dynasty ppr:
Team A:
Vincent Jackson
Team B:
Mike Sims-Walker
Lee Evans
Early Doucet
Team A:
Vincent Jackson
Team B:
Mike Sims-Walker
Lee Evans
Early Doucet
Fantasy Football - Footballguys Forums
This is a sample guest message. Register a free account today to become a member! Once signed in, you'll be able to participate on this site by adding your own topics and posts, as well as connect with other members through your own private inbox!
2010 Offseason Dynasty Trades (3 Viewers)
- Thread starter jeter23
- Start date
Instinctive
Footballguy
I kinda think the QBs both suck for fantasy purposes, and Moreno is definitely > Foster, which leaves Austin and Smith. I think Smith ha s acouple WR1 years in him, and Austin may only have one before Dez takes it away. He's [Austin] already working out of the slot this year anyway...
HenryMuto
Footballguy
Who won in this trade ? Was giving up the 1.01 worth what he got back ?
Instinctive
Footballguy
That depends on a couple things. If Best/Bryant fall to him, it was definitely worth it. If it's a team that needs a RB, and Best doesn't fall, I don't think it was worth it.If he needs a WR, it definitely wasn't worth it, because Bryant is better than anything else in this trade. However, getting Flacco could prove to be a very nice acquisition, and 1.04 isn't that big fo a drop, as most people (not me) have Spiller in the same tier as Best/Mathews/Bryant. I think Gonzalez is a wasted player, because there's simply no room for him in Indy and he wasnt that great pre-injury anyway.The 2nd rounder, while not worth much anyway, seems like it was a bit too much to throw in. 4.03 is like a 1 in 100 shot at a starter...not worth it to me.All in all, I would have kept 1.01, or found a better deal.
Dinsy Ejotuz
Footballguy
Team A: Kolb, Bradshaw
Team B: Felix Jones
Team A: Alex Smith, Garrard
Team B: Garcon
Both leagues can start QBs as a superflex.
Team B: Felix Jones
Team A: Alex Smith, Garrard
Team B: Garcon
Both leagues can start QBs as a superflex.
Instinctive
Footballguy
With QBs as a superflex, the first trade let team B get away with robbery. That's a nice deal.
ptsteelers
Footballguy
Team A gets - Matthew Stafford QB-Det
Team B gets -
Matt Hasselbeck QB-SEA
Devin Aromashodu WR, CHI
Damian Williams WR, TEN
Deon Butler WR, SEA
Jermaine Gresham TE, CIN
2011 Draft, Rnd 1 (projected top 4)
Team B gets -
Matt Hasselbeck QB-SEA
Devin Aromashodu WR, CHI
Damian Williams WR, TEN
Deon Butler WR, SEA
Jermaine Gresham TE, CIN
2011 Draft, Rnd 1 (projected top 4)
wasted space 25
Footballguy
Team A gets : Sidney Rice and two second round rookie picks
Team B gets : Michael Crabtree and two first round rookie picks PICKS ARE FOR NEXT TWO YEARS, this years draft over already
SECOND TRADE
Team A gets : Sidney Rice and Justin Forsett
Team B gets : Dwayne Bowe and Darren McFadden
Team B gets : Michael Crabtree and two first round rookie picks PICKS ARE FOR NEXT TWO YEARS, this years draft over already
SECOND TRADE
Team A gets : Sidney Rice and Justin Forsett
Team B gets : Dwayne Bowe and Darren McFadden
Tickle Monster
Footballguy
Trade #1: Oof...... Team A is getting creamed...Trade #2: Team A is making out here (slightly)wasted space 25 said:
Instinctive
Footballguy
Yeah, the first trade the guy getting Crabs and firsts is a genius.The second trade...Rice>>>BoweForsett=McFadden
I'd say Team A absolutely crushed trade #2.
thriftyrocker
Footballguy
12 team PPR
Team A gets: Roethlisberger (has Brady)
Team B gets: McNabb (next best QB is Henne)
Team A gets: Keller
Team C gets: Fred Jackson (has VDavis)
Team A gets: Roethlisberger (has Brady)
Team B gets: McNabb (next best QB is Henne)
Team A gets: Keller
Team C gets: Fred Jackson (has VDavis)
D'OHtis
Footballguy
Agreed on trade 2. Team B got a fat druggie & a RB with more kids than TD's.
wasted space 25
Footballguy
HAHAHAHAHHAHAHHAHAHAH!!!!!!!!!!!!
