What's new
Fantasy Football - Footballguys Forums

This is a sample guest message. Register a free account today to become a member! Once signed in, you'll be able to participate on this site by adding your own topics and posts, as well as connect with other members through your own private inbox!

***Official*** Heroes Thread (2 Viewers)

Do we have any confirmation of the Haitian using his power cancelling power when Claire's adopted father wasn't around? With the way the powers are working out it would seem strange to me for the Haitian to be able to cancel powers and wipe memories. I know Haitian and neighbor girl seemed to be the only two that confronted Silar at the high school but adopted father was in the area too.

I am starting to wonder if maybe adopted father is the one that can cancel powers and thats how he is going to survive the confrontation with Silar. I am also wondering if adopted father might end up being real father.

 
So nobody thinks it's a possibility that Silar is Claire's father? Can anyone confirm whether or not the watch was the same as Silar's watch?

 
Do we have any confirmation of the Haitian using his power cancelling power when Claire's adopted father wasn't around? With the way the powers are working out it would seem strange to me for the Haitian to be able to cancel powers and wipe memories. I know Haitian and neighbor girl seemed to be the only two that confronted Silar at the high school but adopted father was in the area too. I am starting to wonder if maybe adopted father is the one that can cancel powers and thats how he is going to survive the confrontation with Silar. I am also wondering if adopted father might end up being real father.
Been covered ad nauseum in this thread......still split, with most believing the Haitian has the powers.
 
Nothing like sitting back with some :rolleyes: , looking like I am working, while enjoying a good Heroes show to start my Tuesday morning off.
My bad. I underestimated the power of not doing work. I am a teacher but if I wasnt and didnt have to worry about the students then I would be doing that also. Great idea
 
So nobody thinks it's a possibility that Silar is Claire's father? Can anyone confirm whether or not the watch was the same as Silar's watch?
I think it is a possibility, and an interesting thought, but why would his mission in life be to kill his own daughter?He's the one they had to save the cheerleader from.It's far more likely, based on the previews, that Claire's father is a man of importance. But, I do not discount the possibility.
 
P.S. - whoever was putting together the list, there are a few people Silar killed, including the waitress Hiro liked who worked in that diner and the guy Silar killed just before he wqent to the diner.

 
So nobody thinks it's a possibility that Silar is Claire's father? Can anyone confirm whether or not the watch was the same as Silar's watch?
I think it is a possibility, and an interesting thought, but why would his mission in life be to kill his own daughter?He's the one they had to save the cheerleader from.It's far more likely, based on the previews, that Claire's father is a man of importance. But, I do not discount the possibility.
He's killing the Heroes to takte their powers. He also doesn't know that his daughter is still alive (until he gets the call from his ex-wife next week). Therefore, to him, Claire is just some random girl with powers, not his daughter.edited to make my statement clearer. If Silar is the father, as far as he knows, his daughter died in the fire. So to him Claire would just be some random girl with powers he can steal.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
P.S. - whoever was putting together the list, there are a few people Silar killed, including the waitress Hiro liked who worked in that diner and the guy Silar killed just before he wqent to the diner.
:unsure: He has killed several people. The first was the guy who's address and name he took from his meeting with the professor. He also killed the guy he froze in the house where Matt finds the girl. The FBI is after him because of all the people he has killed. All of these people would have been on the list.
 
Anyone else think Claires mom was a villian type figure, while Claireis clearly a heroine
Yes.But if she's not a villian, then she's probably in the mold of 'tragic hero' who does more harm than good, usually through some sort of emotional conflict within themselves, despite their good intentions.
 
