12. Maybe the People Would Be the Times or Between Clark and Hilldale
Album: Forever Changes (1967)
Mrs. Rannous mentioned that side 2 of Neil Diamond's Tap Root Manuscript is an early example of "world music." "Maybe the People Would Be the Times or Between Clark and Hilldale," which opens side 2 of Love's
Forever Changes, is another example.
Don Quixote could do a better job of picking out the Latin music elements in this track, but I hear samba, rumba, bossa nova, and even jazz -- Arthur Lee scat-singing along with the trumpet solo sounds like something Tony Bennett would do.
However you want to label it, "Maybe the People..." is breezy and infectious and sticks into your head and doesn't let go. It's also memorable for Lee's wordplay -- at the end of each verse, he leaves off the last word, and then starts the next verse with that word.
The title and lyrics are a bit inscrutable, but many fans believe it is about how rock musicians wanted to tell everyone their takes on the Vietnam War and other issues of the day, but the fans don't care, they just want to boogie. The "Maybe the People Would be the Times" part of the title may refer to the false hope that the fans might become as socially conscious as the bands they like, and "Between Clark and Hilldale" is probably a reference to Love's frequent performance space The Whisky Au Go Go, which is on Sunset Boulevard in LA between the parallel streets of Clark and Hilldale.
What is happening and how have you been
Gotta go but I'll see you again
And oh, the music is so loud
And then I fade into the...
Crowds of people standing everywhere
'Cross the street I'm at this laugh affair
And here they always play my songs
And me, I wonder if it's...
Wrong or right they come here just the same
Telling everyone about their games
And if you think it obsolete
Then you go back across the street
Yeah, street, hey hey
When I leave now don't you weep for me
I'll be back, just save a seat for me
But if you just can't make the room
Look up and see me on the...
Moon's a common scene around my town
Here where everyone is painted brown
And if we feel that's not the way
Let's go paint everybody gray
Yeah, gray, yeah
There were no documented live performances of "Maybe the People..." until 1993, but it has been played regularly since 2002, including at the show I saw that year, and continues to be performed by The Love Band with John Echols today. Judging from stage setlists that have been posted to the internet, and from how Lee introduced it, it seems like the band refers to it as just "Between Clark and Hilldale" -- a lot less typing that way.
Alternate Mix:
https://open.spotify.com/track/6KGbZPd4hPNOFV4DBdydvZ?si=b0e9692ab9784074
Live version from the Roskilde Festival in Denmark in 2002 (appears on
Coming Through to You: The Live Recordings (1970-2004)):
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=hfilUnp4rw0
Live version from London in 2003 (appears on
The Forever Changes Concert):
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Qa32txV5nDk
Live version from the Glastonbury Festival in 2003:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ICHMHRXKecU
Live version from 2003 on Later With Jools Holland:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=pbmGpvLaf1U
Live version from 2006 at one of the Arthur Lee benefit concerts, with Baby Lemonade, who served as "Love" from the '90s on:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=NMjUIWsxFGc
The Love Band live in Costa Mesa, CA in 2023:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=UYgy5GQPoG8
Eephus: Michael Head covered this, with trumpets:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=BGs6U4IuMaE and
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=H1Cf2BfA6YM
The weirdest thing I am going to post in this countdown is Teenage Fanclub's cover on
We're All Normal and We Want Our Freedom: A Tribute to Arthur Lee and Love, which sounds like it was recorded underwater (Lee hated it):
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=TF9a2-STN38
At #11, after three straight from
Forever Changes, we return to
Da Capo and exchange trumpets for flutes.