What's new
Fantasy Football - Footballguys Forums

This is a sample guest message. Register a free account today to become a member! Once signed in, you'll be able to participate on this site by adding your own topics and posts, as well as connect with other members through your own private inbox!

***Official Super Bowl XLII Game Thread*** (2 Viewers)

OC Zed said:
Joe Bryant said:
Craig_MiamiFL said:
How's the studio Tiki? Speak up ....can't hear you. #####It's nice of ex-Giant TE Jeremy Shockey to make the trip to take in the game.
Click to expand...
Agreed. Why wasn't Shockey on the sidelines?J
Click to expand...
It's not uncommon for injured players to be in the stands/team box. Sometimes it's actually team policy set by the head coach. When Parcells coached the Giants, players on IR were strictly forbidden from being near the active players on gameday.
Click to expand...
#15 Michael Jennings on the IR was on the sidelines with his teammates
 
Last edited by a moderator:
My mistake. Watched again. Tyree's but was not down. His butt landed on Harrison. He was not down until his shoulders hit. Still clearly a catch, but I did not want to confuse the issue. I should have reviewed the play closer before posting.

 
Ditkaless Wonders said:
My mistake. Watched again. Tyree's but was not down. His butt landed on Harrison. He was not down until his shoulders hit. Still clearly a catch, but I did not want to confuse the issue. I should have reviewed the play closer before posting.
Click to expand...
Not your fault. I just got the first really good reviews of it on Sportscenter too. But my point is still valid, regardless of whether we argue about the catch, why the hell didn't the booth call down a review?
 
HellToupee said:
OC Zed said:
Joe Bryant said:
Craig_MiamiFL said:
How's the studio Tiki? Speak up ....can't hear you. #####It's nice of ex-Giant TE Jeremy Shockey to make the trip to take in the game.
Click to expand...
Agreed. Why wasn't Shockey on the sidelines?J
Click to expand...
It's not uncommon for injured players to be in the stands/team box. Sometimes it's actually team policy set by the head coach. When Parcells coached the Giants, players on IR were strictly forbidden from being near the active players on gameday.
Click to expand...
#15 Michael Jennings on the IR was on the sidelines with his teammates
Click to expand...
:shrug: I'm sure it's a player's decision. I understand a lot of the hate against Schockey, but I wouldn't get riled up over this issue.
 
newteech said:
Ditkaless Wonders said:
newteech said:
tangfoot said:
NinerDownUnder said:
tangfoot said:
tangfoot said:
hammerva said:
How is that a catch?
Click to expand...
Did that even get reviewed?
Click to expand...
Yesno?
Click to expand...
Wasn't reviewed because it was a clear catch
Click to expand...
That's odd, because the replay I saw showed him taking a hand off the ball and the tip of it hitting the ground. :shrug: The most important play in NFL history doesn't even merit a cursory look? The league should be ####### ashamed of themselves for that.
Click to expand...
I also thought the tip of the ball touched the ground. Hopefully there will be a clear replay available online.
Click to expand...
Doesn't matter if the ball was controlled before and throughout, which it was. What is your opinion as to whether there was interference on that play?
Click to expand...
I'm not an expert on the rules. He definitely had total control of the ball but it looked like the tip of the ball scraped the ground when he held it over his head. Is this still considered a catch even if it hits the ground?
Click to expand...
It never touched the ground, it was as clear as day when FOX replayed it.
 
Dentist said:
Friggin' horrible.. a 10-6 team winning disgusts me.. a team that went 3-5 at home...They certainly played a great game and came up with some RIDICULOUSLY lucky plays in the end.....Super Bowl was just so similar to the 2001 Pats over St. Louis super bowl...I haven't been rooting for the right team in the superbowl since 2000... this is just another disappointment..I really wish they'd reduce the size of the playoffs because it's disgusting me seeing these teams with pretty mediocre playoff seasons turning it on at the right time and winning..2008 Giants2006 Steelers2006 St. Louis CardinalsThese come to mind off hand... I'm sure there's more...This is as frustrating as some stupid fantasy team that just gets hot and rolls through the playoffs.. and that keeps happening time and time again also.I've had it.I think the NFL should just have a points title and the Pats should've been VOTED champs a long time ago...I'm sick of determining it on the field.. the Pats already beat 'em once.. IN THEIR house.. should be best of 3.#### THIS.. #### ALL OF IT.
Click to expand...
Want some cheese with the whine?
 
