What's new
Fantasy Football - Footballguys Forums

This is a sample guest message. Register a free account today to become a member! Once signed in, you'll be able to participate on this site by adding your own topics and posts, as well as connect with other members through your own private inbox!

Bush, ADP, or 2008 #1 pick (most likely McFadden) in PPR (1 Viewer)

Bush or 2008 #1 pick (most likely McFadden) in PPR

  • Reggie Bush - 2nd yr, 22 yrs old

    Votes: 0 0.0%
  • 2008 #1 pick (most likely McFadden)

    Votes: 0 0.0%

  • Total voters
    0

KellysHeroes

Footballguy
Thought this poll would be interesting.... which would you rather have in PPR Dynasty... the 1st rookie pick in 2006 (Reggie Bush), the 1st Rookie Pick in 2007 (Adrian Peterson), or the 1st Rookie Pick in 2008 (Most likely McFadden)

 
Ok, so the Patriots have the #1 pick from the 49ers? McFadden could be a good fit for them, with the way that Maroney gets dinged up. If he goes to the Patriots, is ADP still the higher pick than him?

 
McFadden is going to the Jets... TJ isn't working out... I'm calling here

*I'm a JETS fan since I started watching Football

Edit............................

I'm a little surprised by this one

Reggie Bush - 2nd yr, 22 yrs old [ 23 ] [82.14%]

2008 #1 pick (most likely McFadden) [ 5 ] [17.86%]

I thought it would be even

 
Last edited by a moderator:
McFadden is going to the Jets... TJ isn't working out... I'm calling here*I'm a JETS fan since I started watching FootballEdit............................I'm a little surprised by this oneReggie Bush - 2nd yr, 22 yrs old [ 23 ] [82.14%] 2008 #1 pick (most likely McFadden) [ 5 ] [17.86%] I thought it would be even
its not TJ's fault, not even close. RB is the least of their problems.Not to hijack, but it takes a very special RB to run well behind 2 second year guys, 2 lousy guards and a lousy RT, especially when your QB has a noodle arm and your defense cant stop anyone.
 
McFadden is going to the Jets... TJ isn't working out... I'm calling here*I'm a JETS fan since I started watching FootballEdit............................I'm a little surprised by this oneReggie Bush - 2nd yr, 22 yrs old [ 23 ] [82.14%] 2008 #1 pick (most likely McFadden) [ 5 ] [17.86%] I thought it would be even
its not TJ's fault, not even close. RB is the least of their problems.Not to hijack, but it takes a very special RB to run well behind 2 second year guys, 2 lousy guards and a lousy RT, especially when your QB has a noodle arm and your defense cant stop anyone.
True... the entire team is playing every bad.. the TJ move seemed to be a win now move and it didn't work out; the Team stinks.. TJ will be 30 yrs old next season and is only getting paid $900,000... it would make sense to pair him up with a great young talent like McFadden...
 
Last edited by a moderator:
What happened to all the talk about Dallas getting McFadden with the Cleveland pick???
Slim chance they can move into the top 5 with the way Cleveland's been playing. Packaging both picks would just get them into the top 10...Using the pick value chart (approx)Browns - 20th overall - 850 pointsCowboys - 30th overall - 620 pointsThat would move them to around 8th overall ... it could happen, but seems very unlikely.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Bush in all formats, he has shown he can be a viable starting player in a PPR league. Peterson 2nd as he has shown some skill but is also made of glass. Draft picks can turn out to be zeros.

 
Bush in all formats, he has shown he can be a viable starting player in a PPR league. Peterson 2nd as he has shown some skill but is also made of glass. Draft picks can turn out to be zeros.
He misses one game, maybe two and now he's made of glass?
Peterson has missed significant playing time the last three years. Two of which were shorter college seasons.

I have serious doubts that he can stand up to the punishment of the NFL. Bush is the most proven commodity, Peterson second and a rook who hasnt played third.

 
Last edited by a moderator:
Bush in all formats, he has shown he can be a viable starting player in a PPR league. Peterson 2nd as he has shown some skill but is also made of glass. Draft picks can turn out to be zeros.
He misses one game, maybe two and now he's made of glass?
Peterson has missed significant playing time the last three years. Two of which were shorter college seasons.

