It will be really interesting to see how things play out in the fall. Which plans succeed, and which plans fail despite best efforts. My son was supposed to work at a summer camp this summer - the last term of the summer starting in late July. Because of concerns over Covid, along with the fact that his college moved up the start date by a week, he ended up not signing his contract and is working a remote internship instead. Well, we found out that during the first term of the camp, there was a Covid outbreak amongst the campers and they’ve now canceled camp for the remainder of the summer.USC is tough because as you mentioned it’s right in the middle of Los Angeles. How do you keep it a closed environment? You can’t.
College aged kids can drive, already hang out with friends and probably about half already have leases for off campus housing. There’s going to already be a lot there to start.
Were kids and staff actually tested right before going or just a temperature check, questions, etc.? Did they figure out who started it?It will be really interesting to see how things play out in the fall. Which plans succeed, and which plans fail despite best efforts. My son was supposed to work at a summer camp this summer - the last term of the summer starting in late July. Because of concerns over Covid, along with the fact that his college moved up the start date by a week, he ended up not signing his contract and is working a remote internship instead. Well, we found out that during the first term of the camp, there was a Covid outbreak amongst the campers and they’ve now canceled camp for the remainder of the summer.
How does this relate to college campuses? Well I think the cautionary tale is that you can be located in a small town/remote location, and take precautions to ensure that arriving kids have been tested and are in a largely closed environment with minimal outside contact, and it can still turn into a ####show once Covid starts spreading amongst the student population
Don’t get me wrong, I am hoping and praying that colleges are able to successfully navigate the fall. But I fear that best laid plans may not be sufficient once things start spreading amongst a student population. Tracing is going to be a nightmare at many schools I think. If my son ends up getting a space in the dorms (unlikely) and we end up letting him go (possible), I would honestly bet against him finishing the semester there.
Well, I know they were testing all the camp counselors (since my son was going to be a counselor). Not sure about the campers, but perhaps so. But your point is well taken about things being more lax in June than now (though the did have all sorts of policies they were implementing). But that’s sort of my point. Once you have thousands of 18-22 year-olds converging on a college town, I just don’t think there will be sufficient vigilance amongst that population to prevent an outbreak. And once things start spreading amongst students at a large college, I don’t see how you can effectively institute tracing and quarantine protocols. There will simply be too many kids to deal with.Were kids and staff actually tested right before going or just a temperature check, questions, etc.? Did they figure out who started it?
I know you are in Texas and I’m assuming that the first term started in what middle of June? Middle of June in Texas was likely like Florida, an entirely different time. Florida had 1k cases back them compare to 15k cases per day now.
My wife wanted to take a break so we actually went to Hilton Head for Memorial Day. I didn’t really feel comfortable but I was the anal retentive one while we were there at the hotel. Outside of ordering food at the pool are we were pretty distant, but I also wasn’t crazy worried because there weren’t a lot of cases in SC. Different world now.
Anyway, long winded way to say that in June, it wouldn’t shock me if a summer camp in Texas was way more lax than anyone would be today.
On the athletes, Clemson had 20+ football players test positive. It’s one of the reasons why I think the number of cases is way higher than we think. None of those players would have even know unless someone they knew developed symptoms. I think there will be a lot of kids testing positive that are shocked.Well, I know they were testing all the camp counselors (since my son was going to be a counselor). Not sure about the campers, but perhaps so. But your point is well taken about things being more lax in June than now (though the did have all sorts of policies they were implementing). But that’s sort of my point. Once you have thousands of 18-22 year-olds converging on a college town, I just don’t think there will be sufficient vigilance amongst that population to prevent an outbreak. And once things start spreading amongst students at a large college, I don’t see how you can effectively institute tracing and quarantine protocols. There will simply be too many kids to deal with.
Texas A&M is a perfect example. They had some student athletes back to campus this summer to start workouts. This is in a small college town and in a purportedly controlled environment with a tiny percentage of the student population. And they’ve already had a number of positive cases across multiple sports, including very recently three positive tests on the swim team. What happens when 47,000 undergrads converge on College Station in a few weeks?
Not trying to be doom and gloom here, but I’m worried.
Yeah, it's a really awkward situation here in our college town (Ithaca). The town is totally dependent on the colleges and we need the students back. But our COVID-19 numbers have been kept relatively low throughout - as of yesterday, the county had a total of 176 positives and only 9 active cases. So while the residents want the students back, we aren't looking forward to the likely influx of the virus from all over the country.Faust said:
https://www.nbcnews.com/news/us-news/unc-chapel-hill-converts-remote-learning-after-reporting-135-new-n1236977It will be really interesting to see how things play out in the fall. Which plans succeed, and which plans fail despite best efforts. My son was supposed to work at a summer camp this summer - the last term of the summer starting in late July. Because of concerns over Covid, along with the fact that his college moved up the start date by a week, he ended up not signing his contract and is working a remote internship instead. Well, we found out that during the first term of the camp, there was a Covid outbreak amongst the campers and they’ve now canceled camp for the remainder of the summer.
