What's new
Fantasy Football - Footballguys Forums

This is a sample guest message. Register a free account today to become a member! Once signed in, you'll be able to participate on this site by adding your own topics and posts, as well as connect with other members through your own private inbox!

DYNASTY: Top 2013 College Prospects (2 Viewers)

There is talent in this crop of QB's, but they're all flawed. All need the right system to mask their limitations. I think there are several guys right now that are better prospects than Gabbert, Locker, and Ponder - all of which I did not like regardless of system fit. I don't think their flaws are ones that can be worked around.

 
Montee Ball, Landry Jones among top bowl prospects in January

By Bucky Brooks

Analyst, NFL.com and NFL Network

Published: Dec. 31, 2012 at 05:17 p.m.

Updated: Dec. 31, 2012 at 08:50 p.m.

Last week, I took a look at many of the top college football prospects getting a chance to shine on the stage provided by some of the country's bigger bowl games. This week brings another slate of games that promise to put high-level talent on display for NFL scouts.

Here are some of the players I'll be watching over the next few days as they test themselves against big-time competition.

*Denotes underclassmen

Capital One Bowl: Nebraska vs. Georgia



Tuesday, Jan. 1, 1 p.m. ET, ABC

Aaron Murray*, QB, Georgia: The Bulldogs star has been on fire this season as a pinpoint passer from the pocket. Murray has completed 65.4 percent of his passes while posting a gaudy 31:8 touchdown-to-interception ratio. Most importantly, he has shown the ability to fire accurate strikes to open receivers at every level of the field. Although Murray's height (6-foot-1) and arm strength have been cited as concerns by some scouts, the fact that he has been an outstanding playmaker in the SEC has some evaluators intrigued about his potential as a franchise quarterback.



Jarvis Jones*, OLB, Georgia: Georgia coach Mark Richt thinks Jones might be the best defensive player in college football -- a notion that's tough to dispute, considering Jones' dominance over SEC competition. Jones has amassed 26 sacks and 42 tackles for loss over the past two seasons, showcasing a flashy game built on speed, quickness and burst. He has been nearly impossible to slow down off the corner and has shown a penchant for producing negative plays.

Alec Ogletree*, ILB, Georgia: The changing nature of the NFL game demands that defenses have a sideline-to-sideline playmaker in the middle. Ogletree is a premier defender with exceptional speed and athleticism. He excels at making big hits within the tackle-to-tackle box while displaying remarkable instincts and awareness. NFL scouts would like to see Ogletree play with more physicality when taking on blocks, but it's hard to dispute his production as the heart and soul of the Bulldogs' defense.

Bacarri Rambo and Shawn Williams, S, Georgia: This is arguably the best safety tandem in college football. Both players display excellent ball skills, awareness and tackling ability. Rambo, in particular, is a dynamic ball hawk with rare anticipation and instincts in the deep middle. Williams is a hard hitter with the size and strength to bang runners in the box. He's also shown solid ball skills in the back end. Collectively, Rambo and Williams make plays all over the field. NFL scouts are certainly curious to see if both guys have the tools to be star-quality playmakers at the next level.



Outback Bowl: Michigan vs. South Carolina

Tuesday, Jan. 1, 1 p.m. ET, ESPN

Denard Robinson, QB, Michigan: Robinson is still listed as the Wolverines' quarterback, but he played primarily as a running back over the final month of the season due to an elbow injury on his throwing arm. This shift has taken Robinson away from his preferred position, but it has given NFL scouts an opportunity to see his potential as a designated offensive playmaker. Most evaluators still view Robinson as a potential slot receiver in the NFL, and they'll get one more chance to see how his athleticism could transition to a non-quarterback position, possibly even defensive back.

Taylor Lewan*, OT, Michigan: There has been plenty of discussion in the NFL scouting community about Lewan's potential as a franchise-caliber left tackle. Lewan is not only a big, physical edge blocker with great tools, but he is an impressive athlete for his size (6-8, 309 pounds). Although he remains a work in progress in pass protection, Lewan's overall potential makes him an intriguing prospect for teams looking for solutions at offensive tackle. With a blockbuster matchup against an elite pass rusher (see: next blurb), Lewan can show scouts how much he's developed.

Jadeveon Clowney*, DE, South Carolina: If Clowney were eligible for the 2013 NFL Draft, he would quite possibly rank as the top defensive end. However, he has two years of eligibility remaining. Scouts are excited to monitor Clowney's continued development as an elite pass rusher. In breaking down his game this season, scouts have come away impressed with his combination of size, athleticism and rush skills. Facing a talented edge blocker in Lewan, Clowney will have an opportunity to show evaluators that he is unquestionably the top defensive end in college heading into the 2013 season.

Rose Bowl: Stanford vs. Wisconsin

Tuesday, Jan. 1, 5 p.m. ET, ESPN

Montee Ball, RB, Wisconsin: The former Heisman Trophy finalist has put together an impressive résumé for NFL scouts. Ball has posted back-to-back seasons with at least 1,700 rushing yards, scoring an NCAA-record 76 rushing touchdowns over the course of his career. Most impressively, Ball has shown improved vision, instincts and running skills as a powerful runner between the tackles in 2012. Some scouts still question Ball's burst and home-run ability, but he has consistently churned out big runs against elite competition. With a chance to showcase his skills against a rugged Cardinal defense that features a number of future pros, Ball could make a strong statement about his NFL prospects in Pasadena.

Stepfan Taylor, RB, Stanford: Taylor has been underrated on the national scene, but NFL scouts have plenty of respect for his pro-like game. Taylor has posted three straight 1,000-yard seasons, thriving as a dependable workhorse in the Cardinal's power-based scheme. In addition, he has flashed solid hands and receiving skills as a dynamic weapon out of the backfield. Most NFL offensive coordinators are looking for three-down playmakers at the running back position. The Rose Bowl could be a showcase for Taylor's immense talent and potential.

Chase Thomas and Shayne Skov, LB, Stanford: The dynamic duo has been critical to the success of the Cardinal defense over the past three seasons. Both have specialized in making big plays in key moments while showing the passion and intensity that has become a hallmark of the unit. Thomas has blossomed into a disruptive playmaker off the edge, displaying a relentless motor, outstanding hands and an impressive closing burst. Skov is a disruptive force with sneaky athleticism and quickness. He excels at making plays within the box and sets the tone with jaw-rattling shots in the hole. Facing a Wisconsin team that prefers smash-mouth football over finesse, Skov and Thomas should have plenty of opportunities to prove their mettle to scouts.

Orange Bowl: Florida State vs. Northern Illinois

Tuesday, Jan. 1, 8:30 p.m., ESPN

E.J. Manuel, QB, Florida State: There is no denying Manuel's unbelievable physical gifts. He possesses rare size, athleticism and arm talent. Most importantly, he can make accurate throws from the pocket or on the run. While most NFL scouts have come away impressed with Manuel's physical skills, the majority of evaluators still harbor concerns about his ability to read and decipher coverage on the move. Manuel has struggled in big games against elite defenses. He must display better awareness and anticipation from the pocket. Given a final opportunity to show off his skills against a feisty opponent, Manuel must play well to silence his doubters and build some momentum heading into the pre-draft process.



Bjoern Werner*, DE, Florida State: The Seminoles have a reputation for producing elite pass rushers, and Werner certainly fits the bill. The 6-4, 255-pound defensive end finished the regular season with 13 sacks, displaying a relentless motor and underrated athleticism. Werner's ability to create consistent pressure off the edge has not only drawn the attention of NFL scouts, but led some to envision him as an eventual difference maker at the next level.

Sugar Bowl: Florida vs. Louisville

Wednesday, Jan. 2, 8:30 p.m. ET, ESPN

Sharrif Floyd*, DL, Florida: Floyd has developed into one of the best defensive tackles in college football after entering Florida regarded as the best prep prospect in years. Yup, he's certainly lived up to the billing. Floyd overwhelms opponents with his combination of size and athleticism, flashing impressive instincts and awareness. He has shown glimpses of being a pass rusher, but is at his best creating disruption against the run. Facing an explosive Louisville offense, Floyd will get a chance to show scouts his capacity to dominate as a run stuffer and pass rusher.



Matt Elam*, safety, Florida: Elam is a standout box-area playmaker with outstanding instincts and awareness. He has a strong nose for the ball, which is reflected in his four interceptions in 2012. Some scouts question his speed and athleticism, but his penchant for playmaking is hard to ignore. With an opportunity to play extensively in coverage against a talented pocket passer, Elam can dispel some of the concerns about his ability to be an impact player as a future pro.

Teddy Bridgewater*, QB, Louisville: Bridgewater is still in the early stages of his collegiate career, but that hasn't stopped scouts from paying attention to his considerable talent as a pocket passer. Bridgewater has completed 69 percent of his passes and sports an impressive 25:7 touchdown-to-interception ratio. Although scouts haven't extensively studied Bridgewater's game at this point, he can build some positive buzz with a stellar performance against an SEC heavyweight.

Fiesta Bowl: Kansas State vs. Oregon

Thursday, Jan. 3, 8:30 p.m. ET, ESPN

Dion Jordan, DE, Oregon: NFL scouts covet defenders with exceptional speed, athleticism and versatility. Jordan is a former tight end with freakish movement skills. In the pass-happy Pac-12, Jordan recorded five sacks and dazzled scouts with his ability to also drop into coverage from his hybrid defensive end position. In his final outing, scouts would love to see Jordan dominate off the edge while showing the ability to put together a series of moves to win consistently against heavy-handed offensive tackles. If he can display a better feel for getting after the passer, it will be hard for teams to bypass a big, talented athlete like Jordan on draft day.

Kenjon Barner, RB, Oregon: Barner is still not regarded as an elite running back prospect, even though he just put up a 1,600-yard season for the Ducks. The slithery ball carrier has flashed speed, quickness and burst as the feature runner in the spread, but scouts wonder if his production is really a product of playing in a wide-open system. In addition, some evaluators question whether he's tough enough to withstand the punishment that comes with playing running back at the next level. Barner can answer several questions with a strong showing in the Fiesta Bowl against a physical Kansas State squad.



Arthur Brown, LB, Kansas State: It's hard to find a more productive linebacker in college football than Brown. He has posted 10 or more tackles in four games this season, showing exceptional range as a sideline-to-sideline defender. Most importantly, he possesses the tenacity and physicality to thump runners in the hole in big games. While the Ducks' spread offense will not test Brown's ability to stand up against big blockers, the speed of Oregon's skill players will provide scouts with an opportunity to see him work in space. Given the changing nature of the NFL game, that could be enough to send his stock soaring on draft boards across the league.

