American Primeval (Netflix) - 6.5/10.
I traveled for work this week so was able to binge this series ("AP") when I had some downtime. This series is created by the same people who did The Revenant and is even set in the same world a few decades later (Bridge, one of AP's best characters, was the kid from The Revenant). In short, the plot is pretty simple: a mom and her son are trying to get from the east coast to a town called "Crooks Springs" where the boy's dad lives and is talked about like it's the land of milk and honey. However, to get there, they need to cross the southern Utah terrain where the US Government, the Mormons, and multiple Native American tribes are all fighting for the control of the land. Mom and son come across Bridger's outpost near the disputed territory and get introduced to Isaac, a loner with an obvious tortured pass. While he doesn't agree initially, he eventually agrees to guide them to Crooks Springs amongst the ongoing warfare. Oh, and the mother has a bounty out for her from the east coast because she apparently killed a guy so there are bounty hunters interested in her, too.
That's it - that's basically the plot. Which I suppose is fine. The acting throughout the series is overall good (Taylor Kisch does a nice job playing the mysterious superhero, the Badger character is fantastic, the child actors do well, and the antagonists are well acted). Further, the scenery is good. However, what separates this series from The Revenant and justifies my rating is that the series' violence and brutality (especially towards women and children) are so over the top that it doesn't offset the positives about the show. I mean, we're talking 300 or Sin City level violence and gore but unlike those movies where the directors are smart enough to make those scenes almost cartoonish, AP maintains its ultra-serious, ultra-realistic presentation so it's just a really uncomfortable watch. Perhaps I erred by binging the series (watched in three sessions so two episodes per) but even though the middle episodes do have some good character development I just wanted the series to end because I was over the violence. And I say this as a viewer who, I believe, has a significantly higher tolerance from on-screen sensitive content. In other words, I'm probably this show's demographic and it was even too much for me and I desperately wanted it to end so I could leave the world protrayed.
Additionally, the show fails because it contains too mainly of the standard tropes such as a main character who makes objectively bad decisions (with a finally decision that arguably underscores the gravity of what happened in the very scene prior), the plot becomes predictable, the hero and villains are almost superhuman (which doesn't work when it's supposed to be a realistic depiction), and the villains are so pure evil that, again, it loses its realiism.*
Ultimately, I wouldn't say that one shouldn't view this show and those that really like The Revenant will appreciate the scenery, characters, and harshness of the setting of AP, but I do want to caution you that it isn't for the faint of heart in the least bit.
...slight spoiler below (though I don't think I'm giving anything away)....
*The main antagonists are the Mormons and Brigham Young. They are portrayed as horrific monsters . I also believe their portrayal may not be consistent with actual history and assuming my understanding is correct, I did find it distasteful to villainize a prominent religious group in this country for no real reason. In other words, while there are many legitimate reasons to be critical of the LDS faith and its religious beliefs, etc., demonizing one of their most prominent figures when such is not supportive by historical fact seems unnecessary and, frankly, juvenile considering the series seems to take itself very seriously by using real life characters and injecting no humor whatsoever into the show.