2012 In Season Dynasty Trade Thread (1 Viewer)

[DoubleG]

12 Team PPR with Developmental Picks

Team A got:

Trent Richardson

Leonard Hankerson

Team B got JOBBED:

Jonathan Stewart

Marques Colston

Michael Crabtree

2013 1st (late)

2013 Devy pick (late)

FYP. Some might sugges that Crabtree helps even the deal because it's PPR - but Richardson is going to be a 3 down back who will also catch a ton of passes (he is already tied for 3rd amoung RBs in targets - and his coaching staff is trying to get him more involved in the passing game). Team A got a stud - Team B got a bunch of decent (but less talented) players. In dynasty, I usually like to see who got the best player. Richardson is better than all the others - and it's not really that close. If all the players in this deal live up to their potential, Team A destroyed this deal.

Agree that A got a great deal, but strongly disagree with your last sentence. If all the players in this deal live up to their potential, then Stewart will be every bit as productive as Richardson, and Team B will wind up with a Colston/Crabtree/2 pick kicker. Team A's guys are more likely to hit their upside, but if we're talking about pure, unadulterated upside/potential, team B's package is huge.

Fair enough - I see your point in regards to Stewart. The only thing with Stewart though is situation. He is already 5 years in the league and still has not taken the starters job. Richardson is already a starter and is 4 year younger. As such, even if Stewart "lives up to his potential" - the number of years remaining to cash in on his production will likely be lower than Richardson's - possibly by a significant margin if the waters of RB playing time continues as muddy as it has been into 2013. Obviously we have no clue what the two picks will yield, but if they are late, odds are, not much. Sure, they could land a Denarious Moore type pick...or a James Hardy, Knowshon Moreno pick. When I was talking about potential, I was mainly talking about the players.

But a good point on Stewart and Crabtree.

 

[jwb]

12 team PPR. Start 1/2/3/1 plus rb/wr/te flex.

Give: Ridley/Vereen/Meachum

Got: Bowe/Damaris Johnson/N Toon

 

[Concept Coop]

MOX: 14 Team, Non PPR, QRRWWFF TE=WR

Gave:

Dwayne Bowe

2013 1st (mid-late)

Got: C.J. Spiller

Gave:

Matt Schaub

Got:

Peyton Manning

 

[Concept Coop]

MOX: 14 Team, Non PPR, QRRWWFF TE=WR

JUST pulled trigger on the following:

Gave:

Cruz

Mendenhall

Hernandez

Filler(L. Ball)

Got:

Nicks

Wallace

S.Jackson

I.Pead

Thoughts: I consider this my "main league" and HATE giving Cruz. Sick to my stomach, hate it. That said, I think the upgrade from Hernandez to Wallace was worth it. On top of that, in this RB heavey league, I still like Pead.

 

[Lott's Fingertip]

Last week:

12 team PPR

gave Spiller, LeShoure, Cassel

received Ray Rice, A.Dalton, M.Goodson

Rice owner took over abandoned team and is rebuiding it.

 

[Todem]

I traded Willis McGahee straight up for Demarius Thomas last week.

I have sick RB depth and this guy had sick WR depth. He needed a RB bad...I wanted to get younger at WR.

Heck of trade for me I think in the long term. And I am a first place team...so feel good about this one.

10 team PPR (1 pt per) league 6 pt td's rushing/rec 4 point for passing

 

[Concept Coop]

I traded Willis McGahee straight up for Demarius Thomas last week.I have sick RB depth and this guy had sick WR depth. He needed a RB bad...I wanted to get younger at WR.Heck of trade for me I think in the long term. And I am a first place team...so feel good about this one.10 team PPR (1 pt per) league 6 pt td's rushing/rec 4 point for passing

Well done.

 

[Eminence]

Dez Bryant

Matt Stafford

for

Peyton Manning

Chris Johnson

2013 First Rounder (Team Record: 1 -4)

Stafford has flopped and Peyton can win me a championship this year. Didn't need Bryant, Wayne and Demaryius Thomas can win it for me this year.

Johnson can put up numbers, Texans game is an example of that.

The pick I traded for will likely be Top 5. So if that can turn into a future stud RB/WR this could be a huge win for me.

 

[ConnSKINS26]

Ouch.