Cotton Bowl: Oklahoma vs. Texas A&M

Friday, Jan. 4, 8 p.m. ET, FOX

Damontre Moore*, DL, Texas A&M: Moore took the SEC by storm with his exceptional prowess as a pass rusher. He collected 80 tackles, 12.5 sacks and 20 tackles for a loss in 2012. Those numbers are impressive by any standard, but they're especially so when one factors in his transition to a new position (defensive end) within a new scheme this year. Scouts have lauded Moore's natural rush skills and athleticism while also praising his non-stop motor. Although some evaluators are still waiting to see more tape on Moore before suggesting he's a certain top-10 talent, a standout performance in the Cotton Bowl could make it hard to discount Moore's immense potential as a pass rusher.

Luke Joeckel* and Jake Matthews*, OT, Texas A&M: It's hard enough to secure one franchise-caliber offensive tackle in a program, but the Aggies have defied the odds by having a pair of top-notch edge blockers in the lineup. Joeckel and Matthews are as good as they come on the collegiate level; scouts are blown away by their natural skills and potential. This game presents a chance to show off their talents against a gritty Oklahoma defense that features speed on the edges.

Landry Jones, QB, Oklahoma: Jones seemingly has become a forgotten man in all the talk about the 2013 quarterback class, but NFL scouts are still monitoring his play to see if he's grown as a decision maker. Jones has repeatedly made critical errors under duress, and his miscues have cost the Sooners dearly in big games. However, Jones could make amends for his inconsistent play by performing well against an Aggies defense that features one of the best pass rushers in college football (Moore). If Jones can avoid the big mistakes while showcasing his outstanding arm talent with a few magnificent throws, he could earn a reprieve from NFL scouts who doubt his ability to grow into a franchise-caliber playmaker at the next level.

Check back on Friday for Bucky Brooks' full scouting report on the BCS National Championship Game between Notre Dame and Alabama.
 
Stacy, Vanderbilt steal spotlight from Glennon, NC State

By Rob Rang | The Sports Xchange/CBSSports.com

December 31, 2012 5:56 pm ET

NFL talent evaluators might have been hoping to see North Carolina State senior Mike Glennon step forward in a tight quarterback race. Instead, they saw him fade to the background as Vanderbilt running back Zac Stacy enjoyed the most impressive performance of the Music City Bowl's top NFL prospects helping to lead the Commodores to a 38-24 victory on Monday.

Stacy, a 5-foot-9, 210-pound dynamo who entered the game ranked by NFLDraftScout.com as a late round prospect, flashed the patience, lateral agility and leg drive that has led other relatively unheralded backs to surprise in the NFL. The Commodores leaned heavily on their senior running back in this contest, giving him 25 carries (107 yards and a touchdown) from a variety of formations, including the Wildcat. He likely would have toted the rock even more had he not suffered an apparent ankle injury in the fourth quarter. After sitting out a series, Stacy returned.

Durability has been a key question for Stacy throughout his career. He showed immediate playmaking ability as a freshman, but suffered through multiple leg injuries over his first two seasons. Since that time, however, he's proven to be one of the country's better backs, rushing for a school-record 1,193 yards and 14 touchdowns in 2010 (5.9 yards per carry) and nearly duplicating those numbers this year (1,141, 10 touchdowns) this season. He leaves Vanderbilt as a two-time Second Team All-SEC running back and the school's all-time leader in rushing yardage.

Despite these accomplishments, Stacy will be fighting history as no Vanderbilt running back has ever heard his name called in the first seven rounds of the NFL Draft. While Vanderbilt has struggled to churn out pro prospects at running back, Stacy is clearly deserving of NFL consideration.

His natural running skills were apparent on the summer tape I did on him entering the year and prompted CBSSports.com's Bruce Feldman to highlight Stacy as one of the Ten Underrated Players fans should watch during the bowl season. The bowl game performance was simply an appropriate cap to a strong final two seasons in the SEC.

While Stacy ended his collegiate career on a high note, the same can't be said for Glennon.

As he has virtually throughout his two seasons as NC State's starting quarterback, Glennon flashed the arm talent that has led to some lofty NFL projections. Unfortunately, the same struggles in a collapsing pocket also were obvious throughout this game as Glennon threw three interceptions, each of which demonstrated the poor decision-making and inaccurate passing that has caused NFLDraftScout.com to rank Glennon much lower than others in the scouting community virtually all year long.

The 6-foot-5, 232 pound Glennon began the game well, stepping up in the pocket, spreading the ball and making pinpoint passes that required both NFL-caliber velocity and touch. He threw multiple catchable passes that simply went through the hands of his intended targets, which makes his statline (35-for-53, 383 yards) appear all the more impressive -- if not for the three interceptions.

On his first interception, just as he was being pressured, Glennon lofted a deep ball down the right sideline toward sophomore receiver Bryan Underwood. Unable to fully step into the throw, Glennon underthrew it, making it an easy read and interception for Vanderbilt safety Kenny Ladler, who was sitting back in Cover-2. The pass came while NC State was deep in its own territory and gave the Commodores (up 7-0 in the first quarter) the ball at the 45-yard line.

As curious as Glennon's first interception was, his second was worse.

Again, deep in his own territory, Glennon attempted a skinny-post down the seam to Underwood, who was well-covered. Vandy corner Eric Samuels did a terrific job of catching the ball, as it was on him right as he turned to look back but it was a play he made nonetheless. Returning the ball 12 yards to the NC State 18-yard line, Samuels' turnover came on first down and with just 54 seconds remaining in the half. Rather than the Wolfpack being in position to whittle away at Vanderbilt's 21-14 lead, instead they saw it doubled when Jordan Rodgers hit his favorite target, Jordan Matthews, for a touchdown two plays later.

Glennon successfully guided the Wolfpack down the field on the opening drive of the third quarter. Down just two touchdowns and hitting big-gainers for 18 and 26 yards, it appeared that NC State might take back momentum.

Instead, facing third-and-2 and in field-goal range from the 25-yard line, Glennon inexplicably tossed a deep ball into coverage down the left sideline to true freshman wideout Charlie Hegedus. Vanderbilt defensive back Trey Wilson stepped in front of Hegedus to win the jump ball, intercepting the pass and racing 65 yards to the 35-yard line, putting the Commodores in position to kick a field goal and extend their lead to 17.

Glennon has the physical traits scouts are looking for and, as such, will continue to earn plenty of attention. As my colleague Dane Brugler pointed out, an impressive showing at the Senior Bowl will give him plenty of opportunity to resurrect what "falling" stock he might have after this game.

Ultimately, scouts will have to ask themselves how a relatively immobile and inexperienced quarterback who struggles as the pocket collapses is going to fare against the increasingly exotic blitz packages in the NFL? This wasn't, after all, the first time Glennon has struggled in this kind of environment.
 
Postgame analysis: Chick fil-A Bowl -- No. 14 Clemson 25, No. 9 LSU 24

By Shawn Krest | CBSSports.com

January 1, 2013 12:42 am ET

Clemson (11-2) officially led LSU (10-3) for no time in the 2012 Chick fil-A Bowl. But with the clock reading double-zero, Chandler Catanzaro's 32-yard field goal gave No. 14 Clemson a 25-24 victory over No. 9 LSU on Monday night in Atlanta.

Clemson scored 12 unanswered points in the fourth quarter after LSU seized control of a one-point game with 10 points in the third. Catanzaro kicked two field goals, helping to make up for a blocked PAT in the second quarter. It was Catanzaro's first unsuccessful PAT attempt in 57 attempts this season.

QB Tajh Boyd led the Clemson offensive comeback, setting career highs in completions (36) and attempts (50). After WR Sammy Watkins suffered a right ankle injury on Clemson's second offensive snap of the game, WR DeAndre Hopkins carried the offensive load. He finished with 13 catches for 191 yards and two touchdowns.

Clemson controlled the ball for 11:26 of the fourth quarter, as LSU ran the ball twice. LSU's lead was built on the running of true freshman Jeremy Hill, who scored touchdowns in the first minute of each half and finished with 124 yards on 12 carries.

When the game turned: Clemson faced fourth-and-16 from its 14-yard line with 1:22 remaining in the game and trailing 24-22. Boyd faced down an oncoming LSU pass rusher and completed a 26-yard pass to a sliding Hopkins. Clemson didn't face another third or fourth down until Catanzaro's game-winning kick.

Highlight moments: Trailing by eight on its second-to-last possession of the game, Clemson ran a hook-and-lateral from its 46-yard line. Boyd threw to WR Adam Humphries, who lateraled to RB Andre Ellington, who weaved through the LSU defense for a 21-yard gain. … On the first snap of the second half, Hill broke a tackle attempt by Clemson S Rashard Hall and ran 57 yards for a touchdown. … Clinging to a two-point lead with 2:47 remaining, LSU ran three pass plays. The last two were incomplete, stopping the clock. LSU was able to run just one minute off the clock and didn't force Clemson to use any of its three time outs.

Significance of Clemson's victory: The Tigers wiped out the memory of last season's 70-33 loss to West Virginia in the Orange Bowl. The win gave Clemson a 2-1 record against the SEC this season. The Tigers were the only ACC team to defeat an SEC foe this year. Boyd made a case for 2013 Heisman consideration, should he stay for another season.

Significance of LSU's loss: Les Miles solidified his reputation as a wild card with his play calling late in the game. The Tigers lost in the Peach/Chick-fil-A Bowl for the first time in six appearances and likely cost themselves a top-10 finish in the polls.
Boyd carries to Clemson to victory; could NFL be next?

By Rob Rang | The Sports Xchange/CBSSports.com

December 31, 2012 11:21 pm ET

On on a night full of terrific Tigers, Tajh Boyd's roar was the loudest, leading Clemson to an unbelievable comeback victory over LSU in the Chick-fil-A Bowl.

With a gritty performance against a ferocious defense, the Clemson junior demonstrated the combination of toughness, accuracy and mobility that scouts had been hoping to see from Geno Smith, Mike Glennon or any other of the "top" senior quarterbacks this bowl season, perhaps setting the stage for Boyd to make himself eligible for the 2013 NFL draft.

