Dynasty Value Discussion Thread (7 Viewers)

[Big Nate]

12 team TEP PPR, no D/ST start 10 format

Drafted well in the start-up but have had horrific schedule luck, 3x facing top team of the week to go 1-4. My TEs are Mason Taylor, Theo Johnson, and Fergusen & a competing team wants one of em.

I think my team is poised for a run next year, but I’m considering offering Ferguson + Devonte Smith for hurt Nabers.

My current WR room is Lamb, Deebo, DeSmith, AJB, DJM, Jamo and Calvin Austin.

I have no idea how to value Nabers fresh off the ACL, but I feel like this should be close? Might even offer DJM+TE. After losing Nabers, dude needs a WR, and he’s desperate for a TE.

Your thoughts on Nabers post-injury value? Is this an overpay? A Lowball?

Here's my take on Nabers and I've mentioned this in other threads.

If I'm competing, I'm selling Nabers ASAP. The reports of him being back for training camp next season are optimistic at best. Realistically he's probably back to top 3 WR form in 2027. I don't take less than full value for him right now. Even with the ACL tear, he's got name recognition and youth on his side.

If I'm not competing he's a hold. He has top 3 WR ceiling in 2027 with risk, obviously.


All that to say, I think your offer ideas boarder on lowball. Great on you if you can get it, though!

I agree with this. Also I think it is a bit of a lowball but if it gets you in the door I'd be willing to sweeten the pot a bit. Top 10 WRs don't come up often for trade so this is a time to kick the tires.

 

[InDitkaWeTrust]

Price check on Woody Marks. I have a team that could go either way, but should make the playoffs. 12-team, current RBs: Barkley, Dobbins, White, Carter, Marks, Gordon (start 2). Have been offered a projected mid 2026 2nd. KTC says he is valued at an early 2nd. Instinct is that it is not quite enough.

Reasonable trade. Guys who are willing to risk a future pick for a questionable talent rookie probably aren't the same guys with early picks. If it's me and I don't have much invested in him (his ADP was 4th round rookie draft), I'd probably sit him on my bench with the idea that he's probably going to incorporate into the offense a bit more making his value to you (and to potential trade partners) higher than a mid 2nd.

 

[Big Nate]

Long time lurker, first time poster here.

Was offered BTJ straight up for my George Pickens in SF Half PPR 12 Team Dynasty, but now the guy is hesitating. What's your take?

I’d probably deal Pickens for BTJ.

I'm not a big fan of 1 for 1 deals and usually try to avoid it unless say one is injured and I need a guy now. Having said that I agree that long term I would rather have BTJ than Pickens.

 

[Big Nate]

Price check on Woody Marks. I have a team that could go either way, but should make the playoffs. 12-team, current RBs: Barkley, Dobbins, White, Carter, Marks, Gordon (start 2). Have been offered a projected mid 2026 2nd. KTC says he is valued at an early 2nd. Instinct is that it is not quite enough.

It is hard to say with Marks - I want to see more long term. Probably early 2nd is proper value right now but that is because this could go any number of ways. From Marks getting more reps, carries, touches to Chubb still being the guy to Mixon eventually coming back and this being a 3 way backfield.

Getting a 2nd locks in the value and it will only go up as you get closer to your draft. Downside is you miss out on getting a first if he ends up the lead back. On the flip side is Marks is the 3rd back in this backfield and he's not worth a second.

I don't have a crystal ball. It is either hold and go the risky route hoping his value grows or lock in your gains and just be happy with a 2nd.

 

[FreeBaGeL]

12 team TEP PPR, no D/ST start 10 format

Drafted well in the start-up but have had horrific schedule luck, 3x facing top team of the week to go 1-4. My TEs are Mason Taylor, Theo Johnson, and Fergusen & a competing team wants one of em.

I think my team is poised for a run next year, but I’m considering offering Ferguson + Devonte Smith for hurt Nabers.

My current WR room is Lamb, Deebo, DeSmith, AJB, DJM, Jamo and Calvin Austin.