So nobody thinks it's a possibility that Silar is Claire's father? Can anyone confirm whether or not the watch was the same as Silar's watch?
I think it is a possibility, and an interesting thought, but why would his mission in life be to kill his own daughter?He's the one they had to save the cheerleader from.It's far more likely, based on the previews, that Claire's father is a man of importance. But, I do not discount the possibility.
He's killing the Heroes to takte their powers. He also doesn't know that his daughter is still alive (until he gets the call from his ex-wife next week). Therefore, to him, Claire is just some random girl with powers, not his daughter.edited to make my statement clearer. If Silar is the father, as far as he knows, his daughter died in the fire. So to him Claire would just be some random girl with powers he can steal.
Hard to believe that Sylar had made it to a phone number the ex-wife would know and had gotten dressed up that fast, french cuffs no less. Timeline seems to make him an impossibility plus I don't think he is old enough.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
NCCommish said:
Boone22 said:
Marc Levin said:
Boone22 said:
So nobody thinks it's a possibility that Silar is Claire's father? Can anyone confirm whether or not the watch was the same as Silar's watch?
I think it is a possibility, and an interesting thought, but why would his mission in life be to kill his own daughter?He's the one they had to save the cheerleader from.It's far more likely, based on the previews, that Claire's father is a man of importance. But, I do not discount the possibility.
He's killing the Heroes to takte their powers. He also doesn't know that his daughter is still alive (until he gets the call from his ex-wife next week). Therefore, to him, Claire is just some random girl with powers, not his daughter.edited to make my statement clearer. If Silar is the father, as far as he knows, his daughter died in the fire. So to him Claire would just be some random girl with powers he can steal.
Hard to believe that Sylar had made it to a phone number the ex-wife would know and had gotten dressed up that fast, french cuffs no less. Timeline seems to make him an impossibility plus I don't think he is old enough.
That, and the fact that there is no way either Silar or HRG would wear a gay magenta shirt. :lmao:
 
-I also heard a ticking clock in the scenes with Sylar, I think they started when he opened his eyes after being "dead". Did he learn to die, or learn to not die, from the cockroach??

-The beginning of one of the scenes with Matt and wife showed wind chimes outside their window. I think it was after the scene were Claire hangs hers in the window.

-I am thinking the thing hanging from Sylar's head was what HRG and the doctor were using to try and figure out what his powers were, and how he got them.

 
NCCommish said:
Boone22 said:
Marc Levin said:
Boone22 said:
So nobody thinks it's a possibility that Silar is Claire's father? Can anyone confirm whether or not the watch was the same as Silar's watch?
I think it is a possibility, and an interesting thought, but why would his mission in life be to kill his own daughter?He's the one they had to save the cheerleader from.It's far more likely, based on the previews, that Claire's father is a man of importance. But, I do not discount the possibility.
He's killing the Heroes to takte their powers. He also doesn't know that his daughter is still alive (until he gets the call from his ex-wife next week). Therefore, to him, Claire is just some random girl with powers, not his daughter.edited to make my statement clearer. If Silar is the father, as far as he knows, his daughter died in the fire. So to him Claire would just be some random girl with powers he can steal.
Hard to believe that Sylar had made it to a phone number the ex-wife would know and had gotten dressed up that fast, french cuffs no less. Timeline seems to make him an impossibility plus I don't think he is old enough.
Also, he ends up waiting for Claire at her house and threatens Claire's adoptive mom. I think it's a pretty long shot to think it's Sylar.I think all signs are pointing to Linderman. IMO, Nathan is too young to be the father. Hiro was great, and there is a record of Hiro coming to the states. He had to fly coach with Ando.
 