 

[Concept Coop]

Dez BryantMatt StaffordforPeyton ManningChris Johnson2013 First Rounder (Team Record: 1 -4)Stafford has flopped and Peyton can win me a championship this year. Didn't need Bryant, Wayne and Demaryius Thomas can win it for me this year.Johnson can put up numbers, Texans game is an example of that.The pick I traded for will likely be Top 5. So if that can turn into a future stud RB/WR this could be a huge win for me.

If the pick nets you Lattimore or Geno - not bad.Otherwise, I like the other side by a good margin. If you win it all due to this trade, of course, who can blame you for giving up some value?

 

[jdoggydogg]

Not asking or advice on these two trade offers I received this week. Just pasting them as a barometer for perceived trade value:

TRADE #1:

Brady, Tom NEP QB

Decker, Eric DEN WR

for:

Freeman, Josh TBB

QB Marshall, Brandon CHI WR

(Brady owner also owns Andrew Luck, Brady's salary is very high)

TRADE #2:

Nelson, Jordy GBP WR

Witten, Jason DAL TE

for:

Johnson, Andre HOU

WR Hernandez, Aaron NEP TE

---------------

(Salary cap dynasty league, so remember that losing very high priced players for a younger, cheaper player is sometimes advisable)

 

[thriftyrocker]

10 team non-PPR - 1/2/3/1/1/1 + 1 RB/WR

Witten

Forte

for

Graham

2013 2nd (worst team's got through trade)

 

[Tau837]

MOX: 14 Team, Non PPR, QRRWWFF TE=WR

JUST pulled trigger on the following:

Gave:

Cruz

Mendenhall

Hernandez

Filler(L. Ball)

Got:

Nicks

Wallace

S.Jackson

I.Pead

Thoughts: I consider this my "main league" and HATE giving Cruz. Sick to my stomach, hate it. That said, I think the upgrade from Hernandez to Wallace was worth it. On top of that, in this RB heavey league, I still like Pead.

Interesting bolded comment. Last season, Wallace outscored Hernandez by ~1 ppg. I know how high you are on Cruz, so I assume you expect it to be a wider gap over the next several years. I play with Couch Potato in MOX VI, and we own Hernandez. I think TEs tend to be a bit underrated in the MOX format.All that said, I'm not as high on Cruz as you are, and I prefer what you got by a decent margin over what you gave.

 

[Tau837]

Dez BryantMatt StaffordforPeyton ManningChris Johnson2013 First Rounder (Team Record: 1 -4)Stafford has flopped and Peyton can win me a championship this year. Didn't need Bryant, Wayne and Demaryius Thomas can win it for me this year.Johnson can put up numbers, Texans game is an example of that.The pick I traded for will likely be Top 5. So if that can turn into a future stud RB/WR this could be a huge win for me.

That is quite a gamble. I would never have made that trade.

 

[SSOG]

Last week:12 team PPRgave Spiller, LeShoure, Casselreceived Ray Rice, A.Dalton, M.GoodsonRice owner took over abandoned team and is rebuiding it.

Not very well. Spiller is the same age as Rice, Cassel is older, less talented, and less productive than Dalton, and LeShoure is a throw-in. So he managed to simultaneously make his team both older and less productive in one fell swoop.

 

[bengalbuck]

Saw an interesting trade today in a 12 team PPR:

Jimmy Graham straight up for Stevan Ridley.

Graham hasn't looked great the past couple weeks and Ridley has put up nice numbers, but I'd still prefer Graham by quite a bit.

 

[ConnSKINS26]

Just offered Calvin straight up basically for McCoy. Feeling crazy tonight I guess.

 

[Lott's Fingertip]

Last week:12 team PPRgave Spiller, LeShoure, Casselreceived Ray Rice, A.Dalton, M.GoodsonRice owner took over abandoned team and is rebuiding it.

Not very well. Spiller is the same age as Rice, Cassel is older, less talented, and less productive than Dalton, and LeShoure is a throw-in. So he managed to simultaneously make his team both older and less productive in one fell swoop.

I presume the thought process for him would be that Spiller = Rice next year, so getting LeShoure is a bonus. It depends on how one rates LeShoure. The QBs are backups, not big pieces.Getting Rice, I agree with your view. If Spiller is the lead dog next year, I might slightly prefer him over Rice beginning then. Rice is obviously the safer play and has proven production on his side.

