Let's replay the 1st round in redrafts shall we... (1 Viewer)

[Ministry of Pain]

1.01 LT...I'll let you all discuss

1.02 ADP...not scoring a lot of TD but he certainly is going to rack up close to 2,000 rushing this year.

1.03 Westbrook

1.04 T.Brady...OUCH!!!

1.05 J.Addai...not lightin it up so far

1.06 S.Jackson...not so much

1.07 R.Moss...with Brady gone I wonder how many would take him at this point again.

1.08 MB III...so far so good

1.09 C.Portis...good 1 week, not so good the last

1.10 Larry Johnson...not so much

1.11 M.Lynch...looks pretty good

1.12 R.Wayne/TO...either one of these seems like good choices so far.

Knowing what you know so far, what would you change?

 

[CASS101]

Frank Gore down?

 

[Marc Levin]

Frank Gore down?

 

[travdogg]

I'd say in a 12-teamer with ppr the 1st round would go as follows:

1. Westbrook

2. Tomlinson

3. Peterson

4. Romo, I'm not sure there's another RB or any WR I'd rather have.

5. Barber

6. Addai

7. Owens

8. Wayne

9. Marshall, he's looking like he'll be huge this year.

10. Portis

11. Lynch

12. Manning, the Colts are gonna be fine

Honorable mention: McNabb, comeback player of the year?

I don't like Jackson(team is awful and likely will stay awful) or LJ(doesn't look to be himself and has even worse team than Jackson)

Brady is out and Moss isn't the same without him.

Sleeper: Michael Turner, struggled against Tampa, but the Falcons have a nice schedule and he'll have some big runs.

 

[djjosee]

1.09 C.Portis...good 1 week, not so good the last

 

[Ministry of Pain]

1.09 C.Portis...good 1 week, not so good the last

He did great this week...last week he had 23/84 which is good from an NFL perspective, but he wasn't in the top30 I don't think last week.

 

[Eviloutsider]

If I was going to redraft right now here is my first round...

1) Peterson

2) LT

3) Westbrook

4) Barber

5) Portis

6) Gore

7) S Jackson

8) Lynch

9) Addaii

10) Manning

11) Moss

12) W. Parker (reach)

 

[AhrnCityPahnder]

Frank Gore down?

for real. any draft that I had 1.05 or later, I took Gore.

 

[Krewe]

1.09 C.Portis...good 1 week, not so good the last

He did great this week...last week he had 23/84 which is good from an NFL perspective, but he wasn't in the top30 I don't think last week.

Um, since his "not so good the last" was against the Giants, who havent given up a rushing TD since the first play of the second quarter of the Super Bowl---I'd be inclined to cut him some slack. He looks just fine.

 

[FavreCo]

Larry Johnson is totally worthless. Everyone should have seen that coming.

 

[CASS101]

Frank Gore down?

for real. any draft that I had 1.05 or later, I took Gore.

Absolutely.

 

[Raider Nation]

Peterson had 180 total yards yesterday, and nobody even talks about it. He's so taken for granted already.

STUD

If we drafted today for '08 in a non-PPR, would anyone not take him first?

 

[jurb26]

Peterson had 180 total yards yesterday, and nobody even talks about it. He's so taken for granted already.

STUD

If we drafted today for '08 in a non-PPR, would anyone not take him first?

Yeah, I'd take Westy ahead of him.

 

[Raider Nation]

Peterson had 180 total yards yesterday, and nobody even talks about it. He's so taken for granted already.

STUD

If we drafted today for '08 in a non-PPR, would anyone not take him first?

Yeah, I'd take Westy ahead of him.

I respect that. I disagree... but I respect it.

 

[Ghost Rider]

Peterson had 180 total yards yesterday, and nobody even talks about it. He's so taken for granted already.

STUD

If we drafted today for '08 in a non-PPR, would anyone not take him first?

Is Brad Childress still his coach and Tarvaris Jackson his QB?

 

[Raider Nation]

Peterson had 180 total yards yesterday, and nobody even talks about it. He's so taken for granted already.

STUD

If we drafted today for '08 in a non-PPR, would anyone not take him first?

Is Brad Childress still his coach and Tarvaris Jackson his QB?

Imagine the numbers he'd put up with an NFL QB in front of him?

 

[Garts]

Steven Jackson is not a first round pick...he plays on a CFL team.

 

[Raider Nation]

I guarantee that after yesterday's performance, Marshall would sneak his way into the 1st round of many drafts if we drafted tomorrow for the rest of the '08 season... and in a PPR, it's a no-brainer. Moss went in the 1st round of most drafts. Well, Marshall is what most people thought Moss would be.

 

[Ghost Rider]

Peterson had 180 total yards yesterday, and nobody even talks about it. He's so taken for granted already.

STUD

If we drafted today for '08 in a non-PPR, would anyone not take him first?

Is Brad Childress still his coach and Tarvaris Jackson his QB?

Imagine the numbers he'd put up with an NFL QB in front of him?

Oh, I have. It would be sick.

 

[jurb26]

I guarantee that after yesterday's performance, Marshall would sneak his way into the 1st round of many drafts if we drafted tomorrow for the rest of the '08 season... and in a PPR, it's a no-brainer. Moss went in the 1st round of most drafts. Well, Marshall is what most people thought Moss would be.

No, he really isn't. Moss scored 23 TDs last year and has gone for 17+ TDs on 3 occasions. Catching a few balls, while impressive, doesn't put you near that company if you ask me. It's still about scoring and I'd still take Moss over Marshall for that even with Cassel throwing to him. PPR leagues, I'd probably agree with you.