NCCommish said:
Boone22 said:
Marc Levin said:
Boone22 said:
So nobody thinks it's a possibility that Silar is Claire's father? Can anyone confirm whether or not the watch was the same as Silar's watch?
I think it is a possibility, and an interesting thought, but why would his mission in life be to kill his own daughter?He's the one they had to save the cheerleader from.It's far more likely, based on the previews, that Claire's father is a man of importance. But, I do not discount the possibility.
He's killing the Heroes to takte their powers. He also doesn't know that his daughter is still alive (until he gets the call from his ex-wife next week). Therefore, to him, Claire is just some random girl with powers, not his daughter.edited to make my statement clearer. If Silar is the father, as far as he knows, his daughter died in the fire. So to him Claire would just be some random girl with powers he can steal.
Hard to believe that Sylar had made it to a phone number the ex-wife would know and had gotten dressed up that fast, french cuffs no less. Timeline seems to make him an impossibility plus I don't think he is old enough.
Also, he ends up waiting for Claire at her house and threatens Claire's adoptive mom. I think it's a pretty long shot to think it's Sylar.I think all signs are pointing to Linderman. IMO, Nathan is too young to be the father. Hiro was great, and there is a record of Hiro coming to the states. He had to fly coach with Ando.
He flew twice actually. After the trip back 6 months, he had to fly back to the US to reuite with Ando as well.Lindeman's also my guess as well, although they seem to be focusing a lot on watches for a lot of people, possibly in an effort to throw a little confusion into the mix.
 
Another Hero to add is the guy in the Shed that was flinging flames from one hand to the other in last weeks episode.

I believe Claire's real mother is a teacher from Boston Public if anyone watched that show.

 
NCCommish said:
Boone22 said:
Marc Levin said:
Boone22 said:
So nobody thinks it's a possibility that Silar is Claire's father? Can anyone confirm whether or not the watch was the same as Silar's watch?
I think it is a possibility, and an interesting thought, but why would his mission in life be to kill his own daughter?He's the one they had to save the cheerleader from.

It's far more likely, based on the previews, that Claire's father is a man of importance. But, I do not discount the possibility.
He's killing the Heroes to takte their powers. He also doesn't know that his daughter is still alive (until he gets the call from his ex-wife next week). Therefore, to him, Claire is just some random girl with powers, not his daughter.edited to make my statement clearer. If Silar is the father, as far as he knows, his daughter died in the fire. So to him Claire would just be some random girl with powers he can steal.
Hard to believe that Sylar had made it to a phone number the ex-wife would know and had gotten dressed up that fast, french cuffs no less. Timeline seems to make him an impossibility plus I don't think he is old enough.
Also, he ends up waiting for Claire at her house and threatens Claire's adoptive mom. I think it's a pretty long shot to think it's Sylar.I think all signs are pointing to Linderman. IMO, Nathan is too young to be the father.

Hiro was great, and there is a record of Hiro coming to the states. He had to fly coach with Ando.
I can't believe one person mention Nathan being too young, but no one said Sylar was too young. Sylar is probably around Peter's age, i.e. younger than Nathan. Based on his clock fixing abilities, I would say his sexual prowess at about age 9 was probably not enough to register.I would stake my ability to post in the Lost thread on the fact that Sylar is most definitely not the father and I would bet $$$ that Nathan is not.

It seems pretty simple that they have to introduce Linderman soon (Simone setting up a meeting), so he is the odds on favorite. The only other potential father to me is someone we have not met.

ETA: Damn NCC did mention Sylar being too young. Missed that one.

 
Last edited by a moderator:
SuperJohn96 said:
AcerFC said:
Anyone else think Claires mom was a villian type figure, while Claireis clearly a heroine
Yes.But if she's not a villian, then she's probably in the mold of 'tragic hero' who does more harm than good, usually through some sort of emotional conflict within themselves, despite their good intentions.
I definitely don't think she is a villain (note the spelling :pics: ).She has thought for 14 years that she killed her own 18 month old daughter. It was a fire, so I think with the display of her power, we can safely assume that the mom started it. That would make sense since that fire might have been one of the first times her power manifested. See radioactive man killing his own wife. She definitely seemed emotionally scarred, so she is probably unstable at best, but I doubt she is a villain.
 
NCCommish said:
Boone22 said:
Marc Levin said:
Boone22 said:
So nobody thinks it's a possibility that Silar is Claire's father? Can anyone confirm whether or not the watch was the same as Silar's watch?
I think it is a possibility, and an interesting thought, but why would his mission in life be to kill his own daughter?He's the one they had to save the cheerleader from.