 

[Donsmith753]

16 team .5 PPR can start 4 WR

Not me involved but

Lynch

Jeffrey

For

White

13 3rd

 

[Concept Coop]

Interesting bolded comment. Last season, Wallace outscored Hernandez by ~1 ppg. I know how high you are on Cruz, so I assume you expect it to be a wider gap over the next several years. I play with Couch Potato in MOX VI, and we own Hernandez. I think TEs tend to be a bit underrated in the MOX format.All that said, I'm not as high on Cruz as you are, and I prefer what you got by a decent margin over what you gave.

Thanks for your thoughts.To be honest: I wasn't aware that Hernandez was that close to Wallace in terms of PPG. I wouldn't say that I expect the gap to grow, but I do think Wallace is safer. He is less reliant on his offense/QB, and has fewer target threats on his team. Also, as you know, the difference bewteen a WR/TE scoring 9.5PPG, and 11.5PPG is huge in MOX's format. I think has a better chance to have 11.5PPG seasons than Hernandez.

 

[Dr. Octopus]

Last week:

12 team PPR

gave Spiller, LeShoure, Cassel

received Ray Rice, A.Dalton, M.Goodson

Rice owner took over abandoned team and is rebuiding it.

Rebuilding =/ making moves. Rice and Dalton are aguably the two best dynasty assets in that trade. Ok, Spiller is likely the second best asset, but he's a significant drop down from Rice and the same age.

 

[Dr. Octopus]

Last week:12 team PPRgave Spiller, LeShoure, Casselreceived Ray Rice, A.Dalton, M.GoodsonRice owner took over abandoned team and is rebuiding it.

Not very well. Spiller is the same age as Rice, Cassel is older, less talented, and less productive than Dalton, and LeShoure is a throw-in. So he managed to simultaneously make his team both older and less productive in one fell swoop.

Basically the point I was trying to make.

 

[Buck Stop]

Just made the following in a PPR dynasty

Gave: Stokely, Mike Nugent, 2 1st rounders

Got: Wright, Zuerlein

I feel like both 1sts won't be in the top 5 so hopefully no regrets come next draft.

Starting to like my chances this year, but ESPECIALLY next year

Manning, Vick, Tannehill

Richardson, Morris, Wilson, Miller, Hillis, Ballard, Royster

Calvin, Fitz, Wright, Cobb, James Jones, Hawkins, Sanu, Royal

Hernandez, Gates

 

[Concept Coop]

MOX: 14 Team, Non PPR, QRRWWFF TE=WR 4pt passing.

Gave:

Peyton Manning

Steven Jackson

2014 1st (Mid-Late)

Got:

Marshawn Lynch

 

[Concept Coop]

Just made the following in a PPR dynastyGave: Stokely, Mike Nugent, 2 1st rounders Got: Wright, Zuerlein I feel like both 1sts won't be in the top 5 so hopefully no regrets come next draft.Starting to like my chances this year, but ESPECIALLY next yearManning, Vick, TannehillRichardson, Morris, Wilson, Miller, Hillis, Ballard, RoysterCalvin, Fitz, Wright, Cobb, James Jones, Hawkins, Sanu, RoyalHernandez, Gates

I think 2 firsts for Wright is a bit much. Those would both have to be late for you to have much of a shot at winning the deal. Wright is a good player, but there are plenty of good WRs in this class. You could have just traded 2 for 1, and Wright is not going to help you much this year.

 

[Buck Stop]

Just made the following in a PPR dynastyGave: Stokely, Mike Nugent, 2 1st rounders Got: Wright, Zuerlein I feel like both 1sts won't be in the top 5 so hopefully no regrets come next draft.Starting to like my chances this year, but ESPECIALLY next yearManning, Vick, TannehillRichardson, Morris, Wilson, Miller, Hillis, Ballard, RoysterCalvin, Fitz, Wright, Cobb, James Jones, Hawkins, Sanu, RoyalHernandez, Gates

I think 2 firsts for Wright is a bit much. Those would both have to be late for you to have much of a shot at winning the deal. Wright is a good player, but there are plenty of good WRs in this class. You could have just traded 2 for 1, and Wright is not going to help you much this year.

Well one of the 1sts is a team with the 3rd highest VPs. I think his will be late. And I think if Hernandez comes back healthy my team is capable of making a run too. And I am very high on Wright, in a class where most rookie WRs are struggling, he's consistently done well each week despite mediocre QB play at times.