Boyd, who requested a grade from the Advisory Committee before Monday's Chick-fil-A Bowl, entered the game already well on scouts' radar. Blessed with a strong, accurate right arm and surprising mobility given his compact 6-1, 225 pound frame, Boyd is precisely the type of dual-threat passer that has suddenly caught the imagination of NFL decision-makers. It was Boyd, not Heisman Trophy winner Johnny Manziel, who led the country with an average of 21.83 points scored per game. He completed nearly 67% of his passes for 3,550 yards and 34 touchdowns against just 13 interceptions and ran for another 492 yards and nine scores. He did this against a tough schedule, leading the Tigers to a 10-2 regular season record with their only losses coming at Florida State September 22 and a tough loss to rival South Carolina to end the regular season, November 24.

Statistically-speaking, Boyd's numbers in 2012 weren't that much better than the ones he posted in 2011, his first season as Clemson's starter. Boyd threw for more yards (3,828) and remarkably similar touchdown (33) and interception (12) numbers a year ago. Boyd's succcess this season, however, came despite attempting 122 less passes, providing some statistical evidence to support what talent evaluators have seen from Boyd all year long, namely better decision-making, poise in the pocket, and accuracy to all levels of the field.

One of the knocks scouts had about Boyd was that he was protected with two of the better pass-catchers in college football in junior DeAndre Hopkins and sophomore Sammy Watkins. Any reliance Boyd might have had on Watkins, however, was erased one play into the game when the Clemson star suffered an ankle injury that ended his night early.

Just as he had throughout much of the year, Boyd simply carried Clemson in this game. He rushed a jaw-dropping 29 times for 22 yards and a touchdown. He completed 35 of 49 passes for 339 yards and two touchdowns without an interception despite the fact that he was under constant attack from LSU's dynamic pass-rush duo of Barkevious Mingo (who supplied the hit that knocked Watkins out) and Sam Montgomery, among others. His throws ranged from Brett Favre-like flicks of the wrist while being pressured to touch passes down the seam to rifling deep and intermediate passes through narrow windows, including down the middle to Hopkins for the 12-yard touchdown that cut LSU's lead to just two in the closing minutes. It was the touch and accuracy he demonstrated with a beautifully lofted ball over NFLDraftScout.com's top-ranked free safety Eric Reid on fourth and 12 that put the Tigers in position to kick the game-winning field goal as time expired.

As much as Boyd carried Clemson offensively, it was senior defensive end Malliciah Goodman who did the heavy lifting for the Tigers on the other side of the ball. The 6-4, 280 pound Goodman had been counted on this year to be Clemson's primary pass rusher but entered the Chick-fil-A Bowl with just four sacks on the season. Because of his obvious potential, however, Goodman remained within NFLDraftScout.com's top 150 prospects.

He'll certainly be moving up our board -- and the boards of NFL teams, as well -- with his spectacular performance in the clutch tonight, however.

Goodman was virtually unstoppable off the edge in this game, nearly matching his season-total with 3.5 sacks of LSU's Zach Mettenberger. He demonstrated not only better speed off the edge than he'd shown much of the year but strong hands to disengage and a quick counter back inside. It was Goodman who knocked down Mettenberger's third down pass to force LSU to punt the ball and give Boyd the opportunity to lead Clemson to victory.
Chick-fil-A Bowl Quick Hits: No.14 Clemson 25 No. 9 LSU 24

By Tom Fornelli | Blogger

December 31, 2012 11:40 pm ET

CLEMSON WON: It was the last college football game of 2012 and it just might have been one of the best college football games of 2012. For years we've seen the SEC's top defenses put the clamps on the best offenses in college football but on Monday night in Atlanta Clemson scored as many points as it needed to win.

Tajh Boyd was named the game's Most Valuable Player, and for good reason. Despite spending most of the night running for his life as LSU's front seven wreaked havoc on the Clemson offensive line, Boyd finished with 361 total yards and 3 touchdowns. More than the stats, though, it was some of the impeccable throws Boyd made throughout the night when big throws were needed, with DeAndre Hopkins usually on the other end.

Hopkins finished the night with 13 receptions for 190 yards and 2 touchdowns, having a big night after fellow receiver, Sammy Watkins, was injured on the very first play of the game and never returned.

WHY CLEMSON WON: It endured the storm. LSU's defense made Boyd's life rough all night long, and although the LSU offense only managed 208 yards of offense, it still managed 24 points thanks largely to that defense and the running of Jeremy Hill. Still, with only a few minutes remaining, LSU had a chance to run out the clock and salt this game away.

Instead LSU called three straight passing plays, with two incompletions and Clemson didn't have to use a single one of its three timeouts. Boyd would then lead his Tigers on a 10-play 60-yard drive -- which included a huge conversion on fourth and 16 -- in 1:39 to set up Jordan Catanzaro's 37-yard field goal.

WHEN CLEMSON WON: As Catanzaro's field goal soared through the uprights and its players began celebrating. Though I guess you can say Clemson won when LSU decided to throw the ball three straight plays instead of giving the ball to a guy who averaged 10.4 yards per carry on the night, Jeremy Hill.

WHAT CLEMSON WON: This is a huge win for Clemson. As a team in 2012 and as a program. First of all, the 70-33 loss to West Virginia is now a distant memory. Second of all, it's the first time Clemson has won 11 games in a season since its national championship in 1981. Finally, while Clemson did beat Auburn earlier this year, beating Auburn is not the same thing as beating one of the SEC's premiere teams in a major bowl game.

WHAT LSU LOST: I think it's against SEC rules to lose to the ACC. In the grand scheme of things this loss doesn't mean a whole lot for LSU save for having to hear from other SEC fans how they lost to Clemson from the ACC for the next nine months. Les Miles will also hear a lot about LSU's playcalling in the final minutes too.

THAT WAS CRAZY: Tajh Boyd. Just a great night, and one he'll celebrate tonight and then spend the next four months in an ice tub.
 
'MAC_32 said:
Big cases made by tahj and hopkins tonight
:goodposting: - any guesses on what Hopkins really runs? I sense that his 10 may be amongst the best this year; he gets off quick and establishes separation. Can't tell if that translates to long term speed but his game speed is plenty. I am not sold on Tahj but last night WAS the best game I have seen from him. Brandon Floyd is intriguing as well - I thought he stood out most of the year.
 
'MAC_32 said:
Big cases made by tahj and hopkins tonight
:goodposting: - any guesses on what Hopkins really runs? I sense that his 10 may be amongst the best this year; he gets off quick and establishes separation. Can't tell if that translates to long term speed but his game speed is plenty. I am not sold on Tahj but last night WAS the best game I have seen from him. Brandon Floyd is intriguing as well - I thought he stood out most of the year.
I was disappointed that the LSU CBs didn't challenge Hopkins at the LOS and try to get physical with him. They normally do this a lot so I'm not sure what to make of it. Did they not think it would work or just didn't feel the need for it. Either way, those more informed on Hopkins, is this a area he's good at or not?
 
'MAC_32 said:
Big cases made by tahj and hopkins tonight
:goodposting: - any guesses on what Hopkins really runs? I sense that his 10 may be amongst the best this year; he gets off quick and establishes separation. Can't tell if that translates to long term speed but his game speed is plenty. I am not sold on Tahj but last night WAS the best game I have seen from him. Brandon Floyd is intriguing as well - I thought he stood out most of the year.
Hopkins looks like a 4.5 guy. But he's very quick and sudden in his routes so that aids in his getting open.
 
If I remember correctly, Hopkins lined up on the left side most of the time. When he lined up on the right, he didn't run too many routes, except for one route up the right sideline where Boyd overthrew him. I don't watch much Clemson football, so question is: is there anything gimmicky or overly simplistic to Clemson's offense where you'd think Hopkins will need longer to develop in the pros? Brian Hartline is my 2nd highest scoring receiver, so I need some major help.

 
Been pleasantly surprised with Ball thus far. Good vision and a bit more burst than I remember.
He uses that spin move a lot which doesn't translate well.to the pros but other than that he has looked like a prototypical workhorse back...
 
I keeping wanting to like EJ Manuel more than I do. Nice physical specimen, throws a nice ball, moves well enough, does not seem like a mental midget, but something is just missing.

 
Rose Bowl Quick Hits: Stanford 20, Wisconsin 14

By Chris Huston | Blogger/Heisman Pundit

January 1, 2013 9:18 pm ET

STANFORD WON: Behind a physical defense and a grind-it-out offense, No. 8 Stanford finished off a 12-2 season with a hard-fought 20-14 win over Wisconsin (8-6) in the Rose Bowl in Pasadena on New Year's Day. It was the Cardinal's first Rose Bowl win since 1972. Running back Stepfan Taylor was named the offensive MVP after rushing for 88 yards and a touchdown on 20 carries. Cornerback Usua Amanam was the defensive MVP after securing the victory with a key fourth-quarter interception. Kevin Hogan threw for 123 yards and rushed for 54 to become the first freshman quarterback to win a Rose Bowl since Brook Bollinger did so for Wisconsin in 2000. Stanford held the Badgers to 83 yards passing and just 301 total yards. Wisconsin acquitted itself well for the most part and, after rallying from a 14-0 first-quarter deficit, was in the game until the final drive. Montee Ball led all rushers with 100 yards on 24 carries. His second-quarter touchdown gave him 83 for his career. The Badgers defense stepped up after a slow start, holding the Cardinal in the second half to just three points and 98 total yards. Neither team team turned it over until the final two minutes, when Wisconsin quarterback Curt Phillips was picked off by Amanam. The game was a tale of two halves, with the offenses dominating the first half and the defenses clamping down in the second.

WHY STANFORD WON: The game was highly competitive and physical, but cleanly played. The two teams combined for 10 penalties and just one turnover and each side had 17 first downs. The total yardage was relatively close (Stanford 344, Wisconsin 301). The Cardinal win can best be attributed to an early offensive outburst that led to 14 first-quarter points. A pass off a reverse by receiver Drew Terrell to Jamal-Rashad Patterson set up receiver Kelsey Young's 16-yard touchdown dash off another reverse. A bomb from Hogan to tight end Zach Ertz for 43 yards set up Taylor's 3-yard touchdown plunge. Once the normal flow of the game resumed, the two teams were evenly matched, but Stanford had more of a cushion to work with and was able to hold on for the victory.

WHEN STANFORD WON: The Cardinal took a 20-14 lead after Jordan Williamson's 22-yard field goal with 4:23 to play, but the Wisconsin offense came to life on the ensuing drive and it looked like the game might go down to the wire. The Badgers advanced to the Stanford 49-yard line from their own 25 in five plays and had a second-and-five with a little more than two minutes to play. That's when Amanam stepped in front of a Phillips pass at the Stanford 42-yard line to put an end to any potential drama. Stanford picked up one more first down and ran out the clock.

