M
Fan vote = Offensive PlayerUndeserving. Lofa and Merriman much better for there teams this year off top of my head.
I think it clearly shows the involvement of the player in the gameplan, and the corresponding success of that gameplan with him in it.Not much different than Brady's playoff record or Ben R's record being constantly pointed out, IMO.The Bucs go 8-1 when Carnell gets 19 carries.
Shouldn't this read: Carnell gets 19 carries when the Bucs go 8-1? I have no problem with Carnell winning ROY. He's a great young RB. The carries = wins stats have no meaning, imho.
It also could mean that the team was winning so the RB got more carries late to run out the clock and he wasn't really a huge part of the game plan.I think it clearly shows the involvement of the player in the gameplan, and the corresponding success of that gameplan with him in it.Not much different than Brady's playoff record or Ben R's record being constantly pointed out, IMO.The Bucs go 8-1 when Carnell gets 19 carries.
Shouldn't this read: Carnell gets 19 carries when the Bucs go 8-1? I have no problem with Carnell winning ROY. He's a great young RB. The carries = wins stats have no meaning, imho.
It could, but it doesn't in this case. As I described earlier, Carnell had a lot of meaningful carries late in wins.It also could mean that the team was winning so the RB got more carries late to run out the clock and he wasn't really a huge part of the game plan.
Yeah well, he didn't. If Caddy didn't get hurt for a 3-game stretch, his already impressive numbers are even better.Looking forward to seeing Caddy in a Super Bowl sometime soon.If Ronnie brown gets Caddy's attempts he walks away with this award.
Sucks bigtime.Sucks that they put the Diet Pepsi logo right on the trophy.
Always someone knocking a solid player's play.It also could mean that the team was winning so the RB got more carries late to run out the clock and he wasn't really a huge part of the game plan.I think it clearly shows the involvement of the player in the gameplan, and the corresponding success of that gameplan with him in it.Not much different than Brady's playoff record or Ben R's record being constantly pointed out, IMO.The Bucs go 8-1 when Carnell gets 19 carries.
Shouldn't this read: Carnell gets 19 carries when the Bucs go 8-1? I have no problem with Carnell winning ROY. He's a great young RB. The carries = wins stats have no meaning, imho.
Alittle biased?Yeah well, he didn't. If Caddy didn't get hurt for a 3-game stretch, his already impressive numbers are even better.Looking forward to seeing Caddy in a Super Bowl sometime soon.If Ronnie brown gets Caddy's attempts he walks away with this award.
The reason why Caddy got hurt is he isn't going to be able to take the pounding in the Nfl. Get use to having him out 3-5 games a year. He is a tough little SOB when he's in there though. No disrespect to him, he's a tough little guy.Alittle biased?Yeah well, he didn't. If Caddy didn't get hurt for a 3-game stretch, his already impressive numbers are even better.Looking forward to seeing Caddy in a Super Bowl sometime soon.If Ronnie brown gets Caddy's attempts he walks away with this award.
What did I say was wrong exactly? You arguing his stats would be worse if he played more games?Alittle biased?Yeah well, he didn't. If Caddy didn't get hurt for a 3-game stretch, his already impressive numbers are even better.Looking forward to seeing Caddy in a Super Bowl sometime soon.If Ronnie brown gets Caddy's attempts he walks away with this award.
Thanks, doctor.The reason why Caddy got hurt is he isn't going to be able to take the pounding in the Nfl. Get use to having him out 3-5 games a year. He is a tough little SOB when he's in there though. No disrespect to him, he's a tough little guy.Alittle biased?Yeah well, he didn't. If Caddy didn't get hurt for a 3-game stretch, his already impressive numbers are even better.Looking forward to seeing Caddy in a Super Bowl sometime soon.If Ronnie brown gets Caddy's attempts he walks away with this award.
No need to be a doctor here buddy. He got hurt at Auburn when he got too many carries and he got hurt in Tampa. A man his size can't run the way he does. I don't need to be a doctor I'll just go by the past instead. Nice try though. I'll make you a sig bet he doesn't play in all 16 games next year Doc.Thanks, doctor.The reason why Caddy got hurt is he isn't going to be able to take the pounding in the Nfl. Get use to having him out 3-5 games a year. He is a tough little SOB when he's in there though. No disrespect to him, he's a tough little guy.Alittle biased?Yeah well, he didn't. If Caddy didn't get hurt for a 3-game stretch, his already impressive numbers are even better.Looking forward to seeing Caddy in a Super Bowl sometime soon.If Ronnie brown gets Caddy's attempts he walks away with this award.
Reading comprehension down? I didn't knock anyone's play; I think Cadillac is a great player. That doesn't change the fact that the stat of how much a team runs the ball in their wins is misleadingAlways someone knocking a solid player's play.It also could mean that the team was winning so the RB got more carries late to run out the clock and he wasn't really a huge part of the game plan.I think it clearly shows the involvement of the player in the gameplan, and the corresponding success of that gameplan with him in it.Not much different than Brady's playoff record or Ben R's record being constantly pointed out, IMO.The Bucs go 8-1 when Carnell gets 19 carries.
Shouldn't this read: Carnell gets 19 carries when the Bucs go 8-1? I have no problem with Carnell winning ROY. He's a great young RB. The carries = wins stats have no meaning, imho.