It's far more likely, based on the previews, that Claire's father is a man of importance. But, I do not discount the possibility.
He's killing the Heroes to takte their powers. He also doesn't know that his daughter is still alive (until he gets the call from his ex-wife next week). Therefore, to him, Claire is just some random girl with powers, not his daughter.edited to make my statement clearer. If Silar is the father, as far as he knows, his daughter died in the fire. So to him Claire would just be some random girl with powers he can steal.
Hard to believe that Sylar had made it to a phone number the ex-wife would know and had gotten dressed up that fast, french cuffs no less. Timeline seems to make him an impossibility plus I don't think he is old enough.
Also, he ends up waiting for Claire at her house and threatens Claire's adoptive mom. I think it's a pretty long shot to think it's Sylar.I think all signs are pointing to Linderman. IMO, Nathan is too young to be the father.

Hiro was great, and there is a record of Hiro coming to the states. He had to fly coach with Ando.
I can't believe one person mention Nathan being too young, but no one said Sylar was too young. Sylar is probably around Peter's age, i.e. younger than Nathan. Based on his clock fixing abilities, I would say his sexual prowess at about age 9 was probably not enough to register.I would stake my ability to post in the Lost thread on the fact that Sylar is most definitely not the father and I would bet $$$ that Nathan is not.

It seems pretty simple that they have to introduce Linderman soon (Simone setting up a meeting), so he is the odds on favorite. The only other potential father to me is someone we have not met.

ETA: Damn NCC did mention Sylar being too young. Missed that one.
I thought it, there was just enough eveidence pointing to Sylar not being the father to focus on. The only reason everyone thinks Nathan is the father is because the preview showed a nicely dressed man.
 
Buckychudd said:
Zalf said:
Do we have any confirmation of the Haitian using his power cancelling power when Claire's adopted father wasn't around? With the way the powers are working out it would seem strange to me for the Haitian to be able to cancel powers and wipe memories. I know Haitian and neighbor girl seemed to be the only two that confronted Silar at the high school but adopted father was in the area too. I am starting to wonder if maybe adopted father is the one that can cancel powers and thats how he is going to survive the confrontation with Silar. I am also wondering if adopted father might end up being real father.
Been covered ad nauseum in this thread......still split, with most believing the Haitian has the powers.
We have seen the Haitian do his trick many times and he has even said to Claire that he wiped the memories of many people. We have never seen HRG display any power or be in a room by himself and not be affected. It sure looked like Sylar was tossing HRG around in the previews.I think that the Haitian's powers are all about memories/mind control. I do not think he has any type of cancelling powers. We saw Nathan fly away right in front of him and HRG. You can't say that they didn't know because they grabbed him from the hotel room and said to leave Nikki for the time being.In all of the Haitian's power use, I think we can explain it without assuming he can cancel powers. Even in the case with the persuasion girl (I forgot her name), it appeared that she had HRG, but then he snapped out of it, i.e. the Haitian wiped out the thought of persuasion.The only thing I still don't get and I don't know if they will ever explain it, is how they stopped Sylar from doing anything. I was just thinking that maybe it was the drugs that they were using to examine him, but that wouldn't explain how Sylar killed the girl.
 
This is an article from TV Guide.com as written in TV Guide. Some minor spoilers are included, nothing major imo especially if you're up to date on the episodes. Enjoy.

A Hero Will Die!

Brace yourself for shocking revelations and unexpected plot twists

by Michael Logan

Claire finds her birth parents. Peter vanishes. Hiro's father shows up, and so does a startling new Israeli hero with high-tech capabilities. Someone will die. NBC's Heroes is headed for an explosive February. To get the scoop on the next few episodes (and a hint of what's to come in Season 2) TV Guide went to the man with the real superpowers — Heroes creator and executive producer Tim Kring.