I have no idea how to value Nabers fresh off the ACL, but I feel like this should be close? Might even offer DJM+TE. After losing Nabers, dude needs a WR, and he’s desperate for a TE.

Your thoughts on Nabers post-injury value? Is this an overpay? A Lowball?

I like buying Nabers but this is a lowball and would likely do more damage to future talks for him than start negotiations imo.

 

[Big Nate]

12 team TEP PPR, no D/ST start 10 format

Drafted well in the start-up but have had horrific schedule luck, 3x facing top team of the week to go 1-4. My TEs are Mason Taylor, Theo Johnson, and Fergusen & a competing team wants one of em.

I think my team is poised for a run next year, but I’m considering offering Ferguson + Devonte Smith for hurt Nabers.

My current WR room is Lamb, Deebo, DeSmith, AJB, DJM, Jamo and Calvin Austin.

I have no idea how to value Nabers fresh off the ACL, but I feel like this should be close? Might even offer DJM+TE. After losing Nabers, dude needs a WR, and he’s desperate for a TE.

Your thoughts on Nabers post-injury value? Is this an overpay? A Lowball?

I like buying Nabers but this is a lowball and would likely do more damage to future talks for him than start negotiations imo.

I'd probably start by sending a message saying I see you need a WR and could use a TE. I have DJM or Smith available and a TE to trade.... Get the talks started before sending an official offer. Get him thinking about it that he can get 2 guys immediately to fill in and start if he is a contender. Than can bridge the gap from there. I agree it is low but no idea how close it could be already.

 

[BearsFan4Life]

How much do you have to add to Barkley to get Bijan these days?

Is Barkley, Bill and a 1st for Bijan an overpay or about right? Barkley and 2 -1sts

 

[BespokeJort]

Price check on Woody Marks. I have a team that could go either way, but should make the playoffs. 12-team, current RBs: Barkley, Dobbins, White, Carter, Marks, Gordon (start 2). Have been offered a projected mid 2026 2nd. KTC says he is valued at an early 2nd. Instinct is that it is not quite enough.

The price might be a first but I wouldn’t pay it if it is.

I’ll be wrong from time to time but sending first rounders for 24 year old late round rookie committee backs feels like a low percentage play. If you did it for Tracy last year you’re probably less than stoked about it now

EDIT: pretend I read your post in full and saw you were on the sell side

 

[Hot Sauce Guy]

I like buying Nabers but this is a lowball and would likely do more damage to future talks for him than start negotiations imo.

It is TEP (2 PPR for TE) and he has literally not one start-able TE.

They’re somewhat rare, especially the good ones.



For a healthy Nabers I agree, but a freshly torn ACL Nabers? I mean I know it’s a little low but I don’t see it as “destroy future tradelationships” low.

 

[Hot Sauce Guy]

I'd probably start by sending a message saying I see you need a WR and could use a TE. I have DJM or Smith available and a TE to trade.... Get the talks started before sending an official offer

Exactly what I did after this post last night, though you might have missed in my OP that he approached me for one of my TEs, and sounding desperate as hell.

 

[FreeBaGeL]

How much do you have to add to Barkley to get Bijan these days?

Is Barkley, Bill and a 1st for Bijan an overpay or about right? Barkley and 2 -1sts

I would easily pay that for Bijan but I don't think it's enough.

 

[Hot Sauce Guy]

How much do you have to add to Barkley to get Bijan these days?

Is Barkley, Bill and a 1st for Bijan an overpay or about right? Barkley and 2 -1sts

I would easily pay that for Bijan but I don't think it's enough.

Yeah, I think it’s off hy at least another 1st.

 

[BearsFan4Life]

How much do you have to add to Barkley to get Bijan these days?

Is Barkley, Bill and a 1st for Bijan an overpay or about right? Barkley and 2 -1sts

I would easily pay that for Bijan but I don't think it's enough.

Yeah, I think it’s off hy at least another 1st.

My roster can handle Barkley, Bill and 2 1sts .. worth a shot -- all they can say is no

 

[JoeJoe88]

How much do you have to add to Barkley to get Bijan these days?