Road Warriors said:
Last minute pregame thoughts...First, I hope that there is nothing done by the men in stripes that causes several multi-page threads here. I would love to barely notice the refs tonight. A good, clean controversial free game, first and foremost.Next, I hope the Giants play their brand of football, execute and play well, and stay healthy. I like the way this team has fought adversity thru the season and like the way they play the game.Finally, I hope the Patriots play to the levels they're capable of, the level they played at in the early part of the season. I want them to play like crazed men on a mission, leaving absolutely NO DOUBT as to who the better team is. I want no excuses. I want to see my team make history. I want to see 19-0.Here's to a great game, and a great season. I hope everyone enjoys the game. Stay safe & happy at your Super Bowl parties.
Click to expand...
I got most of what I wanted, aside from the outcome. No excuses. The Giants beat them, straight up. Great game from the G-men. I never thought I'd say this, but 18-1 sucks. Congrats to the Giants and all the fans who rooted for them to win. It was a great, exciting, hard fought game. Till next year...
 
Road Warriors said:
JohnnyU said:
Slinger said:
{Syrus} said:
I think we've seen the last of Twitch. :goodposting:
Click to expand...
What about Maroney = Speed?
Click to expand...
Shhhh....silence is golden....and revenge is a dish best served cold.
Click to expand...
JohnnyU, Syrus? Giants fans? If so... Congrats. If not, rubbing it in <> class.

Congratulations to the Giants and all their fans. Great win!
Click to expand...
Back off. I'm simply saying that silence is golden in response to the trash talking by some Pats fans prior to the game. That has nothing to do with being classless.
 
Road Warriors said:
If not, rubbing it in <> class.
Click to expand...
What a joke. This coming from a fan of a team that ran up the score against every chump team they could and who has a convicted cheater coach. Spare us your lessons about class.edit to add: also a coach who left the field early in a cowardly act
 
Last edited by a moderator:
JohnnyU said:
Road Warriors said:
JohnnyU said:
Slinger said:
{Syrus} said:
I think we've seen the last of Twitch. :goodposting:
Click to expand...
What about Maroney = Speed?
Click to expand...
Shhhh....silence is golden....and revenge is a dish best served cold.
Click to expand...
JohnnyU, Syrus? Giants fans? If so... Congrats. If not, rubbing it in <> class.

Congratulations to the Giants and all their fans. Great win!
Click to expand...
Back off. I'm simply saying that silence is golden in response to the trash talking by some Pats fans prior to the game. That has nothing to do with being classless.
Click to expand...
Back off? I'm trying to congratulate fans that celebrate a victory. Are you one of them? Or do you only celebrate a loss of those who "offend you"
 
{Syrus} said:
Road Warriors said:
If not, rubbing it in <> class.
Click to expand...
What a joke. This coming from a fan of a team that ran up the score against every chump team they could and who has a convicted cheater coach. Spare us your lessons about class.edit to add: also a coach who left the field early in a cowardly act
Click to expand...
Simple question... Are you a Giants fan? If so, Congratulations on a great season and a tremendous game. Championships are forever.If you're not a fan of that organization, and only have a particular issue with the Patriots, rubbing it in is classless.HTH
 
Road Warriors said:
JohnnyU said:
Road Warriors said:
JohnnyU said:
Slinger said:
{Syrus} said:
I think we've seen the last of Twitch. :ptts:
Click to expand...
What about Maroney = Speed?
Click to expand...
Shhhh....silence is golden....and revenge is a dish best served cold.
Click to expand...
JohnnyU, Syrus? Giants fans? If so... Congrats. If not, rubbing it in <> class.

Congratulations to the Giants and all their fans. Great win!
Click to expand...
Back off. I'm simply saying that silence is golden in response to the trash talking by some Pats fans prior to the game. That has nothing to do with being classless.
Click to expand...
Back off? I'm trying to congratulate fans that celebrate a victory. Are you one of them? Or do you only celebrate a loss of those who "offend you"
Click to expand...
Hey, I'm just enjoying the win for Eli and the Manning family. I'm a Colts fan and Patriots hater.
 
The Pats players were class all the way in their interviews. I think everyone was surprised that the Giants really just outplayed NE during the game (not by a lot though). Having more turnovers and winning is pretty shocking, but the defensive line really won the game for the Giants. Ironically, the one time the NE defensive line really pressured Eli was on the final drive.

Great game and what a run for the Giants...The 86 win was fun, the 90 was exciting, but this playoff run was an absolute blast. Had 9-11 crazy fans who were into EVERY play for all the games and it was the most football watching fun I have ever had in my life.

