Ryan said Saturday that Holmes told him he turned off the iPod when asked Thursday night, but fell asleep with the ear buds still in on the Colgan Air flight from Newark Liberty International Airport to Pittsburgh International Airport.
Holmes told Ryan on Friday that the flight attendant came by again and upon seeing the ear buds still in, said he never turned off the iPod. Holmes insisted he had already done so.
"He literally handed the ear things to the lady sitting beside him, and she said, 'Yeah, you can't hear anything. They're off,'" Ryan said Holmes told him.