What's new
Fantasy Football - Footballguys Forums

This is a sample guest message. Register a free account today to become a member! Once signed in, you'll be able to participate on this site by adding your own topics and posts, as well as connect with other members through your own private inbox!

****OFFICIAL**** TOP CHEF THREAD (1 Viewer)

Even though she looks like a fraggle, I find myself rooting for Carla more and more every week. She has a great attitude and I actually think that helps her cook the way she does.

Jamie is obnoxious. Stefan is funny.

 
I'm not surprised to see Ariane go, I think she's been overrated the whole season. Still, judging by the amount of work, it should have been Leah (Not all that good, but they'll keep her around for the "romance" angle) or Radhika (Consistantly overrated, only cooks Indian and not that well.) I would have picked Radhika to go. She'll never make it to the end unless they fix it for some reason. But Ariane was going too, so it doesn't really matter.

Carla is a strange contestant, while most chefs hate pastries and desserts, that's how she's staying in the game. Good strategy so far.

 
If Stephan doesn't win this I will be shocked.

But it only takes one slip, so who knows? No surprises so far. I think this is the most talented group overall, but weakest with women for sure. I like Carla, but there is no way she can win. Radhika and Leah are hacks and while Jamie can cook she takes things way to personal to win.

I could see an all European final, plus the dude from Florida, since they have three in the final; usually.

Totally addicted to this show.

 
If Stephan doesn't win this I will be shocked.

But it only takes one slip, so who knows? No surprises so far. I think this is the most talented group overall, but weakest with women for sure. I like Carla, but there is no way she can win. Radhika and Leah are hacks and while Jamie can cook she takes things way to personal to win.



I could see an all European final, plus the dude from Florida, since they have three in the final; usually.

Totally addicted to this show.
Fabio is lucky he didn't go home last night. His days are numbered, IMO. In the past 4-5 episodes, he hasn't had a single "really good" dish. Hosea, Stefan and Jeff are in a different tier from the rest of the contestants. There will have to be a major screw-up for one of them to get canned before the final . . . of course, next week is restaurant wars . . . the traditional week for big screw-ups. Butterscotch scallops, anyone?

This season is a downer for me. You can sense the judge's are supremely disappointed with what the quality of what's being cooked . . . it's hard to get excited when the judge's are sitting there scowling the entire time.

 
I think it's clear last night exposed the vast majority of these chefs as one-trick ponies. They went out there with the thought they'd be able to cook "their" food and just curled up into a ball when what they wanted to do didn't materialize.

Jamie when she can't cook seafood she goes to a soup whether or not it's seasonal.

Rad - indian

leah - Batali

stefan - east euro

fabio - half hearted MG italian

carla - soul food

Only really two show any sort of range if you can even call it that.

jeff

hosea

I don't think it was the pork/lamb's fault that the teams had not worked with farm only versions of the product. The lamb that is produced in this country is modified to be much more like beef in the diet and other things they do to it to fit our tastess and the pork in the US is corn finished to give it again, beef like marbling. If you purchase farm raised product like this you quickly learn the differences and how they must be treated. Doesn't look like these kids realized the differences. And it's not entirely their fault the USDA is not apt to let these farms get too much traction outside of the really highly motivated consumer lest it upset the apple cart.

Still top to bottom this is the weakest group since season 2. There will be alot more controversy because the chefs that stay from here on have often done nothing more to distinguish themselves than the ones that are going to be going off.

Carla and leah are the only easy outs left. After that there will be some hand wringing.

 
I think it's clear last night exposed the vast majority of these chefs as one-trick ponies. They went out there with the thought they'd be able to cook "their" food and just curled up into a ball when what they wanted to do didn't materialize.

Jamie when she can't cook seafood she goes to a soup whether or not it's seasonal.

Rad - indian

leah - Batali

stefan - east euro

fabio - half hearted MG italian

carla - soul food

Only really two show any sort of range if you can even call it that.

jeff

hosea

I don't think it was the pork/lamb's fault that the teams had not worked with farm only versions of the product. The lamb that is produced in this country is modified to be much more like beef in the diet and other things they do to it to fit our tastess and the pork in the US is corn finished to give it again, beef like marbling. If you purchase farm raised product like this you quickly learn the differences and how they must be treated. Doesn't look like these kids realized the differences. And it's not entirely their fault the USDA is not apt to let these farms get too much traction outside of the really highly motivated consumer lest it upset the apple cart.

