The Case Against Cutler (NY Times blog)
Since Brett Favre retired (again) in February, the buzz in the media and in the blogosphere has been that the Jets cannot enter the 2009 season with a battle of unknowns at quarterback. There has been rampant speculation that the Jets may make a play for Jay Cutler, offering up a young QB and a draft pick, perhaps.
Allow me to say: Don’t do it.
By wrestling his organization to the ground, Cutler has shown that he will deploy the nuclear option (”I won’t play, and you can’t make me”) when he is unhappy. He has shown that, with a guaranteed $16 million left to come in the next two years, and the starting QB job still his, he can still find a way to place a petty quarrel with a coach above the team.
Cutler is behaving as if he ought to be held in the same reverence as John Elway, who won two Super Bowls in his storied career, while Cutler has won exactly nothing, and who presided over a collapse eerily similar to that of the Jets in 2008.
Of course there is an upside: Cutler has a strong arm, good mobility, and might eventually develop into a consistent winner.
But if the Jets trade for Cutler, all of the media attention will immediately lash onto the new quarterback, which will immediately tilt the balance of power in the locker room and between player and organization.
His inflated ego, combined with his selfishness, combined with his seeming emotional instability, combined with the simple fact that he hasn’t won yet, add up to a headache that Rex Ryan does not need.
In other words, not my definition of “leader.”
Some may place less importance on this than I do, but the quarterback needs to be the most respected player on the team. There can be others, of course, but the quarterback must be above controversy and above finger pointing, either from him or toward him. That man is not Cutler, and it is not likely to be Cutler.
I make the occasional point that New York is a different place to play than another city. I’ve seen it written that Cutler has had to live in the shadow of Elway. No, that was Jake Plummer’s miserable fate. Cutler arrived as the antidote to Plummer’s perceived reckless play, and was given a lot of room to find his way by Denver fans. He has poisoned that relationship now, for sure. He would be offered no immunity in New York.
The Jets have three quarterbacks on the roster for a reason. As recently as 2007, they considered Kellen Clemens talented enough to start, and for all of 2008 we kept hearing what a future star Brett Ratliff is destined to be.
So, let’s find out. And while we do, we keep the cost of the position reasonable until we know what we have, and we build team unity, and Ryan has the opportunity to mold his new team in his image.
Which is, after all, what we got him for.
The downside of bringing Cutler in at this time far outweighs the upside, and it assumes facts not in evidence: that the Jets cannot find a reliable starter from the corps they currently have.
A new coach has free rein to jettison deadwood, to accomplish addition by subtraction. Obtaining Cutler runs an unnecessary and, in my view, unacceptable risk of achieving subtraction by addition.