Collins is off the table. Is Nix for Penix, Jerry Jeudy, and a 2027 (probably late) 1st fair?
I would not make that deal but it’s probably fair in a “trade calc” sorta way. But you’re getting 2 dimes and a nickel for a $.50 piece.
My position is that you’re the one taking the downgrade from Nix to Penix - every piece you add to the other side dilutes your value.
The originally proposed 2:2 was fair. Leaned your way, but Penix risk has value as well, whereas Nix is seemingly more secure. They might both be great, but as of this moment you’re giving up the best piece in this deal.
Nix for a risky QB2, an aging Jeudy on a bad browns team and a pick you can’t spend for 2 years (and a late 1st at that?!) seems like bad business to me. I’d hold firm on Penix+Nico, make it a 2:2 or tell them to pound sand.