Game Thread - Wildcard - Carolina V NY Giants (1 Viewer)

[wilked]

No challenge on the Goings fumble?

down by contact, unchallengable

The top rule I'd like to see something done about - this "down by contact" is weak.Not sure what the change I suggest is, but something should be done. And 'letting the play continue' and saying a challenge can fix an injustice - also weak. Lost timeouts and challenges can haunt you.

Be sure to get back to us when you have some idea on how to fix it

Should we start a poll?Wilked contributes something or the Giants score..... which happens first?

link to poll?

 

[Keys Myaths]

No challenge on the Goings fumble?

down by contact, unchallengable

The top rule I'd like to see something done about - this "down by contact" is weak.Not sure what the change I suggest is, but something should be done. And 'letting the play continue' and saying a challenge can fix an injustice - also weak. Lost timeouts and challenges can haunt you.

Be sure to get back to us when you have some idea on how to fix it

Should we start a poll?Wilked contributes something or the Giants score..... which happens first?

He's the Cakeboy champion, though!

And he must be upset at ANOTHER interception.

 

[jeff_eaglz]

No challenge on the Goings fumble?

down by contact, unchallengable

The top rule I'd like to see something done about - this "down by contact" is weak.Not sure what the change I suggest is, but something should be done. And 'letting the play continue' and saying a challenge can fix an injustice - also weak. Lost timeouts and challenges can haunt you.

Be sure to get back to us when you have some idea on how to fix it

i think they could change possession without allowing a return on those plays.

Not a bad start, still doesn't clear up the challenge / timeout rule.

 

[Wildcat]

Eli looking great.

 

[Johnny Ice]

Eli = Pick Machine

 

[Grace Under Pressure]

Not so good.

 

[bostonfred]

Maybe Eli does have a little bit of his big brother in him.

Here, I helped highlight the key part of that statement.

Actually, after that pick, I think it might be a big bit.

 

[wilked]

No challenge on the Goings fumble?

down by contact, unchallengable

The top rule I'd like to see something done about - this "down by contact" is weak.Not sure what the change I suggest is, but something should be done. And 'letting the play continue' and saying a challenge can fix an injustice - also weak. Lost timeouts and challenges can haunt you.

Be sure to get back to us when you have some idea on how to fix it

Should we start a poll?Wilked contributes something or the Giants score..... which happens first?

He's the Cakeboy champion, though!

And he must be upset at ANOTHER interception.

why would that upset me?

 

[MeVsMaradona]

Good game Panther fans you guys deserve to win if you hold the lead. This is not our team.

 

[smcindoe]

Giants need to challenge that INT.

 

[Ghost Rider]

Carolina is looking like they did in the playoffs two years ago. And they seem to better on the road, so they are a very dangerous team right now.

 

[NorvilleBarnes]

Not many new babies will be named Eli this year.

 

[Keys Myaths]

Good game Panther fans you guys deserve to win if you hold the lead. This is not our team.

Another team is wearing Giants' uniforms today?What the hell?

 

[bostonfred]

Not many new babies will be named Eli this year.

 

[Genester]

Maybe Eli does have a little bit of his big brother in him.

Here, I helped highlight the key part of that statement.

Actually, after that pick, I think it might be a big bit.

The "big bit" actually completes passes and produces before choking. The little bit skips straight to the final step.

 

[yellowdog]

Giants need to challenge that INT.

If by challenge, you mean they should waste a timeout for no apparent reason, then I agree.

 

[cowboyz]

dang why couldn't the cowboys have gotten wahle instead of rivera

 

[Johnny Ice]

Foster is going off.

 

[Courtjester]

Great job Foster. Where were you when I needed you this FF year???

 

[Keys Myaths]

Welcome to Giants Stadium, boobirds.

 

[jeff_eaglz]

Apparently the Giants defense was watching the KC defense tackling film.....

 

[Ghost Rider]

This is ugly. Nothing like seeing a team get their asses handed to them on their home field.