At the start of the 4th quarter I said, the Giants are playing for two things in my opinion, either I am going to be extremely proud of my team or I am going to be ecstatic...I a glad the latter happened.

Amazing how many people thought the Giants would implode in spring training and now they win the SB...

Peace!

 
JohnnyU said:
Road Warriors said:
JohnnyU said:
Road Warriors said:
JohnnyU said:
Slinger said:
{Syrus} said:
I think we've seen the last of Twitch. :ptts:
Click to expand...
What about Maroney = Speed?
Click to expand...
Shhhh....silence is golden....and revenge is a dish best served cold.
Click to expand...
JohnnyU, Syrus? Giants fans? If so... Congrats. If not, rubbing it in <> class.

Congratulations to the Giants and all their fans. Great win!
Click to expand...
Back off. I'm simply saying that silence is golden in response to the trash talking by some Pats fans prior to the game. That has nothing to do with being classless.
Click to expand...
Back off? I'm trying to congratulate fans that celebrate a victory. Are you one of them? Or do you only celebrate a loss of those who "offend you"
Click to expand...
Hey, I'm just enjoying the win for Eli and the Manning family. I'm a Colts fan and Patriots hater.
Click to expand...
Fair enough. Celebrate the positives, is all I'm asking.
 
Liquid Tension said:
The Pats players were class all the way in their interviews. I think everyone was surprised that the Giants really just outplayed NE during the game (not by a lot though). Having more turnovers and winning is pretty shocking, but the defensive line really won the game for the Giants. Ironically, the one time the NE defensive line really pressured Eli was on the final drive.Great game and what a run for the Giants...The 86 win was fun, the 90 was exciting, but this playoff run was an absolute blast. Had 9-11 crazy fans who were into EVERY play for all the games and it was the most football watching fun I have ever had in my life.At the start of the 4th quarter I said, the Giants are playing for two things in my opinion, either I am going to be extremely proud of my team or I am going to be ecstatic...I a glad the latter happened.Amazing how many people thought the Giants would implode in spring training and now they win the SB...Peace!
Click to expand...
:goodposting: Didn't see the post game interviews, but what the Giants did on the field was ( IMO ) very surprising. I didn't believe the Giants could slow down the Pats offense, but they went beyond slowing it down, but they shut it down. Great gameplan, great execution, and great heart shown by the Giants in this game. Congrats to the Giants and their fans.
 
Road Warriors said:
Liquid Tension said:
The Pats players were class all the way in their interviews. I think everyone was surprised that the Giants really just outplayed NE during the game (not by a lot though). Having more turnovers and winning is pretty shocking, but the defensive line really won the game for the Giants. Ironically, the one time the NE defensive line really pressured Eli was on the final drive.Great game and what a run for the Giants...The 86 win was fun, the 90 was exciting, but this playoff run was an absolute blast. Had 9-11 crazy fans who were into EVERY play for all the games and it was the most football watching fun I have ever had in my life.At the start of the 4th quarter I said, the Giants are playing for two things in my opinion, either I am going to be extremely proud of my team or I am going to be ecstatic...I a glad the latter happened.Amazing how many people thought the Giants would implode in spring training and now they win the SB...Peace!
Click to expand...
:goodposting: Didn't see the post game interviews, but what the Giants did on the field was ( IMO ) very surprising. I didn't believe the Giants could slow down the Pats offense, but they went beyond slowing it down, but they shut it down. Great gameplan, great execution, and great heart shown by the Giants in this game. Congrats to the Giants and their fans.
Click to expand...
look back at games the Patriots have lost and they are always games when the D is in Brady's face , this game was no different. I really thought with the full starting OL they could protect brady
 
So who eats the most crow here at the Pool? I remember HellToupee talking a lot about how this game would not be even close, be the worst super bowl ever, etc. I am sure there were others, I just remember that one being the most vocal

 
wilked said:
So who eats the most crow here at the Pool? I remember HellToupee talking a lot about how this game would not be even close, be the worst super bowl ever, etc. I am sure there were others, I just remember that one being the most vocal
Click to expand...
:goodposting: I made one comment about the game is the pregame thread
Patriots 42-Giants 17
Click to expand...
I'm not even a Patriots fan
 
HellToupee said:
wilked said:
So who eats the most crow here at the Pool? I remember HellToupee talking a lot about how this game would not be even close, be the worst super bowl ever, etc. I am sure there were others, I just remember that one being the most vocal
Click to expand...
:goodposting: I made one comment about the game is the pregame thread
Patriots 42-Giants 17
Click to expand...
I'm not even a Patriots fan
Click to expand...
maybe I have it completely wrong...hold on
 
Heartbroken... that's all I can say right now. Just heartbroken.

