Warner2. McNabb3. Culpeper4. Brooks5. Manning6. Gannon7. Vick8. Green9. Maddox10. Hasselbeck11. Garcia12. McNair13. Bledsoe14. Favre15. B. Johnson16. Ramsey17. Brady18. Kitna19. Plummer20. Collins21. Pennington22. Stewart23. Hutchinson24. Fiedler25. Carr

 

[RIM]

QB:01. McNabb02. Vick03. Culpepper04. Gannon05. Manning06. Brooks07. Bledsoe08. Garcia09. Warner10. McNair11. Brady12. Favre13. Green14. Hasselbeck15. Maddox16. B Johnson17. Collins18. Brees19. Ramsey20. Pennington21. Plummer22. Stewart23. Fiedler (Griese?)24. Kitna (Palmer)25. Couch (Holcombe)After I hit #13, it felt like a crap shoot after that. Any of those guys 14-25 could be interchanged (and possibly beat out those 9-13 guys easily too). I guess i won't be drafting my #2 QB until very late this year. :wacko:

 

[LivinNsc]

1) Donovan McNabb2) Mike Vick3) Peyton Manning4) Aaron Brooks5) Daunte Culpepper6) Rich Gannon7) Jeff Garcia8) Brett Favre9) Trent Green10) Drew Bledsoe11) Chad Pennington12) Tom Brady13) Steve McNair14) Kerry Collins15) Matt Hasselbeck16) Kordell Stewart17) Joey Harrington18) Kurt Warner19) Patrick Ramsey20) Jay Fiedler21) Tommy Maddox22) Jake Plummer23) Drew Brees24) Brad Johnson25) Brunell

 

[Unlucky]

Unlucky - No Brooks?

my bad. I knew that I forgot someone. This isn't really my "official" list. It was 3 in the morning and I was going off the top of my head.

 

[Shooter McGavin]

1. Culpepper2. McNabb3. Garcia4. Manning5. Brooks6. Vick7. Warner8. Hasselbeck9. Gannon10. Brees11. Pennington12. Brady 13. Favre14 Bledsoe15. McNair16. Ramsey17. Harrington18. Maddox19. Collins20. Green21. Delhomme22. Plummer23. Kitna24. Carr25. Brunell

 

[Hoosier Daddy?]

1 ) Donovan McNabb2 ) Mike Vick3 ) Kurt Warner4 ) Peyton Manning5 ) Daunte Culpepper6 ) Jeff Garcia7 ) Rich Gannon8 ) Drew Bledsoe9 ) Brett Favre10 ) Tommy Maddox11 ) Trent Green12 ) Aaron Brooks13 ) Tom Brady14 ) Steve McNair15 ) Chad Pennington16 ) Kerry Collins17 ) Matt Hasselbeck18 ) Drew Brees19 ) Joey Harrington20 ) Kordell Stewart21 ) Jake Plummer22 ) Jay Fiedler23 ) Jeff Blake24 ) David Carr 25 ) Patrick Ramsey

 

[Miz4]

1 McNabb, Donovan2 Vick, Michael3 Culpepper, Dante4 Gannon, Rich 5 Manning, Peyton6 Garcia, Jeff7 Bledsoe, Drew8 Brooks, Aaron9 Warner, Kurt10 McNair, Steve11 Farve, Brett 12 Pennington, C13 Green, Trent 14 Brady, Tom15 Maddox, Tom16 Hasselback, M17 Collins, Kerry18 Johnson,Brad19 Kitna, Jon20 Ramsey, Patrick21 Fielder, Jay 22 Holcomb, Kelly23 Plummer, Jake24 Brunell, Mark25 Carr, Dave

 

[KKrew]

1 Vick2 Garcia,J3 Manning,P4 Culpepper,D5 McNabb,D6 Warner,K7 Brooks,A8 Gannon,R9 Favre,B10 Pennington,C11 McNair,S12 Green,T13 Bledsoe,D14 Brady,T15 Collins,K16 Johnson,B17 Brunell,M18 Plummer,J19 Hasselbck20 Harrington21 Ramsey22 Kitna,J23 Fiedler,J24 Delhomme,J25 Holcombe,K

 

[PVCap99]

1.Vick2.Mcnabb3.Culpepper4.Manning5.Brooks6.Gannon7.Hassleback8.Bledsoe9.Maddox10.Garcia11.Pennington12.Brady13.Mcnair14.Ramsey15.Warner/Bulger16.Favre17.Ramsey18.Plummer19.Collins20.Green,T21.Couch/Holcombe22.Harrington23.Kitna24.Stewart25.Brees

 

[smlevin]