How does this relate to college campuses? Well I think the cautionary tale is that you can be located in a small town/remote location, and take precautions to ensure that arriving kids have been tested and are in a largely closed environment with minimal outside contact, and it can still turn into a ####show once Covid starts spreading amongst the kids.
Don’t get me wrong, I am hoping and praying that colleges are able to successfully navigate the fall. But I fear that best laid plans may not be sufficient once things start spreading amongst a student population. Tracing is going to be a nightmare at many schools I think. If my son ends up getting a space in the dorms (unlikely) and we end up letting him go (possible), I would honestly bet against him finishing the semester there.
Clemson is pretty much virtual (actually virtual until at least September). My son has all hybrid classes which are basically online with some what seem like office hours. I was really surprised that the NC state schools were going back in person when my son mentioned his friends going back.
There's a LOT of that talk @Kiddnets People saying the colleges knew good and well they'd have to close but they knew they wouldn't get as much tuition money in if they started online.I have a feeling many colleges are moving forward to get the full amount of money and then close down after a short period of time.....i just dont see how they are going to pull this off....
that's terrible....I know they are taking a big hit but if that's true its inexcusable....and it certainly looks that way.There's a LOT of that talk @Kiddnets People saying the colleges knew good and well they'd have to close but they knew they wouldn't get as much tuition money in if they started online.
Lots of parents / students talking about the bait and switch.
This is one a friend sent methat's terrible....I know they are taking a big hit but if that's true its inexcusable....and it certainly looks that way.
my son is going to be a freshman at Rutgers and Im happy they chose to be remote early....they are doing a good job setting up virtual dorms and events so the kids get to know each other a bit......
Good read. An awful lot of ambiguity and statements like the one below really disappoint. We've had 6 months to come up with something better than once we have you, you ain't going anywhere.
I've posted elsewhere that I think re-opening universities is a mistake. I believed that back in April, and I definitely believe it now that we wasted the entire summer and actually allowed the pandemic to become worse instead of better. That said, I do want to push back a little on the "bait and switch" angle. In my experience, that was never the intention.Joe Bryant said:
We were hearing this message loud and clear last spring. It was clear back then that if we went all-online in Fall 2020, we would be looking at a much smaller freshman class and a loss of many of our continuing students. That would be financially devastating to any university not in the super-elite upper tier, which is like 99% of higher ed institutions in the US. So it's not unfair to say that money played a big role in this, but the root of the problem is that students want to be on campus and they don't like online education. If a student wanted to earn their degree online, they would have gone to Southern New Hampshire, not my four-year residential school. We're under a lot of pressure to give students the experience that they want, which means bringing them back to campus.A survey by SimpsonScarborough, a higher education research firm, in July found roughly 40% of incoming first-year college students said they were likely or highly likely to change where they attended school because of the COVID-19 outbreak. And returning college students, who complained of paying full tuition for lackluster classes in the spring, have weighed deferring future enrollment until campuses reopen.
It seems like one's view on this question depends on the extent to which "giving the students what they want" was feasible to begin with. Yes, if these schools had a good faith belief that they could make it happen, then I agree it's not just a money grab. If the schools were telling students that they were going to give them something that they knew or should have known was unrealistic, that's when the accusations of bait-and-switch come in.But this was a well-intentioned decision to do everything possible to provide students with the experience that they signed on for, not just a money grab.
Tough to argue that the expectations aren’t being made perfectly clear. Follow the rules or risk screwing it up for everyone. Do you want to be at college, or not?Email from Virginia Tech...
Dear Hokies,
I write today because though our hopes have been high, our on-campus opportunities for this semester are increasingly fragile, and they will not be realized without ALL of us committed to a successful outcome. As you know, I wrote to you this summer about what will be required. Just last week, our Dean of Students Byron Hughes reinforced the sacrifices that are necessaryfor an in-person residential experience.
The reality as of this morning is that only some are choosing to live by the health imperatives necessary. Many gatherings over the weekend, inconsistent practices of wearing masks and physical distancing, and other overt behaviors are weakening the resolve of many and the reality that we can all remain on campus. While developmental and collaborative approaches are the norm at Virginia Tech, it is now clear that this public health crisis will not be solved without clear and definitive boundaries that are enforced with swift and serious action. The following requirements are to provide clarity in your decision-making:
There should not be ANY non-university sanctioned/monitored gatherings, on or off campus, larger than 15 people.
Face masks/coverings should be worn at all social gatherings, with 6-foot physical distancing. Individuals should remove themselves from situations where this is not possible.
Independent outdoor exercise is the only exception to the obligation of the face covering requirement.
To be clear, failure to follow these expectations is considered endangering the welfare of others and will result in immediate interim suspension and removal from campus housing. Immediate interim suspension means no academic classes or student activities until a full student conduct hearing is complete. This will adversely impact your academic career.
Our student conduct program is typically designed with opportunities built in to learn from one’s mistakes. Yet these aren’t typical times. The nature of the pandemic means the health and well-being of our community must be the values that win the day. Therefore, Virginia Tech will take swift action for all violations, and the academic career of all involved will be impacted.
I am counting on ALL of us. Let’s get this right. Now.
