RB Nick Chubb, HOU (1 Viewer)

[Jacob's Ladder]

A lot of bye week carnage with James Cook, Saquon Barkley, Chase Brown, Breece Hall, Alvin Kamara and the Jags' JAGs all on a bye. I imagine a lot of teams have at least a couple of these guys on their teams based on pre-draft rankings. Nick Chubb will get a lot of fantasy run for this reason alone. I'm starting him. I'm not feeling great about it. I'm not sure I feel about his reconstructed knee getting overused on a sloppy *** field. I'm Just hoping Russ gets a little lose with the ball and Cleveland gets a few redzone opportunities after takeaways. They're brining Chubb along slowly, which is smart, but I really hope he's let loose this week, or at the least gets his snap % over 50.

 

[Pickle Rody]

A lot of bye week carnage with James Cook, Saquon Barkley, Chase Brown, Breece Hall, Alvin Kamara and the Jags' JAGs all on a bye. I imagine a lot of teams have at least a couple of these guys on their teams based on pre-draft rankings. Nick Chubb will get a lot of fantasy run for this reason alone. I'm starting him. I'm not feeling great about it. I'm not sure I feel about his reconstructed knee getting overused on a sloppy *** field. I'm Just hoping Russ gets a little lose with the ball and Cleveland gets a few redzone opportunities after takeaways. They're brining Chubb along slowly, which is smart, but I really hope he's let loose this week, or at the least gets his snap % over 50.

Barkley had his bye in week 5. What are you smoking? I want some.

 

[Jacob's Ladder]

A lot of bye week carnage with James Cook, Saquon Barkley, Chase Brown, Breece Hall, Alvin Kamara and the Jags' JAGs all on a bye. I imagine a lot of teams have at least a couple of these guys on their teams based on pre-draft rankings. Nick Chubb will get a lot of fantasy run for this reason alone. I'm starting him. I'm not feeling great about it. I'm not sure I feel about his reconstructed knee getting overused on a sloppy *** field. I'm Just hoping Russ gets a little lose with the ball and Cleveland gets a few redzone opportunities after takeaways. They're brining Chubb along slowly, which is smart, but I really hope he's let loose this week, or at the least gets his snap % over 50.

Barkley had his bye in week 5. What are you smoking? I want some.

Thank you for calling out my obvious and unintentional mistake in such a wonderfully joyful and helpful manner. My mind was elsewhere, but I intended to post Bijan Robinson there. He hasn't been Saquon, but he's been close. Top 10 non-PPR, right behind Saquon at the top in PPR. Despite my error, the point remains the same. There are a lot of difference makers at RB on a bye this weekend. Some were first rounders, some were great values.

 

[Chicago Hooligan]

I've been carrying Chubb since he was dropped and never used him. Now is the time for me, since I can't count on Pacheco doing anything on Sunday. TD prayer, essentially. Don't need him to put da team on his back.

 

[LionOfGosforth]

I hope that lovely chap Minkah Fitzpatrick stays well away from Mr Chubb tonight. I don't ever want to see that again.

 

[Cowboysfan8]

Thank you for calling out my obvious and unintentional mistake in such a wonderfully joyful and helpful manner.

 

[kyoun1e]

A lot of bye week carnage with James Cook, Saquon Barkley, Chase Brown, Breece Hall, Alvin Kamara and the Jags' JAGs all on a bye. I imagine a lot of teams have at least a couple of these guys on their teams based on pre-draft rankings. Nick Chubb will get a lot of fantasy run for this reason alone. I'm starting him. I'm not feeling great about it. I'm not sure I feel about his reconstructed knee getting overused on a sloppy *** field. I'm Just hoping Russ gets a little lose with the ball and Cleveland gets a few redzone opportunities after takeaways. They're brining Chubb along slowly, which is smart, but I really hope he's let loose this week, or at the least gets his snap % over 50.

Barkley had his bye in week 5. What are you smoking? I want some.

Thank you for calling out my obvious and unintentional mistake in such a wonderfully joyful and helpful manner. My mind was elsewhere, but I intended to post Bijan Robinson there. He hasn't been Saquon, but he's been close. Top 10 non-PPR, right behind Saquon at the top in PPR. Despite my error, the point remains the same. There are a lot of difference makers at RB on a bye this weekend. Some were first rounders, some were great values.

