Getcha passports ready - the middle-aged dummies are going to the British Isles! Top 31 song countdown. (19 Viewers)

[Dr. Octopus]

What was your favorite new-to-you song?

Catch the Sun - Doves
Common People - Pulp
Another Sunny Day - Belle and Sebastian

 

[DrIanMalcolm]

I had twelve songs nobody else selected, only one of which (Changes by David Bowie) was a surprise. Yet due to the fact that my list included 6 of the group's top ten (Gimme Shelter, Into the Mystic, Comfortably Numb, A Day in the Life, Solsbury Hill and Waterloo Sunset), I ended up as the third chalkiest.

By these standards:

* 2 of the top 10 songs
* I appear to have 11 songs not shared w/ anyone, tho I believe it's 10.

Per the 'chalk list,' (someone explain to me?), I end up mid-pack, less chalky than Pip, which makes no sense at all, given he's forgotten more about music in the last week than I've known in my lifetime.

Looking forward to the "countries that have not been the primary source of imperialism in the last 200 years" contest.

 

[Pip's Invitation]

I had twelve songs nobody else selected, only one of which (Changes by David Bowie) was a surprise. Yet due to the fact that my list included 6 of the group's top ten (Gimme Shelter, Into the Mystic, Comfortably Numb, A Day in the Life, Solsbury Hill and Waterloo Sunset), I ended up as the third chalkiest.

Per the 'chalk list,' (someone explain to me?)

Remember how each song got a point total? So if a song got a first-place vote for 31 points, a second-place vote for 30 points, and no other votes, it would have a point total of 61. Adding up the point totals of all the songs you picked gives you your chalk score. A higher score means you had a lot of songs that were picked (and probably ranked high) by other people, so your list is "chalk," and a lower score means most of your picks were not picked by others, so your list is "not chalk." We were both in the middle.

 

[Dr. Octopus]

@timschochet made me a lot chalkier by taking two songs I figured would end up only on my list, Let My Love Open the Door and Loving Cup.

 

[Pip's Invitation]

@timschochet made me a lot chalkier by taking two songs I figured would end up only on my list, Let My Love Open the Door and Loving Cup.

Speaking of which, Let My Love Open the Door was the only Townshend solo song to appear. I thought we might see more from Rough Mix, Empty Glass, All the Best Cowboys... and/or White City. But everyone went all-in on The Who instead.

Similarly, only one Robert Plant solo song, Big Log, appeared, despite him having a successful post-Zep career.

 

[Pip's Invitation]

This thread is 197 pages vs. 103 for the US thread.

 

[Andy Dufresne]

Similarly, only one Robert Plant solo song, Big Log, appeared, despite him having a successful post-Zep career.

I dig In The Mood.

 

[zamboni]

This thread is 197 pages vs. 103 for the US thread.

The British pound has strengthened versus the US dollar.

 

[krista4]

Similarly, only one Robert Plant solo song, Big Log, appeared, despite him having a successful post-Zep career.

I dig In The Mood.

I love that one.

 

[Chaz McNulty]

I had twelve songs nobody else selected, only one of which (Changes by David Bowie) was a surprise. Yet due to the fact that my list included 6 of the group's top ten (Gimme Shelter, Into the Mystic, Comfortably Numb, A Day in the Life, Solsbury Hill and Waterloo Sunset), I ended up as the third chalkiest.

By these standards:

* 2 of the top 10 songs
* I appear to have 11 songs not shared w/ anyone, tho I believe it's 10.

Per the 'chalk list,' (someone explain to me?), I end up mid-pack, less chalky than Pip, which makes no sense at all, given he's forgotten more about music in the last week than I've known in my lifetime.

Looking forward to the "countries that have not been the primary source of imperialism in the last 200 years" contest.

Where is this 'chalk list' you speak of?

 

[Mister CIA]

I had twelve songs nobody else selected, only one of which (Changes by David Bowie) was a surprise. Yet due to the fact that my list included 6 of the group's top ten (Gimme Shelter, Into the Mystic, Comfortably Numb, A Day in the Life, Solsbury Hill and Waterloo Sunset), I ended up as the third chalkiest.

By these standards:

* 2 of the top 10 songs
* I appear to have 11 songs not shared w/ anyone, tho I believe it's 10.

Per the 'chalk list,' (someone explain to me?), I end up mid-pack, less chalky than Pip, which makes no sense at all, given he's forgotten more about music in the last week than I've known in my lifetime.

