What's new
Fantasy Football - Footballguys Forums

This is a sample guest message. Register a free account today to become a member! Once signed in, you'll be able to participate on this site by adding your own topics and posts, as well as connect with other members through your own private inbox!

Hines Ward voted the NFL's dirtiest player again (2 Viewers)

Ghost Rider

Footballguy
In this week's SI, as voted on by 296 NFL players, the top 5 vote-getters were:

Hines Ward 11.6%

Albert Haynesworth 6.0%

Joey Porter 6.0%

Roy L. Williams 5.1%

Kevin Mawae 4.6%

 
Odd that it's only 296 players. Must mean that not all turned it in. Greatly skews the results, as only the whiniest actually bother with this tripe.

Not a Hines owner either, actually a S Holmes (x2) owner. But you can't deny as a :D fan that Hines Ward is a baller, and about as far from "dirty" as there is. Tough as nails: yes, Dirty? :goodposting:

 
Last edited by a moderator:
I wonder how Keith Rivers and Ed Reed voted?

:mellow:

Ward is one of the few complete WR's left in a game rapidly losing it's soul.

 
Last edited by a moderator:
I like hard-nosed football. I wonder, though, if hitting someone who is unaware would be considered unsporting and therefore "dirty".

 
Albert I agree with.

Rodney Harrison epitomizes this award.

Hines? I agree with the QBs from Detroit.

 
I like hard-nosed football. I wonder, though, if hitting someone who is unaware would be considered unsporting and therefore "dirty".
Like the LB's and S's who hit wr's crossing in the middle? Just seems to me that def. players love to hit, but when a WR lays them out consistently, it is "dirty" I know i am a homer, but i honestly doubt anyone can come up with a WR that is better overall than he is. Alot are better at receiving, but there is no one close to him in blocking, and his receiving is pretty damn good too.
 
Hines is definitely dirty.

Willing blocker, but nobody lives to spear unsuspecting defenders like that guy. The other players hate him cause he's kinda "sneaky" when trying to lay out a defender, a lot of times away from the action of the play. He's been fined several times late hits and unessecary roughness, when the officials didn't even catch the play in live action.

Kind of a dumb poll though. I mean, does Roy Williams even see the field these days?

 
Hines is definitely dirty. Willing blocker, but nobody lives to spear unsuspecting defenders like that guy. The other players hate him cause he's kinda "sneaky" when trying to lay out a defender, a lot of times away from the action of the play. He's been fined several times late hits and unessecary roughness, when the officials didn't even catch the play in live action.
This, he'll drive his helmet right into defender's knees.And then, of course, get up grinning.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Hines is definitely dirty. Willing blocker, but nobody lives to spear unsuspecting defenders like that guy. The other players hate him cause he's kinda "sneaky" when trying to lay out a defender, a lot of times away from the action of the play. He's been fined several times late hits and unessecary roughness, when the officials didn't even catch the play in live action.
This, he'll drive his helmet right into defender's knees.And then, of course, get up grinning.
Hines plays aggressively and blocks to the whistle. He'll go downfield during a run and setup outside a defender and lay into him (which some have called a dirty "blindside" block) but he absolutely does NOT dive at the knees. The blocks on Reed and Rivers mentioned above were well above the waist. Call him dirty if you like but be accurate about what he does and doesn't do on the field.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
If a 200 lb WR is the dirtiest player then the NFL has become a league of pansies.
Not buying this argument. Dirty is all about intent. A guy could be 5'4" and 120 lbs and still be the dirtiest player in the league if he stomped on players on the ground, spit on opponents, punched people in the nuts at the bottom of the pile, and attempted to intentionally break fingers or dislocate shoulders.
 
This kinda makes me laugh. If people think hitting guys who don't see the hit coming is dirty, it's the same thing defensive players try to do on every play. The thing is, those defensive players are involved in a play trying to make a tackle. They're as fair game as anyone else, and until the whistle blows, that's not dirty. That's football.

He plays to the whistle and hits harder than a WR is supposed to. He's had some big hits on guys who didn't see them coming, but he's also had a lot of big hits on guys who did. Just because the guy didn't see the hit coming doesn't mean it was dirty, it means they should've been more aware of where Hines was on the field, because if they're trying to make a tackle, they SHOULD be fair game for ANYONE to hit them.