WHAT STANFORD WON: It was Stanford's first Rose Bowl win since 1972. But the game also cemented the Cardinal as an emerging national power under coach David Shaw. Stanford has been to three consecutive BCS games (winning two) and has three consecutive seasons of 11 wins or more (and two 12-win seasons). "It's not always pretty, it's not always perfect, but we finish what we start," Shaw said after the game. With most of this team coming back next year and a talented recruiting class emerging, the Cardinal are not going away any time soon.



WHAT WISCONSIN LOST: It took some good fortune for the five-loss Badgers to even be in this game, but this one will stick in their craw nonetheless. Even with an interim coach and with poor quarterback play, Wisconsin had a chance to win. Instead, it became the first team since Michigan in 1977-79 to lose three consecutive Rose Bowls.
 
That was not a pretty game between Stanford and Wisconsin. Poor QB play.

Neither RB really did much. Taylor showed good power and balance with some nice second effort runs, but his longest gain of the night was 10 yards. I like his overall game, but he doesn't really have that "wow" kind of explosiveness. And Ball was very pedestrian. He gets what's there, but doesn't look like a playmaker to me. I might like James White more as a pro prospect in a vacuum, although I do think Ball could be serviceable if thrust into duty on a decent team.

 
'EBF said:
That was not a pretty game between Stanford and Wisconsin. Poor QB play. Neither RB really did much. Taylor showed good power and balance with some nice second effort runs, but his longest gain of the night was 10 yards. I like his overall game, but he doesn't really have that "wow" kind of explosiveness. And Ball was very pedestrian. He gets what's there, but doesn't look like a playmaker to me. I might like James White more as a pro prospect in a vacuum, although I do think Ball could be serviceable if thrust into duty on a decent team.
:goodposting: ball isn't much of a prospect imo. there area 3 or 4 rb's id's rather have this draft. i do think mevlin gordon is someone to watch though in the future. love his potential.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
NFL Draft prospects to watch in bowl games: Part 4

Tony Pauline

Breaking down the players to watch in the season's first batch of bowl games, as well as a projection as to where they'll be drafted.

Sugar Bowl: Florida vs Louisville

Shariff Floyd/DT/Florida: Floyd elevated his game this season and was a force every weekend. The junior explodes off the snap and fires through the gaps to make plays in the backfield. He also has the strength to occupy blockers, creating opportunities for teammates. Word out of Florida is Floyd will enter the draft. 2nd Round

Jordan Reed/TE/Florida: Reed is developing into a dominant pass-catching tight end and has a style similar to former Gator Aaron Hernandez. He's slightly undersized but has the speed to create mismatches in the secondary. There's a distinct possibility Reed forgoes his senior season in favor of the NFL in 2013. 2nd Round

Mike Gillislee/RB/Florida: The Gators primary running back comes off a career campaign and is moving up draft boards. Gillislee shows a large degree of versatility in his ball carrying, making defenders miss on the inside or outrunning them around the corner. He also proved himself to be a competent receiver out of the backfield and projects as a third-down back/situational ball handler for the next level. 3rd/4th Round

Adrian Bushell/CB/Louisville: Bushell has been an asset at cornerback and on special teams the two years he has played for Louisville. He can line up in man coverage or back off the line of scrimmage. Bushell will find a home as a dime back/kick returner at the next level. 5th Round



Fiesta Bowl: Kansas State vs Oregon

Dion Jordan/OLB/Oregon: Jordan started his Oregon career at tight end then moved to defensive end before making his mark at linebacker this season. He's a tall (6-feet, 6-inch) defender who displays terrific athleticism. Jordan is more than just a pass rusher and has developed into a three-down defender. He is receiving high praise in the scouting community. 1st/2nd Round

Kyle Long/OL/Oregon: The son of former All Pro Howie Long began his college career at defensive end before moving to offensive line in 2011. He was barely mentioned by scouts at the start of the season but now grades as a potential top-40 choice. The ability to line up at guard or tackle enhances Long's value. 2nd Round

Arthur Brown/LB/Kansas State: The undersized Brown is being compared to Ray Lewis of Baltimore. The fierce defender displays terrific speed and covers a lot of area on the field. Brown is proficient defending the run or covering the pass. He offers potential at a number of linebacker spots and should quickly break into a starting lineup at the next level. 2nd/3rd Round

Kenjon Barner/RB/Oregon: Barner is the latest game-breaking ballcarrier produced by the Oregon program. He plays with great quickness and speed and shows the ability to consistently pick up big chunks of yardage. Barner has a nose for the end zone and has shown steady improvement as a pass catcher. He'll be a good fit in the NFL as a situational skill player. 3rd Round

Cotton Bowl: Oklahoma vs Texas A&M

Damontre Moore/OLB-DE/Texas A&M: The Aggies star defensive player is drawing comparisons to former Texas A&M standout Von Miller, and with good reason. He's a game-changing pass rusher who consistently disrupts the action behind the line of scrimmage. Moore also brings a lot of athleticism and is developing into a three-down defender. Moore has already announced he will enter April's draft, where he projects as a top six pick. 1st Round

Luke Joeckel/T/Texas A&M: This polished pass blocker successfully protected the blind side of Johnny Manziel, the 2012 Heisman Trophy winner. He's fundamentally sound and shows terrific knowledge of the position, effectively using blocking angles and positioning to shut down opponents. The junior projects as a top-12 selection if he enters the draft. 1st Round

Jake Matthews/T/Texas A&M: Another blocker who protected Manziel, Matthews' specialty is run blocking. He's a large lineman with the strength necessary to turn defenders off the line and open the running lanes. Matthews also holds his own in pass protection and offers starting potential at right tackle. 1st Round

Lane Johnson/T/Oklahoma: Johnson entered the season with mid-round grades and elevated every aspect of his game. He's a terrific pass blocker for the Sooners' spread offense and plays smart football. Johnson's battle against Demontre Moore in the Cotton Bowl is one scouts will watch carefully. 2nd Round

Landry Jones/QB/Oklahoma: Jones was described as a potential franchise signal caller after his sophomore season, but his game has hit a rough patch the past two seasons. He offers the size and arm strength to start at the next level; his decision-making and poise under pressure leaves much to be desired. 3rd Round

BBVA Compass Bowl: Mississippi vs Pittsburgh

Devin Street/WR/Pittsburgh: Street is poised to be the next big-time receiver prospect from the Panthers program. He's a well-sized pass catcher with a smooth style and reliable hands. Street consistently comes away with the difficult reception in a crowd. He is expected to be rated by NFL scouts as one of the top senior receivers. 2nd/3rd Round

Ray Graham/RB/Pittsburgh: The elusive Graham successfully returned from a knee injury that cut short his 2011 season. He's a quick ballcarrier with the ability to make defenders miss anywhere. He's also a terrific pass catcher out of the backfield. 3rd/4th Round



Charles Sawyer/DB/Mississippi: The draft stock of this versatile defensive back is on the rise. He plays bigger in run defense than his listed 185 pounds and has the ball skills necessary to play over the slot receiver. The junior filed paperwork with the NFL Advisory Committee asking for a preview of his draft grade. He's expected to make a decision in the coming weeks. 3rd Round

GoDaddy.com Bowl: Arkansas State vs Kent State

Brian Winters/OL/Kent State: Winters has been a dominant blocker three years running and is the best offensive line prospect you've never heard of. He possesses next-level size, strength and intensity. Winters easily annihilates opponents and plays hard until the whistle blows. The college left tackle projects to guard or right tackle at the next level and offers immediate starting potential. 2nd/3rd Round

Roosevelt Nix/OLB/Kent State: Nix is an undersized but productive college defensive end who's been compared to Elvis Dumervil of the Denver Broncos. The junior has been awarded all-Conference honors since his freshman campaign and posted 14.5 tackles for loss with six sacks this season. He's a constant nuisance for opponents and gets the most from his ability. 4th/5th Round

Taylor Stockemer/WR/Arkansas State: Stockemer is a well-sized receiver with dependable hands and the ability to consistently make the tough grab. Though not stopwatch fast, Stockemer sneaks it downfield on occasion for the long gainer. He quickly returned to form after missing the first month of the season with a knee injury. Scouts like Stockemer as a fifth receiver at the next level. 7th Round
 
2013 NFL Draft: Fiesta Bowl Risers and Fallers

By Dane Brugler | NFLDraftScout.com Senior Analyst

January 4, 2013 12:25 am ET

Speed. Speed. And more speed. Oregon's high-tempo offense proved to be too much for Kansas State Thursday night in the Fiesta Bowl as the Ducks defeated the Wildcats, 35-17. This performance had it all, everything from a game-opening kickoff return for a touchdown to the rare one-point safety.

Regardless if this was Chip Kelly's final game at the helm of the Ducks, he showed why several NFL teams are currently wooing him for their open head coaching vacancies. But several NFL prospects also stood out, both good and bad.

PROSPECTS WHO HELPED THEMSELVES:

DE Meshak Williams, Kansas State – The Wildcats 2012 leader in sacks had another impactful performance in this one. Although he has tweener size (6-3, 245), he uses leverage and toughness to battle his way to the pocket with the intensity and motor to finish. Williams showed his length limitations, but after a strong senior season, his NFL Draft arrow is pointing north.

MLB Kiko Alonso, Oregon – He'll need to answer questions about the character issues, but Alonso is a prospect scouts are intrigued by and he showed why in the Fiesta Bowl. Whether dropping in coverage or attacking the line of scrimmage, he brought the same aggressive nature on each play, flashing speed and a fearless attitude.

RB Kenjon Barner, Oregon – It took 30 carries, but Barner registered his eighth 100-yard rushing performance of 2012 against a Wildcat defense that ranked 17th in the nation in rush defense. He used his vision and quick feet and chip away at Kansas State, finishing with 143 rush yards and just a few yards short of breaking the school record for all-purpose yardage in a career.

FB Braden Wilson, Kansas State – Regardless if it's the pros or college, the fullback position seems to be an afterthought for most offenses. But not for Kansas State and not for Wilson who proved his value on several occasions against Oregon, throwing his body around with a violent attitude. As a player who doesn't receive a lot of touches, he will be lucky to be drafted, but Wilson might be the best blocking fullback in this class.