Still top to bottom this is the weakest group since season 2. There will be alot more controversy because the chefs that stay from here on have often done nothing more to distinguish themselves than the ones that are going to be going off.

Carla and leah are the only easy outs left. After that there will be some hand wringing.
Jamie when she can't cook seafood she goes to a soup whether or not it's seasonal. Still hanging in. Rad - indian Gone, and deserved it. One trick pony who ran out of gas.

leah - Batali - Could easily have gone home for substandard food, luckily the Euros pulled it out for her.

stefan - east euro - Can singlehandedely save a team? In Resteraunt Wars? Final 3.

fabio - half hearted MG italian - Damn good host.

carla - soul food - Probably the next to go. Just doesn't have the skills.

Hosea: "Romance" with Leah could be his downfall. Still good, but may lack the edge for the final. Or may make it and fail.

Jeff: Still good, will probably eliminate himself by trying to do too much

 
My odds board for the TC winner :

Stefan - 3/2. Best chef of the bunch, easily, but that does not guarantee victory. See last year for evidence, when Richard Blais was the class of the field but spit the bit in the finale.

Hosea - 7/2. He can cook, and will be better off once Leah gets punted. Seems to have some range in terms of being able to cook meat, fish, etc.

Fabio - 4/1. Seems to be fading each week, but can still pull off some really good Italian. if he leanrs to keep it simple, will be in the final 3.

Jamie - 5/1. Cooks seasonally and actually got away from scallops for a change. Her odds dropped this week, but might be too pouty and immature to win. She'll be in the final 3 - they won't take 3 guys.

Jeff - 9/1. Has good ideas but seems to get in trouble when he freelances and doesn't have a recipe he uses in his restaurant to fall back on. Will flame out spectacularly at some point

Leah - 20/1. She can cook, but is way too inconsistent and has an awful attitude to boot. She's not long for the show.

Carla - 100/1. Can only do desserts, and doesn't even do that as well as Stefan. No chance. She's been on the brink of elimination since before Xmas and is out of her depth.

 
I really liked it when Fabio said "this is Top Chef not Top Scallops" a couple of weeks ago referring to Jamie :confused:

I am thinking if Hosea doesn't choke like Blais, he will win. Stefan is Eurotrash IMO.

 
I can't imagine Hosea winning

If a little make out session with Leah is enough to throw him off his game that much he's not "Top Chef" material IMO

A Top Chef should be able to ball the head hostess at noon and have his mise en place perfect by 12:30

I'd say the same for Leah but her substandard cooking ability will doom her more than her emotional weakness

 
I love this freaking show and Restaurant Wars is freaking must see TV. That being said and while it pains me to admit, I just don't see how Stefan doesn't win this thing. That guy can freaking cook. And when he's on, he just doesn't get compliments, they really effuse praise on him. Maybe it's just because of the quality of the other chefs, but he really stands out.

Also, I would agree that it does seem now in it's 5th season, the chefs are really becoming more like contestants and have figured out how to play the game. That being said, if you're going to play the game, the one quickfire you probably don't want to win is this one. You know the person in charge almost always goes home in Restaurant Wars. I also think you saw the influence of the new British judge cause he was the one who said if it came down to the food the Sahana team wouldn't be here, which in the end is probably what saved Carla for another week and doomed Rad.

 
I love this freaking show and Restaurant Wars is freaking must see TV. That being said and while it pains me to admit, I just don't see how Stefan doesn't win this thing. That guy can freaking cook. And when he's on, he just doesn't get compliments, they really effuse praise on him. Maybe it's just because of the quality of the other chefs, but he really stands out.

Also, I would agree that it does seem now in it's 5th season, the chefs are really becoming more like contestants and have figured out how to play the game. That being said, if you're going to play the game, the one quickfire you probably don't want to win is this one. You know the person in charge almost always goes home in Restaurant Wars. I also think you saw the influence of the new British judge cause he was the one who said if it came down to the food the Sahana team wouldn't be here, which in the end is probably what saved Carla for another week and doomed Rad.
This is what ruined numerous reality shows like survivor, TAR, and others. I'm afraid it has begun in earnest here. The incentive for winning the weekly prizes is just not high enough early on to bring out anything great.
 