Hines doesn't ever dive at knees or intentionally try to hurt people. But he DOES hit as hard as he can, just like the DBs and LBs do to him every time he comes across the middle.

Defensive players don't like to be the ones getting hit, and that's fine. I LOVE the way Hines plays and if defensive players don't, all the better. It gets them thinking about getting smacked around by a WR instead of tackling the guy with the ball.

In all these years, I've never seen Hines dive at anyone's knees. At least not that I can remember.

 
I like hard-nosed football. I wonder, though, if hitting someone who is unaware would be considered unsporting and therefore "dirty".
Would you consider a QB getting sacked from his blindside dirty?
Would you consider a QB Getting sacked sacked from his blindside the same as a WR away from the play spearing an unsuspecting def player?? Doesnt matter which WR we are talking about it is definately not the same.. horrible example, but expected from a homer. Yes Im a Browns homer but Im not anti Ward, just felt this post was :coffee:
 
I love seeing people in this thread: a) try to discredit the vote of a bunch of players who have WAY more inside info than anyone in this thread, b) pretend that 296 NFL players are "pansies", when in fact all 296 are probably way tougher than anyone on FBGs.

 
Hines is definitely dirty.

Willing blocker, but nobody lives to spear unsuspecting defenders like that guy. The other players hate him cause he's kinda "sneaky" when trying to lay out a defender, a lot of times away from the action of the play. He's been fined several times late hits and unessecary roughness, when the officials didn't even catch the play in live action.
This, he'll drive his helmet right into defender's knees.And then, of course, get up grinning.
:eek: Every single hit I've ever seen anyone complain about regarding Hines has been above the waist.

 
I love seeing people in this thread: a) try to discredit the vote of a bunch of players who have WAY more inside info than anyone in this thread, b) pretend that 296 NFL players are "pansies", when in fact all 296 are probably way tougher than anyone on FBGs.
Not trying to discredit the vote or question how tough an NFL player is.But I've watched enough Steelers football and seen enough of the hits by Ward that people complain about to comment on them. Even when it's a completely perfect block, the defensive players get up whining that Hines shouldn't have hit them or hit them too hard. And yes, Hines loves every minute of it. God forbid he takes a chance to hit a defensive player who doesn't see the hit coming... it's not like that same player wouldn't blindside him if they had the chance, right?I'm sure defensive players consider him dirty because he's one of the few offensive players in the game who's known for his hits on defensive players. He's injured a few and he's blindsided a few. So what? A defensive player who has a hit like that celebrates and ends up on Sportscenter.And he ALWAYS blocks above the waist.
 
I love seeing people in this thread: a) try to discredit the vote of a bunch of players who have WAY more inside info than anyone in this thread, b) pretend that 296 NFL players are "pansies", when in fact all 296 are probably way tougher than anyone on FBGs.
Not trying to discredit the vote or question how tough an NFL player is.But I've watched enough Steelers football and seen enough of the hits by Ward that people complain about to comment on them. Even when it's a completely perfect block, the defensive players get up whining that Hines shouldn't have hit them or hit them too hard. And yes, Hines loves every minute of it. God forbid he takes a chance to hit a defensive player who doesn't see the hit coming... it's not like that same player wouldn't blindside him if they had the chance, right?I'm sure defensive players consider him dirty because he's one of the few offensive players in the game who's known for his hits on defensive players. He's injured a few and he's blindsided a few. So what? A defensive player who has a hit like that celebrates and ends up on Sportscenter.And he ALWAYS blocks above the waist.
S4L - to provide full context, I'm a HUGE H Ward fan. But you can't ignore the results of 300 players voting. I realize that isn't exactly the entire NFL (in fact, it's about 15-20% of the NFL), but that is a decent sample size. And for whatever reason, his peers think Hines Ward is a dirty player.Plenty of folks in here have tried to discredit the vote by implying that anyone voting that Ward is dirty is "just a pansy". I think that's a ridiculous assertion.
 