WR Chris Harper, Kansas State – The Kansas State offense relies on the run game for most of their damage, but when Klein did throw it Thursday night, he was often looking for Harper, his top target. An Oregon-transfer, Harper has a little bit of bad weight on him (6-1, 235), but he uses his physicality to out-muscle defensive backs, finishing the Fiesta Bowl with a game-high eight catches for 71 yards. Harper is an underrated mid-round receiver prospect.

LB Michael Clay, Oregon – Although undersized (5-11, 220), Clay was all over the field in the Fiesta Bowl and earned the Defensive Player of the Game honors. He displayed his versatility as a blitzer, blowing plays up in the backfield and rarely missing a tackle. While his game has some holes, NFL teams will view Clay as a prospect who might be able to make a living on special teams.

PROSPECTS WHO HAD A MIXED BAG:

QB Collin Klein, Kansas State – Through mid-November, Klein appeared to be the frontrunner for the Heisman Trophy, but the final three games of his college career were disappointing, including two losses (Baylor, Oregon). Against the Ducks, he looked tentative throwing passes 10+ yards downfield and had little success running the ball, averaging just 2.3 yards per carry. Klein still has a chance to be a late round draft pick, but the tape from this game won't help.

MLB Arthur Brown, Kansas State – Although he finished strong, it's fair to expect more from a player who might be a first round pick in April. He played fast and aggressive for all four quarters, but often got lost in a crowd and had trouble sifting his way through the trash to bring down the ballcarrier. Brown also misdiagnosed several plays in coverage, something that is very uncharacteristic of the talented linebacker.

DE Dion Jordan, Oregon – When he was on the field, Jordan looked like his usual future-first-rounder self, but he was forced to the sidelines on several occasions, presumably because of a lingering shoulder injury that has limited him much of the season. With his lanky frame, durability will be a question mark moving to the next level and one of the few negatives against the athletic pass rusher.
Fiesta Bowl Quick Hits: Oregon 35, Kansas State 17

By Jerry Hinnen | Blogger

January 4, 2013 12:19 am ET

OREGON WON. It wasn't quite a prototypical Oregon game, not with the Ducks sitting on less than 100 yards of offense when they took over with exactly 60 seconds left to play in the first half; Kansas State had ground out a pair of long scoring drives and the Ducks hadn't been able to get much of their trademark up-tempo game going. And even in the end, 393 yards and 35 points aren't what Chip Kelly sees in his dreams.

But between the start of that critical late-second quarter drive and the Ducks pulling their foot off the pedal in the fourth quarter, the Ducks did what the Ducks do, rattling off a 50-second drive touchdown drive to end the half, a 2 minute, 14-second field goal drive to open the third quarter, and a 2 minute, 34-second touchdown drive the possession after that. Result: a 15-10 lead that looked like it might not even survive to halftime ballooned to 32-10. Given how much work Kansas State seemed to need to score: game over. The Ducks only truly played like the Ducks for that 8-minute stretch of game time, but that's the beauty of Chip Kelly's Oregon; that was enough.

WHY OREGON WON. Kenjon Barner finished with 167 yards from scrimmage and a touchdown, Marcus Mariota was named offensive MVP after 166 yards passing and two touchdowns to go with 62 yards and a touchdown rushing, and De'Anthony Thomas gave the Ducks a lead they would never relinquish by returning the opening kickoff for a score.

But the game belonged first and foremost to the Oregon defense, which never let Collin Klein become the player he was for most of the 2012 regular season and his distinguished career. Harried in the pocket, his receivers regularly blanketed, his running lanes routinely shut down -- the Wildcats' opening drive ended in a stuffed Klein rushing attempt on 4th-and-1, setting the tone for the game -- Klein finished averaging just 4.7 yards per pass attempt and 2.3 yards per-rush. (The primary Duck culprits? Defensive MVP Michael Clay, with 9 tackles and a sack, and omnipresent linebacker Kiko Alonso.)

The Kansas State defense had its moments. But there was never going to be enough of them with the Wildcats' one true superstar bottled up so badly.

WHEN OREGON WON. Down 32-17 with under 8 minutes remaining i nthe game, Kansas State faced 4th-and-9 at their own 28. Long odds or not, two possessions for the Wildcats' glacially-paced offense meant they couldn't afford to give the ball back to Oregon ... which they did anyway. A handful of easy Barner-driven first downs later, the game was finished.

WHAT OREGON WON. Their second straight BCS bowl game after the 2012 Rose Bowl breakthrough and a 12th game for the third consecutive season. This is universally expected to have been Chip Kelly's last game before moving to the NFL; he may have never won Oregon a national title, but after Thursday, it's fair to say he did everything else he possibly could for the program in his four short years as head coach.

WHAT KANSAS STATE LOST. No one at Kansas State will mourn slipping from 11-1 to 11-2 too intensely, not after the Big 12 title has already been won and Bill Snyder's collection of diamonds-in-the-rough had already overachieved so dramatically to make the Fiesta in the first place. But sending Klein and many other fantastic seniors off on such a sour note stings, and it stings all the more for the Wildcats now having lost their last five bowl games. Great regular season or not, winning this one would have been big.

FINAL BOWL GRADE. The first half was entertaining, with big plays on either side and some trickeration deployed by both coaches. But Oregon's 17-0 run over the second and third quarters sucked the life out of the game as the Wildcats never looked like they'd do more than nab some late consolation points. Grade: B-.
 
Geno Smith, Matt Barkley headline 2013 NFL Draft quarterbacks

By Bucky Brooks

Analyst, NFL.com and NFL Network

It's not a coincidence that the majority of coaches and general managers who were displaced from their jobs on "Black Monday" were tied to underachieving quarterbacks. The proper identification and development of a franchise signal-caller has always been a critical component of any successful long-term strategy for an organization. However, the instant impacts of Andrew Luck, Robert Griffin III and Russell Wilson, coupled with the emergence of Cam Newton and Andy Dalton as viable franchise playmakers, have made it even more important for decision makers to identify the right leaders for their respective teams.

This year, the playoffs will feature six quarterbacks in either their first or second NFL seasons. This postseason inclusion of so many young signal-callers will fuel the notion that a team must have a franchise QB in place to have a chance at a ring, as well as the idea that top teams build and develop their rosters around the play of the quarterback.

Given the importance of selecting the right guy and crafting a plan to ensure his success, scouts and coaches already are looking ahead to the 2013 draft class to see which players have the tools to rejuvenate a franchise and guide it back to prominence. Unfortunately, this year's class lacks the star power of 2011 and 2012. General managers and coaches will have to dig deep to identify the right guy for their respective organizations. Most importantly, they will need to adapt their plans and personnel to suit the strengths of their young quarterback.

Here is a look at the top five senior quarterbacks who will be available in the 2013 NFL Draft. I've also specified what I believe organizations must do to help them enjoy immediate success at the next level:

1) Geno Smith, West Virginia

Smith was one of the game's hottest quarterback prospects after a sizzling early-season run saw him put up ridiculous numbers directing the Mountaineers' high-powered attack. Smith dazzled scouts with his arm strength, accuracy and touch while displaying exceptional poise in the pocket. However, Smith faltered down the stretch against the tougher defenses of the Big 12; scouts started to have concerns about his ability to find his secondary options in the route progression when opponents take away his primary receiver with blanket coverage. He struggled to consistently identify the open receiver in games against Oklahoma, Kansas State and Texas Tech, a trend that continued in the New Era Pinstripe Bowl against Syracuse. Although Smith completed 66.7 percent of his passes with two touchdowns and zero interceptions, he was sacked three times and repeatedly looked confused when the Orange took away his No. 1 option. As a result, Syracuse blew out West Virginia, 38-14.

Plan for success: To capitalize on Smith's outstanding skills as a quick-rhythm pocket passer, an NFL offensive coordinator would be wise to incorporate several spread concepts. Bubble screens, slants and various seam throws are staples of the Mountaineers' offensive package, so using those routes as a foundation should help make Smith comfortable. In addition, the utilization of a play-action vertical passing game from the shotgun would create the big-play opportunities that Smith feasted on while directing Dana Holgorsen's offense.

Pro comparison: Jason Campbell

2) Matt Barkley, USC

When Barkley elected to return for his senior season, many expected him to win the Heisman Trophy, lead the Trojans to a national championship and make a compelling case to be the No. 1 overall pick in the 2013 NFL Draft. Barkley started the season like a house on fire, tossing 10 touchdown passes against only one interception in his first two games. He displayed poise, awareness and anticipation from the pocket while directing the Trojans' version of the West Coast offense. Barkley impressed scouts with his balanced distribution to multiple receivers and running backs, suggesting that he could defeat opponents by simply connecting the dots in the passing game. However, things started to unravel in a Week 3 loss to Stanford, with Barkley appearing to crumble under the intense pass rush from the Cardinal. He repeatedly made poor decisions against the blitz, resulting in a pair of interceptions and several negative plays. In addition, Barkley's lack of athleticism and questionable arm strength stood out as possible deficiencies at the next level. Those flaws continued to show up throughout the season, with Barkley tossing 15 interceptions, including nine in his final four games. Poor decision making and sub-standard physical tools were already spawning questions about Barkley's capacity to become a franchise quarterback in the NFL when a shoulder injury in the Trojans' Nov. 17 loss to rival UCLA sparked concern about his health and durability, particularly when he couldn't return for the Sun Bowl.

Plan for success: Barkley certainly is not a blue-chip talent based on his physical tools, but he has the capacity to develop into a franchise player, thanks to his exceptional anticipation, awareness and football IQ. Barkley is successful because he understands how to win the pre-snap phase of the game, and he gets the ball out of his hands quickly. From a schematic standpoint, Barkley lacks the big arm to play in a vertical passing game, but he is a superb game manager capable of stringing together completions on short and intermediate throws. Coaches who employ versions of the West Coast offense will appreciate Barkley's skill and willingly fit him into an offense that favors "dink and dunk" over the long ball. A team located in an area where weather could play a factor late in the year would likely harbor concerns about Barkley's arm strength. A franchise in a mild or warm climate would put Barkley in the best environment to succeed.

Pro comparison: Chad Pennington

3) Mike Glennon, North Carolina State

Glennon has generated significant buzz in the scouting community as a gifted pocket passer with A-plus arm talent. He has impressed scouts with his ability to make any throw to any area of the field with zip and velocity. In addition, Glennon shows exceptional arm strength, touch and accuracy on vertical throws. This combination of traits has thrust Glennon into the conversation as one of the top quarterbacks in the 2013 draft class. However, scouts have been reluctant to put him at the top of the board due to concerns about his decision-making under duress. Throughout the course of his career, Glennon has shown a propensity for throwing the ball to the other team when pressured, a trait that continued to be an issue in his senior season. Glennon finished the year with five games of two or more interceptions, including a three-pick debacle in the Music City Bowl loss to Vanderbilt. While Glennon earned positive marks for guiding the Wolfpack to a stunning win over a heavily favored Florida State squad in the middle of the season, the fact that he failed to perform well down the stretch leads to more questions about his poise under pressure. With a dismal bowl performance overshadowing the positives of Glennon's game, it is hard to get fired up about a mistake-prone playmaker taking over the reins in 2013.

