smbkrypt24
Footballguy
If you can complete the dynasty value of a player in 2 weeks you are good. Players can have bad weeks. You are way off on your assessment.
To make the point. Would you trade Vita Vea for Barkley? The answer is no.
Fantasy Football - Footballguys Forums
Welcome to Our Forums. Once you've registered and logged in, you're primed to talk football, among other topics, with the sharpest and most experienced fantasy players on the internet.
RB Saquon Barkley, PHI (2 Viewers)
- Thread starter Faust
- Start date
To make the point. Would you trade Vita Vea for Barkley? The answer is no.
irish eyes
Footballguy
Actually it's not. He isn't startable at this point. Danny dummy doesn't know he has a good check down.
ConnSKINS26
Footballguy
I was referring to the comment about him having "some value in dyno". Which is an lol comment.
tackle for loss
Footballguy
This, he will be a Giant next year.
People making excuses as if he is even talented at this point just love names. Talent would have popped a run on his own. Im sick of hearing people mock those who have hot takes about big names when the hot take is right.
If you start him next week, you deserve what you get.
3 total TDs from him this year, Gallman had 2 in one game and had more than any game Barkley had, in the one...ONE, game he started..
Last edited by a moderator:
Rhythmdoctor
Footballguy
Wait, you’re saying he’s NOT talented? Barkley is a beast and having a bad season for a ton of reasons. Lack pf talent is not one of those reasons.
irish eyes
Footballguy
He is in the worst situation possible. Coach is terrible, QB is terrible, play calling terrible. Everyone that said eli manning was bad last year, here you go giants fans. What a disaster
The Frankman
Footballguy
Last edited by a moderator:
shadyridr
Footballguy
Blame them all you want the biggest reason for his poor performance is he lacks any explosiveness mostly due to the injury.
IheartGuinness
Footballguy
Last edited by a moderator:
Please get this back to a discussion about Barkley.
timschochet
Footballguy
I don't want to overreact. But I need to know if he is remains an RB1 going into the playoffs. Or even a high end RB2.
What would you consider his starting value going forward?
Play Ekeler? Is he even a flex play? Looks like the opposing D knows that they just need to stop him and they will win. When the Giants do score it looks lucky at best with Barkley just not a factor. Not that I’m watching close
Play Ekeler? Is he even a flex play? Looks like the opposing D knows that they just need to stop him and they will win. When the Giants do score it looks lucky at best with Barkley just not a factor. Not that I’m watching close
irish eyes
Footballguy
irish eyes
Footballguy
I never would have imagined at the beginning of this year that my dynasty team has to be imploded & start from scratch. Barkley garbage, davante garbage, juju garbage, goff (already knew he was garbage), kupp going in the tank because of a horrible qb. Oof
Otis
Footballguy
Praying I get a playoff bye. It's a miracle I'm even in this position understanding Barkley's performance.
In week's 15 and 16, the NYG get MIA and @WASH respectively. He'll perform there.
And for those owners who haven't done so already, there is a great need to grab Gallman to lock up that production those two weeks in the case where Barkley is indeed shut down.
In week's 15 and 16, the NYG get MIA and @WASH respectively. He'll perform there.
And for those owners who haven't done so already, there is a great need to grab Gallman to lock up that production those two weeks in the case where Barkley is indeed shut down.
Dr. Octopus
Footballguy
Things move quickly in the NFL - next year the Giants will probably have a new coaching staff and Jones will be a bit more seasoned and probably not take off running every time he sees pressure. He'll learn to dump it off to a guy like Barkley and watch him gain yards.tackle for loss said:
Also Barkley rushed back from a high ankle sprain and that has sapped some/most of his explosiveness. He hasn't looked the same since he's come back.
Anyone writing off his dynasty value is being shortsighted. This is the same guy that looked like a beast last season and early this season - situations can change for the better and for the worse, it's hard to imagine Barkley being in a worse situation next season.
tackle for loss
Footballguy
DJ has more points than Barkley, and he missed games too.Otis said:
Team Smokin'
Footballguy
Otis said:
From week 13 forward is all that matters now. I prefer Barkley by a long shot over DJ. I mean anything can happen between these two first round re-drafters. One or both or neither could end up kicking it in if they recover from nagging injuries?
Just to be safe I'm going to add Gallman back to my bench in lieu of a second D/ST. Gonna roll with BAL D hosting SF in a very anticipated game of the week. Thought about going one more week with a second D with CAR, PHI, NYJ, GB all available. BAL D probably going to be a top 10 D this week rankings wise. Yet, I gotta go with Gallman as the Giants match ups coming down the stretch are attractive. There's always the possibility that Giants brass save their star from wear n' tear down the stretch.
irish eyes
Footballguy
And it looks like another stellar game in the making for Barkley. Geez, what a disaster of a season.
Kwai Chang Caine
Footballguy
Haven’t been here in a while. Are people still arguing Barkley better than Henry?
irish eyes
Footballguy
I cant imagine why anyone would say that. I will not be starting Barkley anymore. Danny dummy, I mean dimes never throws it to him. And he certainly isn't getting any meaningful rushing yards. Done
The Frankman
Footballguy
Last edited by a moderator:
tackle for loss
Footballguy
Well, my guess is, many who owned this pile of rubbish this year did not make the playoffs.
But on the slim chance that those who owned him did, are you playing him this week and if not, who you benching him for?
I'm rolling Miles Sanders over him if it appears Howard is out again.
But on the slim chance that those who owned him did, are you playing him this week and if not, who you benching him for?
