Take Your Pick (1 Viewer)

[TFN1995]

Eli Manning- 2nd year qb who has struggled with his accuracy. He has a bright future. He has lead the Giants in his 2nd year Pro to a NFC East Title. Jake Plummer- A INT machine. Has lead the Broncos to a first round bye. He has struggled with his accuracy also. Please take your pick. Which QB would you want on your team if you were a GM. This is a fantasy one year deal. Built To Win NOW!

 

[gman8343]

is my team in rebuilding mode or are we built to win now?

 

[rockbottom895]

My friend, this isnt really competition. How can you say that PLummer is an INT machine? He has only thrown 7 picks this year, and has led the Broncos to the 2nd bye in the AFC. Eli on the other hand, has thrown 17 picks. Is that even comparison? Jake Plummer's QB rating this year was 90.2 while Mannings was 75.9. Jake is a much better player than Manning. I rest my case.

 

[Elway Lives]

I don't think your WDIS question is valid anymore.

 

[Ghost Rider]

Jake Plummer- A INT machine. Has lead the Broncos to a first round bye. He has struggled with his accuracy also.

Plummer had the lowest interception percentage of ANY QB in the NFL this season. In other words, based on number of passes attempted, Plummer was the best QB in the NFL this season at not throwing interceptions. Try again.

 

[SSOG]

Eli Manning- 2nd year qb who has struggled with his accuracy. He has a bright future. He has lead the Giants in his 2nd year Pro to a NFC East Title.

Jake Plummer- A INT machine. Has lead the Broncos to a first round bye. He has struggled with his accuracy also.

Please take your pick. Which QB would you want on your team if you were a GM. This is a fantasy one year deal. Built To Win NOW!

As has been mentioned, Jake's tops in the NFL in INT%.As for struggling with accuracy...

Jake Plummer: 60.7% passing, 7.4 ypa.

Eli Manning: 52.7% passing, 6.7 ypa.

 

[Mr. Mojo]

This year - PlummerFor the long haul - Eli

 

[seahawk 17]

Plummer easy.