1) Manning2) Vick3) McNabb4) Culpepper5) Gannon6) Garcia7) Warner8) Brooks9) McNair 10) Pennington 11) Favre 12) T. Green 13) Maddox14) Plummer15) Brady16) Bledsoe17) K. Collins18) B. Johnson19) K. Stewart 20) Hasselbeck21) Drew Brees22) Jay Fiedler23) P. Ramsey24) Kitna25) Harrington

 

[The Godfather]

4. Ramsey

:(

 

[The Godfather]

1) McNabb2) Vick3) Culpepper4) Warner5) Brooks6) Brady 7) Manning8) Gannon9) Favre 10) Garcia11) Hasselbeck12) Green 13) McNair 14) Collins15) Pennington 16) Maddox17) Harrington18) Brees19) Kitna 20) Plummer21) Hutchinson22) Stewart 23) Johnson24) Fiedler25) Carr

 

[bagger]

1. D. Culpepper2. D. McNabb3. J. Garcia4. P. Manning5. R. Gannon6. M. Vick7. A. Brooks8. B. Favre9. S. McNair10. T. Brady11. T. Green12. K. Stweart13. J. Plummer14. D. Bledsoe15. B. Johnson16. C. Pennington17. K. Collins18. M. Hasselback19. K. Warner20. D. Brees21. M. Brunell22. T. Couch23. P. Ramsey24. D. Carr25. J. Fiedler

 

[bagger]

15.Warner/Bulger21.Couch/Holcombe

how did you combine two people into one?

 

[gobosox]

I like Unlucky's call on Ramsey too......lot of weapons and Spurrier year 2.

 

[ffdude69]

1 Culpepper2 Warner3 Mcnabb4 Gannon5 Manning6 Brooks7 Vick8 Mcnair9 Favre10 Garcia11 Maddox12 Bledsoe13 Hasselbeck14 Plummer15 Collins16 Brady17 Green18 Pennington19 Brees20 Kitna21 Ramsey22 Johnson23 Stewart24 Brunell25 Fiedler

 

[AhrnCityPahnder]

SandBagger:Maddox omitted on purpose, or an oversight? if on pupose, you honestly think Carr will put up better #s?My top 251. McNabb2. Culpepper3. Gannon4. Vick5. Garcia6. Manning7. Brooks8. Bledsoe9. Farve10. TGreen11. Warner12. Maddox13. McNair14. Pennington15. Brady16. Hassleback17. Collins18. BJohnson19. Brees20. Ramsey21. Plummer22. Kitna23. Hutchenson24. Stewart25. Fiedler

 

[bagger]

SandBagger:

Maddox omitted on purpose, or an oversight? if on pupose, you honestly think Carr will put up better #s?

yes, i do think that carr will put up better numbers than maddox, only because i have a hard time seeing maddox either performing at the level he did last year and/or missing a few games with injuries.if i knew that maddox would take 100% of the snaps then, yes, maddox would be ranked higher, probably around #12 (edit: just saw that's where you have him).

i have maddox as the #29 qb under my current projections, under a yardage and a td scenario similar to the 2000 pittsburgh team.

 

[LadyBeBop]

1) McNabb 2) Culpepper 3) Vick 4) Garcia 5) Warner 6) Manning 7) Brooks 8) Gannon 9) Favre10) Maddox11) Bledsoe12) McNair13) Brady14) Pennington15) Kitna16) Ramsey17) Collins18) Green19) Brad Johnson20) Hasselbeck21) Fiedler22) Holcomb23) Brees24) Harrington25) Stewart

 

[BlueDredSo]

1) Culpepper2) McNabb3) Vick4) Gannon5) Manning6) Garcia7) Favre8) Bledsoe9) Brooks10) Maddox11) McNair12) Warner13) Brady14) Green15) Collins16) Plummer17) Pennington18) Hasselbeck19) B Johnson20) Stewart21) Brees22) Brunell23) Fiedler24) Ramsey25) Harrington

 

[dozer]

1 Mcnabb2 Manning3 Culpepper4 Vick5 Garcia6 Warner7 Gannon8 Favre9 Brooks10 Bledsoe11 Maddox12 Pennington13 Hasselbeck14 Green15 Mcnair16 Brady17 B. Johnson18 Collins19 Kitna20 Ramsey21 Plummer22 Harington23 Brees24 Stewart25 Couch

 

[IvanKaramazov]

I like Unlucky's call on Ramsey too......lot of weapons and Spurrier year 2.

IMO, Ramsey is the best candidate for the annual "QB that comes out of nowhere and goes nuts all season" derby. Entering 2nd year in the league (when most QBs show the biggest improvement) and 2nd year in Spurrier's system. Pass-happy offense. Very good weapons in the passing game. Ramsey is such an obvious sleeper pick that I'm surprised others aren't projecting bigger numbers for him.Go back and look at what "Redskin QB" did last year. Then remember that those numbers were achieved with Danny Weurffel, Shane Matthews and a rookie under center. And no Coles. And a RB who didn't fit "the system." And a shakier o-line. If Ramsey starts all season (Spurrier's hook being the biggest risk here), he's a lock to finish in the top 10 at least.