I'm rolling Miles Sanders over him if it appears Howard is out again.
Team Smokin'
Footballguy
If Barkley and Kamara would just progress into their mean from here on out.
Little bit more confidence in Alvin over Saquon.
Danny Dimes outta drop a few passes off to Saquon in space please.
Little bit more confidence in Alvin over Saquon.
Danny Dimes outta drop a few passes off to Saquon in space please.
tackle for loss
Footballguy
Danny in a boot, if Eli plays, he will drop 10 to barkley and throw to him more no doubt. Eli wants to look good if he plays and he knows saquan can do that. He isnt an arrogant rook trying to make something happen where its impossible.
Team Smokin'
Footballguy
WHAT, Eli may play? That was my logic / experts for missing short dump off passes in the first place. I follow this stuff everyday, first to hear that Dimes is in a boot. WOW!
Last edited by a moderator:
Oooh.
I would just love to see Eli catch some lightning in a bottle here down the stretch. He sure as hell knows the PHI D...getting weapons back.
Maybe if they're competitive vs. the Eagles management decides to mothball D. Jones for the year and Eli, Barkley, and the rest of the offense roll through some easy matchups.
I would just love to see Eli catch some lightning in a bottle here down the stretch. He sure as hell knows the PHI D...getting weapons back.
Maybe if they're competitive vs. the Eagles management decides to mothball D. Jones for the year and Eli, Barkley, and the rest of the offense roll through some easy matchups.
tackle for loss
Footballguy
Barkley rushed for 100 yards each time he has played the Eagles. He also caught 9 catches for 99 yards in one and 7 for 41 in another with 3 total TDs.
If he bounces back this week in a big way, all will be forgotten from me. If he stinks it up he goes on that personal black list we all have.
I only see snippets - but watching Barkely not get targeted well in the passing game is bAD.
Even a glance in Barkely's direction will move safety's and LB's - especially if he has a clean release and is 1-1 with the LB. Meanwhile Danny dime seems to stare downfield and throw bounce passes
Even a glance in Barkely's direction will move safety's and LB's - especially if he has a clean release and is 1-1 with the LB. Meanwhile Danny dime seems to stare downfield and throw bounce passes
Otis
Footballguy
Starting with confidence. Thinking with Eli we’ll see more touches and better overall production.
Otis
Footballguy
tackle for loss
Footballguy
Well, Barkley did have b2b 100 yard games to start the season like the player he should be with eli and as always with a rookie scrub QB, yes thats what this Jones kid is, he starts his decline. Barkley isnt even blaming his injury, so I wont. Especially after seeing how bad this Jones kid was.
Rookie or not, he should know better for his own survival the best thing for him to do was put it in Saquan hands often, instead he threw at WRs ankles 20 yards down the field. Thats a low IQ QB and nothing anyone will say will convince me that this Jones kid is gonna be good. He just doesnt have it mentally, Eli isnt that much better anymore, but for Barkleys sake. He knows to just dump it to him instead of trying to throw to some dude named slayton.
The Big Donkey
Footballguy
I'm not seeing this "throw at WR ankles 20 yards down field" take. Granted this article is from November but he's been pretty accurate with this throws, that is when he isn't fumbling.
"Per Sports Info Solutions, there have been 25 quarterbacks who have thrown at least 20 passes that have traveled at least 20 yards beyond the line of scrimmage. Of those quarterbacks, no one has thrown on-target (a pass considered catchable) more than Jones at 67.9%. But, no quarterback has completed fewer of his deep attempts than Jones at just 21.4%."
Are Barkley owners cuffing Gallman?
I have not to date and figure if the fantasy gods want to be super cruel and mess with us just prior to the best matchups of the season in week 15 (MIA) and 16 (@WASH) well...the hell with it, it's probably not my year and not meant to be.
If he can perform the next two weeks all of this year's underperformance will not matter.
I have not to date and figure if the fantasy gods want to be super cruel and mess with us just prior to the best matchups of the season in week 15 (MIA) and 16 (@WASH) well...the hell with it, it's probably not my year and not meant to be.
If he can perform the next two weeks all of this year's underperformance will not matter.
Buck Allen got one carry against GB and Penny got two. I don't know if Gallman is the clear cut backup anymore.
I'm waiting on Guice's MRI so if it's bad I'll be dropping him for some NYG RB before MNF.
I need a decent game from him tonight to win my playoff matchup
His splits have been better with Eli. Most of those were with ODB and not post high ankle sprain, but hopefully Eli checks down to him a bunch this game.
Fantasy wise had two great games against PHI last year, but both were aided by two long TDs - not sure if that is sustainable
Perhaps playing against Miles Sanders will give him a spark
He's definitely due for some TDs
His splits have been better with Eli. Most of those were with ODB and not post high ankle sprain, but hopefully Eli checks down to him a bunch this game.
Fantasy wise had two great games against PHI last year, but both were aided by two long TDs - not sure if that is sustainable
Perhaps playing against Miles Sanders will give him a spark
He's definitely due for some TDs
tackle for loss
Footballguy
I hate this saying more than anything.
No, he isnt. No player is due anything.
Players dont get TDs cuz they are due. Now he may get some TDs, but he was "due" a long time ago. Technically. He is "due" every game. But the fact is, being due means nothing.
tackle for loss
Footballguy
Projected stat lines tonight, lets hear it?
Not what you need, but what u reasonably expect him to do.
Not what you need, but what u reasonably expect him to do.