Hit us with the bad news first. Who's dying? Are we going to hate you? Some people will be upset, sure. During February sweeps we are going to kill off one of our regulars, someone who has been with the show from the very beginning.

You're using the word "regular" as opposed to "hero." Is that a clue? You know what? I personally never use the term "hero" because I happen to know that, ultimately, some of these seemingly heroic characters will not be heroic. But with our ability to bend time and change things, not all those who are killed are making their last appearance on the show — and we actually do have plans for the character who's dying.

We'll see Claire's biological mom — played by Nip/Tuck's Jessalyn Gilsig — on Jan. 29. How will that unfold? Claire sets out to locate her birth mother and finds her living in a trailer park in an old Airstream. That'll be a shock, but the identity of Claire's father will be a bigger shock.

There's a rumor that this will be a highly soapy revelation and that viewers are already familiar with the dad. True? I'll say no more about that except that the reveal will be a lot of fun for the audience. That'll also happen in February, but then Claire still has to go on the road to find him. Once she meets her true parents, it will become even more important for her to find other people like her.

Will H.R.G. know about these meetings? No, they will be clandestine. Claire will not have a lot of family stuff at home in Odessa, Texas, for the remainder of the season. Her trust in H.R.G. is out the window.

So after riding the fence with H.R.G., you're making him a true villain? There's no shade of gray with him, but I've never tried to fool the audience with that. Both sides of the guy's personality are equally honest. He's very nefarious and very loving.

After Eden shot herself in the head, why did you have H.R.G. go to such drastic lengths to get rid of her body? It seemed like overkill! I liked the idea that the audience knew she died in Odessa, but that she ended up in a lake 2,000 miles away in Canada. For me it shows that the organization has a tremendous reach and a capability to do crazy things. It means they can make all kinds of things go away.

Continuing with your "Meet the Parents" theme, Hiro's father — played by George Takei — also pops up Jan. 29, right? And it's going to be blow-your-mind cool. The character will provide a gateway into a whole world back in Japan that we will explore in Season 2 — a story about Hiro's family and his past.

Will Hiro regain control of his powers? He'll be a little handicapped for a while. Hiro can't be so powerful that he becomes a crutch for bad writing. That's why we had him fail to save the waitress. We can't have him go back in time and fix everything. Hiro's quest for the sword will take him from naive boy to a real man.

The mysterious, unseen mobster Linderman is growing in importance. Hiro and Ando are headed to Las Vegas to find him, and we know he has connections to Niki, D.L., Simone and Nathan. Will we see him soon? He will continue to grow as a force and be revealed after February. The casting on this one is tricky. We've already built such a huge aura around Linderman that we don't want to disappoint, yet it could be cheesy to suddenly see a big-name star in the role. This isn't that kind of show.
 
I dont know if this has been suggested yet but does anyone think that Linderman may have funded Mohinder's father and his research. There is just too much coincidence for him to not know certain things.

 
Last edited by a moderator:
This is an article from TV Guide.com as written in TV Guide. Some minor spoilers are included, nothing major imo especially if you're up to date on the episodes. Enjoy.

A Hero Will Die!

Brace yourself for shocking revelations and unexpected plot twists

by Michael Logan

There's a rumor that this will be a highly soapy revelation and that viewers are already familiar with the dad. True? I'll say no more about that except that the reveal will be a lot of fun for the audience. That'll also happen in February, but then Claire still has to go on the road to find him. Once she meets her true parents, it will become even more important for her to find other people like her.

The mysterious, unseen mobster Linderman is growing in importance. Hiro and Ando are headed to Las Vegas to find him, and we know he has connections to Niki, D.L., Simone and Nathan. Will we see him soon? He will continue to grow as a force and be revealed after February. The casting on this one is tricky. We've already built such a huge aura around Linderman that we don't want to disappoint, yet it could be cheesy to suddenly see a big-name star in the role. This isn't that kind of show.
If what is bolded is true, it sounds like Linderman may not be Claire's father.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
This is an article from TV Guide.com as written in TV Guide. Some minor spoilers are included, nothing major imo especially if you're up to date on the episodes. Enjoy.