I have serious doubts that he can stand up to the punishment of the NFL. Bush is the most proven commodity, Peterson second and a rook who hasnt played third.
I have to agree with u sharks... Peterson's injury history was the reason that some drafters didn't want him (I 've even seen people trade out of the spot to avoid him). I don't re-call Reggie ever getting hurt in college (I sure if he was; it would of been brought up by now)... now thats it been over a season and a half (plus 2 play-off games) and he's finally QST for the 1st time, people are jumpin on it and quotin thats he can't hang... drives me nutz. A problem that Bush is having is that NO isn't a very good run blocking system; their all about pass blocking.. I assure you, If Bush had the left-side of Minny's O-Line... Reggie would have a 5 YPC avg and close too 1000 ru yards too.

 
Bush in all formats, he has shown he can be a viable starting player in a PPR league. Peterson 2nd as he has shown some skill but is also made of glass. Draft picks can turn out to be zeros.
That's my thought as well. Draft pick would be the wrong move in any matchup.So, it's 1/2 year wonder, who's had injury concerns or Bush who is descent or better in PPR. I'll take the much higher floor of Bush over the higher ceiling of AP.
 
I assure you, If Bush had the left-side of Minny's O-Line... Reggie would have a 5 YPC avg and close too 1000 ru yards too.
:moneybag:
That Line was brought in for one purpose.... to Run the Rock... a lot of people do not take into account that ADP is behind the BEST Run Blockers in the league. And yes... you give Reggie Bush these types of guys up front... Reggie would be pushing #1 RB in any Format.

LT: Bryant McKinnie: Drafted at #7 in 2002

College Information

Consensus All-America and Outland Trophy winner as a senior for the 2001 National Champs...Played two seasons at Miami after transferring from Lackawanna Junior College...Named National Player of the Year by CNN/Sports Illustrated as a senior...Finished 8th in 2001Heisman voting, receiving 26 1st-place votes...In 2000, earned All-America honors by The Sports Xchange and Football News...Unanimous All-Big East selection...Redshirted at Miami in 1999 after transferring from Lackawanna Junior College in Scranton, PA...Did not allow a sack during his high school or college career.

Steve Hutchison... Noted as the Best LG in the league

Professional Biography

One of the most decorated offensive linemen in the NFL since he came into the League in 2001, earning 3 straight trips to the Pro Bowl from 2003-05 and has been a 3-time All-Pro honoree by Associated Press, a 1st-Team selection in 2003 and 2005 and claimed 2nd-Team notice in 2004...Has been part of a winning tradition at Seattle, going 32-16 from 2003-05, the best record in the NFC over that span...The Seattle offense has excelled in recent years, ranking #2 in 2005, #8 in 2004 and #6 in 2003 in the NFL...Helped Seahawks RB Shaun Alexander earn League MVP honors, set an NFL record with 28 TDs (27 rushing) and run for 1,880 yards in 2005...Helped Alexander run for 31 career 100-yard games, including playoffs...Started in Super Bowl XL in Detroit, just minutes from his collegiate home in Ann Arbor, MI...Joins LT linemate Walter Jones as the only Seattle linemen ever selected to the Pro Bowl in franchise history...Acquired by Vikings on 3/31/06 after Seattle declined to match an offer sheet extended to him as a transition-tag player...Only season he did not earn post-season honors was in 2002 when his season was cut short after a broken leg in the 4th game of the season vs. Minnesota...Member of the same draft class as Vikings Pro Bowl KR/WR Koren Robinson in 2001 with Seattle, Robinson selected #9 and Hutchinson #17...Teammates in Seattle with former Vikings great DT John Randle and remains close friends.

C: Matt Birk: 5th Pro-Bowl selection last yr

FB: Tony Richardson: If you don't know who this is then you shouldn't be playing with the Big Boys...

Professional Biography

Earned Pro Bowl honors following the 2003 and 2004 seasons...Tabbed as a 2nd-team All-Pro choice by Associated Press in 2004...Named All-Pro by Sports Illustrated in 1999 and 2000...Selected to USA Today’s All-Joe team in 2000 and 2001, recognizing the overlooked and under-appreciated in the NFL...Has paved the way in recent years for one of the best rushing attacks in the NFL...Since 2000, the Chiefs offense has not ranked lower than 8th in the NFL and claimed #1 honors in 2004 and 2005...Cleared a path for Pro Bowl rushers Larry Johnson (2005) and Priest Holmes (2001, ‘02, ‘03)...Blocked for 4 of the top 5 single-season rushing performances in Kansas City history, including Johnson’s team-record 1,750 yards on the ground in 2005...Helped Holmes establish an NFL record with 27 rushing TDs in 2003...Played under head coaches Marty Schottenheimer, Gunther Cunningham and **** Vermeil during his tenure with Kansas City...Won AFC West 3 times and advanced to playoffs 3 times in his 11 seasons with Chiefs- 1995, 1997 and 2003.