Looking forward to the "countries that have not been the primary source of imperialism in the last 200 years" contest.

Where is this 'chalk list' you speak of?

The spreadsheet link at the top of post 2, or here (see bottom, third sheet from the right).

 

[Val Rannous]

Just wait for the catch-all countdown.

….that may never happen if no one volunteers to run it.

IF we can get @Krista to do it I think we should all donate to the charity of her choosing.



Or, maybe bribe her with this?

4 Krista4

Weird that he has a guitar

I think that's not Ringo, that's George. It certainly looks more like George, no matter what the description says.

 

[New Binky the Doormat]

welp - bummer ...it's over - really loved this one - there's so much out there we could easily do it again in awhile - and no song taken can be taken again

not saying let's start tomorrow or anything - but it would still create a very cool and different playlist.

whadaya say gang??? let's put on a show!!

meanwhile - looks like I had 13 songs not taken by anyone else ...and only 1 artist no one else took - Culture Club bitches!!!

1	Tin Soldier	Small Faces	31	Y	1
2	Moonage Daydream	David Bowie	30	Y	1
3	Where To Now St. Peter?	Elton John	29
4	Locomotive Breath	Jethro Tull	28	Y	3
5	Yours Is No Disgrace	Yes	27	Y	1
6	Tales Of Brave Ulysses	Cream	26	Y	2
7	What Is Life	George Harrison	25	Y	3
8	Kashmir	Led Zeppelin	24	Y	4
9	Abbey Road Medley	The Beatles	23	Y	3
10	Sabbath Bloody Sabbath	Black Sabbath	22
11	Highway Star	Deep Purple	21	Y	2
12	Holidays In The Sun	Sex Pistols	20
13	Gimme Shelter	The Rolling Stones	19	Y	8
14	Baba O'Riley	The Who	18	Y	8
15	London Calling	The Clash	17	Y	4
16	Tempted	Squeeze	16	Y	4
17	Squonk	Genesis	15
18	20th Century Boy	T. Rex	14
19	10538 Overture	Electric Light Orchestra	13
20	Paper Sun	Traffic	12
21	Church Of The Poison Mind	Culture Club	11
22	Shapes Of Things	The Yardbirds	10
23	No More Heroes	The Stranglers	9
24	All The Young Dudes	Mott the Hoople	8	Y	3
25	Tuesday Afternoon	The Moody Blues	7
26	Conquistador	Procol Harum	6
27	Alison	Elvis Costello	5
28	Maybe I'm Amazed	Paul McCartney	4	Y	1
29	Would I Lie To You	Eurythmics	3	Y	3
30	More Than This	Roxy Music	2	Y	3
31	Personal Jesus	Depeche Mode	1	Y	1

 

[krista4]

I think that's not Ringo, that's George. It certainly looks more like George, no matter what the description says.

I just looked at it again and think you're right.

 

[Chaos34]

Time

I don't know for certain this is my favorite Floyd. I think there's a 20 song tie at the top of my list. I love Wish You Were Here, but it wouldn't be part of the tie. it's a good one, but it isn't what makes Floyd Floyd. Hell, even I can play the chords (after a dozen youtube tutorials and my 4th attempt in this life to learn guitar).

I chose Time because it seemed the best of the songs that fully encompass what I love about the band. The intro with fancy alarm clocks. The droning ominous bass notes setting the mood. Roger's message quickly followed by yet another great, tasteful and toneful perfect David solo. The soaring female backup singers. On Dark Side Roger's message(s) were more poetic than Animals.

You are young and life is long,
and there is time to kill today
And then one day you find
ten years have got behind you
No one told you when to run,
you missed the starting gun
And you run, and you run to catch up with the sun
but it's sinking
Racing around to come up behind you again
The sun is the same in a relative way but you're older
Shorter of breath
and one day closer to death

I interpret this as Roger writing about his yet revealed Sheep. Somewhere in my recent deep dive he said he wanted to be more direct with Animals. Just say it plainly (without the focus on poetic lyrics). He has a similar message for his dogs.

You know it's going to get harder, and harder, and harder as you get older
And in the end you'll pack up and fly down south
Hide your head in the sand,
Just another sad old man
All alone and dying of cancer

Anyway, I miss my daily playlist already, and thought I'd something more to say.

 

[Mrs. Rannous]

Freddie is all dressed up with no place to go.

Tragique.