Is Barkley, Bill and a 1st for Bijan an overpay or about right? Barkley and 2 -1sts

I would easily pay that for Bijan but I don't think it's enough.

Definitely. But as a Bijan owner, that’d be an easy reject. I’d say it’s short by at least a 1st.

 

[menobrown]

How much do you have to add to Barkley to get Bijan these days?

Is Barkley, Bill and a 1st for Bijan an overpay or about right? Barkley and 2 -1sts

Off top of my head seems light.

But I posted in the trade thread that Bijan was just traded for 3 firsts, Michael Carter and Tucker in one of my leagues, my biggest one. And if I look at that way:

The firsts might cancel out(depends where it's projected with one of these 3)

I could see someone trading Barkely or Bill individually for a first.

Carter and Tucker don't move any needles or matter much.

So in that sense, it seems ok to offer.

Also I think I made a major mistake not accepting the offer but before Bijan was traded in that league I was offered him for Judkins/Sampson and a first and passed. Had a whole lot of reasons for doing so, but I think I overly big brained it and blew it, maybe big time. Just relaying all of this to illustrate his trade market.

 

[Yambag]

Price check on Woody Marks. I have a team that could go either way, but should make the playoffs. 12-team, current RBs: Barkley, Dobbins, White, Carter, Marks, Gordon (start 2). Have been offered a projected mid 2026 2nd. KTC says he is valued at an early 2nd. Instinct is that it is not quite enough.

It is hard to say with Marks - I want to see more long term. Probably early 2nd is proper value right now but that is because this could go any number of ways. From Marks getting more reps, carries, touches to Chubb still being the guy to Mixon eventually coming back and this being a 3 way backfield.

Getting a 2nd locks in the value and it will only go up as you get closer to your draft. Downside is you miss out on getting a first if he ends up the lead back. On the flip side is Marks is the 3rd back in this backfield and he's not worth a second.

I don't have a crystal ball. It is either hold and go the risky route hoping his value grows or lock in your gains and just be happy with a 2nd.

Appreciate the feedback. I like to target rookie RB's in ambiguous backfields and am of the belief that Chubb does not have much left in the tank and feel like Mixon is not coming back this year. Doesn't mean Marks is the answer, but chances seem good and he has flashed a bit.

 

[waiver wire]

I am trying to decide to accept an offer as I am torn between a rebuild or acquiring a stud
I was a top team (never won)but got old over the last couple of years so blew it up
14 team 24 man roster dynasty
Start 1 qb , 1-2 rb, 3-4 wr , 1-2 te 1 k 1 def
rb .25 ppr
wr and te .5 ppr
rushing and receiving yards .1 for every 1 yard
6 pts for a td

I get
Justin Jefferson
I give
2026 1st (currently 1.1 and its the teams trading jj) ,2026 1st (mine & could be 1.4-1.10) and my 2027 1st
I would have no 2026 1sts and no 2026 2nds but still 1 2027 1st and 2 2027 2nds

my line up would be
Herbert
Hampton so woods or haskins while on IR
Achane
Jefferson (currently starting marquis brown)
Lamb (currently starting Kayshon Boutte)
Rice (currently starting jayden higgins)
Jake ferguson

I am the 4th lowest scoring team at this point of the season on average

A few of you commented on this and wanted to follow up
I rejected this trade a couple of days before I posted and was curious if I looked at this right. I had a plan to rebuild to acquire drafts picks which I hope would get me valuable players and depth. I just didn't want to reject a deal because i was to stubborn to change my my mind

When I 1st saw the offer, i thought it was an overpay as well but agreed with that owners thought process. I have lamb and you would have to overpay to get him off my roster.
With my current injuries and lack of depth , I also agreed with the comments about acquiring JJ wouldn't put me over the top this year and probably not even in 2027 but keeping all my 1st over the next 2 years could.
I also thought picks and hopefully 1.1 have way more value at the draft so I may pick something up when we draft

Thanks for all the input

 

[Intston]

Thank you all for the input regarding Pickens and BTJ, now I just need the guy to stop stalling. Although I feel Pickens is the stronger play this year as he has a functioning QB which helps me trying to contend for a title.

