2012 In Season Dynasty Trade Thread (1 Viewer)

[Concept Coop]

10+ years? LOL. Eli is already 31. And it's not like the Broncos aren't going to field a QB after Peyton retires. As for the upside comment, Demaryius is a more prodigious physical specimen. Bigger, stronger, and possibly faster than Nicks. I think he has the potential to be a dominant player. We've seen glimmers of it over the past 12 months.

You have to go with your valuations, so I respect that. You gave up market value, but that only goes so far. If this was the only way for you to get Bey Bey, and you like him more - can't really argue that.

 

[Concept Coop]

A few recent trades that I have made in a Mox league (Q/R/R/W/W/F/F; TE=W, Non PPR/14 Team):

Gave:

Lynch

Got:

Bradshaw

Colston

Gave:

Hillis

Got:

Hernandez

Gave:

Romo

Colston

Got:

Schaub

D. Wilson

The Bradshaw trade came before Brown's big game. I don't know that I would have made it in hindsight. There is potential for Brown to be the new Jacobs, in terms of stealing carries. Lynch is a RB1 in non-PPR leagues, but his style and age is such that I wanted to cash out. If I could have acquired Turbin at a fair rate, I wouldn't have moved Lynch.

Giving Hillis for Hernandez was easy for me. Hillis is not a starting caliber RB anymore, and Hernandez is a 22 year old stud.

Giving Romo and Colston for Schaub and Wilson was hard - the other guy probably won the trade, in a vacuum. But, I wanted to hedge my Bradshaw bet, and believe in Wilson still. 4 pt passing TDs, so I value Cam Newton as very elite, and will be starting him weekly - Romo was a luxury. Colton was my WR6/7 (Cruz, Bryant, Austin, Bowe, Blackmon, Hernandez) and I wanted to get value for him before a big injury.

 

[Gawain]

Gave:HillisGot:Hernandez

Why did someone roster Livan Hernandez?

 

[bmsarvis]

10 team idp dynasty. .5 ppr start 1qb2rb2wr1te flex 1 rb/wr/te... he owns turner i have fosterI gave quiz wells and pierre thomas and my 2013 first rd pick- hopefully lateFor ben tate and percy harvinMy relevant lineupcamFostertrichspiller/alf Ajgreennicksharvinjimmy graham

I'd have sent all that for just Harvin as fast as I possible could. Is this really Harvin's value? I may have to go buy him wherever I can...

Im not sure but i would have gave more if need be. Ive was trying to get those two for a long time now. He started tate week 1&3 but sat him week2 the week tate blew up and got tired of em i guess. I getting some crap in my league about givin up too much lol i thought i got the better side of the deal idk

 

[Spike]

Zealots league.

Team A trades Andrew Luck and a 2013 2nd round rookie pick

Team B trades Dez Bryant

Brought this up for 2 reasons:

1. Which side did better - not taking into account the 2 teams respective rosters?

2. In dynasty, should your roster really be the main consideration or should it be the talent level?

 

[FUBAR]

I gave up:

Maclin, Jeremy PHI WR

Pettigrew, Brandon DET TE

Witten, Jason DAL TE

Urlacher, Brian CHI LB

Polamalu, Troy PIT S



For

Jackson, Vincent TBB WR

Finley, Jermichael GBP TE

Lewis, Ray BAL LB

Bell, Yeremiah NYJ S

I'll need a new backup TE and maybe I'm wrong for thinking it, but I still like Finley's potential.

 

[Skeletore Eh]

alex green

for

andre brown

 

[lsutigers]

Team A trades Andrew Luck and a 2013 2nd round rookie pick

Team B trades Dez Bryant

Brought this up for 2 reasons:

1. Which side did better - not taking into account the 2 teams respective rosters?

2. In dynasty, should your roster really be the main consideration or should it be the talent level?

1. Team B2. Always talent level

B won this on both levels. A is a moron.

Am in a dynasty league where owner had Griffin and Brady. Surplus at QB. Traded Brady for Gore. Awful, awful trade. Just because you have a surplus doesn't mean you sell for cheap.

