What's new
Fantasy Football - Footballguys Forums

This is a sample guest message. Register a free account today to become a member! Once signed in, you'll be able to participate on this site by adding your own topics and posts, as well as connect with other members through your own private inbox!

Explosion in New York City (1 Viewer)

Thankfully I only had to deal with rain while trying to find the school bus for the first time.  I'm just glad that this guy seems to be a total dope. 
we keep saying he's a dope... and yeah- some bizarre choices for bomb placement. but he still was capable enough to make and place bombs that inflicted some (limited) harm and damage. hopefully the next one won't learn from his mistakes.

 
So they got a suspect in about 12-18 hours from the videos.  Good...no great job NYPD/FBI, et al.
:goodposting:

it's what we were hoping/assuming on saturday night in the previous thread.... just HAD to figure there'd be plenty of surveillance footage to see whoever did it. and they didn't even need 4chan/reddit's help.... I think.

 
Last edited by a moderator:
we keep saying he's a dope... and yeah- some bizarre choices for bomb placement. but he still was capable enough to make and place bombs that inflicted some (limited) harm and damage. hopefully the next one won't learn from his mistakes.
I just can't get beyond the whole placement thing.  There are thousands of better places to put the 23rd st bomb to inflict more carnage.  My only guess is there was enough police presence in more trafficked areas that he couldn't place them without being seen by police at that time of night.  Like many NYers, I know my friends and I have talked/thought about how the next one would happen, and I don't think any of us even thought of the dead part of 23rd and the flower district on a Sat night.

 
I just can't get beyond the whole placement thing.  There are thousands of better places to put the 23rd st bomb to inflict more carnage.  My only guess is there was enough police presence in more trafficked areas that he couldn't place them without being seen by police at that time of night.  Like many NYers, I know my friends and I have talked/thought about how the next one would happen, and I don't think any of us even thought of the dead part of 23rd and the flower district on a Sat night.
yeah... always assumed Union Sqare, or any of the busier transit hubs- either below or above ground. but probably (eta) harder to just leave a bag/package in a subway station and walk away without somebody seeing you, especially the busier ones that I just mentioned. it's probalby like you say- the guy was super paranoid about getting caught and chose the locations based on privacy and convenience.

and as we said before- the 27th st placement was even more bizarre for a saturday night. dunno if this is going to work, but I'm trying to link the google street of that block. what's shown is even more busy than what would be on a saturday night on that block- there's nothing there. 

 
Last edited by a moderator:
yeah... always assumed Union Sqare, or any of the busier transit hubs- either below or above ground. but probably 

and the 27th st placement was even more bizarre for a saturday night.
I'm guessing higher risk of being caught in more populated areas. The guy is a coward, thankfully more the half-measures type of #######.

 
I don't think so- at least based on the british crime dramas I've seen for tv and film. but ubiquitous enough.
They're more numerous in the past couple of years.  In the old thread I alluded to it, but they're now at least every major east-west intersection in Manhattan and frankly at a lot more.  Every non-brownstone residential building or hotel has them as well and most major-ish businesses. 

Put it this way...23rd has cameras everywhere.  The EastVillage/LES maybe not. 

 
I'm guessing higher risk of being caught in more populated areas. The guy is a coward, thankfully more the half-measures type of #######.
agree. I finished my thought in the quoted post above.

I think the only way this works with maximum damage is if the perp(s) blow themselves up.

 
Surveillance cameras are, apparently, more ubiquitous than I thought.  Have we caught up to London in this regard?
In DC there aren't even cops visible anymore. It's all eye in the sky stuff. A couple cops at the NE corner of the WH fence and a couple at the NW corner. With all the Fed buildings in that area you can walk in any direction and not see any police presence. But every square inch is covered.

 
I'm guessing higher risk of being caught in more populated areas. The guy is a coward, thankfully more the half-measures type of #######.
That's the part that made/makes no sense though...23rd is a major street these day even where the bomb was placed.  Now granted if you go a block east of where he was and you get to the Flatiron area which has Eataly, Lego Store, load of people outside eating at Shake-Shack, a whole host of other restaurants, etc.  A block to the west and you get into the start of Chelsea proper which leads into the High Line.  So, he put the bomb was basically smack-dab in the middle of two highly populated areas at 8:30 on a Saturday night.