Frank Shushok Jr.
Vice President for Student Affairs
I’m really sorry to hear that. Are classes all online? Based on what we’ve been hearing about our son’s school, we’re feeling better about our/his decision to stay at home for Fall Semester.My Daughter has been at MTSU since Thursday. On Friday she got an email from administration saying that if the kids don’t cut out the parties and rule breaking that they will shut down the campus.
My kid knows no one on campus and has basically been stuck in her dorm room for 3 days (no roommates). So far, she says college sucks. Classes haven’t even started yet...
No, she has some in-person and some online. If she had been all online we would have just kept her home. I don’t think the campus will stay open for long tho.I’m really sorry to hear that. Are classes all online? Based on what we’ve been hearing about our son’s school, we’re feeling better about our/his decision to stay at home for Fall Semester.
Hopefully she’ll make some friends in her in-person classes (before things get shut down). My son is a week into his classes and it doesn’t sound like he’s connected with anyone outside of class, which is unfortunate. Hard to make friends during a Zoom class when everyone just logs off as soon as class is over.No, she has some in-person and some online. If she had been all online we would have just kept her home. I don’t think the campus will stay open for long tho.
She's had a couple of days of marching band practice, so she met a couple of people in her section. Unfortunately, noone is allowed to visit anyone, so outside of practice or class, she won't be socializing much.Hopefully she’ll make some friends in her in-person classes (before things get shut down). My son is a week into his classes and it doesn’t sound like he’s connected with anyone outside of class, which is unfortunate. Hard to make friends during a Zoom class when everyone just logs off as soon as class is over.
That really sucks. I’m so glad my son was a freshman last year otherwise he wouldn’t be living off campus with 4 friends and have other friends off campus as well. Clemson still hasn’t opened the campus so freshman are still at home and all classes are online but he couldn’t wait to leave home again.She's had a couple of days of marching band practice, so she met a couple of people in her section. Unfortunately, noone is allowed to visit anyone, so outside of practice or class, she won't be socializing much.
Agreed, and along the same lines you can judge by how realistic the plan is that they came up with. The plan can't be we are going in person and if we get any cases we shut down, because you will get cases. How you handle those who get sick or the people who repeatedly violate the health policy are the things you need to have down in advance. Also, you should have an idea of what level of outbreak you start to change course.It seems like one's view on this question depends on the extent to which "giving the students what they want" was feasible to begin with. Yes, if these schools had a good faith belief that they could make it happen, then I agree it's not just a money grab. If the schools were telling students that they were going to give them something that they knew or should have known was unrealistic, that's when the accusations of bait-and-switch come in.
I'm generally in agreement with your position though. There has been so much uncertainty about everything that I don't believe that schools were actually promising things they knew they would never deliver.
Oh my God. I’m so, so sorry. Did classes start for her today. Such a tough situation for her.This is brutal. I took my daughter's dog to the park yesterday to get some exercise, and he developed heat stroke. We're going to have to have him euthanized tonight. My daughter is a wreck, she's alone, and a couple hundred miles away. On top of that, her grandfather has terminal cancer, and she has some kind of health issue of her own that we haven't got figured out yet. She's crying and wants to come home. This is breaking my heart.
Yeah, she started today. I guess she's had a couple opportunities to socialize but is just so sad that she doesn't want to leave her room. I'm trying to convince her to see a councilor on campus, but she doesn't want to make the effort. My wife may drive up there tomorrow just to give her some support.Oh my God. I’m so, so sorry. Did classes start for her today. Such a tough situation for her.
This was from a few days ago:U of SC beginning it’s spiral into closure. Cases doubled on Thursday. President asked everyone to prep for a closure in case he has to pull the trigger. 3 more house in Greek village quarantined. Lots of large house parties. Daughter told me freshman are just acting stupid on campus.
480 positive tests so far at ASU with their random testingASU (not sure still the case but at one time largest student population in country) starts here in a couple days I believe. Going to be a disaster.
Welp, I’ll be shocked if Clemson moves forward. It’s not open yet. Classes started online and my son, like probably half the students, is in off campus apartments. He was just hoping to have a library open so he could study outside of his room.U of SC beginning it’s spiral into closure. Cases doubled on Thursday. President asked everyone to prep for a closure in case he has to pull the trigger. 3 more house in Greek village quarantined. Lots of large house parties. Daughter told me freshman are just acting stupid on campus.
Most of these students returning to campus are going to get it. And as I posted upthread, many, if not most, will not report it to the school. And while they won’t admit it, I think some of these schools are probably fine with that.So USC just bailed on the spit test. The official transcript was the lab was overwhelmed and short staffed. The unofficial version from my boss, who's daughter is a freshman on the cheerleading squad, all of the cheerleading squad except two tested positive so they sent everyone home. They all used the saliva test. The two that didn't used the nose swab test and were negative. The school questioned the lab on the results, they said they were jacked up so the school quit using the saliva test. They went back to only nose swabs. Unless they are feeling under the weather, kids typically won't be voluntarily getting their brains scrambled so the numbers of positive cases have dropped dramatically (from a high of 1,440 to 193 today).