 

[FUBAR]

Team A trades Andrew Luck and a 2013 2nd round rookie pick

Team B trades Dez Bryant

Brought this up for 2 reasons:

1. Which side did better - not taking into account the 2 teams respective rosters?

2. In dynasty, should your roster really be the main consideration or should it be the talent level?

1. Team B2. Always talent level

B won this on both levels. A is a moron.

Am in a dynasty league where owner had Griffin and Brady. Surplus at QB. Traded Brady for Gore. Awful, awful trade. Just because you have a surplus doesn't mean you sell for cheap.

I prefer Luck straight up to Dez, but I don't think it's that far off. Consider rosters, but it can't be the main consideration when it comes to what is fair - just what you're looking to give and receive.

 

[Dez]

12 team FFPC Dynasty PPR (1.5 TE)

I was the team trading away Benson for Stewart...I don't think this helps me this year and I used to be a big Stewart fan but I have soured on him lately but I felt I had to do it for the future.

--- Big Baller ---

Traded Away:

Detroit Lions (DET)

Jonathan Stewart (CAR)

Acquired:

San Francisco 49ers (SFO)

Cedric Benson (GNB)

--- Wyverns ---

Traded Away:

San Francisco 49ers (SFO)

Cedric Benson (GNB)

Acquired:

Detroit Lions (DET)

Jonathan Stewart (CAR)

 

[Buck Stop]

12 team PPR dynasty league

Team A received:

Foster

Gonzo

Benn

Ryan Fitzpatrick

Streater

Team B received:

Luck

Ingram

Stephen Hill

Fleener

LaMike James

 

[Dez]

12 team FFPC PPR (1.5 TE)

--- Team Wet Dream ---

Traded Away:

Scott Chandler (BUF)

Chris Johnson (TEN)

Acquired:

Andre Brown (NYG)

Jermaine Gresham (CIN)

Bilal Powell (NYJ)

--- DonkeyPower D500 ---

Traded Away:

Andre Brown (NYG)

Jermaine Gresham (CIN)

Bilal Powell (NYJ)

Acquired:

Scott Chandler (BUF)

Chris Johnson (TEN)

 

["The Waterboy"]

A simple trade...I trade Cobb for Michael Floyd??? I have plenty of depth at the WR position so I can be patient with either of these guys...I've actually been somewhat patient with Cobb as I've owned him since I drafted him last year....

 

[SSOG]

Team A gives:

RGIII

Team B's 2013 1st rounder

Team A's 2014 2nd rounder

Team B gives:

Stafford

Team B's 2014 1st rounder

Team C's 2014 1st rounder

Team D's 2014 1st rounder

 

[Donsmith753]

16 team .5 PPR

Kaunas Buckeyes gave up:

Pettigrew, Brandon DET TE

Year 2013 Round 2 Draft Pick from Kaunas Buckeyes

Darth Ewing Colts gave up:

Year 2013 Round 1 Draft Pick from Darth Ewing Colts

Year 2013 Round 1 Draft Pick from Corstorphine Steelers

 

[Buck Stop]

a few trades that left me scratching my head about in one of my PPR dynasty leagues

Team A gets:

Chris Johnson

Antonio Brown

LaMike James

Team B gets:

Ridley

Vereen

Ogletree

Then the same team that got CJ and Brown did a 2nd trade

Team A gets:

Foster

Wilson

Celek

Team B gets:

Chris Johnson

Wallace

Steve Smith Rams

V. Brown

 

[Kleck]

Not sure if these were posted yet. Same league. 12 team, PPR, 1/2/2/1/flex/1/1

Team A Gave: Brown, Andre NYG RB

Team B Gave: Holmes, Santonio NYJ WR; Year 2014 Round 2 Draft Pick from Oakland Invaders

Team C Gave: Brown, Bryce PHI RB;Lynch, Marshawn SEA RB

Team B Gave: Powell, Bilal NYJ RB;Williams, DeAngelo CAR RB; Year 2013 Round 1 Draft Pick from Team B; Year 2013 Round 1 Draft Pick from Team D

