bolded all in one thread....impressive but accurate...more bourbon!To better explain, running these leagues is mentally draining (in addition to taking up a lot of time). Ask bueno how it is to keep No Mercy afloat. It can take me 5 or 6 tries to get folks out of hibernation just to check in and commit to a league. Of course, if I replace someone and start a draft, then the original team owner has a conniption and wants me to give the new team the old heave-ho.
Or I can set a league up and turn on the draft and people go AWOL to start the draft and the other owners want to decapitate them and have them replaced. The next issue has always been what happens when someone disappears. A few times I have started drafts and had to replace 4 owners while everyone else sat around (but it took a while to figure that I needed to replace 4 teams).
If I turn the timer on, each round people will miss picks and we've tried having the MFL system award a player (which usually will be a guy already on IR). Given that is forcing a 0 on a roster spot in a total points league, that is a death knell.
If I pick a player for that team, half the time the owner has an aneurysm that I picked the wrong player and then drops out mid draft. Or other owners will send me fan mail saying how dare I give TEAM X that player, that's who they were going to pick next!
When I've tried letting owners make a replacement pick for a computer generated pick, I have had people that may have already drafted their pick after that spot say they would rather have had the player thrown back into the free agent pool to be picked from.
I will probably still figure a way to do these again, but it's going to take some Xanax and bourbon to make it through.
But whichever team this happens to is essentially out of the running before the season even starts (if it's a league with half competent owners). That's been part of the issue for years. So the goal should be more focused on getting people committed to making timely picks . . . not punishing people for being out on drunken benders with call girls and platinum Amex cards.if you don't require signing up for the test alert...and you have missed picks you could do this
1st missed pick....replaced with a PK (if possible due to lineup restrictions)
2nd missed pick ....replaced with a PK (if possible due to lineup restrictions)
3rd missed pick....replaced by DST(if possible due to lineup restrictions)
4th missed pick....replaced by DST (if possible due to lineup restrictions)
5th missed pick....no replacement pick...SOL
so even if it's third round and they miss a pick...they get a PK in the third...no crying....at least they got something....
requiring text message alert eliminates 98% of this....and there are no excuses....if you don't want to sign up for the alert, then you don't participate...But whichever team this happens to is essentially out of the running before the season even starts (if it's a league with half competent owners). That's been part of the issue for years. So the goal should be more focused on getting people committed to making timely picks . . . not punishing people for being out on drunken benders with call girls and platinum Amex cards.
Firing squad had come to mind in the past.requiring text message alert eliminates 98% of this....and there are no excuses....if you don't want to sign up for the alert, then you don't participate...
how you chose to deal with the 2% that still miss a pick is up to you....lots of options
LOLOLOLOLbolded all in one thread....impressive but accurate...more bourbon!
At some point, you have to cut your losses. It’s a free league, and I would say you’re seriously inflating people’s expectations by your high standards. I would explain the rules upfront (set your own pre-rankings, auto draft if you miss your pick), and ignore the complainers. I get this will result in a few bad picks. So be it. In a league of 16 teams a few bad picks may mean 13 teams are in it - which is plenty enough competition. More likely, given injuries and weird things happening, it’s not even going to be that much of a handicap.But whichever team this happens to is essentially out of the running before the season even starts (if it's a league with half competent owners). That's been part of the issue for years. So the goal should be more focused on getting people committed to making timely picks . . . not punishing people for being out on drunken benders with call girls and platinum Amex cards.
Why not simply configure MFL to only be able to autodraft a valid roster? Am I mistaken in thinking that option exists (by enforcing roster starting requirements)? The challenge with allowing FAs after the draft is that it could turn into an advantage, as more info becomes available (e.g. kicker getting released or injuries / suspensions happening).What say the masses on the following idea: owners that miss a pick will get an auto pick from MFL. If that results in an illegal roster or if they want to replace that pick, they can only do so from the remaining free agents AFTER the draft has been completed. That way if a team gets stuck with someone on IR, they can at least swap out for someone else but after the cupboards are pretty bare.
Agree with Nittany Lion here, but would also be fine with the replace undesired pick after draft, with the caveat that it is immediately after the draft.Yuds, isn't there an option where if someone misses their pick, the Draft just continues to move right along, and they can just make their skipped pick whenever the next time they log in? Keep things simple, is my opinion: miss your pick, pay a price. Draft moves on, Owner makes pick from what's available when he gets back in the Draft Room.
