I don't think it's a rip-off like some of these deals, but I view both Barber and Bradshaw about even with the 1.06, which is a Tate, Hardesty type player (rather have Bradhsawh than either of those guys or D. Thomas).... so I'd rather have that side.
Fantasy Football - Footballguys Forums
This is a sample guest message. Register a free account today to become a member! Once signed in, you'll be able to participate on this site by adding your own topics and posts, as well as connect with other members through your own private inbox!
2010 Offseason Dynasty Trades (1 Viewer)
- Thread starter jeter23
- Start date
Riffraff
Footballguy
Tate went mid second 14 + 8. Rookie + free agent draft.1.01 Mathews, Ryan SDC RB ® Sat May 1 12:31:41 a.m. ET 2010
1.02 Spiller, C.J. BUF RB ®
1.03 Best, Jahvid DET RB ®
1.04 Bryant, Dez DAL WR ®
1.05 Tate, Ben HOU RB ®
1.06 Hardesty, Montario CLE RB ®
1.07 McCluster, Dexter KCC WR ®
1.08 Bradford, Sam STL QB ®
1.09 Tate, Golden SEA WR ® Pick Skipped By Commissioner Replacement pick made by Commissioner
1.10 Benn, Arrelious TBB WR ®
1.11 Thomas, Demaryius DEN WR ®
1.12 Gerhart, Toby MIN RB ®
1.13 LaFell, Brandon CAR WR ®
1.14 Dwyer, Jonathan PIT RB ®
2.01 McCoy, Colt CLE QB ®
2.02 Aromashodu, Devin CHI WR
2.03 Williams, Mike TBB WR ®
2.04 Whitehurst, Charlie SEA QB
2.05 Tebow, Tim DEN QB ®
2.06 Dixon, Anthony SFO RB ®
2.07 Starks, James GBP RB ®
2.08 Williams, Damian TEN WR ®
......this is where GTate was really taken.
2.09 Clausen, Jimmy CAR QB ®
GTate shows up at 1.09, but he was a replacement pick inserted by the Commish on a skipped pick. The same owner drafted Tate and then selected Clausen with his second round pick.
Biggest surprise was McCluster instead of Thomas, but the same owner got Thomas 4 picks later.
RBs are worth more than WRs in a 14 team non-PPR league.
jeter23
Footballguy
I agree about RBs being worth more in non-PPR, but that just means you take Tate/Hardesty before Thomas ect, not Anthony Dixon over Tate. And Damien Williams over Tate?
Riffraff
Footballguy
I can understand questioning taking another WR over him, but team needs play a part when taking prospect RBs. 3rd/4th string WR prospects were plentiful still. This is Golden Tate we're talking about, not a sure thing WR by any stretch. Heck on May 1st, I shouldn't have taken Mike Williams over him according to any cheatsheets or hype at the time. Can't speak for the other owners other than maybe they weren't that into GT.
Sabertooth
Footballguy
Just sent and owner Kenny Britt and Antonio Bryant in exchange for Ahmad Bradshaw and Ladell Betts. Obviously this is basically a two for one trade. My rationale was that Britt is risky at best for many reasons and I don't think Bryant is going to do a lot for the Bengals at all. He's flaky and they have a lot of young talent over there. I also worry a lot about Palmer's arm and I have Ocho as well. Just too much passing stock in a team that likes to rush the ball and play defense.
On the Bradshaw side I think he takes a bit bigger slice of the pie this season. He played last season with a severe injury that caused him to wear a walking boot Monday through Saturday and still made Jacobs look inferior on Sundays. I'd say it is close to a 50/50 split this season. I also like that fact that he's still quite young at 24. He's 4 years younger than Jacobs and I think it is only a matter of time until he's the man in New York.
On the Bradshaw side I think he takes a bit bigger slice of the pie this season. He played last season with a severe injury that caused him to wear a walking boot Monday through Saturday and still made Jacobs look inferior on Sundays. I'd say it is close to a 50/50 split this season. I also like that fact that he's still quite young at 24. He's 4 years younger than Jacobs and I think it is only a matter of time until he's the man in New York.
BrainDeadGenius
Footballguy
PPR Trade
Team A Gives
James Davis
Jonathon Stewart
DeMaryus Thomas
Team B Gives
LeSean McCoy
Mike Sims-Walker
Early Doucet
Team A Gives
James Davis
Jonathon Stewart
DeMaryus Thomas
Team B Gives
LeSean McCoy
Mike Sims-Walker
Early Doucet
Last edited by a moderator:
jeter23
Footballguy
Like the side getting Stewart here.