Team C Gave: Cobb, Randall GBP WR;Gronkowski, Rob NEP TE

Team D Gave: Lynch, Marshawn SEA RB;Hernandez, Aaron NEP TE

Team A Gave: Moore, Lance NOS WR; Year 2013 Round 1 Draft Pick from Team F

Team E Gave: 2013 Round 1 Draft Pick from Team E

 

[HAM]

Team A gave up:

Mathews, Ryan SDC RB

Hankerson, Leonard WAS WR

Lewis, Marcedes JAC TE

Year 2013 Round 3 Draft Pick from Team A

Team B gave up:

Goodson, Mike OAK RB

Edwards, Braylon SEA WR

Gronkowski, Rob NEP TE

Year 2013 Round 4 Draft Pick from Team B

 

[Buck Stop]

Team A gave up:Mathews, Ryan SDC RBHankerson, Leonard WAS WRLewis, Marcedes JAC TEYear 2013 Round 3 Draft Pick from Team ATeam B gave up:Goodson, Mike OAK RBEdwards, Braylon SEA WRGronkowski, Rob NEP TEYear 2013 Round 4 Draft Pick from Team B

Wow. Gronk ain't worth THAT much. Nice coup for Team B!

 

[SSOG]

Team A gave up:Mathews, Ryan SDC RBHankerson, Leonard WAS WRLewis, Marcedes JAC TEYear 2013 Round 3 Draft Pick from Team ATeam B gave up:Goodson, Mike OAK RBEdwards, Braylon SEA WRGronkowski, Rob NEP TEYear 2013 Round 4 Draft Pick from Team B

Wow. Gronk ain't worth THAT much. Nice coup for Team B!

Disagreed. Trade seems close, but I prefer the side getting Gronk.

 

[ConnSKINS26]

maybe Rodgers develops into a cheap man Sproles who knows remember Spiller looked horrible his first year and 10 games too.

There is really no comparison between Spiller and Quiz. Spiller has elite speed and typical size, Quiz is small and slow, and even as agile as he is, he'll need to develop elite vision to make a big impact. Spiller was a top-10 pick who has been understandably "stuck" behind a great RB in Fred Jackson. Quiz was a 5th rounder who has been unable to pass the corpse of Michael Turner, who is now so slow and so lacking in explosion that he might as well be running backwards through the hole. Spiller has proven that he can score from anywhere on the field, that he can produce with limited touches, and that he can carry the load admirably when given the chance. Quiz has done exactly nothing in the NFL. In summary: Spiller vs. Quiz is not a fair comparison by any stretch of the imagination. Pedigree, play-making ability, and an entirely reasonable excuse for the delay in his "coming out party" vs. well...uh...Quiz has a cool name and lots of wishful-thinking hype from fantasy football owners. Oh, and all off-season his coach talked up a role for him in the offense that to this point doesn't seem to actually exist.

I wasn't comparing their size and speed. I was comparing how bad they sucked their rookie years, that is all.

But it only matters in context. And in the context of their skill-sets, they are not similar players at all. You might as well say that Kellen Moore will one day be an All-Pro QB because he hasn't played at all his rookie year yet, and neither did Aaron Rodgers. Wait, you say they have completely different skill-sets, different pedigrees, different situations? Exactly.

 

[ConnSKINS26]

10 team idp dynasty. .5 ppr start 1qb2rb2wr1te flex 1 rb/wr/te... he owns turner i have fosterI gave quiz wells and pierre thomas and my 2013 first rd pick- hopefully lateFor ben tate and percy harvinMy relevant lineupcamFostertrichspiller/alf Ajgreennicksharvinjimmy graham

I'd have sent all that for just Harvin as fast as I possible could. Is this really Harvin's value? I may have to go buy him wherever I can...

Im not sure but i would have gave more if need be. Ive was trying to get those two for a long time now. He started tate week 1&3 but sat him week2 the week tate blew up and got tired of em i guess. I getting some crap in my league about givin up too much lol i thought i got the better side of the deal idk

I would be ####### FURIOUS if a team in my league that already had Cam, Foster, Richardson, Spiller, Green, Nicks, and Graham got Harvin and Tate at that price.