 

[Big Nate]

Price check on Woody Marks. I have a team that could go either way, but should make the playoffs. 12-team, current RBs: Barkley, Dobbins, White, Carter, Marks, Gordon (start 2). Have been offered a projected mid 2026 2nd. KTC says he is valued at an early 2nd. Instinct is that it is not quite enough.

It is hard to say with Marks - I want to see more long term. Probably early 2nd is proper value right now but that is because this could go any number of ways. From Marks getting more reps, carries, touches to Chubb still being the guy to Mixon eventually coming back and this being a 3 way backfield.

Getting a 2nd locks in the value and it will only go up as you get closer to your draft. Downside is you miss out on getting a first if he ends up the lead back. On the flip side is Marks is the 3rd back in this backfield and he's not worth a second.

I don't have a crystal ball. It is either hold and go the risky route hoping his value grows or lock in your gains and just be happy with a 2nd.

Appreciate the feedback. I like to target rookie RB's in ambiguous backfields and am of the belief that Chubb does not have much left in the tank and feel like Mixon is not coming back this year. Doesn't mean Marks is the answer, but chances seem good and he has flashed a bit.

If I owned Marks I am probably holding to see where it goes. Even if Chubb stays healthy Marks could keep improving and earn more play time. They do like the veteran so outside of injury I don't see Marks totally taking over (yet) but he's showing he can play in the NFL which is good.

 

[Raging weasel]

Have a contender that is short on WR depth due to injuries to Lamb and Evans. Going to try and trade for either MHJ or McConkey but can't decide which one to target. Ladd has better QB and team but MHJ has better chance at targets.
Which would you guys target?

 

[Big Nate]

Have a contender that is short on WR depth due to injuries to Lamb and Evans. Going to try and trade for either MHJ or McConkey but can't decide which one to target. Ladd has better QB and team but MHJ has better chance at targets.
Which would you guys target?

I would prefer Ladd but would depend on cost and how willing the person is to move them. Both young guys so even rebuilding teams might want to hang on. MHJ has massive upside but struggles at times. His QB situation isn't great either.

More target competition for Ladd this year but long term things look good.

MHJ has more upside for this year but also high bust potential. I think it really comes down to cost and which one you could realistically acquire.

 

[Hot Sauce Guy]

I'd probably start by sending a message saying I see you need a WR and could use a TE. I have DJM or Smith available and a TE to trade.... Get the talks started before sending an official offer

Exactly what I did after this post last night, though you might have missed in my OP that he approached me for one of my TEs, and sounding desperate as hell.

Update: He's gonna think it over and get back to me after the weekend. So that's not a no.

 

[roarlions]

Which do you prefer in a 12 team PPR league

Nabers or 2026 1.01 + Addison?

 

[Raging weasel]

Nabers. Addison isn't enough of an upside player to increase your odds of winning this year imo.

 

[kutta]

Which do you prefer in a 12 team PPR league

Nabers or 2026 1.01 + Addison?

Nabers and it’s not very close. That’s short at least another first.

 

[roarlions]

Which do you prefer in a 12 team PPR league

Nabers or 2026 1.01 + Addison?

Nabers and it’s not very close. That’s short at least another first.

It's interesting looking at a few trade calculators, they actually have that deal rated fairly close. Not sure how well they take into account the value of 2026 1.01 versus an early 2026 1st. The FBGs calculator actually has Nabers currently valued equal to Jeanty or Egbuka alone.

 

[InDitkaWeTrust]

Which do you prefer in a 12 team PPR league

Nabers or 2026 1.01 + Addison?

You didn't mention superflex, but in SF the 2026 1.01, likely the best QB in a good QB class, moves this into the 'pretty close' category.

 

[roarlions]

Which do you prefer in a 12 team PPR league

Nabers or 2026 1.01 + Addison?

You didn't mention superflex, but in SF the 2026 1.01, likely the best QB in a good QB class, moves this into the 'pretty close' category.

Sorry, not superflex