Plan for success: There is no denying Glennon's natural talent as a classic drop-back passer. He can spin it better than most players in the game with exceptional zip and velocity. In addition, Glennon can push the ball down the field regardless of the conditions, because of his extraordinary arm strength and touch. To maximize Glennon's strengths, a coach has to be willing to feature a vertical passing game that places a premium on taking shots to outside areas of the field, exploiting one-on-one coverage on the perimeter. Interested teams should also have a legitimate speedster or two in the lineup to provide Glennon with a long-ball option on every play. Glennon could be a viable option for a team in need of a franchise quarterback if that team is willing to follow the blueprint used by the Baltimore Ravens to develop Joe Flacco.

Pro comparison: Joe Flacco

4) Tyler Wilson, Arkansas

Wilson was expected to blossom into a standout pocket passer under the tutelage of Bobby Petrino in 2013. NFL scouts hoped to see Wilson combine his outstanding physical skills with better footwork and fundamentals in his second full season as the Razorbacks' starting quarterback. But Petrino lost his job in April thanks to a well-publicized scandal, and his departure certainly affected Wilson's development.

While Wilson performed admirably for the Razorbacks amid the chaos (completing 62.1 percent of his passes for more than 3,300 yards with 21 touchdowns against 13 interceptions), he didn't appear to take another step in his development as a player. He continued to display sloppy footwork in the pocket, which greatly contributed to his spotty accuracy and ball placement. Scouts will spend a lot of time studying the 2011 tape to see Wilson at his best. However, the fact that he slightly regressed this season is understandable, given the circumstances. In fact, some evaluators might show some leniency in their grading and withhold their final evaluation until they examine his progress over the course of the week at a college all-star game. Given Wilson's talent, potential and performance in difficult circumstances, he is the quarterback in the class who most intrigues scouts and coaches.

Plan for success: Wilson looked like one of the top quarterbacks in this draft class heading into the 2012 campaign, based on his rapid development over the course of his junior season. He displayed all of the physical tools that scouts covet in franchise quarterbacks (outstanding arm talent and anticipation) as well as experience in a pro-style system, and evaluators expected him to continue improving as a playmaker from the pocket. To set the table for Wilson's success as a pro, a franchise must surround him with a coaching staff that stresses the fundamentals of playing the position. Wilson would also benefit from playing in a system designed to get the ball out of his hands quickly on an assortment of short and intermediate passes. Although Wilson has the ability to push the ball down the field, he was at his best directing Petrino's quick-rhythm system and could emerge as a legitimate franchise quarterback in a scheme that plays to his strengths as a quick decision maker.

Pro comparison: Matt Ryan

5) E.J. Manuel, Florida State

Manuel is arguably the biggest enigma of the 2013 quarterback class. He is chock full of blue-chip traits (size, athleticism and arm talent) but has been maddeningly inconsistent throughout his career. Manuel's up-and-down play continued in 2012 when he followed some spectacular performances (against Clemson and Boston College) with a few stinkers in key games (against North Carolina State and Florida). He has shown poor judgment under duress; scouts question his ability to read the field based on some pedestrian mistakes he's made with the ball. However, Manuel has also provided moments of brilliance as a dual-threat playmaker, including his dazzling performance against Northern Illinois in the Orange Bowl (26-of-38 for 291 passing yards with one touchdown, plus six rushes for 26 yards and another score). While evaluators are instructed to keep positive and negative performances in perspective, the fact that Manuel has been all over the board throughout the course of the season will lead scouts to question whether he can play at a winning level on a weekly basis in the NFL, despite his immense talent and potential.

Plan for success: Manuel has played in a pro-style offense at Florida State, but concerns about his ability to execute full-field reads should prompt coaches to give him a simplified playbook that allows him to process information quickly from the pocket. In addition, Manuel needs to play in a system that utilizes movement to capitalize on his athleticism and running skills. Bootlegs and roll-outs would task Manuel with reading just half of the field while also giving him the run/pass option to avoid negative plays. While some would suggest that it is impossible to simplify the game in this manner, the systems run in Houston, Washington and Seattle provide terrific examples of how the stretch-bootleg combination can be used by coaches to help their quarterbacks succeed.

Pro comparison: Josh Freeman
 
Lions', Raiders' coaching staffs will lead Senior Bowl teams

The coaching staffs of the Detroit Lions and Oakland Raiders will serves as the coaches for the 2013 Senior Bowl, it was announced Thursday.

Jim Schwartz and his Lions staff and Dennis Allen and his Raiders staff will prepare some of the nation's top senior prospects for the well-respected college all-star game, which will be played in Mobile, Ala. on Saturday, Jan. 26.

"The Senior Bowl is fortunate to have the Detroit Lions and Oakland Raiders as our coaching staffs this year," said Senior Bowl executive director Phil Savage. "Both organizations really watned to be here and will do a great job of coaching both of our outstanding rosters."

Schwartz has previous experience coaching in Mobile, having done so while a member of the Titans defensive coaching staff.

"I think there is some insight involved in getting to know those guys over a course of the week," Schwartz said. "And it can confirm some of our scouts' evaluations that have already worked very long and hard into getting guys evaluated this fall season. It can also maybe give us a different perspective on some other guys. Maybe we get a little bit more time with some other guys."
 
Geno Smith, Matt Barkley headline 2013 NFL Draft quarterbacks

By Bucky Brooks

Analyst, NFL.com and NFL Network

It's not a coincidence that the majority of coaches and general managers who were displaced from their jobs on "Black Monday" were tied to underachieving quarterbacks. The proper identification and development of a franchise signal-caller has always been a critical component of any successful long-term strategy for an organization. However, the instant impacts of Andrew Luck, Robert Griffin III and Russell Wilson, coupled with the emergence of Cam Newton and Andy Dalton as viable franchise playmakers, have made it even more important for decision makers to identify the right leaders for their respective teams.

This year, the playoffs will feature six quarterbacks in either their first or second NFL seasons. This postseason inclusion of so many young signal-callers will fuel the notion that a team must have a franchise QB in place to have a chance at a ring, as well as the idea that top teams build and develop their rosters around the play of the quarterback.

Given the importance of selecting the right guy and crafting a plan to ensure his success, scouts and coaches already are looking ahead to the 2013 draft class to see which players have the tools to rejuvenate a franchise and guide it back to prominence. Unfortunately, this year's class lacks the star power of 2011 and 2012. General managers and coaches will have to dig deep to identify the right guy for their respective organizations. Most importantly, they will need to adapt their plans and personnel to suit the strengths of their young quarterback.

Here is a look at the top five senior quarterbacks who will be available in the 2013 NFL Draft. I've also specified what I believe organizations must do to help them enjoy immediate success at the next level:
Do these comparisons seem "lazy" to anyone else? I don't do comparisons because a) it is very difficult b) is wildly inaccurate in my opinion; but these had me scratching my head. The guy comparable to Jason Campbell is better than the guy comparable to Matt Ryan? Seems off to me.
 
Geno Smith, Matt Barkley headline 2013 NFL Draft quarterbacks

By Bucky Brooks

Analyst, NFL.com and NFL Network

It's not a coincidence that the majority of coaches and general managers who were displaced from their jobs on "Black Monday" were tied to underachieving quarterbacks. The proper identification and development of a franchise signal-caller has always been a critical component of any successful long-term strategy for an organization. However, the instant impacts of Andrew Luck, Robert Griffin III and Russell Wilson, coupled with the emergence of Cam Newton and Andy Dalton as viable franchise playmakers, have made it even more important for decision makers to identify the right leaders for their respective teams.

This year, the playoffs will feature six quarterbacks in either their first or second NFL seasons. This postseason inclusion of so many young signal-callers will fuel the notion that a team must have a franchise QB in place to have a chance at a ring, as well as the idea that top teams build and develop their rosters around the play of the quarterback.

Given the importance of selecting the right guy and crafting a plan to ensure his success, scouts and coaches already are looking ahead to the 2013 draft class to see which players have the tools to rejuvenate a franchise and guide it back to prominence. Unfortunately, this year's class lacks the star power of 2011 and 2012. General managers and coaches will have to dig deep to identify the right guy for their respective organizations. Most importantly, they will need to adapt their plans and personnel to suit the strengths of their young quarterback.

Here is a look at the top five senior quarterbacks who will be available in the 2013 NFL Draft. I've also specified what I believe organizations must do to help them enjoy immediate success at the next level:
Do these comparisons seem "lazy" to anyone else? I don't do comparisons because a) it is very difficult b) is wildly inaccurate in my opinion; but these had me scratching my head. The guy comparable to Jason Campbell is better than the guy comparable to Matt Ryan? Seems off to me.
I thought the exact same thing.
 
'pacman_fl said:
Do these comparisons seem "lazy" to anyone else? I don't do comparisons because a) it is very difficult b) is wildly inaccurate in my opinion; but these had me scratching my head. The guy comparable to Jason Campbell is better than the guy comparable to Matt Ryan? Seems off to me.
Not exactly lazy. The "plan for success" portion tells a little bit about how a scheme fits their different skill sets. The right scheme would make all the difference between success and failure for a class like this.
 
Chance Warmack, Manti Te'o head top players in BCS title game

By Bucky Brooks

Analyst, NFL.com and NFL Network

The BCS Championship Game is always a must-see event for NFL scouts because it routinely features the best players in college football. Evaluators relish the opportunity to see prospects square off in this game because its speed and intensity mirrors the energy of an NFL contest. This not only provides scouts with a glimpse of the pro potential of these top prospects, but it showcases the poise and competitiveness of players on college football's biggest stage.

With a pencil and notebook in hand, here are 10 guys I will be watching closely on Monday night:

* Denotes underclassmen

1) Chance Warmack, OG, Alabama: It is uncommon for an interior blocker to sit atop any list of top prospects, but Warmack's talent is too good to ignore. Warmack is a mountain of a man with remarkable athleticism and movement skills. Most importantly, he is a physical blocker capable of moving defenders off the ball in the running game. With Warmack also adept at stalemating rushers in pass protection, there are few questions regarding his game. Bottom line: He is unquestionably the most pro-ready prospect in the BCS Championship Game.