 

[dickey moe]

12 team PPR

Team A gives

Calvin Johnson

Brian Hartline

Team B gives

Jamaal Charles

Santonio Holmes

 

[bmsarvis]

10 team idp dynasty. .5 ppr start 1qb2rb2wr1te flex 1 rb/wr/te... he owns turner i have fosterI gave quiz wells and pierre thomas and my 2013 first rd pick- hopefully lateFor ben tate and percy harvinMy relevant lineupcamFostertrichspiller/alf Ajgreennicksharvinjimmy graham

I'd have sent all that for just Harvin as fast as I possible could. Is this really Harvin's value? I may have to go buy him wherever I can...

Im not sure but i would have gave more if need be. Ive was trying to get those two for a long time now. He started tate week 1&3 but sat him week2 the week tate blew up and got tired of em i guess. I getting some crap in my league about givin up too much lol i thought i got the better side of the deal idk

I would be ####### FURIOUS if a team in my league that already had Cam, Foster, Richardson, Spiller, Green, Nicks, and Graham got Harvin and Tate at that price.

So your saying i did good lol trade went through before beanie hit ir fyi. Thx for the response

 

[cstu]

Team A Gave: Greg Little

Team B Gave: Dwayne Allen and a 2013 3rd

 

[Papa Georgio]

xX No Jinx Xx

I just traded away Dez for Demarco Murray in a dynasty league.

Feel pretty good about it.

xX No Jinx Xx

If anyone knows any good voodoo please post it here. Usually the second I make a trade like this the guy I get rid of goes off and the guy I get is out of the league in 6 months.

 

[Coeur de Lion]

12 team, 1/2/3+1 flex, PPR, 4 pts TD pass

Team A gives Vick, Brandon Marshall, Bilal Powell

Team B gives Aaron Rodgers, Davone Bess, Bernard Pierce, 2013 2nd

 

[ConnSKINS26]

2QB league.

Gave:

Stafford

Rod Streater

Got:

Spiller

Freeman

 

[Nucker101]

16 Team, Deep IDP Dynasty starts QB, 2RB, 2WR, TE, FLEX

Team A Gave: Colston, Stephen Hill, Greene

Team B Gave: Maclin, A.J Jenkins, D.Brown

 

[Andrew74]

Standard 12 team

I gave: Bilial Powell, Andre Brown and my 2013 1st

Team B gave: 2013 1st and 3rd

We only have 18 man rosters plus 4 taxi spots Powell was about to be cut. Brown was down the depth chart. Team B is one of the worst teams so I *should* see a high pick in both rounds. I have a high prob of being in bottom half of round.

 

[Concept Coop]

2QB league.Gave: StaffordRod StreaterGot:SpillerFreeman

This is selling low on Stafford, in a start 2 league.

 

[ConnSKINS26]

2QB league.Gave: StaffordRod StreaterGot:SpillerFreeman

This is selling low on Stafford, in a start 2 league.

Definitely. But Spiller is going to be nearly impossible to acquire soon. I see him being valued top-5 by the start of next season. I feel I can upgrade from Freeman, even if I have to overpay, easier than I can acquire a young RB1 that I love. Might seem backwards in a 2QB league, but there you have it.

 

[runner06]

Traded:

Victor Cruz

Russell Wilson

Jonathan Dwyer

2013 1st round draft pick

Received:

Andrew Luck

Pierre Garcon

Donnie Avery

2013 3rd round draft pick

I already own Cam Newton but I'm a huge Colts fan and really wanted Luck. I certainly didn't want him in my own division. Would have made this trade as a non-Colts fan too but only if I didn't already own Newton.

 

[ConnSKINS26]

Traded:Victor CruzRussell WilsonJonathan Dwyer2013 1st round draft pickReceived:Andrew LuckPierre GarconDonnie Avery2013 3rd round draft pickI already own Cam Newton but I'm a huge Colts fan and really wanted Luck. I certainly didn't want him in my own division. Would have made this trade as a non-Colts fan too but only if I didn't already own Newton.