S4L - to provide full context, I'm a HUGE H Ward fan. But you can't ignore the results of 300 players voting. I realize that isn't exactly the entire NFL (in fact, it's about 15-20% of the NFL), but that is a decent sample size. And for whatever reason, his peers think Hines Ward is a dirty player.Plenty of folks in here have tried to discredit the vote by implying that anyone voting that Ward is dirty is "just a pansy". I think that's a ridiculous assertion.
:lmao: Ward finishes near the top or are at the top of this poll every year, and I doubt the exact same players are polled every year, so it sounds like Ward reputation as a dirty player is well-deserved, no matter how much Steelers fans try to discredit the results. 296 players is about, oh, 1/6 of the NFL, so yeah, the sample size is more than big enough for these results to be statistically significant.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
S4L - to provide full context, I'm a HUGE H Ward fan. But you can't ignore the results of 300 players voting. I realize that isn't exactly the entire NFL (in fact, it's about 15-20% of the NFL), but that is a decent sample size. And for whatever reason, his peers think Hines Ward is a dirty player.Plenty of folks in here have tried to discredit the vote by implying that anyone voting that Ward is dirty is "just a pansy". I think that's a ridiculous assertion.
The pansy assertions were obviously facetious and if they were stated in any other context I agree they are ridiculous.Thing is if one actually understands the rules of the game, it is patently obvious that prior to this seasons rule change Ward's crackbacks were 100% legal blocks and were directly related to the plays in question.I don't think a player can be considered "dirty" when their actions are legal and are in context of the action.If 31 of Ward's peers choose to deem him that, it's certainly their prerogative but it comes off sounding like sour grapes.I'd be willing to bet you though that every one of them is a defensive player that doesn't like or doesn't want to be hit in the exact same fashion they are trying to hit the offensive players on the field.In this case, I think Ward should consider the results of the poll a compliment.
 
S4L - to provide full context, I'm a HUGE H Ward fan. But you can't ignore the results of 300 players voting. I realize that isn't exactly the entire NFL (in fact, it's about 15-20% of the NFL), but that is a decent sample size. And for whatever reason, his peers think Hines Ward is a dirty player.

Plenty of folks in here have tried to discredit the vote by implying that anyone voting that Ward is dirty is "just a pansy". I think that's a ridiculous assertion.
Unless I know the demographics of the players voting I sure as heck can. And will.
 
I actually think Hines is kind of dirty

He has a patented Helmet to facemask hit that he loves throwing on unsuspecting DB's

Defensive players can't hit Helmet to Helmet or they are penalized. Hines somehow manages to get around this rule since he is on offence.

Hines Ward will always lead with his helmet. Rarely do I see the guy throw a shoulder to shoulder block.

 
I actually think Hines is kind of dirtyHe has a patented Helmet to facemask hit that he loves throwing on unsuspecting DB'sDefensive players can't hit Helmet to Helmet or they are penalized. Hines somehow manages to get around this rule since he is on offence.Hines Ward will always lead with his helmet. Rarely do I see the guy throw a shoulder to shoulder block.
Defensive players absolutely can and frequently do hit helmet to helmet.It is not a penalty unless the player is in a defenseless potion, which the players Hines hits are not.Gotta know the rules.
 
If a 200 lb WR is the dirtiest player then the NFL has become a league of pansies.
Not buying this argument. Dirty is all about intent. A guy could be 5'4" and 120 lbs and still be the dirtiest player in the league if he stomped on players on the ground, spit on opponents, punched people in the nuts at the bottom of the pile, and attempted to intentionally break fingers or dislocate shoulders.
Agreed 100% ... I would love hines on my squad but the truth is the guy gets his rep for a good reason.
 
I would love hines on my squad but the truth is the guy gets his rep for a good reason.
Because...He. Will. Blow. You. Up.The NFL met with him in '08 about his hits and fines... and didnt even tell him to change anything. Didnt even explain to him what he was being fined for other then "hitting too hard". Bad ###.
leading with the head ... over and over and over
 
I would love hines on my squad but the truth is the guy gets his rep for a good reason.
Because...He. Will. Blow. You. Up.