I love this freaking show and Restaurant Wars is freaking must see TV. That being said and while it pains me to admit, I just don't see how Stefan doesn't win this thing. That guy can freaking cook. And when he's on, he just doesn't get compliments, they really effuse praise on him. Maybe it's just because of the quality of the other chefs, but he really stands out.

Also, I would agree that it does seem now in it's 5th season, the chefs are really becoming more like contestants and have figured out how to play the game. That being said, if you're going to play the game, the one quickfire you probably don't want to win is this one. You know the person in charge almost always goes home in Restaurant Wars. I also think you saw the influence of the new British judge cause he was the one who said if it came down to the food the Sahana team wouldn't be here, which in the end is probably what saved Carla for another week and doomed Rad.
This is what ruined numerous reality shows like survivor, TAR, and others. I'm afraid it has begun in earnest here. The incentive for winning the weekly prizes is just not high enough early on to bring out anything great.
Maybe they shouldn't have said what the winner of the Quick Fire would have won this week. Seemed like several were content to lose it.
 
This is Stefan's competition to lose. I think Jaime also stands a chance. Too bad they are two of the biggest dooshes in the history of the show.

 
I love this freaking show and Restaurant Wars is freaking must see TV. That being said and while it pains me to admit, I just don't see how Stefan doesn't win this thing. That guy can freaking cook. And when he's on, he just doesn't get compliments, they really effuse praise on him. Maybe it's just because of the quality of the other chefs, but he really stands out. Also, I would agree that it does seem now in it's 5th season, the chefs are really becoming more like contestants and have figured out how to play the game. That being said, if you're going to play the game, the one quickfire you probably don't want to win is this one. You know the person in charge almost always goes home in Restaurant Wars. I also think you saw the influence of the new British judge cause he was the one who said if it came down to the food the Sahana team wouldn't be here, which in the end is probably what saved Carla for another week and doomed Rad.
:lmao: I don't see how Stefan manages to lose this. They've had other winners with questionable personalities (I'm looking at you, Hung), and he is just far superior to the others. I wish Leah had been gone last night, but Radhika was going to be out soon enough anyway. They ended up with the two worst leaders possible on Restaurant Wars. Next week's show looks great...
 
I love this freaking show and Restaurant Wars is freaking must see TV. That being said and while it pains me to admit, I just don't see how Stefan doesn't win this thing. That guy can freaking cook. And when he's on, he just doesn't get compliments, they really effuse praise on him. Maybe it's just because of the quality of the other chefs, but he really stands out. Also, I would agree that it does seem now in it's 5th season, the chefs are really becoming more like contestants and have figured out how to play the game. That being said, if you're going to play the game, the one quickfire you probably don't want to win is this one. You know the person in charge almost always goes home in Restaurant Wars. I also think you saw the influence of the new British judge cause he was the one who said if it came down to the food the Sahana team wouldn't be here, which in the end is probably what saved Carla for another week and doomed Rad.
:lmao: I don't see how Stefan manages to lose this. They've had other winners with questionable personalities (I'm looking at you, Hung), and he is just far superior to the others. I wish Leah had been gone last night, but Radhika was going to be out soon enough anyway. They ended up with the two worst leaders possible on Restaurant Wars. Next week's show looks great...
[Fabio]Acid and cheese! Mamma mia! You have an Italian restaurante![/Fabio]
 
I love this freaking show and Restaurant Wars is freaking must see TV. That being said and while it pains me to admit, I just don't see how Stefan doesn't win this thing. That guy can freaking cook. And when he's on, he just doesn't get compliments, they really effuse praise on him. Maybe it's just because of the quality of the other chefs, but he really stands out.

