Blick
Footballguy
Pickens on a second contract really scares me. But assuming he either stays in Dallas or gets a WR1 contract and usage, I think I'd want a 1st on top of Pickens to make me think about it.
Fantasy Football - Footballguys Forums
This is a sample guest message. Register a free account today to become a member! Once signed in, you'll be able to participate on this site by adding your own topics and posts, as well as connect with other members through your own private inbox!
Dynasty Value Discussion Thread (4 Viewers)
- Thread starter spider321
- Start date
InDitkaWeTrust
Footballguy
Agreed. Not enough for ARSB. An early 26 1st or early to mid projected 27 1st has to enter the conversation before it's worthwhile. That's all assuming Jerry Jones does the right thing and extends Pickens ASAP. I'm not sure I want any part of Pickens if Jones slow plays the contract negotiations...
Boston
Footballguy
Agreed...that second piece needs to have more meat on it whether it is draft pick or picks or another good young player...Tracy doesn't move the needle at all in this type of deal...Pickens is such a tough one to evaluate in this type of deal...ARSB is as safe as you get as he checks all the Dynasty boxes...Pickens has been light's out this year and this could be the start of a string of huge years but there is still a bit of the fear of the unknown with him (especially when you are talking about trading ARSB for him)...you don't know where he will be playing next year or how he will be once he gets the big deal...due to that I would want to make sure that you get a second more substantial piece just in-case there is a worst-case scenario with Pickens next year.
TartanLion
Footballguy
Agreed guys, I have no interest whatsoever in Tracy. The guy even said ‘this is a starting bid’
It’s a TE premium league I removed Tracy and added Tyler Warren just to see what he does. Ultimately, I’m not really entertaining this unless there’s an overpay that helps me now and doesn’t damage the future. Pickens gives me availability and likewise scoring for this year, going forward Warren hopefully replaces Kelce and Pickens remains an adequate fill in for Amon-Ra.
Talking just right now, to me, Pickens just about looks like the best blend of height, power, speed and hands in the entire league. He literally looks imperious out there
It’s a TE premium league I removed Tracy and added Tyler Warren just to see what he does. Ultimately, I’m not really entertaining this unless there’s an overpay that helps me now and doesn’t damage the future. Pickens gives me availability and likewise scoring for this year, going forward Warren hopefully replaces Kelce and Pickens remains an adequate fill in for Amon-Ra.
Talking just right now, to me, Pickens just about looks like the best blend of height, power, speed and hands in the entire league. He literally looks imperious out there
Boston
Footballguy
On the flipside I wouldn't give up Warren and Pickens for ARSB...especially in TE-Premium...if you can add something in to get that done that could be a nice deal.
InDitkaWeTrust
Footballguy
Anyone considering a cash out on JSN? He's the one player on all my rosters that I've watched the least.
As always it depends on what you get offered. It would take a ransom for me to move him as he is the only game in town and he gets open at will. He should be a top 5 PPR WR for the next couple years. If you are not a contender and want to replenish the cupboard you can shop him and see what kind of return rolls in.
InDitkaWeTrust
Footballguy
Not a contender and #4 in the 2026 draft. SF, deep bench. Was offered Egbuka, Sutton, and a (likely late) 27 1st. Currently have 2 26 and 2 27 1sts. IMO, it's not enough, but Egbuka has me reconsidering.
It's not a bad offer but I do believe it's a little light. I would probably like another high pick as well. Can you counter with Egbuka, 2026 1st and 2027 1st or is that too aggressive?
BearsFan4Life
Footballguy
As a Sutton owner, I am trying to unload him. Egbuka and 2 1sts seems fair, but would depend on my roster construction
Speaking of Egbuka what is his value compared to Hampton. I asked it up thread and didn't get any responses. Any thoughts?
titusbramble
Footballguy
It's a little bit more for me. Wouldn't take much on top of Hampton for me to deal.
Blick
Footballguy
I’d want something small on top of Egbuka.
That’s what she said
Marauder
Footballguy
I'm not trading JSN unless offered a kings ransom. I traded for him a few weeks ago. Gave up Bucky, Golden, 26 1st (mid to late) for JSN and Kyle Williams. I'm happy with the deal.
kutta
Footballguy
I’ve been saying for a couple years now that I think JSN is a top tier stud. This year isn’t an anomaly. He’s in the class of Chase and JJ, and maybe better because he’s so young.
Unless you get a huge haul, I’d hang on. He’s the kind of dynasty player we all dream about.
eighsse2
Footballguy
Just thought this was funny. On the CBS app, one of the most recent articles is Heath Cummings' dynasty trade value list. And it includes 4 embedded spreadsheets listing the rankings for each position separately. Each embedded item is supposed to be a single tab from his spreadsheet. But two of them are the entire spreadsheet file. So you can actually go through all of his tabs and see miscellaneous rankings that I don't necessarily know what they all mean. One of the tabs is titled "Fav Massage Therapists", don't know what that's about -- OKAY OKAY THAT'S A JOKE, I MADE THAT ONE UP, don't sue me Heath!
Hurl Bruce
Footballguy
What value does Jacoby Brissett hold? Is there a non-zero chance he's the starter in AZ next season?
BearsFan4Life
Footballguy
I am holding just in case ... I would sell for something if I could, but way he is playing I am probably starting him over Dak in Semis with Daniels out for year.
BearsFan4Life
Footballguy
What's the value of CMC?
Swap Barkley for CMC or would you give up a 2027 1st for CMC?
Swap Barkley for CMC or would you give up a 2027 1st for CMC?
Hot Sauce Guy
Footballguy
Personally if I had JSN I’d consider that offer, but it’s not a godfather - I love Egbuka, but he’s probably less relevant with Godwin & Evans in the mix. His future is very bright though. The future 1st is nice, and always difficult to say it’ll be late as you never know what’ll happen to a team with regard to injury/schedule luck.
Maybe counter for that package + a 2nd?
I don’t think it’s that far off. I expect SEA to bring in another receiver as Kupp wasn’t it. Shaheed is getting more action as he gets comfortable in that offense. Not saying JSN won’t still be great, it’s just that it’s also difficult to project for future considerations we don’t yet know.
I think it’s a good opening salvo, at least.
What’s your rebuild strategy? JSN is still very young - he’s the kind of dude you build around. I agree with @Gally that you could counter for a bit more. Also Sutton is getting long in the tooth (30), so maybe counter for another young upside asset rather than Sutton.
sheerterror
Footballguy
All depends on the state of your roster. I've owned Cmc since his rookie year and am looking for my 4th chip in the last 7 seasons, so a 2027 1st is not worth it for my roster, nor would the lateral step of swapping for Barkely.
If my team is middling or rebuilding, then I think the 1st is a decent enough cashout given how quickly the value of these RBs depreciates. Still don't think I would move him for Barkley in this case as you are still sitting on another depreciating asset, except one now coming off a disappointing season, 1 year removed from a high mileage career year.
BearsFan4Life
Footballguy
I am not rebuilding as I will contend for some time
Daniels, Dak, Brissett
JTaylor, Barkley, JJacobs
Chase, Njigba, ARSB, Collins
McBride
Have to start 5 of the 7 in bold each week
The 2027 1st, have 2, probably don't help a ton
