T Bell
Footballguy
Really? I'm not saying I see them leaping to a top 5 offense, but I don't see how anyone can say they look the same as last year. Regardless of whether you think Kelly and Thomas are worthy of their draft spot, the WRs are an improvement over last year. Moving ARE to the slot and not having to play a guy like James Thrash is a step forward. They simply have more playmakers on the field than last year.With this improvement at WR, I expect a more aggressive attack. Their willingness to throw deep in preseason, I believe, is going to carry over into the regular season. Now, of course, to do that you have to have pass protection and the OL is the big question. If healthy, I think they are a slight improvement over last year's starting unit because of Dockery replacing Kendall and Heyer having another year under his belt. Yes, Thomas could break at any time and the backups are less reliable this year.Really, other than one game...our offense looks the same.
I think Malcolm Kelly is going to have a big impact simply because of his size. I've been impressed by him. ARE couldn't get separation a lot of times from the flanker spot, and he didn't have the size to make plays anyway by leaping or using body position. ARE in the slot is perfect. We now have the option of using 3 WR sets or 2 TE sets to create mismatches. I think this passing offense will finally start to look strong. It's up to the line to allow that to happen now.
I think we are mostly in agreement; it's just that I expect an improvement and you'd be surprised by one. I was initially excited to see Campbell against NE, but we've actually seen that before. He's had good games. He's looked like a Pro Bowler in a few games before. The problem is we haven't seen it week to week. Hopefully he can take that step and, like you say, the playcalling can take a step forward too.

I haven't been worried about anything offensively about the Giants all offseason thinking about this game. Until late last night. I started having visions of Bradshaw on sweeps and tosses finding the edge breaking off big plays. Somebody talk me back over to the bright side.
, though not nearly as much as any of us would like. Huge upgrade at punter.