26. Softly to Me
Album: Love (1966)
Writer: Bryan MacLean
Lead vocals: Bryan MacLean
"Softly to Me" is the first of four songs from Love's self-titled debut album and the only song in my top 31 that was neither written nor sung by Arthur Lee. It is the work of Bryan MacLean, the Karl Wallinger to Lee's Mike Scott -- the second banana of the band's early years.
MacLean was a roadie for the Byrds before joining Love, so it is no surprise that there are some Byrdsy elements to this song. Most obviously in the harmonies on the chorus, but also in the rumbling guitar parts at the beginning that sound a bit like "Eight Miles High." Wait, how can that be? This album was recorded before "Eight Miles High" was released. But MacLean's relationship with McGuinn et al made it likely that he knew of the song's existence before the general public did. However, "Softly to Me" is also distinctly Love: John Echols' jazzy guitar solo anticipates the direction that the band would take for the follow-up
Da Capo. It's a breezy slice of '60s pop that remains groovy to this day.
"Softly to Me" was issued as a single in the UK in 1967, after the release of the band's first two albums; it was backed with the
Da Capo track "The Castle". The single was reissued in 1969 with A and B sides flipped after "The Castle" was featured on a BBC show called "Holiday '69".
There are no documented live performances of "Softly to Me" from when MacLean and Lee were alive, but The Love Band with Echols has performed it occasionally since 2019, including at seven shows this year so far.
MacLean was one of many unsuccessful applicants for The Monkees and after that met Lee, who, figuring MacLean might draw some of the Byrds' fans to their shows, asked him to join his new band, then called The Grass Roots. The band's first three albums included four songs written by MacLean, three co-written by him and a cover on which he sang lead. But he wanted more of his songs to be recorded and fought with Lee about the issue constantly. This led to him quitting the band in 1968 and pursuing a solo deal, first with Love's label Elektra and then with Capitol. None of this came to fruition at the time, but the Elektra demos were finally released in 1997 as
ifyoubelievein. MacLean then became a Christian artist and had brief reunions with Lee in the late '70s and early '80s. His half-sister Maria McKee came to prominence in the '80s as frontwoman for the roots-rock band Lone Justice, and their debut album included a song penned by MacLean. MacLean died of a heart attack in 1998 at age 52, while Lee was in prison.
There are two other MacLean-penned songs in my top 31, both of which have Lee on some or all of the lead vocals. This means MacLean's
"Old Man," on which he did sing lead, is the only song from
Forever Changes that did not make my top 41, and the MacLean-fronted cover of
"Hey Joe" on the debut album (a song also recorded by MacLean's friends The Byrds and Lee's friend Jimi Hendrix) also missed the cut.
Live version by The Love Band with Echols from 2019 in Brighton, UK:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=lZwvkT6aW68
At #25, our first foray into
Da Capo. From side 1, of course.