 

[Unlucky]

IMO, Ramsey is the best candidate for the annual "QB that comes out of nowhere and goes nuts all season" derby. Entering 2nd year in the league (when most QBs show the biggest improvement) and 2nd year in Spurrier's system. Pass-happy offense. Very good weapons in the passing game. Ramsey is such an obvious sleeper pick that I'm surprised others aren't projecting bigger numbers for him.Go back and look at what "Redskin QB" did last year. Then remember that those numbers were achieved with Danny Weurffel, Shane Matthews and a rookie under center. And no Coles. And a RB who didn't fit "the system." And a shakier o-line. If Ramsey starts all season (Spurrier's hook being the biggest risk here), he's a lock to finish in the top 10 at least.

I'm sorry that even started this. I was just throwing stuff out there to be a little bit different. Please refrain from posting anymore positive things about Ramsey. I'd really like to be able to draft a top 5 QB in round 7, so let's keep this quiet.

 

[blkgolf23]

1) Donovan McNabb2) Mike Vick3) Peyton Manning4) Aaron Brooks5) Daunte Culpepper6) Rich Gannon7) Jeff Garcia8) Brett Favre9) Trent Green10) Drew Bledsoe11) Steve McNair12) Kerry Collins13) Matt Hasselbeck 14) Tom Brady 15) Kurt Warner 16) Kordell Stewart17) Joey Harrington18) Chad Pennington19) Patrick Ramsey20) Drew Brees21) Tommy Maddox22) Jake Plummer23) Jay Fiedler 24) Brad Johnson25) Mark Brunell

 

[paydrt]

1. D. Culpepper 2. D. McNabb3. M. Vick 4. A. Brooks 6. P. Manning7. K.Warner 8. S. McNair9. T. Green 10.M.Hasselback 11.T. Brady12.D.Bledsoe 13.J. Garcia 14.B.Favre15.C.Pennington 16.T.Maddox 17.J.Plummer18.K.Collins19.D.Carr 20.J.Harrington21.P.Ramsey22.K.Holcombe23.J.Kitna24.J.Delhomme 25.D.Brees

 

[Leo2228]

1. McNabb2. Culpepper3. Gannon4. Vick5. Garcia6. Manning7. Brooks8. Bledsoe9. Farve10. TGreen11. Warner12. Maddox13. McNair14. Pennington15. Brady16. Hassleback17. Collins18. BJohnson19. Brees20. Ramsey21. Plummer22. Kitna23. Hutchenson24. Stewart25. Fiedler

 

[sos32]

1) Donovan McNabb PHI2) Daunte Culpepper MIN3) Rich Gannon OAK4) Peyton Manning IND5) Mike Vick ATL6) Steve McNair TEN7) Kurt Warner STL8) Drew Brees SD9) Brett Favre GB10) Aaron Brooks NO11) Matt Hasselbeck SEA12) Jeff Garcia SF13) Patrick Ramsey WAS14) Drew Bledsoe BUF15) Tom Brady NE16) Tommy Maddox PIT17) Trent Green KC 18) Redman/Boller BAL19) Chad Pennington NYJ20) Jake Plummer DEN21) Jay Fiedler MIA22) Kerry Collins NYG24) Joey Harrington DET24) David Carr HOU25) Kordell Stewart CHI

 

[zulu]

1. Vick2. Culpepper3. Gannon4. McNabb5. Manning6. Garcia7. Maddox8. Warner9. Bledsoe10. Brady11. Ramsey12. Favre13. Collins14. Hasslebeck15. Green16. McNair17. Pennington18. B Johnson19. Plummer20. Kitna21. Stewart22. Breese23. Fiedler24. Harrington25. Carr

 

[sos32]

1. Rich Gannon - OAK 2.Donovan Mcnabb - PHI 3. Michael Vick - ATL 4. Daunte Culpepper - MIN 5. Peyton Manning - IND 6. Aaron Brooks - NO 7. Brett Favre - GB 8. Kurt Warner - STL 9. Drew Bledsoe - BUF 10. Drew Brees - SD11. Jeff Garcia - SF 12. Steve McNair - TEN 13. Tom Brady - NE 14. Patrick Ramsey - WAS 15. Jake Plummer - DEN 16. Matt Hasselbeck - SEA 17. Jay Fiedler - MIA18. Chad Pennington - NYJ 19. Tommy Maddox - PIT 20. Kerry Collins - NYG 21. Trent Green - KC 22. Joey Harrington - DET23. Brad Johnson - TB 24. Mark Brunell - JAC 25. Kordell Stewart - CHI

 

[NYCelt]

