Raised in a family that doesn't believe in car payments. Driving a used 2015 Honda Civic around the northern US for the last 5 years. Got it at 26K miles, up to 88K. It has been economical, but man alive..... it's eating away at my soul this snowy winter.
I could really use a pick-me-up....
Enter an ad for an 2004 F-150 with 200K miles on it Asking $4,000 OBO. Checks all the boxes for what you would like to see in a CL ad for a very high mileage vehicle (single owner, cosmetic defects well documented, affluent part of town). Appears to have potential for "good" fair condition that's in the neighborhood of $1K below KBB private party at their full asking price.
If I check it out and it runs as well as can be expected, just how bad of an idea would it be to shell out $3800 on something like this? I mean, is there any chance I could have good luck, get 30-40K miles and a few years out of it? Or would it just be an instant and unrelenting cash drain from the moment of purchase at that kind of mileage? I would never throw away $5K with that kind of mileage, but.... I might be open to gambling if it's checking in below $4K. Something like this is probably the only avenue in which someone like me might actually own a truck in my life. Is this as bad of an idea as I'm thinking it probably is?
I almost exclusively drive high mileage vehicles. 250-300K. Except my '03 Subaru that's still a baby at 135K.
I wouldn't worry about the miles. At some point, all vehicles are just a collection of parts. If it drives okay, and seems okay, it just comes down to how much you want to spend.
I don't even have mechanics look at them. I know everybody says too, but all the good mechanics I know are too busy doing real work to help me shop for a car. Some would, I'm sure, but I ain't bothering them with it.
But anyway, that's the point of buying cheap cars.
I have a very scientific formula for how much car someone can afford.......If you took this amount of money into the backyard and set it on fire, would you be screwed financially? If the answer is no, you are spending about the right amount. At some point, all cars will be worth $0. We just don't know when.
Anyway, if you like the truck, go for it. $3500-3800ish sounds like a solid deal on an F150 with 200K. Around here, any truck that runs at all is going to for at least $2K (don't even remember the last time I saw on that cheap though).
Something breaks, fix it. Gets to a point that it doesn't seem worth fixing, don't. It's a very different situation than dropping $20K on a depreciation buggy.
Nothing about what you are describing sounds dumb at all.
Obviously, the more due diligence, like Ron is talking about, to make a sound decision the better.