Pie vs. Cake (1 Viewer)

[Buckychudd]

So where does Boston Cream Pie fall under?

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Boston_cream_pie

A Boston cream pie is a cake that is filled with a custard or cream filling and frosted with chocolate. Although it is called a Boston cream pie, it is in fact a cake, and not a pie.

Was being facetious as I know it is cake but I like the pictures so thanks for those

If cakes get Boston Cream Pie, then pies get Cheesecake. It has a crust, it's a pie.

 

[Leroy Hoard]

Apple pie: Served warm or cold?

I'm a big fan of cold pie.

I, too, am preferential to a chilled pie.

If it's just the pie I guess me too.

But if there is a scoop of ice cream with it then the combo of warm pie & cold ice cream works really well together.

 

[Fat Nick]

I voted Pie...In general I'll argue that

-A superb pie > A superb cake

-An average pie < an average cake

Pies are difficult to master. Cakes have a higher margin for error...To put it in football terms, Pies are that raw prospect with freakish potential that might be an HOF'er, or might beat his baby momma and end up in jail, and Cakes are like that guaranteed role player.

 

[gianmarco]

Apple pie: Served warm or cold?

I'm a big fan of cold pie.

I, too, am preferential to a chilled pie.

If it's just the pie I guess me too.

But if there is a scoop of ice cream with it then the combo of warm pie & cold ice cream works really well together.

Yes, that's definitely the exception and when I want it warm as well.

 

[urbanhack]

As of today, I will have eaten an entire peach crumble pie by myself since Saturday.

PIE >>>> cake

 

[The Z Machine]

As of today, I will have eaten an entire peach crumble pie by myself since Saturday.

PIE >>>> cake

Work it, girl

 

[-OZ-]

I voted Pie...In general I'll argue that

-A superb pie > A superb cake

-An average pie < an average cake

Pies are difficult to master. Cakes have a higher margin for error...To put it in football terms, Pies are that raw prospect with freakish potential that might be an HOF'er, or might beat his baby momma and end up in jail, and Cakes are like that guaranteed role player.

Based on the year written would that make cake = Laken Tomlinson and pie Jamis Winston?

 

[Chemical X]

pie has 15, cake 14. the waiver wire in pie is pathetic.

 

[Cowboysfan8]

Pie. Because pumpkin and key lime

 

[Fat Nick]

I voted Pie...In general I'll argue that

-A superb pie > A superb cake

-An average pie < an average cake

Pies are difficult to master. Cakes have a higher margin for error...To put it in football terms, Pies are that raw prospect with freakish potential that might be an HOF'er, or might beat his baby momma and end up in jail, and Cakes are like that guaranteed role player.

Based on the year written would that make cake = Laken Tomlinson and pie Jamis Winston?

Man. 9 years later. I'm aligned with the pie comparison to Winston, and I think we all can agree that he was a disappointing pie. While I have no issues with the Laken Tomlinson reference either, I am very curious why you chose him out of all the 2015 draftees...

 

[CGRdrJoe]

Tres Leches is considered cake so I vote cake.

:cakeboy:

 

[-OZ-]

I voted Pie...In general I'll argue that

-A superb pie > A superb cake

-An average pie < an average cake

Pies are difficult to master. Cakes have a higher margin for error...To put it in football terms, Pies are that raw prospect with freakish potential that might be an HOF'er, or might beat his baby momma and end up in jail, and Cakes are like that guaranteed role player.

Based on the year written would that make cake = Laken Tomlinson and pie Jamis Winston?

Man. 9 years later. I'm aligned with the pie comparison to Winston, and I think we all can agree that he was a disappointing pie. While I have no issues with the Laken Tomlinson reference either, I am very curious why you chose him out of all the 2015 draftees...

and seemed safe, solid career.

 

[nirad3]

I do like some pies (chocolate cream, yum... and pumpkin at Thanksgiving only), but cake is far more preferable. So many good types of cake.

 

[Hastur]

I wouldn't cross the street for cake, but I'd do some shady stuff for pecan pie.

 

[Ted Lange as your Bartender]

Ice cream cake > pie > cake

 

[The Z Machine]

Ice cream cake > pie > cake

Nah

 

[BLOCKED_PUNT]

to the 82 of you that agree with me that pie is so much better than cake I applaud you.

to the 32 that like cake better than I'm sorry that you have defective taste buds.

 

[BobbyLayne]

Every year wifey bakes me a birthday pie

That's love, brother man

 

[Phil Elliott]

Pie Day is 3/14

 

[urbanhack]

Pie Day is 3/14

Exactly....cake doesn't have its own day.

 

[El Floppo]

Pie Day is 3/14

My birthday.

Team cake.

 

[Pipes]

Voted pie as others have said the ceiling on pie is much higher than cake but it does have a lower floor.

 

[El Floppo]

And while I'm team cake, because **** all you pie people.... The real answer is pie AND cake

 

[Alex P Keaton]

And while I'm team cake, because **** all you pie people.... The real answer is pie AND cake

This has been the answer since the OP!

 

[Alex P Keaton]

Ice cream cake > pie > cake

No idea why this has to be framed as mutually exclusive. Nothing wrong with having all 3, followed by a donut chaser

 

[BLOCKED_PUNT]

Ice cream cake > pie > cake

No idea why this has to be framed as mutually exclusive. Nothing wrong with having all 3, followed by a donut chaser

and then diabetes?

 

[GennyScreamers]

Cake. I love frosting. Also I think some people associate cake with mediocre boxed cake mix. But if you get a good quality cake from a local bakery, for example, beats a pie every time.

 

[The Z Machine]

Cake. I love frosting. Also I think some people associate cake with mediocre boxed cake mix. But if you get a good quality cake from a local bakery, for example, beats a pie every time.

Wrong again

 

[BLOCKED_PUNT]

that's one of the reasons that I dislike cake. I usually take off most of the frosting since it's just too sweet.

 

[GennyScreamers]

that's one of the reasons that I dislike cake. I usually take off most of the frosting since it's just too sweet.

Can be. I like a buttercream that’s less sweet and more buttery. More of a French style buttercream.

 

[urbanhack]

I love cake.

Cake is great.

Pie is just better.

 

[Leroy Hoard]

that's one of the reasons that I dislike cake. I usually take off most of the frosting since it's just too sweet.

Can be. I like a buttercream that’s less sweet and more buttery. More of a French style buttercream.

Yes, some frostings are really good without killing you with sugar. But most store bought are too sweet.

 

[WDIK2]

You Need Pie! | Diner & Bakery In Estes Park, Colorado

You Need Pie offers the best breakfast, lunch, and dinner options to satisfy any hunger. Our bakery also serves delicious pies, cakes, and so much more!

youneedpie.com

 

[Gatorade]

Add ice cream to either and that would be my choice. But I like cookies too.

 

[El Floppo]

Add ice cream to either and that would be my choice. But I like cookies too.

You monster.

 

[nirad3]

I love pie.

Pie is great.

Cake is just better.

Fixed for me.

 

[Harry Manback]

Did we ever get a ruling on Cheesecake? Is it a pie or a cake? Or some beautiful amalgam uniting two halves?

 

[Cowboysfan8]

Did we ever get a ruling on Cheesecake? Is it a pie or a cake? Or some beautiful amalgam uniting two halves?

Cake imo

 

[Harry Manback]

Did we ever get a ruling on Cheesecake? Is it a pie or a cake? Or some beautiful amalgam uniting two halves?

Cake imo

Sure cake is in the name, but it has a filling and it’s in a pie crust, no?