 

[Chaos34]

welp - bummer ...it's over - really loved this one - there's so much out there we could easily do it again in awhile - and no song taken can be taken again

not saying let's start tomorrow or anything - but it would still create a very cool and different playlist.

I like it. We could even do a combined US and British Isles Only Leftovers. But I've been working on my Catch All list. Gonna get irie some this time. I have 5 songs ready to go.

 

[krista4]

welp - bummer ...it's over - really loved this one - there's so much out there we could easily do it again in awhile - and no song taken can be taken again

not saying let's start tomorrow or anything - but it would still create a very cool and different playlist.

I like it. We could even do a combined US and British Isles Only Leftovers. But I've been working on my Catch All list. Gonna get irie some this time. I have 5 songs ready to go.

I've thought through this a lot, and I'm worried that because of the ineligibles from the US and UK, when added to places like Canada and the Antipodes, other countries are going to get short shrift in the catch-all. Almost thought it would be worth doing separate countdowns with the ineligibles. But it seems like some people already have their lists, so even if that were a good idea (I'm not certain), that ship has likely sailed.

I also wonder if we might want to break these up (especially since no one has volunteered to run the catch-all) and do another draft first instead, like the Beatles/Dylan cover or whatever.

 

[Don Quixote]

welp - bummer ...it's over - really loved this one - there's so much out there we could easily do it again in awhile - and no song taken can be taken again

not saying let's start tomorrow or anything - but it would still create a very cool and different playlist.

I like it. We could even do a combined US and British Isles Only Leftovers. But I've been working on my Catch All list. Gonna get irie some this time. I have 5 songs ready to go.

I've thought through this a lot, and I'm worried that because of the ineligibles from the US and UK, when added to places like Canada and the Antipodes, other countries are going to get short shrift in the catch-all. Almost thought it would be worth doing separate countdowns with the ineligibles. But it seems like some people already have their lists, so even if that were a good idea (I'm not certain), that ship has likely sailed.

I also wonder if we might want to break these up (especially since no one has volunteered to run the catch-all) and do another draft first instead, like the Beatles/Dylan cover or whatever.

I started mine, but could pivot depending on what is decided. I don't think I was hit as much by the ineligibles with US/UK connections as much as some others (and only a few from Canada that I listen to); so, the majority of mine were outside US, UK, and Canada.

 

[AAABatteries]

A few random songs that I had on my original list before I pared things down.

Ed Sheeran - Perfect - I'm linking the version with Bocelli which I know would not be eligible but I just love it. For my wife
Dave Clark Five - Glad All Over
Dead or Alive - You Spin Me Round (Like a Record) - so cheesy but just a prototypical 80's song and it's impossible not to dance to it.

ETA - I didn't fully vet the rest of my list so if one of those last two isn't eligible oh well.

 

[AAABatteries]

welp - bummer ...it's over - really loved this one - there's so much out there we could easily do it again in awhile - and no song taken can be taken again

not saying let's start tomorrow or anything - but it would still create a very cool and different playlist.

I like it. We could even do a combined US and British Isles Only Leftovers. But I've been working on my Catch All list. Gonna get irie some this time. I have 5 songs ready to go.

I've thought through this a lot, and I'm worried that because of the ineligibles from the US and UK, when added to places like Canada and the Antipodes, other countries are going to get short shrift in the catch-all. Almost thought it would be worth doing separate countdowns with the ineligibles. But it seems like some people already have their lists, so even if that were a good idea (I'm not certain), that ship has likely sailed.

I also wonder if we might want to break these up (especially since no one has volunteered to run the catch-all) and do another draft first instead, like the Beatles/Dylan cover or whatever.

Please just let me know which countdown or draft this is eligible

 

[AAABatteries]

That may be the greatest video in the history of music. I lose it every time Hitler comes on the screen for the first time.

 

[New Binky the Doormat]

welp - bummer ...it's over - really loved this one - there's so much out there we could easily do it again in awhile - and no song taken can be taken again

not saying let's start tomorrow or anything - but it would still create a very cool and different playlist.

I like it. We could even do a combined US and British Isles Only Leftovers. But I've been working on my Catch All list. Gonna get irie some this time. I have 5 songs ready to go.

I've thought through this a lot, and I'm worried that because of the ineligibles from the US and UK, when added to places like Canada and the Antipodes, other countries are going to get short shrift in the catch-all. Almost thought it would be worth doing separate countdowns with the ineligibles. But it seems like some people already have their lists, so even if that were a good idea (I'm not certain), that ship has likely sailed.