Congrats on a well balanced, unemotional response to a somewhat jerky reply.

 

[VikingFrog]

Nice TD. I’d be happy with just that based on my expectations. And a whole half to play!

 

[Faust]

Browns RB Nick Chubb powers in for memorable touchdown vs. Steelers

 

[TLEF316]

We did it!!

 

[Jacob's Ladder]

 

[VikingFrog]

We did it!!

It’s like Saquon’s Thursday night game last week minus the yards.

 

[Jacob's Ladder]

We did it!!

It’s like Saquon’s Thursday night game last week minus the yards.

Realistically, anyone who started Chubb was hoping for 8-10 points. That was my personal best case scenario I had in my mind for this forced start. Bad weather, bad matchup, TNF, minimal usage into this game. Things were bleak. This result was abso-****ing-lutely FANTASTIC!

 

[Pickle Rody]

We did it!!

It’s like Saquon’s Thursday night game last week minus the yards.

Realistically, anyone who started Chubb was hoping for 8-10 points. That was my personal best case scenario I had in my mind for this forced start. Bad weather, bad matchup, TNF, minimal usage into this game. Things were bleak. This result was abso-****ing-lutely FANTASTIC!

By the way, I wasn't intentionally attempting to give you a jerky response previously. I was attempting humor that unfortunately didn't land quite right.

Anyway, good on you for starting Chubb and reaping the rewards. I too had him in my lineup, as a flex, in hopes that something good might come of it. I am pleased with the results. He's back in my lineup this week also.

 

[Runkle]

Broken foot: https://twitter.com/kelseyyrusso/status/1868406762963124449

 

[jumper]

Broken foot: https://twitter.com/kelseyyrusso/status/1868406762963124449

So is Jerome Ford a plausible Fantasy Playoffs RB2 now?

 

[Jppaul]

any rumors?

Is he asking too much? If the 'guaranteed' money isn't too much, i'd sure love my Broncos to bring him in. The risk-reward seems positive?

 

[standarsh]

Forget about the money, is he even worth a roster spot at this point?

He's a 30 year old running back who has played 10 games in the past 2 years (averaging 3.3 ypc this year).

I don't even think it's worth bringing him in. Just pick up somebody in the 4th round.

 

[Jppaul]

is he even worth a roster spot at this point?

aren't roster spots like 90 players right now?

 

[brewer]

Forget about the money, is he even worth a roster spot at this point?

He's a 30 year old running back who has played 10 games in the past 2 years (averaging 3.3 ypc this year).

I don't even think it's worth bringing him in. Just pick up somebody in the 4th round.

Oh, I think there are reasons to be skeptical for sure, but one man I would never count out is Nick Chubb. If the price were right, I would absolutely roll the dice on him.

 

[MAC_32]

any rumors?

Is he asking too much? If the 'guaranteed' money isn't too much, i'd sure love my Broncos to bring him in. The risk-reward seems positive?

Browns told him to test the market and asked him to come back to them with his best offer then they'll decide whether to match or not.

 

[travdogg]

Forget about the money, is he even worth a roster spot at this point?

He's a 30 year old running back who has played 10 games in the past 2 years (averaging 3.3 ypc this year).

I don't even think it's worth bringing him in. Just pick up somebody in the 4th round.

Oh, I think there are reasons to be skeptical for sure, but one man I would never count out is Nick Chubb. If the price were right, I would absolutely roll the dice on him.

This 100%.

Nobody in the 4th round has Chubb's upside, hell, its arguable nobody in the 2nd round does (he was arguably the best runner in the NFL as recently as the beginning on 2023) and the capital to sign him will be a lot lower than a 2nd rounder, where you can draft a player at a more important position, and still get that 4th round RB if you really want one.

Honestly, he would have been my #1 FA RB (on a dollars to value scale) just on the chance he can get even 80% back to his old self another year removed from major knee surgery.

 

[Jppaul]

Honestly, he would have been my #1 FA RB (on a dollars to value scale) just on the chance he can get even 80% back to his old self another year removed from major knee surgery.

This

I feel like some people just want to be contrary.

I'd love for my Broncos to bring him in for summer. If it's only a few million, I think the risk-reward is very positive

... And still draft a RB very high

 

[rockaction]

I'm really hoping he can still tote it and gives us another year to appreciate his greatness at RB, but with this class coming in and everything else, it's not looking too good as of now. Teams aren't going to spend that much on him when all these young guys are burning 4.4s at the combine or on their pro day.

