jm192
Footballguy
Great post.The problem with comparisons to guys like Cam and Fields is that they were EXPONENTIALLY better passers and players than Richardson when they entered the draft.
Newton
66"% completion, 10.2 YPA, 30 TD, 7 INT, 180rtg
Undefeated season, national champion
Fields
68% completion, 9.2 YPA, 41 TD, 3 INT, 181rtg
70% completion, 9.3 YPA, 22 TD, 6 INT, 175rtg
21-2 record
Richarson
53% completion, 7.8 YPA, 17 TD, 9 INT, 131rtg
6-7 record
He's just not even in the same realm of those guys.
Lamar Jackson and Josh Allen are the entire reason Richardson will get paid. Had they been busts he'd be a 5th rounder. So we'll see if he can take the leap they did. But he's even worse as a passer than either of them were, and at least Lamar elevated his team around him and turned a historically mediocre Louisville into a contender for a few years, whereas Florida actually looked better with the 2nd stringer in there at times when Richardson missed time.
Which is another thing being overlooked here. Richardson's entire value will be as a runner, but his career was a pretty constant string of soft tissue injuries that prevented him from running or caused his coaches to gameplan around his injuries by not letting him run. He only ran for 654yds as a career high in college. Lamar Jackson eclipsed 1500 rushing yards in a season twice.
A lot of "IF this, IF that,"
And basically it comes down whether or not his passing is ever up to snuff. And that's the whole thing. IF he isn't competent as a passer, he isn't going to hold onto a job long term. And then his rushing ability won't matter.