Carolina Hustler
Footballguy
Agreed. Stewart is the best player in this trade. Although I do like Sims-Walker a bit
Donsmith753
Footballguy
Like Team A here. Cant't decide in the other one, give me a while to think about it.
BrainDeadGenius
Footballguy
I forgot to mention that this is a PPR league.Carolina Hustler said:
The Real Hipster Doofus
Footballguy
Like the VJax side and the Calvin side. I am one of the biggest Felix fans out there too.
scientist
Footballguy
12 Team PPR $250 Salary Cap Contract League
Team A gives:
Welker ($46 at 2 years)
Team B gives:
Pick 1.07 in rookie draft ($10 at 1-4 years)
...
Team A gives:
Pick 1.07
Jerome Harrison ($5 2 years)
Team C gives:
Pick 1.05 ($11 at 1-4 years)
...
Team A gives:
Pick 1.05
Doucet ($1 4 years)
Aromashodu ($1 4 years)
Team D gives:
Pick 1.03 ($13 at 1-4 years)
So for Welker with a bloated contract, Harrison, Doucet, and Aromashodu, Team A got either Ryan Matthews or Jahvid Best for $13 for 4 years.
Team A gives:
Welker ($46 at 2 years)
Team B gives:
Pick 1.07 in rookie draft ($10 at 1-4 years)
...
Team A gives:
Pick 1.07
Jerome Harrison ($5 2 years)
Team C gives:
Pick 1.05 ($11 at 1-4 years)
...
Team A gives:
Pick 1.05
Doucet ($1 4 years)
Aromashodu ($1 4 years)
Team D gives:
Pick 1.03 ($13 at 1-4 years)
So for Welker with a bloated contract, Harrison, Doucet, and Aromashodu, Team A got either Ryan Matthews or Jahvid Best for $13 for 4 years.
Last edited by a moderator:
BrainDeadGenius
Footballguy
PPR League
Team A Gives
Jon Carlson
Team B Gives
Tony Gonzalez
Team A Gives
Jon Carlson
Team B Gives
Tony Gonzalez
The Real Hipster Doofus
Footballguy
12 team league, .5 PPR for WR and TE
Team A Gets:
Kenny Britt
Dexter McCluster
Chaz Schilens
Zack Miller (OAK)
Team B Gets:
Dustin Keller
Louis Murphy
2011 1st round draft pick
The 2011 1st is from the team that picked 1.01 last year.
Team A Gets:
Kenny Britt
Dexter McCluster
Chaz Schilens
Zack Miller (OAK)
Team B Gets:
Dustin Keller
Louis Murphy
2011 1st round draft pick
The 2011 1st is from the team that picked 1.01 last year.
bigern1000
Footballguy
12-team PPR, roster cutdowns at end of week to 14 vets + 3 rooks...
Team A gives
Arian Foster (who would have been cut by Team A)
Robert Meachem
Team B gives
Julius Jones (who will be cut by Team A)
Chad Ochocinco
Team A gives
Arian Foster (who would have been cut by Team A)
Robert Meachem
Team B gives
Julius Jones (who will be cut by Team A)
Chad Ochocinco
Tau837
Footballguy
Today:Traded: Harvin, Ronnie Brown, Ricky WilliamsFor: Fitzgerald, Willie Parker, Louis Murphy, 2010 Rookie Draft Pick 2.6Offseason sum total:Traded: Grant, Moreno, Sims-Walker, Winslow, Meachem, Edelman, Stafford, Doucet, Harvin, 2010 Rookie Draft Pick 2.8For: Chris Johnson, Fitzgerald, Vincent Jackson, Henne, Willie Parker, Louis Murphy, Ogletree, Stroughter, 2010 Rookie Draft Pick 2.6
The Real Hipster Doofus
Footballguy
Not trying to be a jerk, but there must be some terrible owners in that league. That deal for Chris Johnson is absolutely horrid, and the one for Fitzgerald isn't much better. The other two deals are fair IMO. I doubt I could get Chris Johnson alone in any league for that entire list of players you traded this offseason. Definitely a good offseason for your team.Just Win Baby said:Today:Traded: Harvin, Ronnie Brown, Ricky WilliamsFor: Fitzgerald, Willie Parker, Louis Murphy, 2010 Rookie Draft Pick 2.6Offseason sum total:Traded: Grant, Moreno, Sims-Walker, Winslow, Meachem, Edelman, Stafford, Doucet, Harvin, 2010 Rookie Draft Pick 2.8For: Chris Johnson, Fitzgerald, Vincent Jackson, Henne, Willie Parker, Louis Murphy, Ogletree, Stroughter, 2010 Rookie Draft Pick 2.6
gianmarco
Footballguy