Unless you unload Newton for more, thats a VERY expensive price to pay for a player you don't need. You need to separate your fanhood from your ownership of your dynasty teams. Don't like this one at all.

 

[runner06]

Traded:Victor CruzRussell WilsonJonathan Dwyer2013 1st round draft pickReceived:Andrew LuckPierre GarconDonnie Avery2013 3rd round draft pickI already own Cam Newton but I'm a huge Colts fan and really wanted Luck. I certainly didn't want him in my own division. Would have made this trade as a non-Colts fan too but only if I didn't already own Newton.

Unless you unload Newton for more, thats a VERY expensive price to pay for a player you don't need. You need to separate your fanhood from your ownership of your dynasty teams. Don't like this one at all.

In my opinion, fantasy football is what you make it and the ultimate goal should be to make it as enjoyable experience as possible. Most of the time that means being good as possible but on rare occasion I think it's okay to sacrifice a little now to get your favorite player. No reason you can't have your favorite player on your team if you think he's a future top 3 fantasy QB (or top 5 WR or top 5 RB).As I said previously, I went ahead and made the trade because I would have made it because I would make the same trade if I didn't have Newton. If I can trade Newton at top 10 value, then I'm good to go. If not, I'll keep both until I can trade Newton for what he's worth.As far as the actual trade goes, I'd sayLuck > Cruz (though barely)Garcon > Wilson2013 1st rounder (probably mid to late) >>> 2013 3rd rounder (probably early to mid)Avery > Dwyer Pretty even dynasty trade in my opinion in a vacuum.

 

[King of the Jungle]

Traded:

Victor Cruz

Russell Wilson

Jonathan Dwyer

2013 1st round draft pick

Received:

Andrew Luck

Pierre Garcon

Donnie Avery

2013 3rd round draft pick

I already own Cam Newton but I'm a huge Colts fan and really wanted Luck. I certainly didn't want him in my own division. Would have made this trade as a non-Colts fan too but only if I didn't already own Newton.

Unless you unload Newton for more, thats a VERY expensive price to pay for a player you don't need. You need to separate your fanhood from your ownership of your dynasty teams. Don't like this one at all.

In my opinion, fantasy football is what you make it and the ultimate goal should be to make it as enjoyable experience as possible. Most of the time that means being good as possible but on rare occasion I think it's okay to sacrifice a little now to get your favorite player. No reason you can't have your favorite player on your team if you think he's a future top 3 fantasy QB (or top 5 WR or top 5 RB).As I said previously, I went ahead and made the trade because I would have made it because I would make the same trade if I didn't have Newton. If I can trade Newton at top 10 value, then I'm good to go. If not, I'll keep both until I can trade Newton for what he's worth.

As far as the actual trade goes, I'd say

Luck > Cruz (though barely)

Garcon > Wilson

2013 1st rounder (probably mid to late) >>> 2013 3rd rounder (probably early to mid)

Avery > Dwyer

Pretty even dynasty trade in my opinion in a vacuum.

BINGO

 

[Donsmith753]

16 team .5 PPR I'm not either team

Chargers feel like they can win now and only had Bradford/freeman at QB

Craigentinny Chargers will give

Freeman, Josh TBB QB

Binns, Armon CIN WR

To Prestonpans Pirates for

Manning, Peyton DEN QB

 

[cstu]

Traded:Victor CruzRussell WilsonJonathan Dwyer2013 1st round draft pickReceived:Andrew LuckPierre GarconDonnie Avery2013 3rd round draft pickI already own Cam Newton but I'm a huge Colts fan and really wanted Luck. I certainly didn't want him in my own division. Would have made this trade as a non-Colts fan too but only if I didn't already own Newton.

Unless you unload Newton for more, thats a VERY expensive price to pay for a player you don't need. You need to separate your fanhood from your ownership of your dynasty teams. Don't like this one at all.