If the Patriots kick that field goal instead of going on 4th and 13, there's no doubt in my mind that they win.

If the Patriots don't wait until the 4th quarter to open up the offense with 4 or 5 receivers with quick short yardage strikes, they win.

If Belichick throws the challenge flag on the recovered fumble in the first half, they win.

If Asante Samuel holds onto the damn ball, they win.

If Brandon Meriweather holds onto the damn ball, they win.

If Rodney Harrison holds onto the damn ball, they win.

The Giants played a hell of a game, and they clearly put themselves in position to win. But as dominating as they were on the line tonight, and as miserable as they made Brady, I can't help but think that the Pats choked this one way on both sides of the ball. Eli tried to hand this game to the Patriots on four different occasions in the final drive, and the Pats refused to take it.

Ugh.

 
wilked said:
HellToupee said:
wilked said:
So who eats the most crow here at the Pool? I remember HellToupee talking a lot about how this game would not be even close, be the worst super bowl ever, etc. I am sure there were others, I just remember that one being the most vocal
Click to expand...
:goodposting: I made one comment about the game is the pregame thread
Patriots 42-Giants 17
Click to expand...
I'm not even a Patriots fan
Click to expand...
maybe I have it completely wrong...hold on
Click to expand...
I would have sworn it was ou that predicted a 52-7 score or something, but I can't find it so I must be mixed up. My apologies...
 
Wow.

Just freakin WOW.

This hs to be the greatest championship for one of my teams that i remember... better than against buffalo. i think maybe better than the 86 mets. just crazy.

times square is goin ballistic right now. great time to be agiants fan. what an ubelieveably incredible ride.

and in walked, eli the kid (cue billy joels billy the kid)

 
MallRat said:
Heartbroken... that's all I can say right now. Just heartbroken.If the Patriots kick that field goal instead of going on 4th and 13, there's no doubt in my mind that they win.If the Patriots don't wait until the 4th quarter to open up the offense with 4 or 5 receivers with quick short yardage strikes, they win.If Belichick throws the challenge flag on the recovered fumble in the first half, they win.If Asante Samuel holds onto the damn ball, they win.If Brandon Meriweather holds onto the damn ball, they win.If Rodney Harrison holds onto the damn ball, they win.The Giants played a hell of a game, and they clearly put themselves in position to win. But as dominating as they were on the line tonight, and as miserable as they made Brady, I can't help but think that the Pats choked this one way on both sides of the ball. Eli tried to hand this game to the Patriots on four different occasions in the final drive, and the Pats refused to take it.Ugh.
Click to expand...
Sorry, but the Giants simply outplayed the Patriots tonight.
 
MallRat said:
Heartbroken... that's all I can say right now. Just heartbroken.

If the Patriots kick that field goal instead of going on 4th and 13, there's no doubt in my mind that they win.

If the Patriots don't wait until the 4th quarter to open up the offense with 4 or 5 receivers with quick short yardage strikes, they win.

If Belichick throws the challenge flag on the recovered fumble in the first half, they win.

If Asante Samuel holds onto the damn ball, they win.

If Brandon Meriweather holds onto the damn ball, they win.

If Rodney Harrison holds onto the damn ball, they win.

The Giants played a hell of a game, and they clearly put themselves in position to win. But as dominating as they were on the line tonight, and as miserable as they made Brady, I can't help but think that the Pats choked this one way on both sides of the ball. Eli tried to hand this game to the Patriots on four different occasions in the final drive, and the Pats refused to take it.

Ugh.
Click to expand...
Its all about the plays. No sense debating, but...If Steve Smith grabs that ball in the 2nd quarter instead of batting it for a pick

If Steve Smith grabs that ball in the end zone at the end of the half

If the DBs turn on a few of those Moss under throws

If Webster doesn't fall down on the last pass to Moss

It goes both ways!

 
You must log in or register to reply here.

Similar threads

The Noid
2025 Philadelphia Eagles - Need to summon the ghosts of Rodney Pete and Ray Rhodes.
66 67 68
Replies
3K
Views
429K
need2know
need2know
Wingnut
  • Poll Poll
Will you watch the Super Bowl?
2 3 4
Replies
171
Views
6K
Snotbubbles
Snotbubbles
Joey Wright
2025 Scott Fish Bowl Entry Giveaway!
Replies
43
Views
1K
Drunken Cowboy
D

Users who are viewing this thread

Total: 2 (members: 0, guests: 2)
Back
Top