The NFL met with him in '08 about his hits and fines... and didnt even tell him to change anything. Didnt even explain to him what he was being fined for other then "hitting too hard". Bad ###.
leading with the head ... over and over and over
Not according to the NFL. Did you not read or not comprehend?The NFL did NOT state to him that he was leading with the helmet and that he should quit doing so or he will get fined.

They didnt tell him that he was hitting a defensless player either. Heck he doesnt even get penalized on the field.

The simply told him that he was hitting too hard and once fined him for late hit.
Might want to reread his statement before you get your panties all twisted:
"They said 40 percent of the fines that are given out are after a penalty is called," Ward said. "And if there's not a penalty, they review it, and then they start setting out fines after they review it.

"But that's kind of contradictory, because I had a 72-yard reception this year in Houston called back because they said that I had a pass interference call. Well, all they did was review it and say, 'Yes, the ref messed up, here's an apology, we're sorry.' They don't give me that 72-yard reception back.

"So when they look at the plays after the fact, they go back and review it, and they say, 'Oh yeah, this is a personal foul,' and then they hand out fines when there wasn't a flag. That ain't right."

Ward suggested that what's good for players should also be good for referees, and maybe the officials should be forced to pay after a poor performance.

"That was my whole argument, and they never really gave me an answer for that," Ward said. "How can you fine players because a ref may miss a call? You can't go back and then say, 'OK, yeah, I think that's a fine.' Well, give me an apology. Don't take $15,000 out my pocket, because you're not fining the referees for calls that they may miss in a game. All you do is give me an apology letter saying, 'This was an incorrect call, I'm sorry', and then move on.

"In my case, I was never flagged or penalized on the plays that I was given, but yet, they take $15,000 out my pocket. If it was an illegal hit, then the refs missed it. You can't go back and review the plays and then give out fines accordingly, based off what you say. The referees don't get a letter saying, 'You know what? You missed Hines' block, and then him and a guy got into a scuffle.'"
Also, i do know in 2007 he was fined 2x for late hits ... i think it is kinda funny that you actually believe that the NFL just levied him a fine without giving him a reason. He clearly takes issue with being fined for a play he was not penalized on the field for.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
What has Joey Porter done to get labeled a dirty player? Honest question. I know he's a loudmouth and he's irritating, but he never struck me as dirty.

There was that Todd Heap / injury / shove play that some people got pretty upset with, but that's been what ...7 years now? anything else?

 
uhhhh isn't your bolded excerpt basically saying he convened with the NFL and they felt differently about the play. Specifically that he felt he should not be fined for something he wasn't flagged for on the field? Not sure how that is "blocking too hard" .... my guess is it is doing one of forms of illegal blocks.

 
What has Joey Porter done to get labeled a dirty player? Honest question. I know he's a loudmouth and he's irritating, but he never struck me as dirty. There was that Todd Heap / injury / shove play that some people got pretty upset with, but that's been what ...7 years now? anything else?
he doesn't take it out on others on the field ... he saves it for Casinos
 
.... my guess is it is doing one of forms of illegal blocks.
then they woud have stated to the owner and coach exactly as such. they did not.http://www.bing.com/search?q=fined+for+hel...rc=IE-SearchBox

they give fines for helmet to helmet all the time. His are given for "unnessecary roughness" on a legal block.
So that means it could have been a crack block ... which he is well known to do.Either way the guy takes shots when he can ... I don't blame him because I would imagine most of the players he is hitting would do the same to him if he were vulnerable but call a spade a spade.

 
.... my guess is it is doing one of forms of illegal blocks.
then they woud have stated to the owner and coach exactly as such. they did not.http://www.bing.com/search?q=fined+for+hel...rc=IE-SearchBox

they give fines for helmet to helmet all the time. His are given for "unnessecary roughness" on a legal block.
Unnecessary roughness is a penalizable offense. If it were a legal block there would have been no fine. I don't think football should be about cheap shots, there's nothing tough about teeing off on a guy caught in a bad position or someone who doesn't see you coming.
 
