And if you extend it all the way back to the beginning of his career in 2007, it's 8-7 with three AFCCG appearances, two SB appearances and one victory. Which is pretty good! Carroll is 9-5 with the Seahawks (10-7 career) and 2/2/1. Harbaugh is 10-5 and 3/1/1, but he's also only made the playoffs once since 2012. Payton is 7-5, 2/1/1 and has missed the playoffs in five of 11 years.If you extend out to seven years, cuz we're cherry picking, Tomlin's Steelers are 3-5 in the playoffs, one first round bye, one AFC Championship games, 0 SB's
I'd say Carroll is better, but Tomlin is clearly No. 3 (and for the record, Tomlin has a better regular-season win % than any of those coaches).