You're missing Boldin from the sum total.Just Win Baby said:Today:Traded: Harvin, Ronnie Brown, Ricky WilliamsFor: Fitzgerald, Willie Parker, Louis Murphy, 2010 Rookie Draft Pick 2.6Offseason sum total:Traded: Grant, Moreno, Sims-Walker, Winslow, Meachem, Edelman, Stafford, Doucet, Harvin, 2010 Rookie Draft Pick 2.8For: Chris Johnson, Fitzgerald, Vincent Jackson, Henne, Willie Parker, Louis Murphy, Ogletree, Stroughter, 2010 Rookie Draft Pick 2.6
I'm in this league as well. I was really happy when the guy who traded away Chris Johnson & Boldin for a song quit the league like a month later.Not trying to be a jerk, but there must be some terrible owners in that league. That deal for Chris Johnson is absolutely horrid, and the one for Fitzgerald isn't much better. The other two deals are fair IMO. I doubt I could get Chris Johnson alone in any league for that entire list of players you traded this offseason. Definitely a good offseason for your team.Just Win Baby said:Today:Traded: Harvin, Ronnie Brown, Ricky WilliamsFor: Fitzgerald, Willie Parker, Louis Murphy, 2010 Rookie Draft Pick 2.6Offseason sum total:Traded: Grant, Moreno, Sims-Walker, Winslow, Meachem, Edelman, Stafford, Doucet, Harvin, 2010 Rookie Draft Pick 2.8For: Chris Johnson, Fitzgerald, Vincent Jackson, Henne, Willie Parker, Louis Murphy, Ogletree, Stroughter, 2010 Rookie Draft Pick 2.6
Tau837
Footballguy
Yes, some of the deals were a bit surprising... we initiated talks for Chris Johnson but were not expecting to get a deal as good as the one we got, if we got one at all. The other owner ended up proposing that trade. We proposed the VJax trade. The other two trades, including the Fitz trade, were proposed by the other owners. The Fitz trade just came out of the blue this morning.Not trying to be a jerk, but there must be some terrible owners in that league. That deal for Chris Johnson is absolutely horrid, and the one for Fitzgerald isn't much better. The other two deals are fair IMO. I doubt I could get Chris Johnson alone in any league for that entire list of players you traded this offseason. Definitely a good offseason for your team.Just Win Baby said:Today:Traded: Harvin, Ronnie Brown, Ricky WilliamsFor: Fitzgerald, Willie Parker, Louis Murphy, 2010 Rookie Draft Pick 2.6Offseason sum total:Traded: Grant, Moreno, Sims-Walker, Winslow, Meachem, Edelman, Stafford, Doucet, Harvin, 2010 Rookie Draft Pick 2.8For: Chris Johnson, Fitzgerald, Vincent Jackson, Henne, Willie Parker, Louis Murphy, Ogletree, Stroughter, 2010 Rookie Draft Pick 2.6
Tau837
Footballguy
No, my summary is what we gave up from what we started with and what we ended up with as a result. We acquired Boldin in one of the trades and traded him away in another, so I intentionally did not include him.You're missing Boldin from the sum total.Just Win Baby said:Today:Traded: Harvin, Ronnie Brown, Ricky WilliamsFor: Fitzgerald, Willie Parker, Louis Murphy, 2010 Rookie Draft Pick 2.6Offseason sum total:Traded: Grant, Moreno, Sims-Walker, Winslow, Meachem, Edelman, Stafford, Doucet, Harvin, 2010 Rookie Draft Pick 2.8For: Chris Johnson, Fitzgerald, Vincent Jackson, Henne, Willie Parker, Louis Murphy, Ogletree, Stroughter, 2010 Rookie Draft Pick 2.6
gianmarco
Footballguy
Sorry, missed him in the deal where you acquired him. Makes it look even more filthy. Was bad enough without him in there.No, my summary is what we gave up from what we started with and what we ended up with as a result. We acquired Boldin in one of the trades and traded him away in another, so I intentionally did not include him.You're missing Boldin from the sum total.Just Win Baby said:Today:Traded: Harvin, Ronnie Brown, Ricky WilliamsFor: Fitzgerald, Willie Parker, Louis Murphy, 2010 Rookie Draft Pick 2.6Offseason sum total:Traded: Grant, Moreno, Sims-Walker, Winslow, Meachem, Edelman, Stafford, Doucet, Harvin, 2010 Rookie Draft Pick 2.8For: Chris Johnson, Fitzgerald, Vincent Jackson, Henne, Willie Parker, Louis Murphy, Ogletree, Stroughter, 2010 Rookie Draft Pick 2.6
