I said this in "The Nine" thread: I think TV critics missed the boat this season - and underrated "Heroes" and overrated The Nine.
I think it's an open question. After just the pilot's I would have rated The Nine as better than Heroes. Of course, most critics see at least the first four episodes, and by now it's become clear that The Nine's concept isn't particularly engaging.But I do think that The Nine is "better crafted" than Heroes. I like the concept of Heroes a lot. And because we don't have a real comic influenced show on right now, I don't particularly care that it's stealing concepts from just about every successful comic book, sci fi novel, or genre television show ever. I do think that, much like Lost, the premise is far stronger than the execution on Heroes. But Heroes is unapologetic pulp, so it's easy to overlook that. For instance, Heroes is every bit as cliched as Friday Night Lights, but FNL's cliches stand out more in the more "realistic" setting of the show.