 

[Dr. Octopus]

12 team, ppr

Team F traded Schilens, Chaz WR NYJ and Romo, Tony QB DAL to Team Nfor Palmer, Carson QB OAK and Bolden, Brandon RB NE

 

[Drinkin Buddy]

Dynasty PPR

Mcgahee

Little

Battle (Matthews owner)

Fasano

for

Freeman

Golden Tate

Ogletree

Antonio Gates

 

[cstu]

MOX: 14 Team, Non PPR, QRRWWFF TE=WR 4pt passing. Gave: Peyton ManningSteven Jackson2014 1st (Mid-Late)Got:Marshawn Lynch

I've been saying to trade Lynch since his schedule is about to become very difficult - I believe he has six top 10 run defenses coming up.

 

[ExaltedOne]

12 team ppr

Team A (2-3) got

Jeremy Maclin

2013 4th round pick (from 1-4 team)

Team B (5-0) got

Vincent Jackson

2013 2nd round pick (from 2-3 team)

 

[Concept Coop]

MOX: 14 Team, Non PPR, QRRWWFF TE=WR 4pt passing. Gave: Peyton ManningSteven Jackson2014 1st (Mid-Late)Got:Marshawn Lynch

I've been saying to trade Lynch since his schedule is about to become very difficult - I believe he has six top 10 run defenses coming up.

I actually think he is a good sell high, for that reason. But, in dynasty leagues, I won't value him much less because of schedule. Jackson is declining, not getting TDs, and no longer has a clear replacement, in my mind. Lynch is a lock for a 20 touch/game average, and has a clear, young handcuff. Potentially, I could have the Seattle backfield locked up for 5 years. Assuming Carrol stays, that is gold in a standard, RB heavy format. Also, I own Newton in this 4 pt passing TD league, so while Peyton has value, I am comfortable starting Cam week in, week out.

 

[GoodLloydHaveMercy]

Just made this trade in Non-PPR Dynasty with 12 tms & 26 roster spots... 6 pts for all TDs... 25yds/pt passing, 10yds/pt rushing/receiving, 30yds/pt return yds, Starts QB,RB,RB,WR,WR,WR,TE,K,DEF

I gave...

Chris Johnson

Emmanuel Sanders

I got back...

Mike Vick

Alex Green

Im clearly in the "I think CJ is done" camp as long as he doesnt get a full back and the team remains committed to spreading out teams & using draws & delays all the dang day. Even WITH a FB he isnt the same as he was before... doesnt run hard!!

Im not 1 to think that Vick is tremendous anymore but I still dont buy them making a switch this yr

FOR THOSE OF YOU THAT DONT CARE ABT WHAT I HAVE ON MY TEAM AS A REFERENCE TO WHETHER I GOT GOOD VALUE YOU CAN STOP READING NOW!!

After trade...

Vick, Cam, Locker

DMac, D Martin, Blount, Powell, Starks, Alex Green, Ivory, Redman, Dwyer

D Thomas, Nicks, Cobb, D Moore, A Hawkins, Greg Little, Josh Gordon, Jean, Binns, Benn

Hernandez, Celek

Greg the Leg

Dallas

 

[Andrew74]

12 team .5 PPR

Team A gave: Roddy White

Team B gave: Spiller

 

[Concept Coop]

12 team .5 PPRTeam A gave: Roddy WhiteTeam B gave: Spiller

A lot would depend on team needs, as it is not a bad trade. But, value only, in a vacuum - give me Spiller.

 

[Eminence]

Dez BryantMatt StaffordforPeyton ManningChris Johnson2013 First Rounder (Team Record: 1 -4)Stafford has flopped and Peyton can win me a championship this year. Didn't need Bryant, Wayne and Demaryius Thomas can win it for me this year.Johnson can put up numbers, Texans game is an example of that.The pick I traded for will likely be Top 5. So if that can turn into a future stud RB/WR this could be a huge win for me.

That is quite a gamble. I would never have made that trade.

I have a team in contention and Dez / Stafford weren't the players putting up points. Bryant I no longer want longterm and giving up Stafford will be well worth that pick if it turns out Top-3.Til' then, it's time to ride Manning.(We are only required to start 1WR. I start two: Reggie Wayne + Demaryius Thomas.)Chris Johnson becomes my injury filler behind McGahee, Leshoure, and McFadden. Big upside at my RB4.