A Hero Will Die!

Brace yourself for shocking revelations and unexpected plot twists

by Michael Logan

Claire finds her birth parents. Peter vanishes. Hiro's father shows up, and so does a startling new Israeli hero with high-tech capabilities. Someone will die. NBC's Heroes is headed for an explosive February. To get the scoop on the next few episodes (and a hint of what's to come in Season 2) TV Guide went to the man with the real superpowers — Heroes creator and executive producer Tim Kring.

Hit us with the bad news first. Who's dying? Are we going to hate you? Some people will be upset, sure. During February sweeps we are going to kill off one of our regulars, someone who has been with the show from the very beginning.

You're using the word "regular" as opposed to "hero." Is that a clue? You know what? I personally never use the term "hero" because I happen to know that, ultimately, some of these seemingly heroic characters will not be heroic. But with our ability to bend time and change things, not all those who are killed are making their last appearance on the show — and we actually do have plans for the character who's dying.

We'll see Claire's biological mom — played by Nip/Tuck's Jessalyn Gilsig — on Jan. 29. How will that unfold? Claire sets out to locate her birth mother and finds her living in a trailer park in an old Airstream. That'll be a shock, but the identity of Claire's father will be a bigger shock.

There's a rumor that this will be a highly soapy revelation and that viewers are already familiar with the dad. True? I'll say no more about that except that the reveal will be a lot of fun for the audience. That'll also happen in February, but then Claire still has to go on the road to find him. Once she meets her true parents, it will become even more important for her to find other people like her.

Will H.R.G. know about these meetings? No, they will be clandestine. Claire will not have a lot of family stuff at home in Odessa, Texas, for the remainder of the season. Her trust in H.R.G. is out the window.

So after riding the fence with H.R.G., you're making him a true villain? There's no shade of gray with him, but I've never tried to fool the audience with that. Both sides of the guy's personality are equally honest. He's very nefarious and very loving.

After Eden shot herself in the head, why did you have H.R.G. go to such drastic lengths to get rid of her body? It seemed like overkill! I liked the idea that the audience knew she died in Odessa, but that she ended up in a lake 2,000 miles away in Canada. For me it shows that the organization has a tremendous reach and a capability to do crazy things. It means they can make all kinds of things go away.

Continuing with your "Meet the Parents" theme, Hiro's father — played by George Takei — also pops up Jan. 29, right? And it's going to be blow-your-mind cool. The character will provide a gateway into a whole world back in Japan that we will explore in Season 2 — a story about Hiro's family and his past.

Will Hiro regain control of his powers? He'll be a little handicapped for a while. Hiro can't be so powerful that he becomes a crutch for bad writing. That's why we had him fail to save the waitress. We can't have him go back in time and fix everything. Hiro's quest for the sword will take him from naive boy to a real man.

The mysterious, unseen mobster Linderman is growing in importance. Hiro and Ando are headed to Las Vegas to find him, and we know he has connections to Niki, D.L., Simone and Nathan. Will we see him soon? He will continue to grow as a force and be revealed after February. The casting on this one is tricky. We've already built such a huge aura around Linderman that we don't want to disappoint, yet it could be cheesy to suddenly see a big-name star in the role. This isn't that kind of show.
If you read carefully it seems Linderman won't be Claires father..
 
I see Niki getting killed. Her story line isn't really going in the same direction as the rest of the Heros.
I agree with you about the story line but we need to understand what the power is and who has it. I dont think Nikki has any powers. Its Jessica that has the power. I also dont think she is bi polar, I think something happened when Jessica died and somehow she became part of Nikki. Maybe that is Nikkis power. Who Knows. Jessica's power is obviously super strength. It will be interesting to see where it goes. I dont think they kill of the hot girl on the show. Wouldnt be great for ratings unless the Israeli is hot
 
I'm thinking Ted the Nuke guy bites it.

