Help me choose: Slaton or Chris Johnson - (1 Viewer)

[mambomambo]

Help me choose my RB4: Slaton or Chris Johnson. It is a Dynasty Format. Both are the same price...

 

[Enforcer]

Help me choose my RB4: Slaton or Chris Johnson. It is a Dynasty Format. Both are the same price...

You have to realize you'll get nothing but nasty comments posting this here. No?

 

[gbill2004]

Is this a serions question? Chris Johnson!!!

 

[benm3218]

are you serious? Do you watch football ever? Slaton hands down man. He is big and strong and used by his offense a ton.

 

[Jayrod]

Jay Cutler. I think he'll be good in a year or two....

You can thank me later.

 

[benm3218]

now I feel like a jerk for posting the above....

If you are indeed serious and not just fishing then definitely go for Chris Johnson.

He is actually playing every week and is a bonafide weekly starter with MUCH more talent than Slaton.

Slaton = nobody.

If you were fishing then ignore this and reread my original post. Cheers.

 

[BobbyLayne]

CJ3 is the fastest offensive player in the league, blew away the combine, was highly rated out of college (24th pick), plays behind a good line on a run first team, is posting monster numbers; Slayton had a nice career at WVU, had an average combine (4.45 v. 4.24), got drafted in the third round, plays behind an average line on a team that ran the ball 126 less times last year, and had 13 carries for 43 yards in his first game.

In a redraft, keeper or dynasty, I think there is only one obvious answer. How your league determined these two rookies should be priced the same is beyond comprehension. You must be in a very shallow league that CJ3 would be no better than a RB4.

 

[schooner44]

CJ3 is the fastest offensive player in the league, blew away the combine, was highly rated out of college (24th pick), plays behind a good line on a run first team, is posting monster numbers; Slayton had a nice career at WVU, had an average combine (4.45 v. 4.24), got drafted in the third round, plays behind an average line on a team that ran the ball 126 less times last year, and had 13 carries for 43 yards in his first game. In a redraft, keeper or dynasty, I think there is only one obvious answer. How your league determined these two rookies should be priced the same is beyond comprehension. You must be in a very shallow league that CJ3 would be no better than a RB4.

Just a tip--next time you may want to post this in the Assistant Coach forum.

 

[rockalum]

i made this choice opening week ... i went with johnson. i'm happy with the choice.