Jtmonie
Footballguy
10 Team PPR start 1QB 2 RB 2 WR 1 TE & 2 Flex.
I got accused of taking advantage of the other team. My team had Cutler as #1 QB and his has Brady & Rivers. I have great WR & RB depth and he is sparse.
My team gave up
RB Jacobs
RB Dwyer ® -he has Mendy
WR Mason
WR Cotchery
QB Flaco
I received
QB Rivers
Rnd 1 Rookie pick 2011 (prob 1.02-1.04)
I think it was a good trade for him to build depth, and was prob going to keep Rivers on the bench most of the year (he is from Mass. and loves all things patriots)
I got accused of taking advantage of the other team. My team had Cutler as #1 QB and his has Brady & Rivers. I have great WR & RB depth and he is sparse.
My team gave up
RB Jacobs
RB Dwyer ® -he has Mendy
WR Mason
WR Cotchery
QB Flaco
I received
QB Rivers
Rnd 1 Rookie pick 2011 (prob 1.02-1.04)
I think it was a good trade for him to build depth, and was prob going to keep Rivers on the bench most of the year (he is from Mass. and loves all things patriots)
The Real Hipster Doofus
Footballguy
Don't try to convice yourself, it was an awful trade and you know it.
Instinctive
Footballguy
Not sure how you managed to get a first rounder, but it doesn't look THAT bad otherwise. Some people look at Norv, the fact that Rivers has never had more than 500 passign attempts, and McNeil/VJax holdouts looming plus a high pick RB in town........................................and sell a bit low.
gandalas
Footballguy
Yeah....Jacobs and Mason = done. Cotchery = 3rd WR on a non-passing team. Dwyer = lucky to ever be anything special. Flacco = maybe a top-12 QB, if EVERYTHING swings right for him?While Rivers = a top 5 QB, and a top-4 rookie pick in next year's draft is ridiculous. This deal was horrid...even without the first I think it is lopsided.
Agreed, especially in a ten team league. All of those players except Flacco are worthless.
LionsFan78
Footballguy
Britt given away in one league...12 man PPR
Team A gave: Kenny Britt
Team B gave: Johnny Knox, Marcus Easly
Team A gave: Kenny Britt
Team B gave: Johnny Knox, Marcus Easly
King of the Jungle
Footballguy
I am in the minority but I do not think Britt is leaps and bounds above Knox as a prospect.
HenryMuto
Footballguy
What does everything think of this trade ?I am in a league where the guy wants me to give up my 1.02 plus Slaton plus 2 1st round picks in 2011 (one of which likely top 4) all for just Stewart.I said no way that was too much but he says Stewart is worth all that.Then here I see Stewart goes Straight up for the 1.02.
HenryMuto
Footballguy
Give me team B's side here. Anytime I can trade a QB prospect for a 1st round pick I would do it.Is there a reason a QB is worth so much ? Is this a 16 team league or something ? QB's get 12 pts per TD pass ? You must start 2 QB's ?Hasselbeck is worthless but the other players might be something but if he really does get a top 4 pick for Stafford he got a great deal.
tarheel1unc
Footballguy
I think that's a lot for Stewart. I own Stewart in a dynasty and I assure you, it will take a lot more than 1.02 to get him.
Ketamine Dreams
Footballguy
12 team, PPR, dynasty
Trade 1
Team A gives Clinton Portis
Team B gives Carson Palmer
Trade 2
Team A gives Mike Sims-Walker, Todd Heap
Team B gives Dwayne Bowe, Rookie/free agent pick 3.01
Trade 1
Team A gives Clinton Portis
Team B gives Carson Palmer
Trade 2
Team A gives Mike Sims-Walker, Todd Heap
Team B gives Dwayne Bowe, Rookie/free agent pick 3.01
fsufan
Footballguy
stewart owner as well and i would not trade him for the 1.02
No Way Jose
Footballguy
This one is interesting....I've done 2 dynasty startups this year where Matthews went off the board before Stewart, but Dez went off after. I could see Stewart for the 1.1 or 1.2 and a little more. Stewart reminds me of Calvin Johnson, some people really like him and some are just meh. Stewarts value is dependent on the individual owners.