 

[MeVsMaradona]

We cant Tackle,we cant pass, we cant run, we cant stop the run, we cant stop the pass, we cant catch a break on ST...

 

[Brewtown]

Giants are done! Here comes the Dagger!

 

[MeVsMaradona]

Pushing off is legal?

 

[Ghost Rider]

Apparently the Giants defense was watching the KC defense tackling film.....

 

[jwvdcw]

that was a terrible pushoff. I hate how they call defensive PI all the time but not offensive...it should be equal.

 

[snorlax]

Good non-call there.

 

[NorvilleBarnes]

Yeah, that was pushing off - but I hate the excessive campaigning for a flag.

 

[jeff_eaglz]

Colbert stole one.

 

[wilked]

Awful officiating

 

[Genester]

Come on, lets get Steve Smith another TD here!<Giddy Steve Smith play-off owner>

 

[simey]

Good game Panther fans you guys deserve to win if you hold the lead. This is not our team.

i'm very surprised at how poorly the giants are playing today. i'm glad the panthers are ahead, but i was not expecting this.

 

[Routilla]

Very surprising that the Panthers are just blasting the G-Men in NY. I can't imagine how many people bet on the NYG in this one. Will it be a shut-out?

 

[jeff_eaglz]

Pushing off is legal?

Ask Michael Irvin. He'll ramble on about "physical receivers".

 

[jeff_eaglz]

Awful officiating

That's an understatement..... but at least the better team is winning today.

 

[fatness]

What happened to the Giants? They haven't played this badly all year. Good grief.

 

[wilked]

Awful officiating

That's an understatement..... but at least the better team is winning today.

TrueThe only question left is shutout or no?

 

[smcindoe]

If by challenge, you mean they should waste a timeout for no apparent reason, then I agree.

You think they'll need it?Would have been worth a shot... DB seemed to have possession, ball touches the ground, then he readjusts his hold on it. I've seen that overturned. And since it was a season-killing INT, what are you saving the challenge for?

 

[Grace Under Pressure]

DB's licking their chops...

 

[fatness]

OK, I missed this one. Nick Goings at QB?1-20-NYG 21 (15:00) N.Goings sacked at NYG 30 for -9 yards (A.Jackson).3-26-NYG 27 (13:47) N.Goings pass incomplete to K.Colbert.

 

[gman8343]

Awful officiating

That's an understatement..... but at least the better team is winning today.

TrueThe only question left is shutout or no?

Maybe a garbage time TD to Shockey or Burress, or maybe two more Eli INTs instead.

 

[MeVsMaradona]

Nice day for a come back? Maybe redemption for SF game.

 

[jeff_eaglz]

If by challenge, you mean they should waste a timeout for no apparent reason, then I agree.

You think they'll need it?Would have been worth a shot... DB seemed to have possession, ball touches the ground, then he readjusts his hold on it. I've seen that overturned. And since it was a season-killing INT, what are you saving the challenge for?

Good point.

 

[Genester]

Nice day for a come back? Maybe redemption for SF game.

THAT would be the most amazing turn around I've ever seen, short of the Frank Reich Buffalo comeback against the Oilers.

 

[MeVsMaradona]

OK, I missed this one. Nick Goings at QB?

1-20-NYG 21 (15:00) N.Goings sacked at NYG 30 for -9 yards (A.Jackson).

3-26-NYG 27 (13:47) N.Goings pass incomplete to K.Colbert.

Yeah he didnt pass it though just ran out of bounds, noone open.

 

[jeff_eaglz]

OK, I missed this one. Nick Goings at QB?

1-20-NYG 21 (15:00) N.Goings sacked at NYG 30 for -9 yards (A.Jackson).

3-26-NYG 27 (13:47) N.Goings pass incomplete to K.Colbert.

Halfback option. Stepped OB rather than throw.

 

[MeVsMaradona]

I can smell it...

 

[jeff_eaglz]

Nice day for a come back? Maybe redemption for SF game.

Who's the backup? The bachelor?

 

[bostonfred]

Tiki Barber is the best player on this team. They should be using him more.