The issue in the past has been when someone misses a pick, emails me a replacement pick, I don’t get to my email right away, and the player gets picked by someone else. Now what? Make the owner that picked that player re-pick?Yuds, isn't there an option where if someone misses their pick, the Draft just continues to move right along, and they can just make their skipped pick whenever the next time they log in? Keep things simple, is my opinion: miss your pick, pay a price. Draft moves on, Owner makes pick from what's available when he gets back in the Draft Room.
I don't think that can reasonably fix illegal rosters. Let's say someone goes all-QB strategy and they take two QBs in the first two rounds, then miss their third round pick, and MFL assigns them a QB. (Or a fourth TE, or a sixth RB, etc.) They can swap it out, but then a potentially valuable player is not available to anyone else in the league.What say the masses on the following idea: owners that miss a pick will get an auto pick from MFL. If that results in an illegal roster or if they want to replace that pick, they can only do so from the remaining free agents AFTER the draft has been completed. That way if a team gets stuck with someone on IR, they can at least swap out for someone else but after the cupboards are pretty bare.
I have found the MFL system to be fairly unintelligent. For situations where the player selected automatically creates an illegal roster, I could manually insert a place filler until after the draft. Like inserting Barry Sanders for example. That way the player selected would go back into the player pool.I don't think that can reasonably fix illegal rosters. Let's say someone goes all-QB strategy and they take two QBs in the first two rounds, then miss their third round pick, and MFL assigns them a QB. (Or a fourth TE, or a sixth RB, etc.) They can swap it out, but then a potentially valuable player is not available to anyone else in the league.
I think it could work for "oh but I didn't want that guy" situations, with the answer being "too bad."
I'm sorry if I wasn't clear.The issue in the past has been when someone misses a pick, emails me a replacement pick, I don’t get to my email right away, and the player gets picked by someone else. Now what? Make the owner that picked that player re-pick?
The short answer is no. The longer answer is, a team can only pick if the system has a team listed as the team on the clock. So the only way for a missed or skipped pick to be made up is for the commission to either manually make the change or manually make that team that missed the pick go back on the clock to pick. An owner cannot log in and make a make up pick on his own.I'm sorry if I wasn't clear.
What I mean is, isnt there a way that an Owner can time out, the Draft move along, and they make their pick themselves from what's available when they show back up?
For example, I have the 1.02, and I don't show during my window...the draft moves along, 1.03 and 1.04 make.their picks. I log onto the site, and I make my missed pick, filling my 1.02 slot, hoping all the time that I don't get pushed back further by an eager, ambitious or just plain responsible 1.06, 1.07, etc. while going through the process.
That doesn't involve you, doesn't involve e-mails, doesn't slow down, stall or stop the draft. Can't I just make my own skipped pick whenever I show up? Like in a live draft: if I have to go to the can and wind up talking up some hottie and my league mates decide to proceed without me, I come back in and backfill my empty space from what's left when I show up...doesn't mfl offer that option?
There is but it is giving up control of the draft as everyone can sigh in as commish. Or maybe assign a few people who can change a missed pick.The short answer is no. The longer answer is, a team can only pick if the system has a team listed as the team on the clock. So the only way for a missed or skipped pick to be made up is for the commission to either manually make the change or manually make that team that missed the pick go back on the clock to pick. An owner cannot log in and make a make up pick on his own.
Technically we would both be right, as only someone logged in as commissioner could make the change.There is but it is giving up control of the draft as everyone can sigh in as commish. Or maybe assign a few people who can change a missed pick.
the Survivor leagues basically do this.
So, if you had help, they could commish a league by them selves?Technically we would both be right, as only someone logged in as commissioner could make the change.
Thank you for doing these all these years. These truly were some of the leagues I enjoyed the most from a draft and forget perspective. Unfortunately, real life between new job, family and possibly building a house is taking way to much of my time to give these drafts the dedication they need. If more owners were as honest with themselves you wouldn't have the headaches that you have. Good luck to all of the teams this year and maybe next year will be a different story for me.Snellman - OUT
This struck me as a Trump Tweet. And yes, we all stand for the anthem.15 out of 16 returnees for League 2...THAT is what defines a LEAGUE OF CHAMPIONS!!!