14 team (no PPR) I completed the following 2 deals pre-draft:
Deal 1
I gave up: Michael Turner, 1.1 draft pick, 2.1 draft pick
I received: Larry Fitzgerald, Michael Bush, 2011 1st round pick
Deal 2
I gave up: Ryan Grant
I received: 1.3 draft pick
Deal 1
I gave up: Michael Turner, 1.1 draft pick, 2.1 draft pick
I received: Larry Fitzgerald, Michael Bush, 2011 1st round pick
Deal 2
I gave up: Ryan Grant
I received: 1.3 draft pick
Last edited by a moderator:
The Man With No Name
Footballguy
Some are raising hell over this trade, saying it is lopsided:
Team A gives- C. Portis, C. Ocho Cinco, pick 10
Team B gives- pick 1, pick 25
(rookie picks, of course)
Team A gives- C. Portis, C. Ocho Cinco, pick 10
Team B gives- pick 1, pick 25
(rookie picks, of course)
Sopranos25
Footballguy
I traded AD for Colston Charles Harrison and 2 first rounders 10th and 11th and im glad
But not vetoable. I've seen worse.
Donsmith753
Footballguy
hell there's worse on this page.
JohnnyU
Footballguy
Who is Charles Harrison?
Donsmith753
Footballguy
Yitbos69
Footballguy
Who is Colston Charles Harrison?
Cassius
Footballguy
No Way Jose
Footballguy
Team A gets: J. Finley
Team B gets: D. Keller + 2011 1st
Team B gets: D. Keller + 2011 1st
JohnnyU
Footballguy
Unless that pick is projected top 6 (preferably top 4), I'd keep Finley. Next year's draft should be loaded with WRs such as AJ Green, Julio Jones, Michael Floyd, Jonathan Baldwin, and RBs Mark Ingram and Ryan Williams, and QB Jake Locker.
Last edited by a moderator:
wasted space 25
Footballguy
Team A gets: Adrian Peterson and Tony Gonzalez
Team B gets: Beeine Wells, Jermichael Finley, Hakeem Nicks, Michael Bush
Team B gets: Beeine Wells, Jermichael Finley, Hakeem Nicks, Michael Bush
Last edited by a moderator:
Garts
Footballguy
someone's a guppy14 team, non-ppr standard scoring, start 1QB, 2RB, 2 WR/TE, 2 FlexSpiller + Donald Brown + 2011 1st (mid~late)forBrees + McCoy~~~~~~~~~~~different league, same setup
JohnnyU
Footballguy
I usually like the deal for whoever is getting the best player, but in this case I like Team B's side of that deal, and it isn't close.
Last edited by a moderator:
The Real Hipster Doofus
Footballguy
Thats a kings ransom for AP. It's one of those deal that Team A looks back in two years and wonders why they ever made such a trade.
wasted space 25
Footballguy
I wanted to make sure i got rid of Tony Gonzalez and get good value for him. Pairing him up with AP helped me here.
Sabertooth
Footballguy
Traded Santonio Holmes straight up for Felix Jones? I like Felix's long term potential, but I'm going to be kicking myself if Santonio ends up in New England or someplace else like that next season.
The Real Hipster Doofus
Footballguy
Love that deal for you
No Way Jose
Footballguy
I would guess that pick is in the 1.4-1.8 range....Interesting trade, I had been trying to get Finley from him myself.
Sabertooth
Footballguy
Just took the following trade. Mind you this is from the reigning league champ. Start 2QB league.
I gave up Matt Moore and Jimmy Clausen
He gave up Frank Gore and Brady Quinn
I realize Gore has some miles, but neither Moore nor Clausen excites me at all, even if things do break perfectly for them.
I gave up Matt Moore and Jimmy Clausen
He gave up Frank Gore and Brady Quinn
I realize Gore has some miles, but neither Moore nor Clausen excites me at all, even if things do break perfectly for them.
Similar threads