He's been with the show since the begining, even if he was edited out of the first show.

 
I see Niki getting killed. Her story line isn't really going in the same direction as the rest of the Heros.
I agree with you about the story line but we need to understand what the power is and who has it. I dont think Nikki has any powers. Its Jessica that has the power. I also dont think she is bi polar, I think something happened when Jessica died and somehow she became part of Nikki. Maybe that is Nikkis power. Who Knows. Jessica's power is obviously super strength. It will be interesting to see where it goes. I dont think they kill of the hot girl on the show. Wouldnt be great for ratings unless the Israeli is hot
what if in an internal struggle either either Niki or Jessica bite itthen the other has sole control of the body, while a "regular" on the show is no longer
 
I see Niki getting killed. Her story line isn't really going in the same direction as the rest of the Heros.
I agree with you about the story line but we need to understand what the power is and who has it. I dont think Nikki has any powers. Its Jessica that has the power. I also dont think she is bi polar, I think something happened when Jessica died and somehow she became part of Nikki. Maybe that is Nikkis power. Who Knows. Jessica's power is obviously super strength. It will be interesting to see where it goes. I dont think they kill of the hot girl on the show. Wouldnt be great for ratings unless the Israeli is hot
what if in an internal struggle either either Niki or Jessica bite itthen the other has sole control of the body, while a "regular" on the show is no longer
I like it
 
This is an article from TV Guide.com as written in TV Guide. Some minor spoilers are included, nothing major imo especially if you're up to date on the episodes. Enjoy.

A Hero Will Die!

Brace yourself for shocking revelations and unexpected plot twists

by Michael Logan

There's a rumor that this will be a highly soapy revelation and that viewers are already familiar with the dad. True? I'll say no more about that except that the reveal will be a lot of fun for the audience. That'll also happen in February, but then Claire still has to go on the road to find him. Once she meets her true parents, it will become even more important for her to find other people like her.

The mysterious, unseen mobster Linderman is growing in importance. Hiro and Ando are headed to Las Vegas to find him, and we know he has connections to Niki, D.L., Simone and Nathan. Will we see him soon? He will continue to grow as a force and be revealed after February. The casting on this one is tricky. We've already built such a huge aura around Linderman that we don't want to disappoint, yet it could be cheesy to suddenly see a big-name star in the role. This isn't that kind of show.
If what is bolded is true, it sounds like Linderman may not be Claire's father.
:thumbup: , but since it say she "has to go on the road to find him" that rules out HRG being her dad also. Maybe it is Nathan after all.
 
Sylar is far too young to be Claire's father. Not even a remote possibility IMO.

Since the TV Guide interview seems to indicate that Linderman is not the father, I guess that leaves Nathan.

The character dying could be just about anyone besides: Claire, Hiro, Peter. They're the only ones that I couldn't see leaving the show.

 
Dave Baker said:
Sylar is far too young to be Claire's father. Not even a remote possibility IMO.Since the TV Guide interview seems to indicate that Linderman is not the father, I guess that leaves Nathan.The character dying could be just about anyone besides: Claire, Hiro, Peter. They're the only ones that I couldn't see leaving the show.
we have already seen Claire die once, only to come back to life when the stick was pulled out of her headshe could "die" once again, but it won't be permanent
 
Dave Baker said:
Sylar is far too young to be Claire's father. Not even a remote possibility IMO.Since the TV Guide interview seems to indicate that Linderman is not the father, I guess that leaves Nathan.The character dying could be just about anyone besides: Claire, Hiro, Peter. They're the only ones that I couldn't see leaving the show.
I'm really going to be disappointed if Claire's father is Nathan. Hopefully they were just trying to mislead us in the interview.
 