 

[Grahamburn]

any rumors?

Is he asking too much? If the 'guaranteed' money isn't too much, i'd sure love my Broncos to bring him in. The risk-reward seems positive?

Browns told him to test the market and asked him to come back to them with his best offer then they'll decide whether to match or not.

And he should tell them to pound sand.

 

[Grahamburn]

I’d just retire. He’s risking the ability to walk at this point.

 

[MAC_32]

any rumors?

Is he asking too much? If the 'guaranteed' money isn't too much, i'd sure love my Broncos to bring him in. The risk-reward seems positive?

Browns told him to test the market and asked him to come back to them with his best offer then they'll decide whether to match or not.

And he should tell them to pound sand.

...why?

 

[Uncle Leo]

any rumors?

Is he asking too much? If the 'guaranteed' money isn't too much, i'd sure love my Broncos to bring him in. The risk-reward seems positive?

Browns told him to test the market and asked him to come back to them with his best offer then they'll decide whether to match or not.

And he should tell them to pound sand.

...why?

This is what the Giants told Saquon last year. Saquon did the right thing.

 

[zamboni]

any rumors?

Is he asking too much? If the 'guaranteed' money isn't too much, i'd sure love my Broncos to bring him in. The risk-reward seems positive?

Browns told him to test the market and asked him to come back to them with his best offer then they'll decide whether to match or not.

And he should tell them to pound sand.

...why?

This is what the Giants told Saquon last year. Saquon did the right thing.

Saquon had a lot more in the tank though. Teams are obviously not lining up to sign Chubb right now, whether it be due to his own health, a huge rookie class, or both.

 

[eighsse2]

any rumors?

Is he asking too much? If the 'guaranteed' money isn't too much, i'd sure love my Broncos to bring him in. The risk-reward seems positive?

Browns told him to test the market and asked him to come back to them with his best offer then they'll decide whether to match or not.

And he should tell them to pound sand.

...why?

"Test the market and we'll decide if we want to match the best offer you get" seems like the definition of rational decision-making. What else should Chubb be expecting to hear? "Tell us anything you want and we'll give it to you. No questions asked."

 

[sm8680]

I believe there not lining up due to his gruesome injury which resulted in Nick only playing in 10 games in a 2-year period. He's 29 and someone will eventually sign him to a low-risk contract. He's the type of player you root for comeback player of the year.

 

[Hot Sauce Guy]

any rumors?

Is he asking too much? If the 'guaranteed' money isn't too much, i'd sure love my Broncos to bring him in. The risk-reward seems positive?

Browns told him to test the market and asked him to come back to them with his best offer then they'll decide whether to match or not.

And he should tell them to pound sand.

...why?

This is what the Giants told Saquon last year. Saquon did the right thing.

Saquon wasn’t coming off of a blown out knee though. That’s more than a subtle difference.

 

[JohnnyU]

Will anyone even want him?

 

[Hot Sauce Guy]

any rumors?

Is he asking too much? If the 'guaranteed' money isn't too much, i'd sure love my Broncos to bring him in. The risk-reward seems positive?

Browns told him to test the market and asked him to come back to them with his best offer then they'll decide whether to match or not.

And he should tell them to pound sand.

...why?

"Test the market and we'll decide if we want to match the best offer you get" seems like the definition of rational decision-making. What else should Chubb be expecting to hear? "Tell us anything you want and we'll give it to you. No questions asked."

Kind of weird to see that from the Browns. A bit unexpected since “rational“ hasn’t exactly been their MO.

 

[Wigglytuff's Gruff]

If he doesn't get an offer then presumably the Browns don't make him one either then? If you track the logic.

 

[Jppaul]

Either he's done or he's hinting that he wants too much money

If he's still on the path of healing and doesn't demand too much money, then I really want my Broncos to sign him now

If he's not healthy enough, cut him before week one

 

[MAC_32]

Kind of weird to see that from the Browns. A bit unexpected since “rational“ hasn’t exactly been their MO.

With one very large exception, this is how I'd describe this group's M.O.

 

[Hot Sauce Guy]

With one very large exception, this is how I'd describe this group's M.O.

“A man can build 1000 bridges, but he [explative]s one sheep, no one’s gonna point and say ‘hey, there goes that bridge builder!’”