All 296 players that voted are sissies.
Funny how fantasy football owners can sit in their chairs and call pro football players sissies. If somebody receives the same award over and over, it doesn't mean the defenses are "scared" of a WR. None of them care enough about Hines Ward to be jealous of him-- they're all millionaires many times over, many making more than Ward does. So I think where there's smoke, there's fire. This award should have Rodney Harrison's name on it. Whoever mentioned him first in this thread was right on.
 
I like hard-nosed football. I wonder, though, if hitting someone who is unaware would be considered unsporting and therefore "dirty".
Would you consider a QB getting sacked from his blindside dirty?
Would you consider a QB Getting sacked sacked from his blindside the same as a WR away from the play spearing an unsuspecting def player?? Doesnt matter which WR we are talking about it is definately not the same.. horrible example, but expected from a homer. Yes Im a Browns homer but Im not anti Ward, just felt this post was :thumbdown:
You were the one that said a player hits an unaware player is unsporting and dirty. Certainly a QB getting hit from his blindside is unaware so I was just asking if you considered that to be dirty. :confused: Watch this clip and tell me which hit of Ward's was away from the play. All of these defenders were aggressively going towards the play and were blocked by Ward. Now if you want to say he led with his helmet on some of these you might have an argument but the places and times when the blocks were made were 100% legit.

 
Hines is definitely dirty. Willing blocker, but nobody lives to spear unsuspecting defenders like that guy. The other players hate him cause he's kinda "sneaky" when trying to lay out a defender, a lot of times away from the action of the play. He's been fined several times late hits and unessecary roughness, when the officials didn't even catch the play in live action.
This, he'll drive his helmet right into defender's knees.And then, of course, get up grinning.
I don't recall a single case of Ward going after someone's knees. Do you have a link?
 
:thumbdown: @ cheap.

I hate the Steelers, but Ward is awesome; plays football like it should be played.

 
Neil Beaufort Zod said:
Bigboy10182000 said:
All 296 players that voted are sissies.
Funny how fantasy football owners can sit in their chairs and call pro football players sissies. If somebody receives the same award over and over, it doesn't mean the defenses are "scared" of a WR. None of them care enough about Hines Ward to be jealous of him-- they're all millionaires many times over, many making more than Ward does. So I think where there's smoke, there's fire. This award should have Rodney Harrison's name on it. Whoever mentioned him first in this thread was right on.
every player on defense makes more than Ward does? dang, I knew he was underpaid but that's ridunkulous.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
certificate said:
Britney Spears said:
Hines is definitely dirty. Willing blocker, but nobody lives to spear unsuspecting defenders like that guy. The other players hate him cause he's kinda "sneaky" when trying to lay out a defender, a lot of times away from the action of the play. He's been fined several times late hits and unessecary roughness, when the officials didn't even catch the play in live action.
This, he'll drive his helmet right into defender's knees.And then, of course, get up grinning.
Link?This is an absurd statement. Show me one piece of evidence that he has ever dove at someones knees.
 
StrikeS2k said:
Michael Fox said:
S4L - to provide full context, I'm a HUGE H Ward fan. But you can't ignore the results of 300 players voting. I realize that isn't exactly the entire NFL (in fact, it's about 15-20% of the NFL), but that is a decent sample size. And for whatever reason, his peers think Hines Ward is a dirty player.

Plenty of folks in here have tried to discredit the vote by implying that anyone voting that Ward is dirty is "just a pansy". I think that's a ridiculous assertion.
Unless I know the demographics of the players voting I sure as heck can. And will.
:lmao: So you have some made-up reason to believe that the sample size is skewed toward players who don't like Hines Ward? I love how people continue to try to discredit the survey results, just because they don't like the answer.

 
topdawg24 said:
Quite possibly the best blocking WR of all time!!
Let's call it the Steve Smith (CAR) game, where he likes to hit someone when they have their back turned (in Smith case that's teammates :lmao: ). Yes, that's dirty in my opinion.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Let's put it differently for the slow folks on this board:

Even if you don't believe the "sample" is representative of the overall population of NFL players, and you believe that the remaining 5/6 of players don't think Ward is a dirty player --- that still leaves ~2% of all NFL players who think Ward is the dirtiest player in the league. That is a lot.

 

Users who are viewing this thread

Back
Top