Also, I would agree that it does seem now in it's 5th season, the chefs are really becoming more like contestants and have figured out how to play the game. That being said, if you're going to play the game, the one quickfire you probably don't want to win is this one. You know the person in charge almost always goes home in Restaurant Wars. I also think you saw the influence of the new British judge cause he was the one who said if it came down to the food the Sahana team wouldn't be here, which in the end is probably what saved Carla for another week and doomed Rad.
This is what ruined numerous reality shows like survivor, TAR, and others. I'm afraid it has begun in earnest here. The incentive for winning the weekly prizes is just not high enough early on to bring out anything great.
Maybe they shouldn't have said what the winner of the Quick Fire would have won this week. Seemed like several were content to lose it.
Maybe it's because the others played the QF smart but I think it's just dumb luck that the two contestants least equipped to lead won the leadership responsibilities for Restaurant Wars. Both Radikha and Leah were clueless in the role, especially Radikha who can only blame herself for putting her in a position to fail. The episode would have been a lot different if Stefan, Jamie or Jeff were the team leads.
 
I love this freaking show and Restaurant Wars is freaking must see TV. That being said and while it pains me to admit, I just don't see how Stefan doesn't win this thing. That guy can freaking cook. And when he's on, he just doesn't get compliments, they really effuse praise on him. Maybe it's just because of the quality of the other chefs, but he really stands out.

Also, I would agree that it does seem now in it's 5th season, the chefs are really becoming more like contestants and have figured out how to play the game. That being said, if you're going to play the game, the one quickfire you probably don't want to win is this one. You know the person in charge almost always goes home in Restaurant Wars. I also think you saw the influence of the new British judge cause he was the one who said if it came down to the food the Sahana team wouldn't be here, which in the end is probably what saved Carla for another week and doomed Rad.
This is what ruined numerous reality shows like survivor, TAR, and others. I'm afraid it has begun in earnest here. The incentive for winning the weekly prizes is just not high enough early on to bring out anything great.
Maybe they shouldn't have said what the winner of the Quick Fire would have won this week. Seemed like several were content to lose it.
Maybe it's because the others played the QF smart but I think it's just dumb luck that the two contestants least equipped to lead won the leadership responsibilities for Restaurant Wars. Both Radikha and Leah were clueless in the role, especially Radikha who can only blame herself for putting her in a position to fail. The episode would have been a lot different if Stefan, Jamie or Jeff were the team leads.
I know it is edited for maximum effect, but I loved the shots of Radhika (in that awful dress) leafing through pages of reservations as everything fell apart around her :lmao:

Real Nero moment there

 
This is Stefan's competition to lose. I think Jaime also stands a chance. Too bad they are two of the biggest dooshes in the history of the show.
Yep. I actually prefer Stefan's outward douchiness.
I do too, she grates on me so much. I've been to the restaurant she currently works at a number of times, but told my wife last night I'm now boycotting it on principle. The principle being I hate her.
 
I love this freaking show and Restaurant Wars is freaking must see TV. That being said and while it pains me to admit, I just don't see how Stefan doesn't win this thing. That guy can freaking cook. And when he's on, he just doesn't get compliments, they really effuse praise on him. Maybe it's just because of the quality of the other chefs, but he really stands out.

Also, I would agree that it does seem now in it's 5th season, the chefs are really becoming more like contestants and have figured out how to play the game. That being said, if you're going to play the game, the one quickfire you probably don't want to win is this one. You know the person in charge almost always goes home in Restaurant Wars. I also think you saw the influence of the new British judge cause he was the one who said if it came down to the food the Sahana team wouldn't be here, which in the end is probably what saved Carla for another week and doomed Rad.
This is what ruined numerous reality shows like survivor, TAR, and others. I'm afraid it has begun in earnest here. The incentive for winning the weekly prizes is just not high enough early on to bring out anything great.
Maybe they shouldn't have said what the winner of the Quick Fire would have won this week. Seemed like several were content to lose it.
Maybe it's because the others played the QF smart but I think it's just dumb luck that the two contestants least equipped to lead won the leadership responsibilities for Restaurant Wars. Both Radikha and Leah were clueless in the role, especially Radikha who can only blame herself for putting her in a position to fail. The episode would have been a lot different if Stefan, Jamie or Jeff were the team leads.
If either didn't want to lead the smart thing to do was to pick stefan or jeff to take over and plan the menu. Both of them leaving stefan for last when having him on either team would have swung it one way or the other was just dumb.
 
I love this freaking show and Restaurant Wars is freaking must see TV. That being said and while it pains me to admit, I just don't see how Stefan doesn't win this thing. That guy can freaking cook. And when he's on, he just doesn't get compliments, they really effuse praise on him. Maybe it's just because of the quality of the other chefs, but he really stands out.