Basically you put a bomb on 23rd, you're going to get caught.

 
I just can't get beyond the whole placement thing.  There are thousands of better places to put the 23rd st bomb to inflict more carnage.  My only guess is there was enough police presence in more trafficked areas that he couldn't place them without being seen by police at that time of night.  Like many NYers, I know my friends and I have talked/thought about how the next one would happen, and I don't think any of us even thought of the dead part of 23rd and the flower district on a Sat night.
Maybe he didn't want to hurt anybody but just wanted to send a message? 

 
They're more numerous in the past couple of years.  In the old thread I alluded to it, but they're now at least every major east-west intersection in Manhattan and frankly at a lot more.  Every non-brownstone residential building or hotel has them as well and most major-ish businesses. 

Put it this way...23rd has cameras everywhere.  The EastVillage/LES maybe not. 
pretty sure they're down here too.

I was mostly referring to what appears- based on what has to be zingingly accurate depictions of London- in tv shows that london cops have banks of surveillance cameras that they rely on to catch the bad guys in live-action. I haven't seen that happen on law and order yet.

 
SaintsInDome2006 said:
Haven't they already done so? Maybe we're talking Obama and Hillary here? Because NYPD and DHS already have a suspect and are commenting. 
Having a suspect is the same as speculation and jumping to conclusions in the context of what was said here?  Id disagree.

 
Last edited by a moderator:
sho nuff said:
How so? Tims point was on point.  Leaders shouldont be in the media speculating when facts are not out yet.
Have they ever shown the same reserve in a mass shooting incident? Did they need all the facts before calling for gun control

 
That's the part that made/makes no sense though...23rd is a major street these day even where the bomb was placed.  Now granted if you go a block east of where he was and you get to the Flatiron area which has Eataly, Lego Store, load of people outside eating at Shake-Shack, a whole host of other restaurants, etc.  A block to the west and you get into the start of Chelsea proper which leads into the High Line.  So, he put the bomb was basically smack-dab in the middle of two highly populated areas at 8:30 on a Saturday night.

Basically you put a bomb on 23rd, you're going to get caught.
an article in the LA times interviewed the woman who found the second bomb...

Like other New Yorkers, Schreibman is stumped about the motivation of the bomber. West 27th Street, where she has lived for more than three decades, is a nondescript street a few blocks south of Penn Station, not as fashionable as Chelsea a few blocks to the south.

Her street has a new hotel, but is mostly home to distributors of garments and cheap manufactured goods. Most of the storefronts are emblazoned with ads, in Chinese and Korean, for wholesale underwear and socks, pocketbooks and watches. Schreibman said the bomb had been placed in front of an office building, in a dark location under scaffolding.

“This is the weirdest block,” she said. “I am still wondering: Why here?”

 
leitmotif seems to be: quiet protected area, under scaffolding/side-walk sheds. 

extrapolating to sammy's earlier thought is pretty clear... the guy was more scared of being seen than wanting to inflict maximum damage.

 
Ditkaless Wonders said:
I worry about N.Y.  So many folks close together, so many iconic targets, so much media presence to get news out.  Stay safe Big Apple.
There are parts of my commute in the morning that are just scary.  Hundreds, perhaps thousands of people boxed into tight quarters, all funneling out of commuter trains at peak rush hour and waiting in massive lines to get up stairs/escalators to street level (through exits that just weren't designed to accommodate that kind of volume way back when).  I often wonder not if, but when one of these lunatics will attack in that context.  I wonder whether someone could just stroll in off the street and do that, or if whether, perhaps, our military and police have such incredible technology that they could somehow prevent that or see it coming from a mile away, despite all the chaotic foot traffic from hundreds of thousands of people in all directions.  I often wonder when something like that will happen.  And of course we have lives to lead, and jobs to work, and we just need to go about our routines, hoping that it doesn't happen, or hoping we're just not there -- and too many people aren't in the vicinity -- if something actually does happen.