 
I assure you, If Bush had the left-side of Minny's O-Line... Reggie would have a 5 YPC avg and close too 1000 ru yards too.
:no:
That Line was brought in for one purpose.... to Run the Rock... a lot of people do not take into account that ADP is behind the BEST Run Blockers in the league. And yes... you give Reggie Bush these types of guys up front... Reggie would be pushing #1 RB in any Format.

LT: Bryant McKinnie: Drafted at #7 in 2002

College Information

Consensus All-America and Outland Trophy winner as a senior for the 2001 National Champs...Played two seasons at Miami after transferring from Lackawanna Junior College...Named National Player of the Year by CNN/Sports Illustrated as a senior...Finished 8th in 2001Heisman voting, receiving 26 1st-place votes...In 2000, earned All-America honors by The Sports Xchange and Football News...Unanimous All-Big East selection...Redshirted at Miami in 1999 after transferring from Lackawanna Junior College in Scranton, PA...Did not allow a sack during his high school or college career.

Steve Hutchison... Noted as the Best LG in the league

Professional Biography

One of the most decorated offensive linemen in the NFL since he came into the League in 2001, earning 3 straight trips to the Pro Bowl from 2003-05 and has been a 3-time All-Pro honoree by Associated Press, a 1st-Team selection in 2003 and 2005 and claimed 2nd-Team notice in 2004...Has been part of a winning tradition at Seattle, going 32-16 from 2003-05, the best record in the NFC over that span...The Seattle offense has excelled in recent years, ranking #2 in 2005, #8 in 2004 and #6 in 2003 in the NFL...Helped Seahawks RB Shaun Alexander earn League MVP honors, set an NFL record with 28 TDs (27 rushing) and run for 1,880 yards in 2005...Helped Alexander run for 31 career 100-yard games, including playoffs...Started in Super Bowl XL in Detroit, just minutes from his collegiate home in Ann Arbor, MI...Joins LT linemate Walter Jones as the only Seattle linemen ever selected to the Pro Bowl in franchise history...Acquired by Vikings on 3/31/06 after Seattle declined to match an offer sheet extended to him as a transition-tag player...Only season he did not earn post-season honors was in 2002 when his season was cut short after a broken leg in the 4th game of the season vs. Minnesota...Member of the same draft class as Vikings Pro Bowl KR/WR Koren Robinson in 2001 with Seattle, Robinson selected #9 and Hutchinson #17...Teammates in Seattle with former Vikings great DT John Randle and remains close friends.

C: Matt Birk: 5th Pro-Bowl selection last yr

FB: Tony Richardson: If you don't know who this is then you shouldn't be playing with the Big Boys...

Professional Biography

Earned Pro Bowl honors following the 2003 and 2004 seasons...Tabbed as a 2nd-team All-Pro choice by Associated Press in 2004...Named All-Pro by Sports Illustrated in 1999 and 2000...Selected to USA Today’s All-Joe team in 2000 and 2001, recognizing the overlooked and under-appreciated in the NFL...Has paved the way in recent years for one of the best rushing attacks in the NFL...Since 2000, the Chiefs offense has not ranked lower than 8th in the NFL and claimed #1 honors in 2004 and 2005...Cleared a path for Pro Bowl rushers Larry Johnson (2005) and Priest Holmes (2001, ‘02, ‘03)...Blocked for 4 of the top 5 single-season rushing performances in Kansas City history, including Johnson’s team-record 1,750 yards on the ground in 2005...Helped Holmes establish an NFL record with 27 rushing TDs in 2003...Played under head coaches Marty Schottenheimer, Gunther Cunningham and **** Vermeil during his tenure with Kansas City...Won AFC West 3 times and advanced to playoffs 3 times in his 11 seasons with Chiefs- 1995, 1997 and 2003.
:lmao:
 
Bush in all formats, he has shown he can be a viable starting player in a PPR league. Peterson 2nd as he has shown some skill but is also made of glass. Draft picks can turn out to be zeros.
That's my thought as well. Draft pick would be the wrong move in any matchup.So, it's 1/2 year wonder, who's had injury concerns or Bush who is descent or better in PPR. I'll take the much higher floor of Bush over the higher ceiling of AP.
I can agree with this, AP may have a higher ceiling but I learned a long time ago that nothing is worse in Dynasty than having a player vanish off your roster due to injury, drugs, valuejet or killing his babymomma. I think at this early stage Peterson is more likely to degrade into obscurity than Bush.
 

Users who are viewing this thread

Back
Top