Also, I would agree that it does seem now in it's 5th season, the chefs are really becoming more like contestants and have figured out how to play the game. That being said, if you're going to play the game, the one quickfire you probably don't want to win is this one. You know the person in charge almost always goes home in Restaurant Wars. I also think you saw the influence of the new British judge cause he was the one who said if it came down to the food the Sahana team wouldn't be here, which in the end is probably what saved Carla for another week and doomed Rad.
This is what ruined numerous reality shows like survivor, TAR, and others. I'm afraid it has begun in earnest here. The incentive for winning the weekly prizes is just not high enough early on to bring out anything great.
Maybe they shouldn't have said what the winner of the Quick Fire would have won this week. Seemed like several were content to lose it.
Maybe it's because the others played the QF smart but I think it's just dumb luck that the two contestants least equipped to lead won the leadership responsibilities for Restaurant Wars. Both Radikha and Leah were clueless in the role, especially Radikha who can only blame herself for putting her in a position to fail. The episode would have been a lot different if Stefan, Jamie or Jeff were the team leads.
I know it is edited for maximum effect, but I loved the shots of Radhika (in that awful dress) leafing through pages of reservations as everything fell apart around her :moneybag:

Real Nero moment there
At least she recognized in the exit interview that she should have played the leadership card and forced Jeff to work front of the house. And she seemed to take the whole TC thing as a learning experience. I have faith that Radhika will be successful in one form or another.
 
I love this freaking show and Restaurant Wars is freaking must see TV. That being said and while it pains me to admit, I just don't see how Stefan doesn't win this thing. That guy can freaking cook. And when he's on, he just doesn't get compliments, they really effuse praise on him. Maybe it's just because of the quality of the other chefs, but he really stands out.

Also, I would agree that it does seem now in it's 5th season, the chefs are really becoming more like contestants and have figured out how to play the game. That being said, if you're going to play the game, the one quickfire you probably don't want to win is this one. You know the person in charge almost always goes home in Restaurant Wars. I also think you saw the influence of the new British judge cause he was the one who said if it came down to the food the Sahana team wouldn't be here, which in the end is probably what saved Carla for another week and doomed Rad.
This is what ruined numerous reality shows like survivor, TAR, and others. I'm afraid it has begun in earnest here. The incentive for winning the weekly prizes is just not high enough early on to bring out anything great.
Maybe they shouldn't have said what the winner of the Quick Fire would have won this week. Seemed like several were content to lose it.
Maybe it's because the others played the QF smart but I think it's just dumb luck that the two contestants least equipped to lead won the leadership responsibilities for Restaurant Wars. Both Radikha and Leah were clueless in the role, especially Radikha who can only blame herself for putting her in a position to fail. The episode would have been a lot different if Stefan, Jamie or Jeff were the team leads.
If either didn't want to lead the smart thing to do was to pick stefan or jeff to take over and plan the menu. Both of them leaving stefan for last when having him on either team would have swung it one way or the other was just dumb.
I agree with this, if I was picking teams in kickball or something, I wouldn't hesitate to take the big bully kid who could wallop the ball rather than some friend of mine.You play to win the game.

 
I love this freaking show and Restaurant Wars is freaking must see TV. That being said and while it pains me to admit, I just don't see how Stefan doesn't win this thing. That guy can freaking cook. And when he's on, he just doesn't get compliments, they really effuse praise on him. Maybe it's just because of the quality of the other chefs, but he really stands out.

Also, I would agree that it does seem now in it's 5th season, the chefs are really becoming more like contestants and have figured out how to play the game. That being said, if you're going to play the game, the one quickfire you probably don't want to win is this one. You know the person in charge almost always goes home in Restaurant Wars. I also think you saw the influence of the new British judge cause he was the one who said if it came down to the food the Sahana team wouldn't be here, which in the end is probably what saved Carla for another week and doomed Rad.
This is what ruined numerous reality shows like survivor, TAR, and others. I'm afraid it has begun in earnest here. The incentive for winning the weekly prizes is just not high enough early on to bring out anything great.
Maybe they shouldn't have said what the winner of the Quick Fire would have won this week. Seemed like several were content to lose it.
Maybe it's because the others played the QF smart but I think it's just dumb luck that the two contestants least equipped to lead won the leadership responsibilities for Restaurant Wars. Both Radikha and Leah were clueless in the role, especially Radikha who can only blame herself for putting her in a position to fail. The episode would have been a lot different if Stefan, Jamie or Jeff were the team leads.
I know it is edited for maximum effect, but I loved the shots of Radhika (in that awful dress) leafing through pages of reservations as everything fell apart around her :confused:

Real Nero moment there
At least she recognized in the exit interview that she should have played the leadership card and forced Jeff to work front of the house. And she seemed to take the whole TC thing as a learning experience. I have faith that Radhika will be successful in one form or another.
Yeah, but to be honest, I don't know you don't realize that before the episodeAwful, awful, awful

 
Does anyone think that the mechanical failures of ovens or freezers that seems to happen so often in various competitions are intentional? If the freezer worked properly, chances are Carla's frozen yogurt wouldn't have been yougurt soup and Stefan's first dessert would have not been eliminated. Same thing with Jamie's rotten snapper (was it a rotten RED snapper?) that caused her to switch to Chilean sea bass (is that sustainable fishery, btw?) In past challenges in this and other seasons, ovens haven't worked right or fridges have failed.

I wouldn't put it past TPTB to throw these curve balls at teh cheftestants, but it's becoming a little tiresome.

 
Does anyone think that the mechanical failures of ovens or freezers that seems to happen so often in various competitions are intentional? If the freezer worked properly, chances are Carla's frozen yogurt wouldn't have been yougurt soup and Stefan's first dessert would have not been eliminated. Same thing with Jamie's rotten snapper (was it a rotten RED snapper?) that caused her to switch to Chilean sea bass (is that sustainable fishery, btw?) In past challenges in this and other seasons, ovens haven't worked right or fridges have failed.I wouldn't put it past TPTB to throw these curve balls at teh cheftestants, but it's becoming a little tiresome.
The glitches are exacerbated by the time constraints. Trying to prep and freeze (or defrost and braise) a dish for a dinner service wouldn't be a problem if you had all day. Squeezing it into 1-3 hrs. reduces margin for error.Other factors include having a bunch of people opening freezers or ovens and the fact the episodes were filmed during the heat of summer in New York.
 
Does anyone think that the mechanical failures of ovens or freezers that seems to happen so often in various competitions are intentional? If the freezer worked properly, chances are Carla's frozen yogurt wouldn't have been yougurt soup and Stefan's first dessert would have not been eliminated. Same thing with Jamie's rotten snapper (was it a rotten RED snapper?) that caused her to switch to Chilean sea bass (is that sustainable fishery, btw?) In past challenges in this and other seasons, ovens haven't worked right or fridges have failed.

I wouldn't put it past TPTB to throw these curve balls at teh cheftestants, but it's becoming a little tiresome.
The glitches are exacerbated by the time constraints. Trying to prep and freeze (or defrost and braise) a dish for a dinner service wouldn't be a problem if you had all day. Squeezing it into 1-3 hrs. reduces margin for error.Other factors include having a bunch of people opening freezers or ovens and the fact the episodes were filmed during the heat of summer in New York.
Big factor.Dumping an ###load of hot stuff into a freezer and then expecting it to just pull all those btus out is asking for trouble. Stefan realized this and brought ice into the equation. Carla just said #### it.

 
Does anyone think that the mechanical failures of ovens or freezers that seems to happen so often in various competitions are intentional? If the freezer worked properly, chances are Carla's frozen yogurt wouldn't have been yougurt soup and Stefan's first dessert would have not been eliminated. Same thing with Jamie's rotten snapper (was it a rotten RED snapper?) that caused her to switch to Chilean sea bass (is that sustainable fishery, btw?) In past challenges in this and other seasons, ovens haven't worked right or fridges have failed.I wouldn't put it past TPTB to throw these curve balls at teh cheftestants, but it's becoming a little tiresome.
Even so, both teams had the same handicap. Carla failed epically with it, while Stefan adapted and shined.
 