 

[Raider Nation]

I guarantee that after yesterday's performance, Marshall would sneak his way into the 1st round of many drafts if we drafted tomorrow for the rest of the '08 season... and in a PPR, it's a no-brainer. Moss went in the 1st round of most drafts. Well, Marshall is what most people thought Moss would be.

No, he really isn't. Moss scored 23 TDs last year and has gone for 17+ TDs on 3 occasions. Catching a few balls, while impressive, doesn't put you near that company if you ask me. It's still about scoring and I'd still take Moss over Marshall for that even with Cassel throwing to him. PPR leagues, I'd probably agree with you.

Seriously? You'd rather have Moss than Marshall right now?Really???

 

[jurb26]

I guarantee that after yesterday's performance, Marshall would sneak his way into the 1st round of many drafts if we drafted tomorrow for the rest of the '08 season... and in a PPR, it's a no-brainer. Moss went in the 1st round of most drafts. Well, Marshall is what most people thought Moss would be.

No, he really isn't. Moss scored 23 TDs last year and has gone for 17+ TDs on 3 occasions. Catching a few balls, while impressive, doesn't put you near that company if you ask me. It's still about scoring and I'd still take Moss over Marshall for that even with Cassel throwing to him. PPR leagues, I'd probably agree with you.

Seriously? You'd rather have Moss than Marshall right now?Really???

In non PPR, yes. I'm trying to trade for Moss as we speak. Not giving up Marshall granted.

 

[Raider Nation]

I guarantee that after yesterday's performance, Marshall would sneak his way into the 1st round of many drafts if we drafted tomorrow for the rest of the '08 season... and in a PPR, it's a no-brainer. Moss went in the 1st round of most drafts. Well, Marshall is what most people thought Moss would be.

No, he really isn't. Moss scored 23 TDs last year and has gone for 17+ TDs on 3 occasions. Catching a few balls, while impressive, doesn't put you near that company if you ask me. It's still about scoring and I'd still take Moss over Marshall for that even with Cassel throwing to him. PPR leagues, I'd probably agree with you.

Seriously? You'd rather have Moss than Marshall right now?Really???

In non PPR, yes. I'm trying to trade for Moss as we speak. Not giving up Marshall granted.

Wow. As I said in the Moss thread yesterday, I am a Marshall owner. If the Moss owner emailed me offering him straight up for Marshall, I don't think I would even send a courtesy reply. Cassel is a steaming pile of average.

 

[Anthony Borbely]

I guarantee that after yesterday's performance, Marshall would sneak his way into the 1st round of many drafts if we drafted tomorrow for the rest of the '08 season... and in a PPR, it's a no-brainer. Moss went in the 1st round of most drafts. Well, Marshall is what most people thought Moss would be.

No, he really isn't. Moss scored 23 TDs last year and has gone for 17+ TDs on 3 occasions. Catching a few balls, while impressive, doesn't put you near that company if you ask me. It's still about scoring and I'd still take Moss over Marshall for that even with Cassel throwing to him. PPR leagues, I'd probably agree with you.

Seriously? You'd rather have Moss than Marshall right now?Really???

With Brady gone, I'd take Calvin ahead of both Moss and Marshall.

 

[nordstrom24]

Peterson had 180 total yards yesterday, and nobody even talks about it. He's so taken for granted already.

STUD

If we drafted today for '08 in a non-PPR, would anyone not take him first?

Yeah, I'd take Westy ahead of him.

This happened in our league - in 10 team redraft - #2 overall traded his 1st round pick to #1 overall and first pick went LT and Westy. I was kind of surprised he didn't go ADP given that we're not a PPR...The guy is still 2-0 though...

 

[thehornet]

I guarantee that after yesterday's performance, Marshall would sneak his way into the 1st round of many drafts if we drafted tomorrow for the rest of the '08 season... and in a PPR, it's a no-brainer. Moss went in the 1st round of most drafts. Well, Marshall is what most people thought Moss would be.

No, he really isn't. Moss scored 23 TDs last year and has gone for 17+ TDs on 3 occasions. Catching a few balls, while impressive, doesn't put you near that company if you ask me. It's still about scoring and I'd still take Moss over Marshall for that even with Cassel throwing to him. PPR leagues, I'd probably agree with you.

Seriously? You'd rather have Moss than Marshall right now?Really???

With Brady gone, I'd take Calvin ahead of both Moss and Marshall.

Please. Calvin will be Marshall's Caddy this year in any format.

 

[ScoobyDoo]

Steven Jackson is not a first round pick...he plays on a CFL team.

I agree.And I can't believe I got sucked in..........again.

 

[Billy Ball Thorton]

I guarantee that after yesterday's performance, Marshall would sneak his way into the 1st round of many drafts if we drafted tomorrow for the rest of the '08 season... and in a PPR, it's a no-brainer. Moss went in the 1st round of most drafts. Well, Marshall is what most people thought Moss would be.

No, he really isn't. Moss scored 23 TDs last year and has gone for 17+ TDs on 3 occasions. Catching a few balls, while impressive, doesn't put you near that company if you ask me. It's still about scoring and I'd still take Moss over Marshall for that even with Cassel throwing to him. PPR leagues, I'd probably agree with you.

WOW! Why not mention some of the (not so much) Moss years???If you would rather have Moss now than a guy like Marshall is funny.... Your the guy that drafts stricly off what the cheatsheet suggests I take it. Well the good news is Dodds will most likely still have Moss ahead of him.