 

[massraider]

This is the definition of low risk/ high reward

 

[scothawk]

any rumors?

Is he asking too much? If the 'guaranteed' money isn't too much, i'd sure love my Broncos to bring him in. The risk-reward seems positive?

Browns told him to test the market and asked him to come back to them with his best offer then they'll decide whether to match or not.

And he should tell them to pound sand.

...why?

"Test the market and we'll decide if we want to match the best offer you get" seems like the definition of rational decision-making. What else should Chubb be expecting to hear? "Tell us anything you want and we'll give it to you. No questions asked."

Exactly what they did with Watson

 

[standarsh]

Honestly, he would have been my #1 FA RB (on a dollars to value scale) just on the chance he can get even 80% back to his old self another year removed from major knee surgery.

This

I feel like some people just want to be contrary.

I'd love for my Broncos to bring him in for summer. If it's only a few million, I think the risk-reward is very positive

... And still draft a RB very high

I guess I just disagree - I don't want to see my Bears draft him, despite the disappointing performance of the position last year and the odds that they'll take Jeanty with their 1st round pick.

 

[Jppaul]

Honestly, he would have been my #1 FA RB (on a dollars to value scale) just on the chance he can get even 80% back to his old self another year removed from major knee surgery.

This

I feel like some people just want to be contrary.

I'd love for my Broncos to bring him in for summer. If it's only a few million, I think the risk-reward is very positive

... And still draft a RB very high

I guess I just disagree - I don't want to see my Bears draft him, despite the disappointing performance of the position last year and the odds that they'll take Jeanty with their 1st round pick.

you disagree about what I'd like my broncos to do?

 

[Hot Sauce Guy]

Honestly, he would have been my #1 FA RB (on a dollars to value scale) just on the chance he can get even 80% back to his old self another year removed from major knee surgery.

This

I feel like some people just want to be contrary.

I'd love for my Broncos to bring him in for summer. If it's only a few million, I think the risk-reward is very positive

... And still draft a RB very high

I guess I just disagree - I don't want to see my Bears draft him, despite the disappointing performance of the position last year and the odds that they'll take Jeanty with their 1st round pick.

you disagree about what I'd like my broncos to do?

Can we talk about your haircut for a minute, too?

 

[Jppaul]

Can we talk about your haircut for a minute, too?

I like the cut of his jib.
I like the cut of his hair.
- Venture Bros

 

[sm8680]

Just keep in mind and I'm going off the top of my head. 2022 he tore is acl/mcl. 2023 he broke his foot. He's had some very bad luck lately. But prior to those injuries you could easily argue he was a top 5 RB and difference maker.

 

[pecorino]

Just keep in mind and I'm going off the top of my head. 2022 he tore is acl/mcl. 2023 he broke his foot. He's had some very bad luck lately. But prior to those injuries you could easily argue he was a top 5 RB and difference maker.

I would very much like to see the Steelers pick him up for the right price. Love the idea of Chubb / Warren.

 

[Jppaul]

Just keep in mind and I'm going off the top of my head. 2022 he tore is acl/mcl. 2023 he broke his foot. He's had some very bad luck lately. But prior to those injuries you could easily argue he was a top 5 RB and difference maker.

this

I think some are suggesting that he's got nothing left in the tank (possibly) or that he's injury prone (possibly), but neither of those have been proven. If he heals up and returns to form, then he's a massive steal. There's zero guarantee, but if the signing bonus/guarantees are reasonable, then cut him before week one if he is toast.

I'm unclear why we're not hearing any news.

 

[Grahamburn]

any rumors?

Is he asking too much? If the 'guaranteed' money isn't too much, i'd sure love my Broncos to bring him in. The risk-reward seems positive?

Browns told him to test the market and asked him to come back to them with his best offer then they'll decide whether to match or not.

And he should tell them to pound sand.

...why?

"Test the market and we'll decide if we want to match the best offer you get" seems like the definition of rational decision-making. What else should Chubb be expecting to hear? "Tell us anything you want and we'll give it to you. No questions asked."

There's clearly an enormous culture problem in Cleveland. Chubb is an important part of any positive culture they have. The message that front office continues to send to their players is that there's no accountability here. There's no real loyalty here. We pay scumbags outside the organization a quarter billion, but the guys who lay it on the line for the Browns can kick rocks. Chubb has laid his health on the line multiple times for them and fought hard to get back. I believe sent out an extremely heartfelt and emotional message to the city following his injury.