In my opinion, fantasy football is what you make it and the ultimate goal should be to make it as enjoyable experience as possible. Most of the time that means being good as possible but on rare occasion I think it's okay to sacrifice a little now to get your favorite player. No reason you can't have your favorite player on your team if you think he's a future top 3 fantasy QB (or top 5 WR or top 5 RB).As I said previously, I went ahead and made the trade because I would have made it because I would make the same trade if I didn't have Newton. If I can trade Newton at top 10 value, then I'm good to go. If not, I'll keep both until I can trade Newton for what he's worth.As far as the actual trade goes, I'd sayLuck > Cruz (though barely)Garcon > Wilson2013 1st rounder (probably mid to late) >>> 2013 3rd rounder (probably early to mid)Avery > Dwyer Pretty even dynasty trade in my opinion in a vacuum.

There's no problem getting players you like, but there's no sense in keeping Cam. It shouldn't be hard to get value for him despite the bad game. The pouting is a problem but he had a nearly identical game last year against the Falcons and everything turned out alright for him.

 

[HAM]

Busy day in my league today. 12 teams PPR QB/RB/RB/WR/WR/WR/TE/FLX/FLX/DEF/K 25 Man Rosters

Team A gave up:

Bush, Reggie MIA RB

Team B gave up

Nicks, Hakeem NYG WR

-------

Team C gave up:

Edwards, Braylon SEA WR

Davis, Vernon SFO TE

Team B gave up:

Brown, Vincent SDC WR

Finley, Jermichael GBP TE

-------

Team E gave up:

Fitzgerald, Larry ARI WR

Celek, Brent PHI TE

Year 2013 Round 1 Draft Pick from Team E

Team C gave up:

Harvin, Percy MIN WR

Finley, Jermichael GBP TE

 

[eric rymer]

16 team PPR Dynasty. start QB/RB/RB/WR/WR/WR/TE

I drafted Luck and RG3

Meat of the deal was I gave RG3 and got Julio Jones.

I love me some RG3 but he just takes a ton of hits and I am concerned about him long term. Part of the reason I took Luck and RG3 was hoping for a fast start from RG3 to get an AJ Green/Julio. Luck was always my long term plan.

 

[ConstruxBoy]

Team A Gave: Greg LittleTeam B Gave: Dwayne Allen and a 2013 3rd

Nice doing business with you sir. Just couldn't handle waiting on Little to come around. Good luck this season.

 

[BearsFan4Life]

This deal happened yesterday in my 14 Team NO PPR - I was not involved

Team A gave:

Schaub

Dez

Roddy

2 1st Round Rookie Picks 2013

Team B gave:

Eli (has Brees)

MJD

Stevie Johnson

Colston

I am not sure how to feel but I think Team A got the better deal

 

[Concept Coop]

This deal happened yesterday in my 14 Team NO PPR - I was not involvedTeam A gave:SchaubDezRoddy2 1st Round Rookie Picks 2013Team B gave:Eli (has Brees)MJDStevie JohnsonColstonI am not sure how to feel but I think Team A got the better deal

Not a bad trade, but I like team A's side. NonPPR, 14 teams, MJD is very valuable. Assuming team A is in the running, his team got much better, short term.

 

[Concept Coop]

2QB league.Gave: StaffordRod StreaterGot:SpillerFreeman

This is selling low on Stafford, in a start 2 league.

Definitely. But Spiller is going to be nearly impossible to acquire soon. I see him being valued top-5 by the start of next season. I feel I can upgrade from Freeman, even if I have to overpay, easier than I can acquire a young RB1 that I love. Might seem backwards in a 2QB league, but there you have it.

It depends on league scoring/size. But I think Spiller would need to be top 5 for this deal to work out in your favor - but he's not top 5 today. That, or Stafford needs to fall from his top 5 dynasty spot. Congrats on getting your guy - if you're right, the deal could work out in your favor. I just think you took on most of the risk.

 

[cstu]

This deal happened yesterday in my 14 Team NO PPR - I was not involvedTeam A gave:SchaubDezRoddy2 1st Round Rookie Picks 2013Team B gave:Eli (has Brees)MJDStevie JohnsonColstonI am not sure how to feel but I think Team A got the better deal

Not a bad trade, but I like team A's side. NonPPR, 14 teams, MJD is very valuable. Assuming team A is in the running, his team got much better, short term.