Hoping they catch this guy swiftly, waterboard him into oblivion as he spills every bit of useful intel he's got, and then put him in a cage with no light for the next 60 years. 

 
Last edited by a moderator:
an article in the LA times interviewed the woman who found the second bomb...
Chaos? Does there need to be another explanation? I get that part of the investigative process is the why/where etc, but how can we be expected to understand the motivations of people intent on tearing our country apart at any cost?

 
I should add, while the explosives/suicide bomb scenario in the NYC transit system scares the jesus out of me, the active shooter scenario scares me a whole lot less.  These days we are jam packed with guys in full military fatigues and assault rifles, and elite NYPD units similarly geared up.  If anyone strolls into Penn Station or Grand Central and starts shooting, that guy/those guys would be taken down swiftly.  I just don't see that kind of attack leading to mass casualties given the protective force we have in place at each of these locations.

 
Chaos? Does there need to be another explanation? I get that part of the investigative process is the why/where etc, but how can we be expected to understand the motivations of people intent on tearing our country apart at any cost?
that bag, a block this way or that, actually inflicts damage and causes genuine chaos- because it would be around a place with people and not a shut-down area without them.

of course bombs placed in a major city causes chaos- we're all questioning and talking about the inanity of putting them in the most densely populated city, but then doing your best to avoid the density or population.

 
The speed in which they have determined who this guy is, mainly due, we are being told, to technology, is heartening. We may have a long way to go yet, but it seems to me we are getting better at combatting terrorism all the time. 

 
There are parts of my commute in the morning that are just scary.  Hundreds, perhaps thousands of people boxed into tight quarters, all funneling out of commuter trains at peak rush hour and waiting in massive lines to get up stairs/escalators to street level (through exits that just weren't designed to accommodate that kind of volume way back when).  I often wonder not if, but when one of these lunatics will attack in that context.  I wonder whether someone could just stroll in off the street and do that, or if whether, perhaps, our military and police have such incredible technology that they could somehow prevent that or see it coming from a mile away, despite all the chaotic foot traffic from hundreds of thousands of people in all directions.  I often wonder when something like that will happen.  And of course we have lives to lead, and jobs to work, and we just need to go about our routines, hoping that it doesn't happen, or hoping we're just not there -- and too many people aren't in the vicinity -- if something actually does happen.

Hoping they catch this guy swiftly, waterboard him into oblivion as he spills every bit of useful intel he's got, and then put him in a cage with no light for the next 60 years. 
that's the scenario I've always imagined being next.

but so far we've had this, and off the top of my head (bad memory) the guy who left his car full of explosives near times square. that one would've been absolutely horrible if it had worked... and given times square location, makes "terror sense".

 
There are parts of my commute in the morning that are just scary.  Hundreds, perhaps thousands of people boxed into tight quarters, all funneling out of commuter trains at peak rush hour and waiting in massive lines to get up stairs/escalators to street level (through exits that just weren't designed to accommodate that kind of volume way back when).  I often wonder not if, but when one of these lunatics will attack in that context.  I wonder whether someone could just stroll in off the street and do that, or if whether, perhaps, our military and police have such incredible technology that they could somehow prevent that or see it coming from a mile away, despite all the chaotic foot traffic from hundreds of thousands of people in all directions.  I often wonder when something like that will happen.  And of course we have lives to lead, and jobs to work, and we just need to go about our routines, hoping that it doesn't happen, or hoping we're just not there -- and too many people aren't in the vicinity -- if something actually does happen.

Hoping they catch this guy swiftly, waterboard him into oblivion as he spills every bit of useful intel he's got, and then put him in a cage with no light for the next 60 years. 
I hate the ny and DC subways as a tourist. Even as it is wildly more expensive I take an uber everywhere. Just for convenience sake. Obviously not doable as a daily commuter. 

 
Regarding the location of the bombs, there is a PATH train station right there.  If the suspect is the guy, he probably rolled in from Jersey on the train and planted the first bomb as soon as he hopped of the train. Scary that he was probably on the train with at least two bombs.  But clearly he didn't want to die in an explosion.  