1 Donovan McNabb PHI2 Michael Vick ATL3 Daunte Culpepper MIN4 Rich Gannon OAK5 Jeff Garcia SFO6 Peyton Manning IND7 Aaron Brooks NOR8 Kurt Warner STL9 Steve McNair TEN10 Brett Favre GNB11 Drew Bledsoe BUF12 Chad Pennington NYJ13 Tom Brady NWE14 Trent Green KAN15 Kerry Collins NYG16 Tommy Maddox PIT17 Brad Johnson TAM18 Jake Plummer DEN19 Matt Hasselbeck SEA20 Drew Brees SDG21 Joey Harrington DET22 Jay Fiedler MIA23 Jon Kitna CIN24 Tim Couch CLE25 Mark Brunell JAC25 Rodney Peete CAR

 

[sos32]

Some of the rankings are suprising! Only time will tell

 

[Frenchy Fuqua]

1- Daunte Culpepper2- Donovan McNabb3- Mike Vick4- Peyton Manning5- Rich Gannon6- Brett Favre7- Kurt Warner8- Aaron Brooks9- Drew Bledsoe10-Jeff Garcia11-Matt Hasselbeck12-Tommy Maddox13-Steve McNair14-Trent Green15-Chad Pennington16-Pat Ramsey17-Tom Brady18-Kerry Collins19-Brad Johnson20-Jake Plummer21-Kelly Holcombe22-Joey Harrington23-David Carr24-Drew Brees25-Kordell StewartPretty deep selection at QB this year.

 

[snido10]

1 Manning 2 McNabb3 Gannon4 Garcia5 C-Pep6 T. Green 7 Favre8 Vick9 Bledsoe 10 Brady11 Maddox12 McNair13 Pennington14 Warner15 Plummer 16 Collins17 Hasselbeck18 Fiedler19 Kitna 20 Brad J.21 Brooks22 Brees23 Harrington24 Ramsey25 Carr

 

[Bigdee]

Sorry, but I don't usually follow the crowd when it comes to a lot of these, especially in regard to Culpepper who does well, but is usually somewhat overrated. My picks:GannonManningBrooksBradyGarciaVickMcNabbWarnerFavreCulpepperPenningtonPlummerBledsoeGreenMcNairBrunellFiedlerBreesCollinsB. JohnsonHarringtonMaddoxKitnaBlakeCarr

 

[Bonfire]

My picks:1.McNabb2.Culpepper3.Brooks4.Manning5.Gannon6.Garcia7.Green8.Warner9.Vick10.Bledsoe11.McNair12.Brady13.Plummer14.Hasselbeck15.Collins16.Johnson17.Farve18.Maddox19.Ramsey20.Pennington21.Fiedler22.Kitna23.Carr24.Brees25.Stewart

 

[The Professor]

1) Daunte Culpepper2) Mike Vick3) Donovan McNabb4) Peyton Manning5) Kurt Warner6) Aaron Brooks7) Rich Gannon8) Jeff Garcia9) Brett Farve10) Steve McNair11) Drew Bledsoe12) Tommy Maddox13) Trent Green14) Kerry Collins15) Jake Plummer16) Chad Pennington17) Brad Johnson18) Tom Brady19) Drew Brees20) Jay Fiedler21) David Carr22) Mark Brunell23) Matt Hasselback24) Kordell Stewart25) Patrick Ramsey

 

[Frenchy Fuqua]

Sorry, but I don't usually follow the crowd when it comes to a lot of these, especially in regard to Culpepper who does well, but is usually somewhat overrated.

Culpepper may be overrated as an NFL QB, but as a fantasy QB he is the man. In an off year for him last year he still put up top 3-4 QB numbers in many leagues.

 

[Aaronl5]

1. Culpepper2. McNabb3. Gannon4. Vick5. Bledsoe6. Maddox7. Fiedler8. Hasselbeck9. Brooks10. McNair11. Holcomb12. Collins13. Manning14. Favre15. Brees16. Plummer17. Johnson18. Pennington19. Bulger20. Brady21. Carter22. Garcia23. Green24. Redmen25. Peete

 

[Iwannabeacowboybaby!]

1. Donovan McNAAB2. Daunte Caulpepper3. Michael Vic4. Peyton Manning5. Aaron Brooks6. Rich Gannon7. Tommy Maddox8. Chadd Pennington9. Jeff Garcia10. Drew Bledsoe11, Brett Farve12. Matt Hassleback13. Tom Brady14. Kurt Warner15. Brad Johnson16. Trent Greene17. Joey Harrington (1st couple posts, no Harrington, crazy!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!)18. Steve McNair19. Kerry Collins20. Drew Brees21. John Kitna22. Plummer23. Carr24. Fiedler25. Stewart** If Griest signs and starts, I'd bump him into the 12-15 range and throw Stewart out