OK, here we go. I took out all the negative replacement value hitters (mostly expansion franchise guys... I didn't want a -35 for Cleon Jones throwing off my score when he would just be on the bench). Of course, if you took a guy who was +10 and put him on your bench, you still got a +10 for that even though it won't help you in reality.
Obvious caveat - I should score the best in my own system since I used it to draft by.
Owner Total
Jfranco 663
TRE 645
DougB 581
SNC 575
Oso 543
Pump 540
Sparty 533
DoctorD 523
RNR 519
Moops 510
TUP 496
Eephus 495
Rodg 484
Brady 476
ChemX 467
Hoos 466
Kraft 461
Frosti 458
Koya 442
Socal 441
Greco 428
Larry 424
Arsenal 413
Bogart 328