 
The bozo from Somalia who had the knife in St. Cloud, MN was shot by an off duty policeman who of course was carrying.  Right place at the right time with the right equipment.

Kudos to the shooter or it could have been bad.

 
The bozo from Somalia who had the knife in St. Cloud, MN was shot by an off duty policeman who of course was carrying.  Right place at the right time with the right equipment.

Kudos to the shooter or it could have been bad.
has there been more info about the knife-guy? hope the wounded there are ok- and yeah, glad this was dealt with as quickly as it was.

 
Regarding the location of the bombs, there is a PATH train station right there.  If the suspect is the guy, he probably rolled in from Jersey on the train and planted the first bomb as soon as he hopped of the train. Scary that he was probably on the train with at least two bombs.  But clearly he didn't want to die in an explosion.  
Nice theory, except the PATH train was only going to WTC this weekend.  Nothing north of there.  

http://www.panynj.gov/path/33rdstreetlineclosures.html?utm_source=twitter_pathtrain&utm_medium=tweet&utm_campaign=33rd_Street_Line_Weekend_Service_Suspension

 
Last edited by a moderator:
I wonder if this was a scenario where the FBI was already monitoring and knew about the bomb from the beginning.
I hesitate to ask... but why would they allow a bomb to go off in the middle of nyc? this seems like a pretty far-fetched scenario, IMO.

 
Good, #### this guy... 

Nobody died, suspect in custody (alive) in less than 2 days - You can't ask for a better outcome from a terror attack. 

 
Last edited by a moderator:
just read an article- think it was CNN- where they're talking about a "cell". that's ####### troubling.

A few blocks away from the blast site and shortly after the explosion occurred, investigators found a pressure cooker on 27th street with dark-colored wiring sticking out, connected by silver duct tape to what appeared to be a cell phone, officials said.
Surveillance video shows a man dragging what appears to be a duffel bag with wheels near the site of the West 23rd street explosion about 40 minutes before the blast, according to multiple local and federal law enforcement sources.
About 10 minutes later, surveillance video shows the same man with what appears to be the same duffel bag on West 27th street, multiple law enforcement sources said.

In the video, the man leaves the duffel bag where police later found the unexploded pressure cooker. After he leaves, the video shows two other men removing a white garbage bag believed to contain the pressure cooker from the duffel bag and leaving it on the sidewalk, according to a senior law enforcement official and another source familiar with the video.





 


 



Investigators have not determined if those two men are connected to the man with the duffel bag on both streets, the sources said.
The device was transported to the NYPD Bomb Squad facility at Rodman's Neck Range in the Bronx.
NYPD and FBI Bomb technicians rendered the device safe. A forensic examination of the device and its components will be conducted at the FBI Laboratory at Quantico, Virginia.


 
Last edited by a moderator:
Any chance this is one of those response-time operations? A pre-attack exercise to see how USLE officials are responding to acts like these? Is that something that happens? Serious question. 

 
just read an article- think it was CNN- where they're talking about a "cell". that's ####### troubling.
I'm sure there is a lot of info we aren't being told (and prob shouldn't) as they're doing their digging right now. 

This guy doesn't appear to be the brightest and I'd hope law enforcement can connect dots with anyone he might be involved with. 

 
Suspect shot and taken to hospital. This is one time I hope it doesn't die so they can find the bigger cell if he's part of one. 

 
Any chance this is one of those response-time operations? A pre-attack exercise to see how USLE officials are responding to acts like these? Is that something that happens? Serious question. 
wife and I both thought the same thing. no idea if that happens.

 
The speed in which they have determined who this guy is, mainly due, we are being told, to technology, is heartening. We may have a long way to go yet, but it seems to me we are getting better at combatting reacting to terrorism all the time. 
I mentioned the car with explosives at times square... I intentionally didn't mention all the arrests made over the years where people are taken in talking about or attempting to put together this kind of thing. 

 

Users who are viewing this thread

Back
Top