2) Manti Te'o, LB, Notre Dame: Te'o answered all of the questions about his pro potential with a stellar senior season that showcased his capacity to dominate the game from the middle. Te'o led his team in tackles, generated nine takeaways (seven interceptions and two fumble recoveries) and seemingly had a hand in every big defensive play for the Fighting Irish. Given the importance of having an impact player at the heart of the defense at the next level, Te'o is another standout performance away from cementing his status as the top defensive prospect in the 2013 NFL Draft class.

3) Dee Milliner*, CB, Alabama: It is hard to find cover corners with the size, skills and toughness to be a factor against the run and pass on the perimeter. However, Milliner displays a rare combination of blue-chip traits that will make him a hot commodity in the scouting community. Milliner smothers receivers, showcasing superb technique and instincts in coverage. Although he is most effective in press coverage, he also displays the footwork and movement skills to shadow from distance. With few corners capable of matching Milliner's cover skills and overall game, scouts already envision him blossoming into a shutdown corner as a pro. Milliner might be the best cornerback prospect in America; a solid showing in the BCS title game would further this notion.

4) Tyler Eifert*, TE, Notre Dame: The tight end position has grown in prominence in recent years with more offensive coordinators opting to feature big, athletic playmakers as primary options in the passing game. Eifert possesses the tools to be the next tight end to transform the game at the next level. Eifert overwhelms defenders with his size (6-foot-6, 251 pounds), but also has the athleticism to blow past lumbering linebackers down the field. Brian Kelly capitalizes on his Eifert's skills by frequently aligning him outside as a quasi-receiver in most formations. While some scouts would like to see Eifert playing a more conventional role to better assess his blocking skills against the Crimson Tide's rugged defensive line, the opportunity for him to work in space against SEC competition could enhance his draft standing in the minds of scouts.

5) Jesse Williams, DT, Alabama: Williams hasn't received a ton of attention on the national scene, but scouts view him as one of the top interior defenders in college football. He is nearly impossible to move off the point, and his ability to occupy multiple blockers allows the Crimson Tide's linebacker corps to roam freely within the box. Although Williams isn't nearly as effective as a pass rusher, he has the capacity to create a push up the middle, which alters the launching point for the quarterback. In a game where pressure on the quarterback could be the deciding factor, Williams could boost his draft stock with a few disruptive plays as a pass rusher.

6) Louis Nix*, DT, Notre Dame: Nix already announced his decision to remain at Notre Dame for another season, but that won't stop scouts from closely monitoring his play in this game. He shows rare athleticism and movement skills for a man of his size, and evaluators are smitten by his ability to dominate the game on the interior. Facing a huge challenge in Warmack, Nix will have the opportunity to show scouts how well he could impact the game at the next level as a versatile defensive tackle.

7) Barrett Jones, C, Alabama: Jones is the consummate swing player on the offensive line with significant starts at center, guard and offensive tackle. He has developed into a solid pivot as a senior, but NFL scouts see his future as a long-term solution at offensive guard. Facing the stout but athletic front line of the Fighting Irish, Jones will get an opportunity to show evaluators how well he controls the line of scrimmage against NFL-caliber talent. If Jones can perform well despite dealing with a nagging injury that has limited his practice time heading into this matchup, scouts certainly will feel good about his chances of succeeding as an interior blocker in the NFL.

8) Stephon Tuitt*, DE, Notre Dame: Tuitt is still in the developmental stage of his career as a sophomore, but that hasn't stopped scouts from taking a close look at his overall game in the past year. Tuitt is a gifted edge player with outstanding athleticism and movement skills. He has shown the capacity to take over the game as a pass rusher, but coaches and scouts would love to see him dominate consistently from the corner. While he still has another year or two to refine his overall game, Tuitt can build a case to be included in the conversation as one of the top defenders in college football with a standout performance against the Crimson Tide.

9) Theo Riddick, RB, Notre Dame: Riddick's versatility has drawn the attention of NFL coaches and scouts searching for a third-down back with impact potential. Riddick spent ample time at receiver during his Notre Dame career and is a polished route runner with excellent hands and ball skills. He excels at winning one-on-one matchups in the slot; Brian Kelly will give him plenty of chances to work in space against the Crimson Tide to take advantage of his exceptional skills. In addition, Riddick has emerged as the team's most explosive runner between the tackles. Although he is not viewed as a potential workhorse as a pro, Riddick could create some buzz in scouting circles with a strong performance against Alabama.

10) Eddie Lacy*, RB, Alabama: Nick Saban has enjoyed a ton of success producing NFL backs capable of carrying the load as primary runners. Lacy is next in line based on his strong play since stepping into the starting role as a junior. Lacy rushed for 1,182 yards on only 184 attempts (6.4 yards a pop) with 16 touchdowns. Those numbers aren't eye-popping by today's standards, but they certainly are impressive when considering the fact that he is playing in an old-school offense that prefers smash mouth over finesse. Displaying the rough running style that NFL offensive coordinators covet in big backs, Lacy is squarely on the radar of evaluators looking for future workhorse runners.
 
2013 NFL Draft: Cotton Bowl Risers and Fallers

By Dane Brugler | NFLDraftScout.com Senior Analyst

January 5, 2013 12:18 am ET

This year's Cotton Bowl showcased a Heisman Trophy winning quarterback, the Big 12's all-time leading passer and several defensive prospects that will soon be playing in the league. But for NFL evaluators, this game contained three talented offensive tackles who could soon hear their name called in the first round of April's NFL Draft.

OT Luke Joeckel, Texas A&M (junior) – the Aggies' starting left tackle is not only NFLDraftScout.com's No. 1 draft-eligible offensive tackle for the 2013 NFL Draft, but also the No. 1 overall prospect. He isn't overly flashy, but extremely steady and consistent with NFL intangibles and physical tools for the pros. Listed at 6-6 and 310 pounds, Joeckel has started every game at left tackle the past three seasons and if the Cotton Bowl was his final collegiate game, he went out with a bang. His quarterback, freshman sensation Johnny Manziel, had all day to throw, run or figure out what he was going to do against the Sooners. Joeckel was able to anchor, mirror and adjust to handle Oklahoma's pass rushers while displaying a nasty demeanor in the run game, winning angles and sealing holes. The Kansas City Chiefs' biggest need isn't offensive tackle, but with Joeckel's ability, they'll definitely consider him with the No. 1 overall pick.

OT Jake Matthews, Texas A&M (junior) – For as good as Joeckel is on the left side, Matthews is equally as talented on the right side. While the Mannings have locked down a family legacy at quarterback, the Matthews family has produced numerous pro offensive linemen and Jake is the next in line. Against Oklahoma, he showed why some NFL scouts think he's actually the better pro prospect than his teammate at left tackle. Matthews set up quickly off the snap and got in the correct position, staying patient and jolting rushers at the point of attack. He also did a nice job blocking on the move and showed the mobility that leads many to believe he has the skill-set to play either left or right tackle. If he decides to enter the 2013 NFL Draft, Matthews should join Joeckel as a top-10 pick.

OT Lane Johnson, Oklahoma (senior) – While not nearly as well-known as the Aggies tackle tandem, Johnson isn't far behind Joeckel and Matthews in the minds of NFL scouts. He secured the left tackle position in 2012 for the Sooners and progressed with each game, culminating his collegiate career in the Cotton Bowl with an excellent individual performance. Johnson looked athletic and coordinated in his stance, staying balanced in space and doing damage at the second level. He was very aggressive as a run blocker, especially with his hands, but has shown he has room to improve with his technique. However, it's refreshing to see an offensive lineman with his mean streak and nasty attitude, especially when you consider he started his career as a quarterback before moving to tight end, then to defensive end, before finding his home at offensive tackle last season. Unlike Joeckel and Matthews, Johnson isn't a hot name right now, but with a strong showing at the Senior Bowl, he should cement his status as a first rounder and possible top-20 selection.

OTHER NOTES:

- A smart, tough receiver, Texas A&M senior WR Ryan Swope played well against the Sooners' tough secondary, finishing with eight catches for 104 yards and one touchdown. Swope showed why he's a very “QB-friendly” receiver, routinely working to get open with the toughness to work over the middle.

- Although he will bring a productive resume to the NFL, Oklahoma senior QB Landry Jones showed in the Cotton Bowl why scouts still have questions about parts of his game. On some throws, he flowed away from pressure and showed off his talented arm, delivering a strike downfield. But on other passes, he failed to correctly read the coverage and, with his relaxed throwing motion, was late delivering to the intended target. Jones has the size, arm and experience to be an early round draft pick, but his hot/cold decision-making, like in Friday's game, will push him down draft boards.

- Several prospects from this game will have a tough NFL decision to make over the next week. For the Aggies, it will be tough for Joeckel and Matthews to pass up the top-10 while junior DE Damontre Moore has already decided he's going pro. For Oklahoma, FS Tony Jefferson, WR Kenny Stills, FB Trey Millard and CB Aaron Colvin all project as NFL draft picks, but they will need to decide if they are ready now or need another year of seasoning in Norman.
 
Not a real endosement of skill set when you get compared to Campbell and Freeman.
Both were good prospects, both had flaws they never were able to correct.
Geno to Campbell is a terrible comparison. Campbell was a game manager at Auburn.
I like it from the standpoint of why Smith probably won't be a good pro -- he holds onto the ball way too long. IMO Campbell was similar -- a strong QB in most areas, but had no 'sense' of the defenders around him until he got hit.
 