Does anyone think that the mechanical failures of ovens or freezers that seems to happen so often in various competitions are intentional? If the freezer worked properly, chances are Carla's frozen yogurt wouldn't have been yougurt soup and Stefan's first dessert would have not been eliminated. Same thing with Jamie's rotten snapper (was it a rotten RED snapper?) that caused her to switch to Chilean sea bass (is that sustainable fishery, btw?) In past challenges in this and other seasons, ovens haven't worked right or fridges have failed.I wouldn't put it past TPTB to throw these curve balls at teh cheftestants, but it's becoming a little tiresome.
Even so, both teams had the same handicap. Carla failed epically with it, while Stefan adapted and shined.
His dessert was not frozen though and ice certainly isn't going to get something hard.
 
Does anyone think that the mechanical failures of ovens or freezers that seems to happen so often in various competitions are intentional? If the freezer worked properly, chances are Carla's frozen yogurt wouldn't have been yougurt soup and Stefan's first dessert would have not been eliminated. Same thing with Jamie's rotten snapper (was it a rotten RED snapper?) that caused her to switch to Chilean sea bass (is that sustainable fishery, btw?) In past challenges in this and other seasons, ovens haven't worked right or fridges have failed.I wouldn't put it past TPTB to throw these curve balls at teh cheftestants, but it's becoming a little tiresome.
Even so, both teams had the same handicap. Carla failed epically with it, while Stefan adapted and shined.
His dessert was not frozen though and ice certainly isn't going to get something hard.
His dessert wasn't soup either, like Carla's. If she knew the freezer wasn't working, she should have done something else, not just thrown up her hands. She'll probably the next to go.
 
That British judge is REALLY annoying. WTF was he talking about Elvis Presley. If the joke takes more than a sentence its not made for tv.

 
That British judge is REALLY annoying. WTF was he talking about Elvis Presley. If the joke takes more than a sentence its not made for tv.
All his jokes have the quality of being thought up well beforehand. Like "Hmmm.. I need a good joke about the entire meal I'll be served at restaurant wars. How about a young/old Elvis analogy? Oh that's rich, I'll have to remember to use that at Judges' Table"
 
That British judge is REALLY annoying. WTF was he talking about Elvis Presley. If the joke takes more than a sentence its not made for tv.
All his jokes have the quality of being thought up well beforehand. Like "Hmmm.. I need a good joke about the entire meal I'll be served at restaurant wars. How about a young/old Elvis analogy? Oh that's rich, I'll have to remember to use that at Judges' Table"
How much (1) do they miss Gail (gale?) and (2) are they kicking themselves for this wet napkin of a Brit? For the "new judge" to get SO little facetime, and when he gets it the "humor" is just awful, you know the guy is bringing nothing to the show. Where did they find this turd?
 
SofaKings said:
That British judge is REALLY annoying. WTF was he talking about Elvis Presley. If the joke takes more than a sentence its not made for tv.
I've taken to calling him "The King of the Tortured Metaphor".
 
Koya said:
snitwitch said:
SofaKings said:
That British judge is REALLY annoying. WTF was he talking about Elvis Presley. If the joke takes more than a sentence its not made for tv.
All his jokes have the quality of being thought up well beforehand. Like "Hmmm.. I need a good joke about the entire meal I'll be served at restaurant wars. How about a young/old Elvis analogy? Oh that's rich, I'll have to remember to use that at Judges' Table"
How much (1) do they miss Gail (gale?) and (2) are they kicking themselves for this wet napkin of a Brit? For the "new judge" to get SO little facetime, and when he gets it the "humor" is just awful, you know the guy is bringing nothing to the show. Where did they find this turd?
I thought he was OK in the first episode I saw him in, but his shtick gets old real quick.
 
Whoever pointed out the Jeff angle was right on. the more I think about it, the more that was kind of a **** move on his part. I don't know how calculating he could be, but those people have spent a lot of time with Radhika and had to at least suspect her running the front of the house was going to be a disaster. He's the self proclaimed pretty boy and most likely would have been a much better host. Him clearly not wanting to be there almost seemed calculated.

 
i thought Jeff said something to the effect of: "i am not going home from being in the front, if i get sent home its because of my cooking"

 
i thought Jeff said something to the effect of: "i am not going home from being in the front, if i get sent home its because of my cooking"
He did. And they've never sent a front of the house person home before that I can remember, so being in the kitchen is usually more dangerous. Unless you have no personality and no people or management skills, apparently.
 