 

[Buck Stop]

12 team .5 PPRTeam A gave: Roddy WhiteTeam B gave: Spiller

A lot would depend on team needs, as it is not a bad trade. But, value only, in a vacuum - give me Spiller.

looks like a redraft trade, not a dynasty, just my opinion....

 

[Andrew74]

12 team .5 PPRTeam A gave: Roddy WhiteTeam B gave: Spiller

A lot would depend on team needs, as it is not a bad trade. But, value only, in a vacuum - give me Spiller.

looks like a redraft trade, not a dynasty, just my opinion....

Quite literally team A has Mathews and Draughn and a bunch of injured back ups. He still has Wallace, Wayne and Garçon. Team B has AJ and Hawkins as his next best WR. He has McFadden and Mendenhall at RB.

 

[lsutigers]

Team A - Flacco, Antonio Brown

Team B - Josh Freeman, Larry Fitzgerald

 

[Eminence]

Fox Scream gave up:

McGahee, Willis DEN RB (1 Year Contract)

Pitta, Dennis BAL TE (1 Year Contract)

Malvern Monsters gave up:

Crabtree, Michael SFO WR (2 Year Contract)

Pettigrew, Brandon DET TE (2 Year Contract)

2014 Round 2 Draft Pick from Malvern Monsters

Who wins?

 

[jdoggydogg]

Just sent out this offer:

I offered

Bush, Reggie MIA RB

Johnson, Andre HOU WR

for

Richardson, Trent CLE RB

I think he'll reject it, but this guy is always excited to trade. So at least it'll get the conversation going...

 

[runner06]

Just sent out this offer:

I offered

Bush, Reggie MIA RB

Johnson, Andre HOU WR

for

Richardson, Trent CLE RB

I think he'll reject it, but this guy is always excited to trade. So at least it'll get the conversation going...

Wrong thread. This is for accepted trades only.

 

[jdoggydogg]

Just sent out this offer:

I offered

Bush, Reggie MIA RB

Johnson, Andre HOU WR

for

Richardson, Trent CLE RB

I think he'll reject it, but this guy is always excited to trade. So at least it'll get the conversation going...

Wrong thread. This is for accepted trades only.

No problem. I'm not looking for advice. I'll post if it's accepted.

 

[Short Corner]

Just sent out this offer:

I offered

Bush, Reggie MIA RB

Johnson, Andre HOU WR

for

Richardson, Trent CLE RB

I think he'll reject it, but this guy is always excited to trade. So at least it'll get the conversation going...

Wrong thread. This is for accepted trades only.

Rejected trades are useful as well.

 

[forbidden doughnut]

Trying to decide whether or not I did the right thing in my PPR dynasty:

I got MJD and Greg Jennings

I gave Sproles and Maclin

I've got James Jones, so the fact that Jennings is hurt at the moment doesn't really hurt me as bad as it might others.

Thoughts?

 

[cstu]

Fox Scream gave up:McGahee, Willis DEN RB (1 Year Contract)Pitta, Dennis BAL TE (1 Year Contract)Malvern Monsters gave up:Crabtree, Michael SFO WR (2 Year Contract)Pettigrew, Brandon DET TE (2 Year Contract)2014 Round 2 Draft Pick from Malvern MonstersWho wins?

Fox got the better players with longer contracts and a 2nd as a bonus. Was the trade with Dennis Pitta's brother?

 

[doowain]

12 Team PPR

Team A got:

Bryce Brown

Damaris Johnson

Jeremy Maclin

Jermaine Gresham

Team B got:

Frank Gore

Kendall Hunter

LaMichael James

Vernon Davis

 

[Redmen62]

My team got old and I'm starting a rebuild. Before this past weekend's games I traded:

Drew Brees

Reggie Wayne

Antonio Gates

Michael Bush

Brandon Bolden

and recieved:

Cam Newton

David Wilson

Jermaine Gresham

League = .5 PPR, all TDs are 6pts, 2RB/3WR and a WR/RB/TE flex

 

[jdoggydogg]

Just completed this trade:

Bush, Reggie MIA RB

Bryant, Dez DAL WR

Johnson, Andre HOU WR

for:

Richardson, Trent CLE RB

Nelson, Jordy GBP WR

 

[Buck Stop]

Ppr dynasty

Gave:

Peyton

Cobb

Wilson

Ballard

Got;

Rg3

Garçon

 

[Donsmith753]

16 team .5 PPR

13 1st from a top team

For

13 3rd from a 1-4 team

14 1st from an 0-5 team