Dave Baker said:
Sylar is far too young to be Claire's father. Not even a remote possibility IMO.Since the TV Guide interview seems to indicate that Linderman is not the father, I guess that leaves Nathan.The character dying could be just about anyone besides: Claire, Hiro, Peter. They're the only ones that I couldn't see leaving the show.
I'm really going to be disappointed if Claire's father is Nathan. Hopefully they were just trying to mislead us in the interview.
no clue who claire's father is, but it will NOT be Nathanno facts to back it up, but that just seems like the easy way out, and they are more into surprises
 
Dave Baker said:
Sylar is far too young to be Claire's father. Not even a remote possibility IMO.

Since the TV Guide interview seems to indicate that Linderman is not the father, I guess that leaves Nathan.

The character dying could be just about anyone besides: Claire, Hiro, Peter. They're the only ones that I couldn't see leaving the show.
I'm really going to be disappointed if Claire's father is Nathan. Hopefully they were just trying to mislead us in the interview.
no clue who claire's father is, but it will NOT be Nathanno facts to back it up, but that just seems like the easy way out, and they are more into surprises
???The easy way out is to make Lindehman her father - that is the clear implication from everything going on. HRG Has had no interaction with the Lindehman character and HRG def. knows who Claire's parents are. HRG tried to capture Nathan in episode 1.

IMO, it'll be Lindehman.

Just read the TV Guide piece.

 
Last edited by a moderator:
Dave Baker said:
Sylar is far too young to be Claire's father. Not even a remote possibility IMO.Since the TV Guide interview seems to indicate that Linderman is not the father, I guess that leaves Nathan.The character dying could be just about anyone besides: Claire, Hiro, Peter. They're the only ones that I couldn't see leaving the show.
I'm really going to be disappointed if Claire's father is Nathan. Hopefully they were just trying to mislead us in the interview.
no clue who claire's father is, but it will NOT be Nathanno facts to back it up, but that just seems like the easy way out, and they are more into surprises
???The easy way out is to make Lindehman her father - that is the clear implication from everything going on. HRG Has had no interaction with the Lindehman character and HRG def. knows who Claire's parents are. HRG tried to capture Nathan in episode 1.IMO, it'll be Lindehman.
If you read the T.V. Guide info there are two parts that seem to show no to this:We will see Claire find her father in Feb.Linderman won't be seen until after Feb.Could be a :shrug: look over here, but if we can take the interview at face value it will NOT be linderman.
 
Dave Baker said:
Sylar is far too young to be Claire's father. Not even a remote possibility IMO.Since the TV Guide interview seems to indicate that Linderman is not the father, I guess that leaves Nathan.The character dying could be just about anyone besides: Claire, Hiro, Peter. They're the only ones that I couldn't see leaving the show.
I'm really going to be disappointed if Claire's father is Nathan. Hopefully they were just trying to mislead us in the interview.
no clue who claire's father is, but it will NOT be Nathanno facts to back it up, but that just seems like the easy way out, and they are more into surprises
???The easy way out is to make Lindehman her father - that is the clear implication from everything going on. HRG Has had no interaction with the Lindehman character and HRG def. knows who Claire's parents are. HRG tried to capture Nathan in episode 1.IMO, it'll be Lindehman.
If you read the T.V. Guide info there are two parts that seem to show no to this:We will see Claire find her father in Feb.Linderman won't be seen until after Feb.Could be a :blackdot: look over here, but if we can take the interview at face value it will NOT be linderman.
Ya'll are reading too much into this.The interview said they will reveal who the dad is in Feb, not show him and not have Claire find him. It could easily be that they have the mother call and say "Hey Linderman, guess what? Your daughter is still alive." and never show him.
 
Another way we can interpret the interview is:

Linderman is Claire's father. We find that out nect week but we do not see his face until after Feb.

 

Users who are viewing this thread

Back
Top