I also wonder if we might want to break these up (especially since no one has volunteered to run the catch-all) and do another draft first instead, like the Beatles/Dylan cover or whatever.

Please just let me know which countdown or draft this is eligible

omg.

I have never seen this and could not have imagined that anything like it ever existed.

 

[AAABatteries]

omg.

I have never seen this and could not have imagined that anything like it ever existed.

It's unreal - Hitler, Thor, dinosaurs.....it has it all.

 

[New Binky the Doormat]

omg.

I have never seen this and could not have imagined that anything like it ever existed.

It's unreal - Hitler, Thor, dinosaurs.....it has it all.

didn't i see a very young Johnny Depp?

 

[Dr. Octopus]

Please just let me know which countdown or draft this is eligible

The one from Hell.

 

[Hov34]

Just wait for the catch-all countdown.

….that may never happen if no one volunteers to run it.

IF we can get @Krista to do it I think we should all donate to the charity of her choosing.



Or, maybe bribe her with this?

4 Krista4

Weird that he has a guitar

I think that's not Ringo, that's George. It certainly looks more like George, no matter what the description says.

Yeah, this is the first one I found but it was Canadian Ebay, I think?

Real Ringo

 

[Dr. Octopus]

That may be the greatest video in the history of music. I lose it every time Hitler comes on the screen for the first time.

That Hitler. What a cut up

 

[KarmaPolice]

welp - bummer ...it's over - really loved this one - there's so much out there we could easily do it again in awhile - and no song taken can be taken again

not saying let's start tomorrow or anything - but it would still create a very cool and different playlist.

I like it. We could even do a combined US and British Isles Only Leftovers. But I've been working on my Catch All list. Gonna get irie some this time. I have 5 songs ready to go.

I've thought through this a lot, and I'm worried that because of the ineligibles from the US and UK, when added to places like Canada and the Antipodes, other countries are going to get short shrift in the catch-all. Almost thought it would be worth doing separate countdowns with the ineligibles. But it seems like some people already have their lists, so even if that were a good idea (I'm not certain), that ship has likely sailed.

I also wonder if we might want to break these up (especially since no one has volunteered to run the catch-all) and do another draft first instead, like the Beatles/Dylan cover or whatever.

Please just let me know which countdown or draft this is eligible

WTF? How am I going to resist renting that movie tonight?

 

[AAABatteries]

That may be the greatest video in the history of music. I lose it every time Hitler comes on the screen for the first time.

That Hitler. What a cut up

Yeah - my bad, that sounds horrible on a reread.

 

[Chaos34]

I have 16 unique to me songs and 10 of them are unique to me bands/artists. Yet I managed to finish 8th on the chalk list.

 

[Dr. Octopus]

That may be the greatest video in the history of music. I lose it every time Hitler comes on the screen for the first time.

That Hitler. What a cut up

Yeah - my bad, that sounds horrible on a reread.

I was actually playing along with you on the joke.

 

[Mt. Man]

Data that may possibly be interesting to somebody:

# of songs in Favorites:
Dr. Octopus: 8
Doug B, simsarge, Sullie: 6
8-way tie for 5

Overall, I had 43/44 drafters get at least one favorite. Which speaks more to the scattershot nature of this, considering I wasn't aiming for it. It likely helped that most of the days had 5 selections.

The one left out? landrys hat. Not because I disliked the list. I mean, we shared two songs, so that would be ridiculous. I'm not sure that I have any rhyme or reason for this. Though I suppose it helps that he did well in:

# of songs from didn't know (before any selections were revealed):
Mrs. Eephus 10
titusbramble 7
landrys hat, Oliver Humanzee : 6
7-way tie for 5

This one had 37/44 drafters on it. Partially because of fewer selections (usually 3-4 to Favorites' 4-5). Though I'm sure that some people had, you know, largely known songs, which is not a bad thing. This, perhaps not surprisingly, also means that Mrs. Eephus showed up the most when combining the lists.

Stuck in the Middle Award(s): Eephus and simey, for having 5 on both lists. simsarge was close, with 6 Favorites and 4 "unknowns".

 

[Uruk-Hai]

This thread is 197 pages vs. 103 for the US thread.

I count 96 pages of arguments in this one

 

[Dr. Octopus]

Data that may possibly be interesting to somebody:

# of songs in Favorites:
Dr. Octopus: 8
Doug B, simsa

I finally won something. So its interesting to me.

