haven't watched a ton of Celtics basketball.. does Tatum know he has teammates? he plays like this is a 1v1 game. no passing. no movement. when the ball touches his hands, it's done moving. he's shooting.
he's a black hole.
Cons - Poor court vision which bleeds into everything. Horrible shot selection. Doesn't have humility/confidence to accept he has to do other things to help the team when his shot is not falling. Thinks he can shoot his way out of any situation. ( i.e. the Favre mentality where he'd just throw it into triple coverage ) Not confident/hesitates that he can consistently finish around the rim. Just hasn't gotten progressively better with time ( a few things have gotten incrementally better but the bedrock flaw is the poor court vision/bad decision making)
Pros - Solid fundamentals. Still productive despite being shadowed by the opposites team best individual cover man and while being doubled teamed and the focus of the defense. Can consistently create his own shot, even with bracketed, albeit those are generally bad shots. Legitimate tool set to accomplish anything, the limitations are not his athletic floor.
Playing with Kyrie Irving doesn't help anyone's shot selection post Kyrie Irving if that player isn't a high BBIQ player. Irving is excellent at making bad shots. There's no other way to put it. There aren't too many players who can do this. Trae Young is also good at making objectively bad shots. Just sort of rubbed off onto Tatum. Young player who wants to be Kobe 2.0 ( without realizing Kobe was a supercharged compiler who basically got free reign from the refs ) and doesn't understand that Kobe Bryant actually understood the difference between a good shot and a bad shot, but was too much of a toxic narcissistic sociopath to care.
You know everything you needed to know about Kobe as a chucking shotjacker when he was in a police interrogation room in Colorado and start ratting out his team mates. "If I can't win, everyone else has to lose, even my own teammates" Mamba Mentality washed away from the pedantic boot licking sports media narrative is just Snitch Mentality. Snitch Mentality ruins everything (Just look at what the mouthbreathers who hover their fist over the Report Button in these forums have done to the general community. Everyone needs to pay because they want to grab their football and run home to Mommy)
Jaylen Brown has a lower talent ceiling and a lesser tool set but has actually improved every season. To be fair, he was never bracketed by the opposing defenses like Tatum. It's not that Brown and Tatum can't play together, it's that they clearly don't want to play together. Tatum understands if he passes the ball to Brown, he's not getting it back. Brown knows if he passes Tatum the ball, this hero baller will fire up an ugly contested shot with 22 seconds left on the shot clock. It's a pathetic **** measuring contest by two players not elite enough to have a #### measuring contest.
If you build around Tatum, you have to build a team around him to feature all of Tatum's strengths and shade around his weaknesses. Sort of like how OKC built around Westbrook when Durant, Ibaka and Harden were all gone. You won't win a ring but you will be a nice profitable treadmill team. There's nothing wrong with that, but you have to understand what you are getting.
If you want to win a championship, then you trade both Tatum and Brown, no matter how unpopular that seems.
I've seen Wikkid try to rationalize the upside to this team's construction and core without facing any of the hard truth to it. It's like watching a widely and badly reviewed marriage counselor on Yelp be in constant fear of losing the few clients he has left. When Wikkid talks about his beloved Celtics, the twinge of non authentic desperation just comes seeping out. Kind of like Kobe in an interrogation room who has too much ego to actually invoke.
If Tatum wants to keep doing this, he has to be able to take over individual games and sometimes weeks at a time. This is how Westbrook and Carmelo Anthony stayed useful and relevant for a long time. Have your pure overwhelming moments outstrip your shot jacking your way to some losses. The problem is Tatum is just NOT as talented as other Tier 2 elite guys in the past who have gotten away with it.
Tatum is still though a vastly talented player but not an authentic one. Authentic meaning he understands what he does and does not do well and shapes his game to show an acceptance of those realities to win games. Juan Toscano Anderson is not a talented player. He's a 15th man candidate. He's a fringe guy struggling to stay on a roster and fight for scraps of rotation minutes. But he's completely authentic. He has that Courtney Lee mindset where he knows what he can do and where he will never be strong and adapts to a functional role.
Cue up Wikkid to take four gallons of A1 Sauce to drown a hot dog and try to convince everyone this current Celtics roster is actually a steak.