Could Peyton Manning have won titles ... (1 Viewer)

[Doug B]

Yes -- he's as good as Tom Brady ... certainly wouldn't have been a detriment to the team

Maybe -- his tendency to choke may or may not have stopped the Patriots dynasty

No -- Brady's got something intangible that Manning just doesn't

Curious just how much people think Peyton Mannng really brings a team down.

 

[drdgreenlove]

quick..let make 5 more peyton manning threads!

 

[gman8343]

of course he could have. duh.

 

[Doug B]

of course he could have. duh.

Half of the FFA wold rather have Garo Yepremian at QB for the Colts over Manning.

 

[Nihilist Pig]

No.Furthermore, with Brady at the helm, the Colts would have at least two titles during the same stretch. Except at QB, the Colt teams have been more far more talented top to bottom sinice the start of the Patriot dynasty.

 

[GiantsRule]

No.

Furthermore, with Brady at the helm, the Colts would have at least two titles during the same stretch. Except at QB, the Colt teams have been more far more talented top to bottom sinice the start of the Patriot dynasty.

Stupidest post in the history of this forum! Congratulations (and don't hurt yourself when removing your lips from Brady's butt!)

 

[Marc Levin]

Deja vu from 20 years ago."How many Super Bowls would Dan Marino have if he played for the San Francisco 49ers - or at least had their defense?"

 

[Marc Levin]

No.

Furthermore, with Brady at the helm, the Colts would have at least two titles during the same stretch.  Except at QB, the Colt teams have been more far more talented top to bottom sinice the start of the Patriot dynasty.

Stupidest post in the history of this forum! Congratulations (and don't hurt yourself when removing your lips from Brady's butt!)

GiantsRule - this post is unacceptable.Please try harder to be excellent.

 

[gman8343]

Deja vu from 20 years ago.

"How many Super Bowls would Dan Marino have if he played for the San Francisco 49ers - or at least had their defense?"

One or two more than Montana had with them!

 

[GiantsRule]

No.

Furthermore, with Brady at the helm, the Colts would have at least two titles during the same stretch.  Except at QB, the Colt teams have been more far more talented top to bottom sinice the start of the Patriot dynasty.

Stupidest post in the history of this forum! Congratulations (and don't hurt yourself when removing your lips from Brady's butt!)

GiantsRule - this post is unacceptable.Please try harder to be excellent.

My apologies, but it's simply a ridiculous statement to make. Brady is great but has essential pieces of the puzzle around him. To assume that Brady/Dungy would be successful where Manning/Belichick would fail is asinine and ignorant.

 

[Marc Levin]

No.

Furthermore, with Brady at the helm, the Colts would have at least two titles during the same stretch.  Except at QB, the Colt teams have been more far more talented top to bottom sinice the start of the Patriot dynasty.

Stupidest post in the history of this forum! Congratulations (and don't hurt yourself when removing your lips from Brady's butt!)

GiantsRule - this post is unacceptable.Please try harder to be excellent.

My apologies, but it's simply a ridiculous statement to make.

Maybe it is ridiculous to you, and you are entitled to express that it is a ridiculous opinion - however, your response was unacceptable Shark Pool behavior.