 

[Dr. Octopus]

This thread is 197 pages vs. 103 for the US thread.

I count 96 pages of arguments in this one

In the Queen’s English though.

 

[MAC_32]

This thread is 197 pages vs. 103 for the US thread.

I feel better now about struggling to keep up

 

[MAC_32]

Time

I don't know for certain this is my favorite Floyd. I think there's a 20 song tie at the top of my list. I love Wish You Were Here, but it wouldn't be part of the tie. it's a good one, but it isn't what makes Floyd Floyd. Hell, even I can play the chords (after a dozen youtube tutorials and my 4th attempt in this life to learn guitar).

I chose Time because it seemed the best of the songs that fully encompass what I love about the band. The intro with fancy alarm clocks. The droning ominous bass notes setting the mood. Roger's message quickly followed by yet another great, tasteful and toneful perfect David solo. The soaring female backup singers. On Dark Side Roger's message(s) were more poetic than Animals.

You are young and life is long,
and there is time to kill today
And then one day you find
ten years have got behind you
No one told you when to run,
you missed the starting gun
And you run, and you run to catch up with the sun
but it's sinking
Racing around to come up behind you again
The sun is the same in a relative way but you're older
Shorter of breath
and one day closer to death

I interpret this as Roger writing about his yet revealed Sheep. Somewhere in my recent deep dive he said he wanted to be more direct with Animals. Just say it plainly (without the focus on poetic lyrics). He has a similar message for his dogs.

You know it's going to get harder, and harder, and harder as you get older
And in the end you'll pack up and fly down south
Hide your head in the sand,
Just another sad old man
All alone and dying of cancer

Anyway, I miss my daily playlist already, and thought I'd something more to say.

I have a weird relationship with Floyd. I love them yet I put up 0 songs. Cause with a couple exceptions I don't listen to them on shuffle. It's cover-to-cover albums or not at all. Hey you and Comfortably Numb are the only ones that are still on my shuffle. With hindsight I should've picked one, but given my weird relationship with them I didn't even give them a thought.

 

[krista4]

Data that may possibly be interesting to somebody:

# of songs in Favorites:
Dr. Octopus: 8
Doug B, simsa

I finally won something. So its interesting to me.

I love stats like these, even though I didn't win anything. I'm going to do some counting of my new-to-me playlist when I get home. There are 88 songs on it right now, but I haven't listened to the #1s yet.

 

[krista4]

Forgot to mention that I realized I love a second Pink Floyd song (in addition to "Wish You Were Here"): "On the Turning Away." I've had it stuck in my head for a few days.

 

[Manster]

Time

I don't know for certain this is my favorite Floyd. I think there's a 20 song tie at the top of my list. I love Wish You Were Here, but it wouldn't be part of the tie. it's a good one, but it isn't what makes Floyd Floyd. Hell, even I can play the chords (after a dozen youtube tutorials and my 4th attempt in this life to learn guitar).

I chose Time because it seemed the best of the songs that fully encompass what I love about the band. The intro with fancy alarm clocks. The droning ominous bass notes setting the mood. Roger's message quickly followed by yet another great, tasteful and toneful perfect David solo. The soaring female backup singers. On Dark Side Roger's message(s) were more poetic than Animals.

You are young and life is long,
and there is time to kill today
And then one day you find
ten years have got behind you
No one told you when to run,
you missed the starting gun
And you run, and you run to catch up with the sun
but it's sinking
Racing around to come up behind you again
The sun is the same in a relative way but you're older
Shorter of breath
and one day closer to death

I interpret this as Roger writing about his yet revealed Sheep. Somewhere in my recent deep dive he said he wanted to be more direct with Animals. Just say it plainly (without the focus on poetic lyrics). He has a similar message for his dogs.

You know it's going to get harder, and harder, and harder as you get older
And in the end you'll pack up and fly down south
Hide your head in the sand,
Just another sad old man
All alone and dying of cancer

Anyway, I miss my daily playlist already, and thought I'd something more to say.

I have a weird relationship with Floyd. I love them yet I put up 0 songs. Cause with a couple exceptions I don't listen to them on shuffle. It's cover-to-cover albums or not at all. Hey you and Comfortably Numb are the only ones that are still on my shuffle. With hindsight I should've picked one, but given my weird relationship with them I didn't even give them a thought.

I never tire of Floyd.