Football is a business, but it's a business comprised of people. Treat them poorly and you'll get an appropriate effort in return. I guess I see it differently being a Bucs' fan? We have players like Chris Godwin who isn't too dissimilar from Chubb. Chris tore an ACL in 2021. The Bucs signed him to an extension. Chris dislocated an ankle in 2024. The Bucs signed him to an extension. Is that bad football business process? Maybe, but you know who notices? The players. They know if they perform as a Buc they'll still be compensated even if they sustain injury. You know how I know? Godwin took significantly less money to continue being a Buc.

Chubb has been loyal to Cleveland and their response to him is, "Well, go see if anyone else will compensate you. We'll decide if you're worthy of it or not." Is it a surprise to anyone that the Browns have sucked for eternity treating their players that way?

If I were him I'd take the first offer I got and get the Hell out of there.

 

[rockaction]

Chubb has been loyal to Cleveland and their response to him is, "Well, go see if anyone else will compensate you. We'll decide if you're worthy of it or not." Is it a surprise to anyone that the Browns have sucked for eternity treating their players that way?

I was nodding along with your post until I got to this point, but then I had to double check my own self to make sure the way you're painting it is accurate. I conclude that it is. It's almost like they want a club option on Chubb. That seems weird. It's like they're saying, "Yes, we want you but not if some fool team gives you way more money than we think you deserve. Then we don't want a thing to do with you until we might deign to re-sign you so you can retire in our jersey." Could there be a worse provision in your contract than something like that? I say no. I'd be kicking my own *** out of Cleveland.

Players really do notice how clubs treat the guys because they're the guys that are going to be treated a certain way. I can't get over the fact that some guys still want to play for the Jets with Woody Johnson as the owner. And Haslam is no different, and probably worse. They're not cheap. They're just cement heads when it comes to the organization and its treatment of its players. It shines through and players see it, know it, and make decisions based upon it. Nobody talks about the Browns and Myles Garrett in any tone but hushed reverence, but they gave a guy who started swinging his helmet at another man like he was feral forty million dollars for at least three years just a week ago after he demanded a trade. That's a guy who, at the least, sexually battered women and a guy who attempted defenestration with a helmet and wanted out of the city that are now being paid at least 80 million dollars combined—in 2026. "But, Nick, we've got this situation here see . . . "

Forget that. That's Mickey Mouse crap.

 

[MAC_32]

any rumors?

Is he asking too much? If the 'guaranteed' money isn't too much, i'd sure love my Broncos to bring him in. The risk-reward seems positive?

Browns told him to test the market and asked him to come back to them with his best offer then they'll decide whether to match or not.

And he should tell them to pound sand.

...why?

"Test the market and we'll decide if we want to match the best offer you get" seems like the definition of rational decision-making. What else should Chubb be expecting to hear? "Tell us anything you want and we'll give it to you. No questions asked."

There's clearly an enormous culture problem in Cleveland. Chubb is an important part of any positive culture they have. The message that front office continues to send to their players is that there's no accountability here. There's no real loyalty here. We pay scumbags outside the organization a quarter billion, but the guys who lay it on the line for the Browns can kick rocks. Chubb has laid his health on the line multiple times for them and fought hard to get back. I believe sent out an extremely heartfelt and emotional message to the city following his injury.

Football is a business, but it's a business comprised of people. Treat them poorly and you'll get an appropriate effort in return. I guess I see it differently being a Bucs' fan? We have players like Chris Godwin who isn't too dissimilar from Chubb. Chris tore an ACL in 2021. The Bucs signed him to an extension. Chris dislocated an ankle in 2024. The Bucs signed him to an extension. Is that bad football business process? Maybe, but you know who notices? The players. They know if they perform as a Buc they'll still be compensated even if they sustain injury. You know how I know? Godwin took significantly less money to continue being a Buc.

Chubb has been loyal to Cleveland and their response to him is, "Well, go see if anyone else will compensate you. We'll decide if you're worthy of it or not." Is it a surprise to anyone that the Browns have sucked for eternity treating their players that way?

If I were him I'd take the first offer I got and get the Hell out of there.

You should re-read the previous 2 pages. The Browns already did exactly what you said they should be doing now.