NFL Draft prospects to watch in BCS Championship Game

Tony Pauline

Alabama

Chance Warmack, guard: Warmack approaches April as the most dominant guard in the draft since Steve Everitt, who was selected with the 14th pick in 1993. Warmack is big, strong and controls everything he gets his hands on. He's effective at the line of scrimmage or at the second level blocking in motion. Warmack will be an early first-round choice if no medical red flags are raised at the combine. 1st Round

DeMarcus Milliner, cornerback: Milliner is poised to be the third cornerback from Alabama selected in the first round of the draft since the 2010. He plays with great speed and explosiveness as well as strength, and consistently shuts down opponents. Milliner is incredibly quick moving to the action, whether covering the pass or defending the run. His instincts need to be polished, but the tools are available for the junior to quickly break into a starting lineup in the NFL. 1st Round

C.J. Mosley, outside linebacker: Mosley is a well-rounded linebacker and three-down defender who has displayed constant improvement on the field. He has the speed to pursue ball handlers and cut off the corners in run defense. His ball skills and ability in coverage rate with just about any linebacker in the nation. Mosley also shows terrific instincts and rarely makes mental errors. Despite grading out as a first-round pick, Mosley has stated he will return to Alabama for his senior season. 1st Round

Jesse Williams, defensive lineman: Williams is a former rugby player from Australia who has shown great progress on the football field the past two seasons. He's a large yet mobile athlete with the power required to defeat double-team blocks. Williams is impossible to move off the point of attack at nose tackle, and also shows pass rushing skills on the occasions he lines up at defensive end. He's intense, plays with pain and has the skill to quickly produce at the NFL level. 2nd Round

Barrett Jones, offensive lineman. Jones started at three different offensive line positions for Alabama, but his game took off after claiming the center spot last season. He's a smart, efficient blocker who gets the most from his ability. Jones has a great feel for blocking, possesses above average footwork and reminds many of New York Jets Pro Bowl center Nick Mangold. 2nd Round

Eddie Lacy, running back: Lacy was forced to share the rushing duties for the Tide this season, but made the most of his opportunities. He's a powerful runner who quickly gets through the openings of the offensive line, then breaks tackles or moves the pile. Lacy also displays vision and instincts in his game. He possesses the necessary tools to be a feature runner in the right offense. 2nd Round

Notre Dame

Manti Te'o, linebacker: The Heisman Trophy finalist slimmed down for his senior season and quickened the pace of his game. He developed into a three-down defender, improving his skills in pass coverage ,which nicely complemented his run stopping ability. Te'o is a solid prospect, though not in the class of Von Miller or Patrick Willis, recent linebacker prospects who have gone on to dominate in the NFL. 1st Round

Louis Nix, defensive tackle: Te'o may be the toast of the town, but scouts feel Nix is just as important to the Notre Dame defense. The junior is a versatile lineman with a complete game. He clogs the middle of the field, allowing teammates to make plays on the ball, or makes plays himself in backside pursuit and behind the line of scrimmage. Nix announced he will return to South Bend for his senior campaign and already projects as an early pick for the 2014 draft. 1st Round

Tyler Eifert, tight end: Eifert ranks as the No. 2 tight end on most draft boards and offers a complete game. He's a dominant blocker who aggressively moves defenders off the line and opens running lanes. Eifert also displays natural skills as a pass catcher. Word around South Bend is Eifert will enter April's draft. 1st/2nd Round

Zack Martin, offensive tackle: Martin is an outstanding pass protector on the left side and a lineman whose game took off this season. Fundamentally sound, he possesses the footwork and agility required of a left tackle. His run blocking needs improvement, but Martin already ranks as one of the top tackle prospects in the nation. 2nd Round
 
I haven't the slightest clue where Lacy ends up on my board because situation is going to be more important in this draft crop than any other one I can think of, but I'm going to have a hard time putting him in my top 5. He's...alright, but from a pure talent perspective he's not going to be in my top 30 at RB and his ceiling is pretty low too limiting future upside.

 
I haven't the slightest clue where Lacy ends up on my board because situation is going to be more important in this draft crop than any other one I can think of, but I'm going to have a hard time putting him in my top 5. He's...alright, but from a pure talent perspective he's not going to be in my top 30 at RB and his ceiling is pretty low too limiting future upside.
The last few years have taught me a lesson on situation when it comes to running backs.
 
I haven't the slightest clue where Lacy ends up on my board because situation is going to be more important in this draft crop than any other one I can think of, but I'm going to have a hard time putting him in my top 5. He's...alright, but from a pure talent perspective he's not going to be in my top 30 at RB and his ceiling is pretty low too limiting future upside.
The last few years have taught me a lesson on situation when it comes to running backs.
Agreed, this is why I said I don't have the slightest clue where he will end up on my board. I feel queezy about him in my top 5, but if he goes to...Atlanta? I'm in.
 
I haven't the slightest clue where Lacy ends up on my board because situation is going to be more important in this draft crop than any other one I can think of, but I'm going to have a hard time putting him in my top 5. He's...alright, but from a pure talent perspective he's not going to be in my top 30 at RB and his ceiling is pretty low too limiting future upside.
Alright? He has the footwork of players much smaller than him; speed too. From a talent perspective, he's a 1st round NFL draft pick in a league where RBs are going in the first less and less. He's a stud. Not in your top 30? Crazy talk.And for those that want to credit his offensive line - what about him making players miss? How many times did he create his own yardage last night? A lot.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
I haven't the slightest clue where Lacy ends up on my board because situation is going to be more important in this draft crop than any other one I can think of, but I'm going to have a hard time putting him in my top 5. He's...alright, but from a pure talent perspective he's not going to be in my top 30 at RB and his ceiling is pretty low too limiting future upside.
Alright? He has the footwork of players much smaller than him; speed too. From a talent perspective, he's a 1st round NFL draft pick in a league where RBs are going in the first less and less. He's a stud. Not in your top 30? Crazy talk.And for those that want to credit his offensive line - what about him making players miss? How many times did he create his own yardage last night? A lot.
Disagree about his speed, his feet and vision are his assets and the next time I see him create a play from nothing will be the first time. Although I like the leverage he runs with...but can he be a Marshawn/Gore type? or will his game suffer as he endures the pounding of the season? can he break NFL tackles between the hases consistently like those guys?Now that I'm writing it out his upside is a little higher (Marshawn/Gore) than I first thought, but there are a lot of 'if's' to overcome first to realize that upside. We had seen the breaking tackle and running through garbage ability from Marshawn and Gore...quite simply we haven't seen Lacy do it. Doesn't mean he can't, but it's a variable instead of an asset. Would be foolish to ignore.
 
Disagree about his speed, his feet and vision are his assets and the next time I see him create a play from nothing will be the first time.
There is a 1st, 2nd, 3rd, 4th, 5th, and 6th time for everything. You should check a few other Bama game highlights if you have time too.

 
I haven't the slightest clue where Lacy ends up on my board because situation is going to be more important in this draft crop than any other one I can think of, but I'm going to have a hard time putting him in my top 5. He's...alright, but from a pure talent perspective he's not going to be in my top 30 at RB and his ceiling is pretty low too limiting future upside.
Alright? He has the footwork of players much smaller than him; speed too. From a talent perspective, he's a 1st round NFL draft pick in a league where RBs are going in the first less and less. He's a stud. Not in your top 30? Crazy talk.And for those that want to credit his offensive line - what about him making players miss? How many times did he create his own yardage last night? A lot.
Disagree about his speed, his feet and vision are his assets and the next time I see him create a play from nothing will be the first time. Although I like the leverage he runs with...but can he be a Marshawn/Gore type? or will his game suffer as he endures the pounding of the season? can he break NFL tackles between the hases consistently like those guys?Now that I'm writing it out his upside is a little higher (Marshawn/Gore) than I first thought, but there are a lot of 'if's' to overcome first to realize that upside. We had seen the breaking tackle and running through garbage ability from Marshawn and Gore...quite simply we haven't seen Lacy do it. Doesn't mean he can't, but it's a variable instead of an asset. Would be foolish to ignore.
His upside is higher than Gore and Lynch, but he's just "alright"?
 
Disagree about his speed, his feet and vision are his assets and the next time I see him create a play from nothing will be the first time.
I don't watch highlights, I watch games. Highlights lie because they take the best of the best or the worst of the worst to create a story they want to tell. As I said in the CFB thread I think last night had more to do with unexpected awful play from ND's LB's than anything Yeldon and Lacy did. Opinions cannot be made based off one game one way or the other, it's a piece of the puzzle but it's just that a piece.
 
Disagree about his speed, his feet and vision are his assets and the next time I see him create a play from nothing will be the first time.
He's been doing it all year. What about the UGA game? He destroyed 2 of the best units in the nation in back-to-back weeks.I don't get what else Lacy has to do. It sounds like people are arguing against him being in the Peterson/McFadden/Richardson tier as a prospect, when nobody is really making those claims. He is a solid 1st round prospect, like Martin, Ingram, Mendenhall, Lynch, etc.

 
Last edited by a moderator:
I haven't the slightest clue where Lacy ends up on my board because situation is going to be more important in this draft crop than any other one I can think of, but I'm going to have a hard time putting him in my top 5. He's...alright, but from a pure talent perspective he's not going to be in my top 30 at RB and his ceiling is pretty low too limiting future upside.
Alright? He has the footwork of players much smaller than him; speed too. From a talent perspective, he's a 1st round NFL draft pick in a league where RBs are going in the first less and less. He's a stud. Not in your top 30? Crazy talk.And for those that want to credit his offensive line - what about him making players miss? How many times did he create his own yardage last night? A lot.
Disagree about his speed, his feet and vision are his assets and the next time I see him create a play from nothing will be the first time. Although I like the leverage he runs with...but can he be a Marshawn/Gore type? or will his game suffer as he endures the pounding of the season? can he break NFL tackles between the hases consistently like those guys?Now that I'm writing it out his upside is a little higher (Marshawn/Gore) than I first thought, but there are a lot of 'if's' to overcome first to realize that upside. We had seen the breaking tackle and running through garbage ability from Marshawn and Gore...quite simply we haven't seen Lacy do it. Doesn't mean he can't, but it's a variable instead of an asset. Would be foolish to ignore.
His upside is higher than Gore and Lynch, but he's just "alright"?
Either I write terribly or you are an awful reader.I said he was alright.I amended and said maybe his upside is a little higher than I thought at first.He could be Gore or Marshawn...not better than.But, again, absolute ceiling.Ceiling doesn't = expectations, it's a ceiling. Lots of players have a Gore/Marshawn ceiling and end up like Mendenhall, Beanie, Donald Brown, Blount, Shonn Greene, MB3, Addai, etc. Others are worse. And where is Lacy in the pass game? If he goes to a situation in which he has to pass pro and run routes can he do it now? if not, can he adapt?A lot more questions than answers imho.
 
Disagree about his speed, his feet and vision are his assets and the next time I see him create a play from nothing will be the first time.
UGA game changed when Saban said screw it and just ran at Jarvis Jones (not good vs. the run - gets caught playing too high and struggles in traffic), which then exposed a big weakness in Alec Ogletree's game. His ability to diagnose and fill run lane's. When Ogletree guesses well he looks like a monster, but when he doesn't he looks lost and gets buried out of the play.Up until Saban made that change the entire offense was stuck in neutral.

 

Users who are viewing this thread

Back
Top