It was a bit of a sell cheap I suppose but makes more sense in context. This is a PPR league, and the owner of Stewart already had ADP, Grant, Forte and DeAngelo as RBs (RBs 4, 12, 13 and 17 respectively-Stewart finished 15th @ RB FWIW), whilst his WRs are Fitz, Rice, Driver, Meachem, Knox, Thomas, Jacoby Jones. So he is probably looking to consolidate his young WRs with Bryant (I am 100% sure Mathews will go 1.01 given the needs of the 1.01 owner). I would normally value Stewart as 1.02 plus a bit more, so admittedly I think I got a good deal, even if the guy was loaded with RB.
Last edited by a moderator:
I gladly traded the 1.1 for Stewart a couple months ago, and i would do it again.
King of the Jungle
Footballguy
Love that trade for you.
Cassius
Footballguy
It's impossible not to. That's pretty gross.
Avery
Footballguy
Really?I mean I wouldn't have done it if I didn't like it but I think it addressed what we were both looking for.
So was he also looking to make your team better?
Todem
Footballguy
I guess everyone thinks Bowe is a bust. I beg to differ. He may well be a stud still.
I like the Nicks and 1.2 side but I think Bowe is getting way undervalued right now and that will change after 3-4 weeks into the season. He is a hass and that team will feature him in the passing game no doubt. Boldin will also be a load for another 2-3 years.
If that other team is close to a title....I can see why he made that deal. That is a win now deal.
But again I do prefer the 1.2/Nicks side but it is not a slam dunk. And if Dez does not fall I would be all over Spiller. I am not a Matthews believer long term.
I like the Nicks and 1.2 side but I think Bowe is getting way undervalued right now and that will change after 3-4 weeks into the season. He is a hass and that team will feature him in the passing game no doubt. Boldin will also be a load for another 2-3 years.
If that other team is close to a title....I can see why he made that deal. That is a win now deal.
But again I do prefer the 1.2/Nicks side but it is not a slam dunk. And if Dez does not fall I would be all over Spiller. I am not a Matthews believer long term.
Avery
Footballguy
I'm not trying to defending the equity of the trade but he is sour on draft picks and there is truth to there being a considerable bust rate, even at the top of "can't miss" prospects. He wan't to get rid of his picks, get some established depth at WR and diversify his WRs where he only had Nicks and Smith (NY), and I mean nothing else.Many are picking Bowe to be a bounce back player this year. It was only a year ago that he was being talked about as the next great thing and now he has Weis to draw up the game plan. Many are also picking Boldin as a target hog; gold in PPR.I mean I love Nicks and Bryant but both are competing for targets with young, top level WRs on the other side of the field while Bowe and Boldin are clearly going to be the go to guys.Well, I guess I'm deffending the equity of the trade. 
Avery
Footballguy
I (clearly) agree with this take.It was a had trade to make because I am in "win now" mode too (defending champ), but I always try to be.
I just saw a good opportunity to get a bit younger and build my core. Probably hurt my team a bit now and helped it a lot in the long run.
I'm sitting at 1.02 and 1.06 in the rookie draft now and seeing what it will take to move up a slot or two from 1.06 to grab Bryant and Best or Spiller.
Todem
Footballguy
I think it was a very good deal for both sides....these are the kind of trades that make a dynasty so much fun. I hope you do land Bryant and Spiller....as I think those 2 are clearly the blue chip elite talent of this years crop.
Avery
Footballguy
Seriously?
HenryMuto
Footballguy
5 years ahead and this guy already traded his 2011, 2012 and 2013 1st rounders for Forte last year.How many years ahead can you trade rookie picks?
It would be tough to find a new owner if he decided to drop out of league. I hope he has a good team.5 years ahead and this guy already traded his 2011, 2012 and 2013 1st rounders for Forte last year.How many years ahead can you trade rookie picks?
HenryMuto
Footballguy
Teams in my leauges don't usually drop out.Been running this league since 1997 (CFL in my sig) and I still have 8 of the original owners. We are all very committed to this league.It would be tough to find a new owner if he decided to drop out of league. I hope he has a good team.5 years ahead and this guy already traded his 2011, 2012 and 2013 1st rounders for Forte last year.
Also the guy who made that trade has 1 of the best teams in the league he has
Rogers, P-Manning, Charles, Forte, A-Johnson, Wayne, Des-Jackson, V-Davis, Celek just to name a few of his players.
Similar threads