For this year it may be better for A but long-term B's side is much better. He's taking a hit on his backup QB, but Schaub is a solid backup to have.The way I'd look at it is that you'd be lucky to get two 1st's for Eli and the rest of the trade looks like thisez > MJDWhite > JohnsonSchaub > Colston (this one could go either way but I'm not sold on Colston's health)

 

[Concept Coop]

For this year it may be better for A but long-term B's side is much better. He's taking a hit on his backup QB, but Schaub is a solid backup to have.The way I'd look at it is that you'd be lucky to get two 1st's for Eli and the rest of the trade looks like thisez > MJDWhite > JohnsonSchaub > Colston (this one could go either way but I'm not sold on Colston's health)

In a nonPPR, 14 team league, MJD is worth a good deal more than Dez. RBs are such a premium - a top one provides so much value in even a single season. 2 seaons of top 10 play, after this season of top 5 play, would likely make MJD more valuable than Dez, despite the fact that Dez should have a much longer career. How do you put a price tag on how much better MJD will make a team, over the next 3 years? And I would take Colston over Schaub. Colston is very much startable, while I hope I never have to rely on Schaub to start. Granted, he is a very good backup.

 

[cstu]

For this year it may be better for A but long-term B's side is much better. He's taking a hit on his backup QB, but Schaub is a solid backup to have.

The way I'd look at it is that you'd be lucky to get two 1st's for Eli and the rest of the trade looks like this:

Dez > MJD

White > Johnson

Schaub > Colston (this one could go either way but I'm not sold on Colston's health)

In a nonPPR, 14 team league, MJD is worth a good deal more than Dez. RBs are such a premium - a top one provides so much value in even a single season. 2 seaons of top 10 play, after this season of top 5 play, would likely make MJD more valuable than Dez, despite the fact that Dez should have a much longer career. How do you put a price tag on how much better MJD will make a team, over the next 3 years? And I would take Colston over Schaub. Colston is very much startable, while I hope I never have to rely on Schaub to start. Granted, he is a very good backup.

The million dollar question is whether MJD will stay healthy for 3 years. If his knee holds up for three years then team A is the big winner in the trade.Fair enough about Colston but hasn't been worth starting this year.

 

[r0llin_game]

12 team ppr, QB, 2RB, 2WR, TE, K, RB/WR/TE

Team A gives: Late '13 1st

Teab B gives: Fred Jackson

Team A gives: Danny Ammendola

Team C gives: Cedric Benson

Team B gives: Matthew Stafford

Team D gives: Tony Romo, Late '13 1st

-------

12 team ppr, QB, 2RB, 3WR, TE, K, RB/WR/TE

Team A gives: Jacquizz Rodgers

Team B gives: Dennis Pitta, James Jones

Team C gives: Mid '13 2nd

Team D gives: Nate Washington

Team E gives: Rashard Mendenhall, Isaac Redman

Team F gives: Mid/Late '13 1st

Team E gives: Miles Austin

Team G gives: Late '13 1st

---------

12 team ppr, QB, 2RB, 2WR, TE, K, RB/WR/TE

Team A gives: Kyle Rudolph, Late '13 3rd

Team B gives: Darren Sproles

--------

12 team ppr, QB, 2RB, 2WR, TE, K, RB/WR/TE

Team A gives: Greg Jennings, Marshawn Lynch

Team B gives: Stevan Ridley, Ryan Williams, Pierre Garcon, Mid/Late '13 1st

 

[cstu]

Team B gives: Matthew StaffordTeam D gives: Tony Romo, Late '13 1st

Nice bye low on Stafford. A late 1st is easily worth the upgrade to get a guy who is better and 8 years younger.

 

[Chazzhawk]

Team A gives:RGIIITeam B's 2013 1st rounderTeam A's 2014 2nd rounderTeam B gives:StaffordTeam B's 2014 1st rounderTeam C's 2014 1st rounderTeam D's 2014 1st rounder

As good as RG3 seems to be I would want to be team A