Whoever pointed out the Jeff angle was right on. the more I think about it, the more that was kind of a **** move on his part. I don't know how calculating he could be, but those people have spent a lot of time with Radhika and had to at least suspect her running the front of the house was going to be a disaster. He's the self proclaimed pretty boy and most likely would have been a much better host. Him clearly not wanting to be there almost seemed calculated.
#### move possibly, but if it gets him to the next round, it works.The counter argument of course is that he must know he'd be good at the front of the house -- and knowing this, wouldn't he want to play to his strength and finagle into that position? Could also have helped the team as a whole this way...I wonder if it was false bravado saying "if I get sent home I want it to be b/c of my cooking" and he was really trying to get Radhika eliminated... seems too prescient to me.
 
Whoever pointed out the Jeff angle was right on. the more I think about it, the more that was kind of a **** move on his part. I don't know how calculating he could be, but those people have spent a lot of time with Radhika and had to at least suspect her running the front of the house was going to be a disaster. He's the self proclaimed pretty boy and most likely would have been a much better host. Him clearly not wanting to be there almost seemed calculated.
#### move possibly, but if it gets him to the next round, it works.The counter argument of course is that he must know he'd be good at the front of the house -- and knowing this, wouldn't he want to play to his strength and finagle into that position? Could also have helped the team as a whole this way...I wonder if it was false bravado saying "if I get sent home I want it to be b/c of my cooking" and he was really trying to get Radhika eliminated... seems too prescient to me.
Radhika just picked her friends, until Jeff and Stefan were left. She should have realized she needed a host and picked Fabio first. If she were smart she would have realized Hosea was the first pick of the other team and she would still get her 2 girlfriends. I agree this isn't the quickfire to win if you want to play it safe, but if you do win the quickfire and are captain and hit a homerun with your restaraunt then you can pretty much gaurantee yourself financial backing, so if you don't think you can win it all you may as well take a chance.
 
My odds board for the TC winner :Stefan - 3/2. Best chef of the bunch, easily, but that does not guarantee victory. See last year for evidence, when Richard Blais was the class of the field but spit the bit in the finale.Hosea - 7/2. He can cook, and will be better off once Leah gets punted. Seems to have some range in terms of being able to cook meat, fish, etc.Fabio - 4/1. Seems to be fading each week, but can still pull off some really good Italian. if he leanrs to keep it simple, will be in the final 3.Jamie - 5/1. Cooks seasonally and actually got away from scallops for a change. Her odds dropped this week, but might be too pouty and immature to win. She'll be in the final 3 - they won't take 3 guys.Jeff - 9/1. Has good ideas but seems to get in trouble when he freelances and doesn't have a recipe he uses in his restaurant to fall back on. Will flame out spectacularly at some pointLeah - 20/1. She can cook, but is way too inconsistent and has an awful attitude to boot. She's not long for the show.Carla - 100/1. Can only do desserts, and doesn't even do that as well as Stefan. No chance. She's been on the brink of elimination since before Xmas and is out of her depth.
Though i agree Stefan is the hands down favorite, i'll take 2 units on Jeff at 9/1. :popcorn:
 
I love this freaking show and Restaurant Wars is freaking must see TV. That being said and while it pains me to admit, I just don't see how Stefan doesn't win this thing. That guy can freaking cook. And when he's on, he just doesn't get compliments, they really effuse praise on him. Maybe it's just because of the quality of the other chefs, but he really stands out.

Also, I would agree that it does seem now in it's 5th season, the chefs are really becoming more like contestants and have figured out how to play the game. That being said, if you're going to play the game, the one quickfire you probably don't want to win is this one. You know the person in charge almost always goes home in Restaurant Wars. I also think you saw the influence of the new British judge cause he was the one who said if it came down to the food the Sahana team wouldn't be here, which in the end is probably what saved Carla for another week and doomed Rad.
This is what ruined numerous reality shows like survivor, TAR, and others. I'm afraid it has begun in earnest here. The incentive for winning the weekly prizes is just not high enough early on to bring out anything great.
I wish they would do something like giving "points" to the QF winners, and letting them bank those points to use at their discretion for advantages. let's say each week there's an immunity card, a technical advantage card, and an ingredient advantage card. you can choose to use points for 1 of those cards, or keep your points in the bank. and if more than 1 contestant wants a particular advantage, then they have to bid points on them.
 

Users who are viewing this thread

Back
Top