Time

I don't know for certain this is my favorite Floyd. I think there's a 20 song tie at the top of my list. I love Wish You Were Here, but it wouldn't be part of the tie. it's a good one, but it isn't what makes Floyd Floyd. Hell, even I can play the chords (after a dozen youtube tutorials and my 4th attempt in this life to learn guitar).

I chose Time because it seemed the best of the songs that fully encompass what I love about the band. The intro with fancy alarm clocks. The droning ominous bass notes setting the mood. Roger's message quickly followed by yet another great, tasteful and toneful perfect David solo. The soaring female backup singers. On Dark Side Roger's message(s) were more poetic than Animals.

You are young and life is long,
and there is time to kill today
And then one day you find
ten years have got behind you
No one told you when to run,
you missed the starting gun
And you run, and you run to catch up with the sun
but it's sinking
Racing around to come up behind you again
The sun is the same in a relative way but you're older
Shorter of breath
and one day closer to death

I interpret this as Roger writing about his yet revealed Sheep. Somewhere in my recent deep dive he said he wanted to be more direct with Animals. Just say it plainly (without the focus on poetic lyrics). He has a similar message for his dogs.

You know it's going to get harder, and harder, and harder as you get older
And in the end you'll pack up and fly down south
Hide your head in the sand,
Just another sad old man
All alone and dying of cancer

Anyway, I miss my daily playlist already, and thought I'd something more to say.

I have a weird relationship with Floyd. I love them yet I put up 0 songs. Cause with a couple exceptions I don't listen to them on shuffle. It's cover-to-cover albums or not at all. Hey you and Comfortably Numb are the only ones that are still on my shuffle. With hindsight I should've picked one, but given my weird relationship with them I didn't even give them a thought.

I have a tendency to listen to the same stuff over, and over.......so I listen to Floyd all the time still. Maybe its a comfort thing, I dunno?

 

[MAC_32]

Maybe its a comfort thing, I dunno?

Numb too.

 

[Manster]

I didn't pick Comfortably Numb because it's the obvious choice. Its the Pink Floyd song everyone knows. But there is a reason why.....

These lyrics have always been beautiful, and haunting to me.....

When I was a child
I caught a fleeting glimpse
Out of the corner of my eye
I turned to look but it was gone
I cannot put my finger on it now
The child is grown
The dream is gone

 

[Dr. Octopus]

I didn't pick Comfortably Numb because it's the obvious choice. Its the Pink Floyd song everyone knows. But there is a reason why.....

These lyrics have always been beautiful, and haunting to me.....

When I was a child
I caught a fleeting glimpse
Out of the corner of my eye
I turned to look but it was gone
I cannot put my finger on it now
The child is grown
The dream is gone

I love Gilmour’s solos as well. Also I like that Waters and Gilmour split the vocals between the manic doctor and dream state Pink, respectively.

Is it their most popular song? I’d say Money or Another Brick in the Wall. It’s surely a big one though so not sure it matters.

 

[krista4]

Is it their most popular song?

It is according to middle-aged dummies!

 

[Dr. Octopus]

Is it their most popular song?

It is according to middle-aged dummies!

When you put it that way, nothing else matters.

 

[Manster]

I didn't pick Comfortably Numb because it's the obvious choice. Its the Pink Floyd song everyone knows. But there is a reason why.....

These lyrics have always been beautiful, and haunting to me.....

When I was a child
I caught a fleeting glimpse
Out of the corner of my eye
I turned to look but it was gone
I cannot put my finger on it now
The child is grown
The dream is gone

I love Gilmour’s solos as well. Also I like that Waters and Gilmour split the vocals between the manic doctor and dream state Pink, respectively.

Is it their most popular song? I’d say Money or Another Brick in the Wall. It’s surely a big one though so not sure it matters.

Yea, i'd call those 1a, 1b, and 1c....and throw in Wish You were Here as 1d for good measure

 

[Ilov80s]

I loved seeing Into the Mystic get such a high ranking, such a beautiful song

 

[Manster]

Forgot to mention that I realized I love a second Pink Floyd song (in addition to "Wish You Were Here"): "On the Turning Away." I've had it stuck in my head for a few days.

I feel like if you did a deep dive on Floyd you'd love a few more songs.

 

[Ilov80s]

You can't stop us on our road to freedom
And you can't stop us 'cause our eyes can see
Men with insight, men in granite
Knights in armor intent on chivalry